Apple's UK encryption legal challenge heard behind closed doors
A hearing in Apple's legal battle with the UK government over access to customer data was held behind closed doors on Friday after the press failed to gain entry to proceedings.
The US tech firm has launched an appeal with the investigatory powers tribunal after the Home Office demanded access to encrypted data stored remotely in Apple's cloud servers.
UK media organisations including the Guardian, the BBC, the Financial Times and Computer Weekly made a submission to the tribunal asking for press access on public interest grounds but they failed to gain entry.
Sir James EadieKC, who represents the government in high-profile cases, was seen entering the courtroom at the Royal Courts of Justice on Friday.
Apple is fighting a technology capability notice issued under the Investigatory Powers Act, which requires companies to assist law enforcement in providing evidence. The notice demanded access to Apple's Advanced Data Protection (ADP) service, which heavily encrypts personal data stored remotely in its servers.
Apple refused and has challenged the order at the tribunal, which investigates whether the domestic intelligence services have acted unlawfully. It also withdrew ADP from the UK last month, saying: 'We have never built a backdoor or master key to any of our products or services and we never will.'
ADP uses end-to-end encryption, which means only the account holder can decrypt the files. Messaging services like iMessage and FaceTime remain end-to-end encrypted by default.
The government's secret legal demand is officially known as a technical capability notice. Recipients of a TCN cannot reveal the existence of an order unless they are given permission from the home secretary. The tribunal's website states that hearings should be closed to the public only when 'strictly necessary', but its rules declare there must be no disclosure of information that is 'prejudicial to national security'.
On Thursday, a group of Democratic and Republican lawmakers in the US called on the tribunal to 'remove the cloak of secrecy' around the UK government's order and to make Friday's hearing, as well as any further proceedings, public.
Bloomberg reported on Thursday that British officials had initiated talks with their US counterparts over the order. The UK has reportedly assured the US that it is not seeking blanket access and would only seek data related to serious crimes such as terrorism and child sexual abuse.
The Home Office has been asked for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
2 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Powys council to consider Home Office asylum seeker deal
Powys County Council is to consider a proposal from the Home Office which would see it get a boost to its housing budget in return for supporting asylum seekers. In a meeting of the cabinet next week, councillors will consider a pilot scheme being proposed by the Home Office which could increase support for the county's housing budget from Government funds. The paper recommends the cabinet puts forward a non-binding 'expression of interest' in the scheme on behalf of Powys County Council along with Carmarthenshire and Monmouthshire, to participate in the Home Office Asylum Dispersal Pilot. The plan would see the council buying or building new homes backed by Government money, then leasing them to the Home Office for 10 years before they return to the council's own estate. The Home Office would 'provide capital funding to Local Authorities to increase accommodation supply (of various types) in the medium-term (next 2-5 years)'. This would be through the 'purchase and renovation, or construction of new homes, including where practical on Local Authority owned land'. The Council would then 'lease the properties, which it would own, to the Home Office at Local Housing Allowance (LHA) rates for a 10-year term', with Powys County Council 'regaining control of the properties after this when Home Office demand should be reducing following the implementation of wider initiatives.' It is thought this model 'will support a net increase' in the Powys County Council's own housing portfolio 'as well as add to the net availability of homes in each area where this model is taken forward'. The paper adds that 'should any new development of homes follow it is anticipated such projects would be funded by the Home Office and not incur costs to the Council but would ultimately lead to an increase in the Council's housing portfolio.' It is thought the plan would relieve one of the large financial pressures on Powys County Council which, the report says, has an estimated a budget gap of more than £60m over the next five years. it would cut the need for high-cost temporary accommodation currently being used for people on the social housing wait list. The boost in housing stock would also allow 'for quicker permanent housing to be offered to those in need of a home' and 'increase council tax revenue through a net increase in the number of homes in the county.' Help support trusted local news Sign up for a digital subscription now: As a digital subscriber you will get Unlimited access to the County Times website Advert-light access Reader rewards Full access to our app The council would also have more of a say where people would be housed with the paper adding the council would be 'in a better position to shape the future design of asylum dispersal, especially in rural areas, as an alternative to having to comply with Home Office directives which may not be so sensitive to local need'. The paper adds that: 'The provision of accommodation and support for asylum seekers and refugees is a complex matter, which to be undertaken equitably and safely benefits from understanding and empathy across communities and neighbourhoods.' It goes on to stress that 'the Council, both officers and members, as an accountable public service, has a role to play in helping dispel rumours and misinformation about such matters and encourage a greater understanding within our communities'.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
UK taxpayers face extra costs as France plans Channel small boat interceptions
British taxpayers will be expected to contribute more money to stop irregular migration as the French government prepares to halt small boats carrying asylum seekers even if they are already at sea. It is understood there will be extra costs associated with the scheme to tackle boats within 300 metres of the shore – including paying for police, boats and drones – which the UK will be asked to share with France. The development comes as a refugee charity that successfully intervened to stop the UK sending boats back to France said it would explore legal avenues to stop the latest tactic. It is understood the French government is braced for court challenges. Home Office officials confirmed on Wednesday that the French government hoped to launch interventions in the Channel and in nearby waterways in July. It follows increasing use by traffickers of 'taxi boats', which pick up asylum seekers a few hundred yards from the shore before taking them to the UK. The strategy aims to be ready in time for the Franco-British summit, which begins on 8 July. This coincides with the state visit to London of Emmanuel Macron, the French president. The scheme is intended to give the French authorities the power to halt dinghies that 'taxi' up to beaches from nearby waterways. Current guidelines prevent French police from intervening offshore unless it is to rescue passengers in distress. In practice, the policy means officers can stop boats leaving the beach by puncturing them, but are restricted once they are in the water. The French government has changed the framework so that its officers can now operate in shallow waters up to 300 metres from the coast, allowing them to intercept 'taxi boats'. The UK government will be expected by Paris to contribute further funds to help pay for more officers and equipment along the coast. The UK signed a £480m deal two years ago to pay for additional border patrols and surveillance equipment such as drones and night-vision binoculars. But government sources pointed out that Keir Starmer agreed a deal with Macron at the start of the year to increase measures to halt Channel crossings. This led to a formal agreement a month later under which the UK extended its deal to pay for policing French beaches in return for new measures to stem the flow of boats. France could seek extra funds from the UK for the Compagnie de Marche, a specialist unit of enforcement officers operating on beaches to tackle the people-smuggling trade. Announced in February this year and allocated £2.2m from existing funds, the unit's officers have public order powers to apprehend smugglers and intercept crossings. The unit could be expanded, it is understood. Violent confrontations on French beaches have increased. In a recent incident, French officers confronting a suspect were sprayed with petrol and told they would be set alight unless they backed off. France is expanding its naval forces with six new patrol boats that can rescue migrants and intercept 'taxi boats' before they leave for the UK, the Telegraph reported. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion The French government is expecting legal challenges to come from charities and NGOs, either through the French or European courts. A British charity that operates in France has said it plans to explore possible legal challenges to stop the tactic. Steve Smith, the chief executive of Care4Calais, said: 'When the last Tory government tried to do pushbacks in the Channel, Care4Calais initiated a legal challenge and won. Any attempt to introduce interceptions in French waters must face the same level of resistance. Anything that puts human lives at risk must be opposed, including considering all legal avenues to defeat it.' The UK government has suggested that improved weather conditions may be a factor behind the sharp rise in small boat crossings so far this year. According to official figures, 11,074 people crossed the Channel on small boats before May – nearly 50% more than during the same period in 2024. A Home Office report links this increase to a greater number of 'red days' – when weather and sea conditions are more likely to allow for small boat journeys. Between January and April, there were 60 such days, compared with 27 last year. More than 1,100 migrants crossed the Channel on Saturday, official data shows, the highest number recorded in a single day so far in 2025. It brings the provisional total of people making the perilous journey so far this year to 14,811.
NBC News
3 hours ago
- NBC News
How to buy refurbished tech from Apple, Amazon and more
The latest and greatest tech is usually pretty expensive. Premium prices plus ongoing uncertainty around tariffs has made a lot of people naturally hesitant to invest hundreds (or thousands) of dollars in a new phone or laptop. One of the easiest ways to save money on tech products is by buying them used or refurbished. A refurbished device is one that is 'returned, repaired or restored to a like-new condition,' says Ozzy Russell, former operations manager at Back in the Box, a New Jersey tech refurbisher and seller. We explain everything you need to know about used and refurbished products, plus share a few of the biggest and best retailers marketplaces to shop. Selected. Our top picks What does refurbished mean? People often confuse refurbished, used and open-box products as the same thing. Adding to that confusion are sub-categories like factory refurbished and certified refurbished. Below is a brief explanation of the differences between these categories, according to Russell. Used and pre-owned: These items are returned by a previous owner and may show signs of wear and tear. Typically, they do not come with a warranty, and often have not been tested to see if they work perfectly. Open-box: Near-new products with little or no signs of wear. These products are quick returns from customers, display models from stores or products with damaged packaging. They may or may not include accessories or warranty. Refurbished: Returned products that are repaired or restored to a like-new condition through part replacement and inspection. Refurbished products are often tested by professionals to make sure they perform as advertised, and typically come with a warranty. Certified refurbished: These are returned products that are repaired or restored with a more intensive inspection and certification process. Certified refurbished products are sold by the original manufacturer or an authorized partner of the manufacturer. They often come with extended warranty and return periods. How I picked the best sites to shop refurbished I focused on marketplaces selling certified refurbished products because they 'meet strict quality standards set by the manufacturer and are often indistinguishable from new products in terms of performance and appearance,' says Russell. I also put emphasis on the following perks: Warranty and return: I highlighted marketplaces that offer a warranty period or return policy in case of any unexpected issues with the product. Product selection: Most popular marketplaces sell a variety of certified refurbished electronics, including smart phones, gaming consoles, home goods and cameras. Accessories: We only chose retailers that include necessary accessories like charging and power cables in the box. The best sites to buy refurbished tech Most of our favorite refurbished retailers are larger online retailers and marketplaces like Apple, Amazon and EBay. Best for Apple products: Apple Certified Refurbished What we like: In-house testing Mint condition products Something to note: Pricier than other storefronts Short return policy If you're looking to save money on Apple products, look into Apple's certified refurbished storefront. Buying directly from Apple means the device has been refurbished and tested by Apple's team, according to the brand. All Apple certified refurbished products come with a new battery, new outer shell and relevant accessories in the box. 'These iPhones typically have the highest level of quality assurance and customer support,' says Russell. All of the certified refurbished products come with free shipping and returns. It's also important to note that Apple's certified refurbished storefront has a limited stock of products, and is often more expensive than other refurbished storefronts. Product offered: Apple products | Warranty: 1 year | Return policy: 14 days | Shipping: free | Conditions offered: mint | Accessories: manufacturer included Best shopping experience: Back Market What we like: Easy to use website Great product selection Something to note: Nothing at this time Back Market is an online storefront that only sells certified refurbished tech products — that makes it easier to navigate than most other storefronts. Brands and products are sensibly organized, and you can easily select the condition and configuration of most devices on the site. That means instead of having to scroll through a huge list of iPads, I can easily select one model and choose my preferred color and spec options from there. I was sent a refurbished iPad Air (4th Generation) from Back Market to try out. Labeled as 'excellent' condition, it felt like a brand-new product to me. It had no visible blemishes, knicks or scratches, had a healthy battery and performed as expected, and continues to work great after two years of use. Most items on Back Market are sold through third-party sellers who pass Back Market's screening process. Back Market also has a specific certified renewed page for products that are refurbished and sold directly from manufacturers. Best warranty: EBay Certified Refurbished What we like: Huge selection of products Long warranty Something to note: Nothing at this time You might associate eBay with bidding on used items, but the storefront now has many new ways to shop including its certified refurbished program, which sells electronics, household tools, cameras and sporting goods, to name a few. These items come with a two year Allstate SquareTrade warranty — it's a third-party warranty, but the longest of our top picks. EBay also has a lengthy 30-day return policy. All of its certified refurbished products are in 'pristine, like-new' condition, according to the brand. Product offered: electronics, home goods, auto parts, etc. | Warranty: 2 years, third party | Return policy: 30 days | Shipping: free | Conditions offered: pristine like-new | Accessories: original or new, generic included Widest product selection: Amazon Renewed What we like: Wide product selection Generous return policy Something to note: No manufacturer warranty Hard to navigate website Amazon Renewed has a huge selection of certified refurbished electronics including smartphones, earbuds, office products and cameras. All products sold on Amazon Renewed are professionally inspected and tested to ensure they work as expected by an Amazon performance-managed supplier, according to the brand. Amazon Renewed hosts many third-party sellers, but Amazon ensures that their third-party sellers meet certain criteria to sell on Amazon Renewed. Amazon Renewed products do not come with manufacturer warranty. Instead, they come with either a one year or 90 day return policy, depending on the item's condition. Product offered: electronics, home goods, outdoor tools, etc. | Warranty: n/a | Return policy: one year for premium condition products, 90 days for all other conditions | Shipping: Varies | Conditions offered: premium, excellent, good, acceptable | Accessories: generic or original manufacturer included Other places to shop certified refurbished Samsung Certified Re-Newed What we like: In-house testing and parts Something to note: Pricier than other storefronts Samsung sells older generations of their popular Galaxy smartphones refurbished via its Certified Re-Newed page. Like Apple certified refurbished, these smartphones are refurbished by Samsung, in a Samsung facility, with Samsung parts, according to the brand. All Samsung Re-Newed products come with a one year warranty and a 28-day free return period. Best Buy Geek Squad Certified Refurbished What we like: In-house refurbishing Home or store delivery options Something to note: Possible restocking fees All of Best Buy's Geek Squad certified refurbished products are refurbished by Best Buy staff. The retailer sells electronics like Apple products, headphones and computer accessories and you can ship items to your address or a nearby Best Buy store. Walmart Restored What we like: Wide product categories Competitive prices Something to note: No manufacturer warranty Hard to navigate website Similar to Amazon Renewed, Walmart Restored sells certified refurbished products that have been handled by third party sellers who are accepted and managed by Walmart. Only a select group of Walmart sellers can participate in the program, according to the brand's FAQ page. The brand sells products across categories like tech, appliances and TVs. How to shop for refurbished tech One of the main reasons we focused on certified refurbished tech is confidence. Certified refurbished tech undergoes a more intensive repair and inspection process than returned, open-box and other used conditions. When shopping for certified refurbished products Russell recommends you: Choose a reputable seller: Many marketplaces host third-party sellers with customer reviews you can read. Look for sellers with lots of positive, recent reviews. Check the item's condition: Most marketplaces sell items in different conditions ranging from fair to excellent, although the specific wording may vary. Read up on what these cosmetic conditions mean for each marketplace. Check the age of the product: Old tech products, especially smartphones that rely on software updates, can have issues running current software and hardware, says Russell. This might lead to reduced longevity and more everyday issues over time. Verify details like warranty and return policy: Both policies can be helpful if you need to return and exchange a refurbished product. Inspect your item on arrival: When you receive your refurbished item, be sure to look it over thoroughly. If you find issues that were not mentioned in the listing, contact the seller as soon as possible, says Russell. Meet our expert At NBC Select, we work with experts who have specialized knowledge and authority based on relevant training and/or experience. We also take steps to ensure all expert advice and recommendations are made independently and without undisclosed financial conflicts of interest. Why trust NBC Select? I am a reporter at NBC Select who covers technology and fitness including recent stories on smartwatches, over ear headphones and more. For this piece, I spoke with a professional tech refurbisher and seller to better understand the process and online retailers available. I also own many used and refurbished tech products purchased from different marketplaces.
