How the Club World Cup might reshape SA rugby strategies
The URC could take a backseat as South African teams chase a potentially lucrative Club World Cup spot, writes SIMON BORCHARDT.
SA Rugby CEO Rian Oberholzer was spot-on when he said the introduction of a Club World Cup will force South African franchises to take the Champions Cup seriously.
The Club World Cup, set to occur every four years starting in 2028, will feature 16 teams: Eight from the Champions Cup, seven from Super Rugby Pacific and one from Japan Rugby League One. Had it taken place this season, South African teams would have been absent, having failed to reach the Champions Cup quarter-finals. This was largely because the Bulls, Sharks and Stormers prioritised the URC, a more realistic competition for them to win, while their squad depth was tested by injuries.
Since becoming eligible for Europe's top tournament in 2022/23, SA sides have often selected 'B teams' for away matches in the Champions Cup group stage while fielding their best players for home fixtures. The strategy has been to win both home games, which typically secures a spot in the 16-team play-offs.
However, the Bulls took this approach further last season when coach Jake White controversially left 14 first-choice players in Pretoria for their Champions Cup quarter-final against Northampton in England, prioritising rest for a home URC match against Munster a week later. The Bulls lost 59-22 to Saints, prompting accusations that White disrespected the competition. He denied this, arguing he couldn't risk key players needed for the backend of the URC.
This season, the Bulls lost both away group matches – 27-5 to Saracens and 49-10 to Castres – after fielding weakened teams. Having also lost their first home match, 30-21 to Northampton, the Bulls' Champions Cup play-off hopes were over going into their final group clash against Stade Francais at Loftus, which they won 48-7 to qualify for the second-tier Challenge Cup play-offs.
The Sharks followed a similar pattern. A full-strength team defeated Exeter 39-21 in Durban but couldn't overcome defending champions Toulouse. In between, a second-string side was thrashed 56-17 by Leicester at Welford Road, with coach John Plumtree defending his selections, saying: 'South African players are treated like robots.' Further humiliation followed with a 66-12 loss in Bordeaux. Like the Bulls, the Sharks qualified for the Challenge Cup play-offs but sent what was effectively a Currie Cup team to Lyon (without Plumtree) and predictably relinquished the title they won last season.
The Stormers, meanwhile, failed to qualify for either the Champions Cup or Challenge Cup play-offs – a blessing in disguise for coach John Dobson, who could give his injury-hit squad a much-needed week off.
White, Plumtree and Dobson have all rightly noted that South African teams lack the depth to compete seriously in both the URC and Champions Cup, and with a stronger chance of winning the URC, prioritising it makes sense.
However, the 2027/28 season may change this. To compete against teams like Leinster, Toulouse, the Crusaders, and Chiefs in the inaugural Club World Cup, SA teams must finish among the top eight in the Champions Cup, with potentially lucrative financial incentives for the new tournament making it irresistible.
Also read: Rugby needs Club World Cup – Oberholzer
As a result, SA sides may go all-out in the Champions Cup during a Club World Cup season, potentially settling for a top-eight URC finish rather than chasing a top-two spot and a home semi-final.
In non-Club World Cup years, however, this shift is unlikely unless SA franchises can expand their squads with quality players. This would require a significant increase in the R95m salary cap (approximately €4.6m), which pales in comparison to, for example, Toulouse's €49m budget for the 2024/25 season.
The post Club World Cup big carrot for SA teams appeared first on SA Rugby magazine.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
15 minutes ago
- IOL News
Hugo Broos' backup brigade: five players who must impress in Bafana Bafana friendlies
BAFANA Bafana coach Hugo Broos will be looking to expand his player pool in the upcoming two friendlies. | BackpagePix Image: Backpagepix Bafana Bafana have been on an upward trend and will be eager to maintain their impressive form when they face Mozambique and Tanzania in two upcoming international friendlies. The first match kicks off this Wednesday against Mozambique at the New Peter Mokaba Stadium (3pm kick-off). Coach Hugo Broos will be without several key players, particularly those from Mamelodi Sundowns, who are preparing for the upcoming FIFA Club World Cup in the United States, which begins in under two weeks. This presents Broos with an ideal chance to test the depth of his squad and provide fringe players an opportunity to stake a claim. Here's a look at five players who need to make a strong impression: Sipho Chaine Orlando Pirate's Sipho Chaine celebrates his team's third goal during their league game against Kaizer Chiefs in March ORLANDO Pirates goalkeeper Sipho Chaine is one player who has put up his hand with the absence of Ronwen Williams at Bafana Bafana. | AFP Image: AFP The Orlando Pirates goalkeeper has been biding his time behind Ronwen Williams, who is firmly established as the national team's first-choice keeper. With Williams unavailable, Chaine now has the chance to impress Broos and possibly challenge for the number one spot. The 28-year-old has shown steady improvement under Jose Riveiro and played a key role in Pirates' recent successes. Now, with a rare opportunity at the international level, Chaine must deliver standout performances in these friendlies to put real pressure on Williams. Mbekezeli Mbokazi One to keep an eye on Orlando Pirates defender Mbekezeli Mbokazi has received his maiden call-up to the national team by Bafana Bafana head coach Hugo Broos. Photo: BackpagePix Image: BackpagePix At just 19, Mbokazi has captured the attention of the South African football world after being promoted from the reserve team to the Buccaneers' senior squad, where he hardly put a foot wrong in the few appearances he made for the Sea Robbers last season. Touted as a future star, Mbokazi has already featured in high-stakes matches and could be in line for his international debut. Should he get a run, these friendlies will test whether he can replicate his club form on the international stage. Oswin Appollis Oswin Appollis of Polokwane City. Image: Backpagepix It hasn't been the smoothest season for the versatile midfielder, whose Polokwane City side just secured a top-eight finish on the final day of the campaign with a goalless draw against Kaizer Chiefs. However, Broos has previously shown faith in players who may be out of form, helping them rediscover their best. Appollis will be hoping for similar support as he aims to return to top shape and prove his worth in the national setup. Patrick Maswanganyi Orlando Pirates midfielder Patrick Maswanganyi. Orlando Pirates midfielder Patrick Maswanganyi. Image: Ayanda Ndamane/Independent Newspapers One of the most consistent performers for Orlando Pirates in the 2024/25 season, Maswanganyi has already made a few appearances for Bafana, including scoring his first international goal against Uganda in an AFCON qualifier last November. With uncertainty surrounding Themba Zwane's future at Sundowns, Maswanganyi now has a golden chance to make the attacking midfield position his own, especially with vital World Cup qualifiers on the horizon. Thabo Moloisane STELLENBOSCH defence marshall Thabo Moloisane among the new faces in the Bafana Bafana suqad. | BackpagePix Image: BackpagePix
IOL News
44 minutes ago
- IOL News
Gamesmanship or disrespect? 'The Wink' that sparked a rugby debate
Sharks scrumhalf Jaden Hendrikse was at the centre of a controversial moment during the place-kicking contest against Munster after giving a gamesmanship wink to opponent Jack Crowley, as he lined up for a crucial kick, during their URC quarter-finals clash. Photo: Backpagepix Image: Backpagepix The incident involving Sharks scrumhalf Jaden Hendrikse and that wink towards Munster opponent Jack Crowley, as the flyhalf lined up a kick at goal during their United Rugby Championship quarter-final this past Saturday, raises serious questions about sportsmanship and the spirit of rugby. While such moments may appear minor or even amusing to some, they strike at the core of what distinguishes rugby from many other sports, especially football: its great culture of respect. "The Wink", which looked harmless on the surface, represented a subtle yet intentional act of gamesmanship that undermines the integrity and sportsmanship that rugby prides itself on. Of course, it's caused widespread division and arguments for and against it. However, at the core of the sport's values is mutual respect – between opponents, for referees, and for the game itself. One of the most sacred moments in rugby is the goal-kicking process. You would hear a stadium announcer throughout SA venues at least announce, 'respect the kicker'. It is a moment that requires concentration, mental discipline, and silence – not just from the crowd but from opposing players as well. And although home teams can't control the boos emanating from their spectators, they can regulate their players. Disruptive behaviour during a kick at goal, whether verbal or non-verbal, is widely regarded as poor sportsmanship. Hendrikse's wink, although not a direct physical or verbal interference, was a deliberate act to distract or unnerve Crowley. That subtle provocation crosses a line. And after Crowley slotted his kick, it just made the act all that poorer. Imagine attempting to distract someone during a kick, only for them to successfully convert it. You look like the fool then. Some may argue that Hendrikse's action was a little bit of clever gamesmanship during his treatment for cramping. And yes, he cramped up after playing almost two hours of rugby. However, the line between gamesmanship and disrespect is a thin one. When players begin to push against those boundaries, it erodes the values that rugby relies on. If such behaviour becomes part of the game, it could open the door to further acts of subtle taunting, mind games, or even overt disrespect. That is a slippery slope that could eventually cheapen the sport. Yes, players chirp and try to get under each other's skin for 80 minutes, even after scoring tries. And the Irish are no saints when it comes to this type of behaviour during games. They are after all called masters of the dark arts, especially when it comes to the breakdown and slowing possession of their opponents. But what happens when a goal-kicker kicks at goals, there is a sense of respect for that kicker with no chirps or winks when he lines the ball up.
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Jaden Hendrikse's cheeky wink reminds us that rugby needs characters, not robots
Rugby's struggle for global superstars is evident, as seen in the contrasting reactions to Jaden Hendrikse's sly wink and Northampton's Henry Pollock's flamboyant celebrations. Rugby needs larger-than-life personalities to grow the game. 'Winkgate' stole the headlines after Saturday's United Rugby Championship (URC) quarterfinal clash between the Sharks and Munster, which the South African side won 6-4 by place-kicking shootout after the sides were tied 24-24 after 100 minutes of rugby. It didn't take too much to divert the attention from a match that, outside of the first place-kicking shootout in URC history, offered very little in terms of extended quality entertainment while the referee's clock was running in regular time and the 20 minutes of extra time. But a cheeky wink by one of the kickers in the place-kicking shootout, Jaden Hendrikse, aimed at Munster flyhalf Jack Crowley spurred a few days of social media outbursts from rugby fans globally, calling the act 'unsportmanlike' and 'against the values of the game', along with plenty more unsavoury comments directed towards the Sharks scrumhalf. It even drew a reaction from Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus on X. The social media fallout was largely excessive for an event so frivolous, but it was not uncharacteristic for rugby as a sport, whose loudest voices can evidently be self-righteous of the behaviour of its athletes. Rugby has so few global superstars – unlike soccer, tennis or even basketball – and it does itself no favours by attempting to suppress the personalities of its players on the field. Superstars Northampton Saints backrow Henry Pollock also attracted headlines in recent weeks for his eccentric try celebrations throughout his side's sublime run to the final of the Champions Cup. His celebration – by holding two fingers to his neck, as if to check his pulse – in the Champions Cup semifinal against Leinster drew the most attention. Especially from opponents. Several players from the tournament winning team, the Bordeaux-Bègles, including French flyhalf Matthieu Jalibert and Bègles head coach Yannick Bru, posed for pictures in the same fashion after the final – mocking Pollock's celebration after defeating his side. Pollock doesn't fit into the traditional mould of English rugby players. He is full of flair and exudes confidence, which some may argue as arrogance, on and off the field. But he's a personality that rugby so desperately needs and shouldn't try to suppress, akin to the attempts to stifle Hendrikse. Although, as someone seemingly carrying the torch for rugby players who are a little bit different, being on the receiving end of banter from opponents is to be expected. However, to be slammed by critics for antics – completely within the laws of the game – does nothing to grow the game. Instead, it marginalises players who are a bit different, when it could be used to leverage new fans to the game. Rugby has very few superstars — which are needed to draw new eyes to the sport. French star Antoine Dupont is one of them. US women's Sevens star Ilona Maher is another, for different reasons. Dupont, one of the best players in the world and already a French icon, starred at the Olympic Games for the French Sevens team last year in their gold-medal run. He ensured the limelight was shone even brighter on a sport often considered a little brother to the 15s version. While Maher has more followers than 5 million followers on Instagram — more than any other rugby player in the world — she uses the platform to showcase her personality and the behind-the-scenes action of what being a professional rugby player is like. Maher had a short stint with the Bristol Bears in the United Kingdom at the start of the year and her debut match set a new attendance record for the Bears. Stars bring fans to stadiums and new eyes to the game that desperately needs it. Growing the game Rugby has a massive following in South Africa, with the national team currently enjoying its most successful period in history aiding that. But across the globe, the sport is largely niche with other sports such as soccer and cricket dwarfing rugby in every metric. World Rugby launched several attempts to grow the game and amends its laws almost annually in an attempt to make the game more entertaining to increase its supporter base. But evidently what generates fans, especially new ones, are heroes and interesting characters — such as Dupont, Maher and Pollock. Hendrikse has neither displayed the same larger-than-life personality as the latter two in his five-year professional rugby career to date nor is he quite the superstar that Dupont is, but on Saturday he was cheeky. Although his impudence generally does not extend any further than that of any other scrumhalf. Munster scrumhalf Conor Murray, for example, shook Bradley Davids's hand to 'wish him well' before he took the kick to win the match for the Sharks — not too dissimilar from the gamesmanship that takes place in soccer before a penalty is taken. It's the way sport works. Teams find the tiniest opportunity to find a mental edge, especially in a match where the margins between victory and defeat were evidently so small. These actions should be embraced, it adds an additional layer to the game and simultaneously deepens rivalries — both elements that are positive to growing the game. Although, as with shifting away from the customs of any activity in society, the forebearers often bear the brunt of criticism while paving the way for the next generation. DM
