Auction of ancient Indian gems ‘imbued with living presence of Buddha' condemned
Buddhist academics and monastic leaders have condemned an auction of ancient Indian gem relics which they said were widely considered to be imbued with the presence of the Buddha.
The auction of the Piprahwa gems will take place in Hong Kong next week. Sotheby's listing describes them as being 'of unparalleled religious, archaeological and historical importance' and many Buddhists considered them to be corporeal remains, which had been desecrated by a British colonial landowner.
Prof Ashley Thompson, of Soas University of London, and the curator Conan Cheong, both experts in south-east Asian art, also claimed the auction raised ethical concerns about the ownership of treasures 'wrongfully acquired during the colonial era'.
The gems, which are expected to sell for about HK$100m (£9.7m), are being sold by three descendants of the British engineer William Claxton Peppé, who in 1898 excavated them on his estate in northern India. They include amethysts, coral, garnets, pearls, rock crystals, shells and gold, either worked into pendants, beads, and other ornaments, or in their natural form.
The gems were originally buried in a dome-shaped funerary monument, called a stupa, in Piprahwa, in present-day Uttar Pradesh, India, about 240-200BC, when they were mixed with some of the cremated remains of the Buddha, who died about 480BC.
The British crown claimed Peppé's find under the 1878 Indian Treasure Trove Act, with the bones and ash gifted to the Buddhist monarch King Chulalongkorn of Siam. Most of the 1,800 gems went to the colonial museum in Kolkata, while Peppé was permitted to retain approximately a fifth of them.
Thomson said: 'For the vast majority of devotees, these gem relics are not inanimate objects – they are imbued with the presence of the Buddha.
'The relics – bones, ash and gems – were all found together inside the funerary monument, and were meant by those who deposited them to be together in perpetuity. When excavated they were categorised as human remains on the one hand and gems on the other. This sale perpetuates the colonial violence of that separation.'
Venerable Dr Yon Seng Yeath, the abbot of Wat Unnalom, the headquarters of Cambodia's Mahanikaya Buddhist order, said the auction 'disrespects a global spiritual tradition and ignores the growing consensus that sacred heritage should belong to the communities that value it most'.
Mahinda Deegalle, a Buddhist monastic leader and emeritus professor at Bath Spa University, said the sale was 'appalling' and a 'humiliation of one of the greatest thinkers in the world'.
Chris Peppé, a great-grandson of William Claxton Peppé who owns the gems along with two other relatives, said none of the Buddhist temples or experts he had consulted over the past 10 years regarded them as corporeal remains.
'[These] arguments don't represent Buddhist popular opinion,' said Peppé, a film editor and director based in Los Angeles. 'They belong to Buddhist scholarship and don't help us find a way to get the gems into Buddhist hands. The Piprahwa gems were relic offerings made at the time of the reinterment of the Buddha's ashes over 200 years after his passing.'
The film-maker, who wrote a piece for Sotheby's about his family's custodianship of the gems, said they had considered donating them to temples and museums but this proved to be problematic. 'An auction [in Hong Kong] seems the fairest and most transparent way to transfer these relics to Buddhists and we are confident that Sotheby's will achieve that,' he added.
One of the experts Chris Peppé consulted, John Strong, a professor emeritus of religious studies at Bates College, Maine, said the gems could be regarded in several ways. He said some experts and devotees saw them as special offerings intended to honour the bodily remains of the Buddha, while others viewed them as a special kind of relic, symbolising 'the ongoing incorruptibility of the quality of Buddhahood'.
A Sotheby's spokesperson said: 'We conducted requisite due diligence, including in relation to authenticity and provenance, legality and other considerations in line with our policies and industry standards for artworks and treasures.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Man behind King's cypher to be made MBE says work he does was ‘anonymous'
The man behind the King's cypher who is being made a Member of the Order of the British Empire (MBE) has said the work he does has traditionally been anonymous. Tim Noad, a heraldic designer, said he was 'absolutely delighted' and 'immensely proud' when he received a letter containing the news of his honour, franked with his own design. Mr Noad is becoming an MBE for services to calligraphy, heraldry and design in the King's Birthday Honours. The 58-year-old, of west London, told the PA news agency: 'My name is quite often not associated with the work I've done and I think that is only becoming more regular these days, but I think in the past, traditionally, the kind of work that I do was anonymous really.' Mr Noad, who has worked at the College of Arms for 39 years, was chosen to submit 10 cypher designs for the King to choose his preferred monogram. The designer tried out a range of different styles when putting forward his works. 'I wanted to try out different fonts, so I tried out some that were more cursive and italic, and some that were more flowing and elaborate,' he said. 'And then also the Roman style, which was the style that was used for the previous Queen and that was the style that was eventually chosen.' Mr Noad feared he might not get so many opportunities in heraldry after Queen Elizabeth II died. He said: 'As it's turned out, it's been like a whole new world of designing and wonderful commissions for me.' Mr Noad's interest in heraldry goes back to his childhood, when he joined his local heraldry society aged 12 and started going to art classes with a College of Arms artist. Mr Noad then studied calligraphy, heraldry and illumination at Reigate College before getting a job at the College of Arms. As well as working at the college, the designer does freelance work and runs heraldry courses. He has also run workshops and classes with children and young people in the hope of passing the lesser-known trade on to the next generation. Mr Noad designed the Stole Royal which the King wore at his coronation. He also created the late Queen's golden, diamond and platinum jubilee medals and designed the elaborate and intricately penned 'instrument of consent' from the Queen that formally approved the marriage of William and Kate, now the Prince and Princess of Wales, in 2011. Asked what he is most proudest, Mr Noad said it 'would have to be the royal cypher'. 'I never imagined, even when I designed it, I'd see it so widely reproduced,' he said. 'I suppose it's become very distinctive, almost sort of iconic. It sort of symbolises the King. Yes, that will go down in history for forever.'
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
King's Birthday Honours: What MBE, OBE and others mean
This year's list ranges from politicians, musicians and actors to senior diplomats and elite sports stars, all recognised for their field or perhaps services to charity. But what does each honour mean and how are people nominated? How the British honours system works The British honours system recognises people who have 'made achievements in public life' and 'committed themselves to serving and helping Britain'. This can range from volunteers, innovators, entrepreneurs or individuals across a range of fields, such as sport, education, business, the arts and media. Gallantry awards recognising bravery can also be given to members of the armed forces and the emergency services, as well as civilians. Any member of the public or an official body can nominate someone for an honour, with UK nationals and Commonwealth citizens eligible. People living or working overseas, whose achievements were made in another country or in the UK and have a significant international element, can be nominated too. Non-British or Commonwealth country citizens can also be considered for 'honorary' awards. The suitability of nominees is submitted to the Honours and Appointments Secretariat, before a group of 10 independent honours committees, each covering a specialist subject area such as sport or health, consider them. The recommendations of these groups of independent experts and senior civil servants are passed on to the Prime Minister and, ultimately, the King for approval. The Prime Minister helps to decide on the honours (Image: House of Commons/UK Parliament/PA Wire) The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) oversees the Diplomatic Service and Overseas List. Honours are revealed twice a year, at New Year and in June on the King's official birthday. Ceremonies to award medals are held later, about 30 times a year, at Buckingham Palace, Windsor Castle and, occasionally, the Palace of Holyroodhouse in Edinburgh, and are hosted by senior royals. What MBE, OBE, CBE and others honours mean The honours ranking in descending order is as follows: Companions of Honour (CH) - for those who have made a long-standing contribution to arts, science, medicine or government Dame and Knights Grand Cross (GBE) - the highest rank in many of the orders Order of the Bath (GCB/KCB/DCB/CB) - recognises the work of senior military officials and civil servants Order of St Michael and St George (GCMG/KCMG/DCMG/CMG) - recognises service in a foreign country or in relation to foreign and Commonwealth affairs Knights and Dames Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE/DBE) - typically for people who have made a major contribution at national level Knights Bachelor - an appointment, for men only, which originates from the medieval period Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) - for those who have a prominent but lesser role at national level or a leading role at regional level Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE) - those who have a major local role in any activity, including people whose work has made them known nationally Member of the Order of the British Empire (MBE) - recognises outstanding achievements or service to the community with a significant long-term impact British Empire Medal (BEM) - reintroduced in 2012 by the then-prime minister David Cameron as part of his bid to make the honours system 'classless', saying too few people making a difference in their areas were made MBEs. Who is on the King's Birthday Honours list? There are a number of famous faces recgonised in this year's King's Birthday Honours list. These include TV stars Claudia Winkleman and Strictly Come Dancing co-host Tess Daly, both awarded MBEs for services to broadcasting. Winkleman, 53, said she is "incredibly grateful" for honour. She added: 'It's a real privilege to work with extraordinarily talented people and I have only got this because of them. So this is for the BBC, the traitors and the faithful, for pianos and for the cha cha. 'I will buy a hat and am taking my mum. I am ridiculously lucky and will celebrate with Tess by doing a paso doble.' Various sports stars have been recognised too, including Sir David Beckham, and England darts players Luke Littler and Luke Humphries. David Beckham is set to receive a knighthood in the King's Birthday Honours list! 🎖️ — Sky Sports (@SkySports) June 6, 2025 Sir David, who has been in the running for a knighthood for more than a decade, said in a statement to the PA news agency: 'Growing up in east London with parents and grandparents who were so patriotic and proud to be British, I never could have imagined I would receive such a truly humbling honour. 'To have played for and captained my country was the greatest privilege of my career, and literally a boyhood dream come true. 'Off the pitch I have been fortunate to have the opportunity to represent Britain around the world and work with incredible organisations that are supporting communities in need and inspiring the next generation. Recommended reading: 'I'm so lucky to be able to do the work that I do and I'm grateful to be recognised for work that gives me so much fulfilment. 'It will take a little while for the news to sink in but I'm immensely proud and it's such an emotional moment for me to share with my family.' Other stars recognised include The Who singer Roger Daltrey, actor Gary Oldman and former MP Penny Mordaunt.
Evening Standard
3 hours ago
- Evening Standard
Author Dame Pat Barker thought honours letter was income tax bill
She added: 'One of the things that, in spite of everything, I like about the British honour system is the way it records people who do very low profile, working for free, long hours, weeks, months, years, for something that they genuinely believe in and usually unpaid, and for the benefit of other people, and they are the bedrock of the honour system, and they actually are the reason why it is so respected, and knights and dames are just cherries on the top of that cake.
