Repetition, repetition and more repetition: Why the GAA are ditching the 'Super 16' format
For a man who bemoaned the imminent departure of the 'Super 16' before the Ulster final, Kieran McGeeney didn't sound completely chuffed with it after yet another agonising defeat.
'We've been in the group of death for the past two years, so what's a third one?' he mentioned of Armagh's fate meeting Derry, Dublin and Galway after losing to Donegal last Sunday week.
'It's a tough one.'
Once more, Armagh and their manager will front up. This weekend, they face Derry in the round-robin stages for the second year in a row, the third consecutive season they have faced Ulster opposition in this phase of the championship.
Over the same period, Kerry have faced just one northern team, Monaghan last year.
McGeeney's point about the current format is that it works.
'Leave the bloody thing alone – it was the best format ever,' he said earlier this year. 'Going on about jeopardy, you talk to any manager or any player… the Super 16s? You were worried about every score, never mind every game. Every point was important because right up until the last game you could be sitting top, you lose the last game you could be down to third. It's nonsense.'
But leaving aside McGeeney's masochism, there are some extremely good reasons why the GAA have decided to ditch it in favour of an enhanced qualifier system next season:
1. Repeat fixtures, repeat results.
As the only repeat fixture avoided in the draw is a provincial final meeting, the format has thrown up a number of quick rematches: the Cork-Kerry clash on Sunday week comes six weeks after the counties's Munster semi-final, while Cavan meet Tyrone next month having previously contested an Ulster quarter-final in April. Those games follow Donegal-Tyrone and Roscommon-Mayo last year and in 2023 Dublin-Kildare and Tyrone-Monaghan. In those four rematches, none of the teams beaten in the provincial clash has exacted revenge, Monaghan coming closest by drawing their All-Ireland game. The last team to avenge a provincial result in the All-Ireland series was Armagh against Donegal three years ago.
2. Repeat pairings.
Next month, Armagh will face Galway in the group stages for the third consecutive year, their fifth SFC meeting since 2022. Louth and Monaghan are joined again and also for the second year in a row, Ulster champions Donegal commence their All-Ireland pursuit with a home game against Tyrone. By beating Meath last Sunday week, Louth avoided a third year facing Kerry.
3. Repeatedly unfair.
This weekend's eight teams only have a one-week turnaround to their Round 2 fixtures whereas their opponents have enjoyed a two-week break. Of the 16 Round 2 results in 2023 and '24 Round 2 results, the team with the shortest preparation period won seven times and several of them were no surprises.
4. Repeatedly unfair Mark II.
As we know, this structure was effectively killed off when Derry and Roscommon last year earned their place in the knock-out stages off the back of one victory in four championship games. Monaghan, who added a draw to their sole victory, weren't much better in their qualification. Although they have better chances to win more than once this time around especially Monaghan, that remains a possibility for Derry and Gabriel Bannigan's men.
5. Repeatedly predictable.
The group stages have become a little formulaic these past couple of seasons. In both 2023 and '24, Armagh, Dublin and Kerry earned automatic All-Ireland quarter-final places, while five of the eight preliminary quarter-final spots were populated on both occasions by Cork, Galway, Mayo, Monaghan and Roscommon. Armagh and Dublin obviously can't both go straight through to the last-eight this year but otherwise it could be more of the same.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Rory McIlroy scraps his way to making cut at US Open
The script turned nasty for the two pals, as Rory McIlroy and Shane Lowry – who'd started this 125th US Open with genuine ambitions – were cast as fall guys, forced to find an escape route out of an examination that asked one tough question after another. McIlroy survived. Lowry didn't. Frustration was evident in their behaviour as the pressure mounted, hole by hole, shot by shot. In McIlroy's case, it was a club throw down on the 12th hole after an iron approach to the Par 5 turned so that the ball nestled into the gnarly rough. The two-handed toss of the 3-iron some 20 yards down the fairway left nobody watching in any doubt as to his utter frustration. READ MORE On the 17th, it surfaced again when he smashed his 3-wood into the tee marker after pushing his shot into a greenside bunker, short-siding himself. There was a pair of them in it, sharing the frustration of the game; and the course! For Lowry, his frazzled mind played tricks on him. On the 14th green, he inexplicably bent down to pick up his ball without marking, a one stroke penalty for his actions turning what was a bogey into a double-bogey. Not that it truly mattered at that juncture, as Lowry's fate was well and truly sealed by then after a start to his round that saw him go bogey-double bogey-bogey-bogey in his opening four holes. Shane Lowry of Ireland reacts to a bunker shot on the second hole during the second round of the US Open. Photograph:Somehow, McIlroy found a way to survive into the weekend. The task proved beyond Lowry. McIlroy ensured he would be around for the weekend – some nine shots behind 36-holes leader Sam Burns – after signing for a second round 72 for six-over-par 146, a shot inside the cutline. McIlroy showed his class when it matted on the Par 4 18th, standing on the tee box on the cutline, he unleashed a drive of 372 yards down the middle of the fairway and hit an approach in to five feet for a birdie. He calmly rolled in the putt, and gave a sigh of relief. It hadn't started so well. McIlroy could hardly afford to put a foot wrong in his bid to, firstly, make the cut, and, secondly, to try to play his way back into the championship. Rory McIlroy throws his club on the 12th hole during the second round of the US Open. Photograph:The misstep, though, came right from the off: his driver, so often the foundation in a season that has already claimed him three titles – the Pebble Beach pro-am, The Players and the Masters – was disobedient from the get-go, finding a fairway bunker down the left of the first hole as McIlroy started the second round with a double-bogey six. If that misdemeanour put McIlroy on the back foot from the off, worse was to follow. Another double-bogey six followed in quickstep time, on the third hole. This time, McIlroy's drive found a fairway bunker down the right. Having started his round four-over from an opening round 74, the world number two's challenge to survive had doubled before he knew it. A birdie from 30 feet on the ninth hole at least gave McIlroy some hope as he turned for home, only for another tee shot on the 11th to sneak into a fairway bunker down the left which led to another bogey. The club toss on 12 graphically showcased his frustration, where he would par the Par 5. Finally, McIlroy saw some light, as a 20-footer for birdie on the 15th brought him to 7-over for the championship (onto the cut line). Survival at least within reach. And he closed the deal magnificently on the final hole to get into the weekend's final two rounds and the chance to play pursuit of Burns and those ahead. Lowry, though, will have to wait until a return to Royal Portrush for next month's 153rd Open after a thoroughly disappointing return to Oakmont where he was runner-up in 2016. This time, a 78 second round to add to his opening 79 left him cast well adrift on 17-over-par 157.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Josh Honohan makes amends to secure Shamrock Rovers win over Shelbourne
LOI: Shelbourne 1 (Honohan OG 32) Shamrock Rovers 2 (Cleary 12, Honohan 83) When Josh Honohan's football career eventually stops rising, he will remember the month of June in 2025. Called into the Republic of Ireland squad for friendlies against Senegal and Luxembourg, a muscular injury sustained in training conspired to deny him a dream debut. An own goal appeared to cap a miserable week for the Cork man, until he blasted a late winner to silence the Tolka Park crowd and maintain Shamrock Rovers six-point lead at the top of the Premier Division . Shelbourne , the defending champions, are stranded in sixth, an gaping 12 points adrift of Rovers. READ MORE 'They know we're here, they know we're back,' said Shelbourne manager Damien Duff before kick-off. Maybe so, but it feels like Rovers' league to win again. Shelbourne manager Damien Duff during the game at Tolka Park. Photograph: Dan Clohessy/INpho Following a dreary international break, there were a bundle of stories bouncing around the scene this week. The managerial rivalry between Stephen Bradley and Duff has become as potent as the Ringsend derby itself, but the gaffers agreed on Friday that the break has refreshed their squads ahead of a busy summer of European football. Initially, Duff branded the pause as amateur. 'It came at the right time. The lads have had a chance to get fit, rest and focus on attacking the second half of the season.' They barely attacked the first half of this game. On 12 minutes, Shels' zonal marking at the set-piece was exposed by Jack Byrne's sumptuous free-kick as Dan Cleary timed his run across Mark Coyle to nod the ball into Conor Kearns' net. The goal silenced a lively full house and put Rovers firmly on course to capture a fifth title in six seasons. 'It's June,' Bradley reminded anyone willing to listen prematch. A long way to go, but still, the Hoops looked unbreakable with Pico Lopes taking no prisoners in defence. A lunging intercept by the Cape Verde international on 30 minutes denied John Martin a run on goal. Seconds later, the title race turned into a battle between Rovers and Bohemians, as Alan Reynolds' men were beating Cork City 2-0 at Turners' Cross. Shamrock Rovers' Dan Cleary celebrates scoring a goal. Photograph: Laszlo Geczo/Inpho Shelbourne equalised before half-time when a decent cross by Kameron Ledwidge led to Honohan's unforced error. If he was trying to score, it would have been a fine finish. Until Honohan's match winner, it had not been a great week. A random Galway United fan thought the defender was fair game for abuse during his solo session on the Stade de Luxembourg pitch after Ireland's 0-0 result last Tuesday. He reacted to that disappointment and the own goal by storming past Evan Caffrey into the Shels box, only for referee Robert Harvey to miss a blatant jersey tug by Caffrey. At 1-1, John Martin typified the game's intensity by chasing down a lost cause and denying Lee Grace from guiding the ball for a goal kick. Martin hurt himself making the tackle but he recovered to earn a yellow card for disrupting the subsequent throw-in. Duff was spitting fire on the line. By the turn, he had his sixth yellow card of the season after reacting to Coyle's booking for a foul on Danny Mandroiu after Lopes thundered through Kerr McInroy. That paragraph belongs in an All-Ireland Hurling final report. The unbridled passion might have something to do with Bradley being impressed by a recent leadership talk from Brian Cody. 'It was gold dust' said Bradley of the message imparted by the 11-time winning Kilkenny manager. Byrne continued to sprinkle his magic dust on the occasion, with a spinning delivery for Danny Grant to force a smart save by Kearns. Shamrock Rovers' Aaron McEneff. Photograph: Dan Clohessy/Inpho Shels maintained the pressure in the second half, with Byrne the latest to be cautioned for upending McInroy after Caffrey's shot was blocked by a clump of Rovers defenders. That was Shelbourne's first shot of the night. Rovers were already up to 11 efforts on goal, five finding the target. The lack of chances prompted Duff to unleash his usual strike force, Mipo Odubeko and Sean Boyd, but the tall forwards struggled to wrestle control from Cleary and Lopes. Cleary had a second headed goal disallowed on 70 minutes. Bradley and his players struggled to understand the match officials' reasoning. By then, Rovers had turned to Dylan Watts and Graham Burke to break the deadlock but it was Honohan who came forward to secure all three points. SHELBOURNE: Kearns; Gannon, Barrett, Wilson (Wood 69), Ledwidge, Norris; McInroy (Coote 81), Coyle (Lunney 69); Caffrey, Chapman (Boyd 58); Martin (Odubeko 58). SHAMROCK ROVERS: McGinty; Grant, Cleary, Lopes, Honohan (Clarke 86), Matthews (Grace 6); Healy, McEneff, Mandroiu (Burke 69), Byrne (Watts 69); Gaffney (Greene 69). Referee: Robert Harvey.
The 42
3 hours ago
- The 42
Kevin Holt equaliser rescues point for stuttering City as winless run stretches
Derry City 1 Galway United 1 SSE Airtricity Men's Premier Division KEVIN Holt's fortuitous equaliser clinched a point for Derry City against Galway as the Brandywell club's winless run stretched to four games. For the second game in succession Derry fell behind to an early penalty as David Hurley fired Galway in front from the spot on 10 minutes. Galway's lead lasted just eight minutes as Scottish defender Holt charged down Greg Cunnigham's clearance and the ball found the back of the net for his second of the season. The Candystripes did have plenty of chances to put the game beyond reach for the visitors at the end of the first half with Gavin Whyte and Danny Mullen missing glorious opportunities. There was little urgency or creativity from either side in a lacklustre second half and it proved a repeat of Galway's last visit to Foyleside, ending in a 1-1 draw. The result leaves Derry trailing leaders Shamrock Rovers by 11 points and desperate to find form ahead of a double-header in Dublin against Shelbourne and St Pat's. Sadou Diallo made his first appearance on the bench since returning from a broken arm sustained at the Sligo Showgrounds back in early March. Ronan Boyce made his first start since May 9th. Ben Doherty (thigh) and Cameron Dummigan (hamstring) missed out as Tiernan Lynch made two changes from the team which lost 1-0 against Bohemians prior to the break. Derry registered the first shot on target in the second minute but Duffy's 30 yard free-kick failed to trouble Evan Watts who saved comfortably. Two minutes later Galway should've done better when from Ed McCarthy's long throw-in, Hickey flicked it on and Dyer somehow fired over from six yards under pressure. At the other end Sam Todd crossed low across the face of goal and neither Duffy at the near post nor Gavin Whyte at the back could get a touch with the goal at their mercy. For the second match in succession Derry found themselves behind to an early penalty as referee Declan Toland penalised Kevin Holt for holding Dyer inside the six yard box. Advertisement David Hurley stepped up to take the spotkick and sent Brian Maher the wrong way to put the visitors in front with just 10 minutes gone. Derry fortuitously found themselves back on level terms on 18 minutes when Whyte's cross was hooked clear by Cunningham but bounced off the chest of Holt and into the net. Kevin Holt congratulated for his equaliser. Lorcan Doherty / INPHO Lorcan Doherty / INPHO / INPHO The Candystripes were warming to the occasion and Duffy came close to finding the far corner with a curling strike from the edge of the penalty area but it sailed narrowly wide on the half hour mark. Galway almost capitalised from a lovely move on the right flank when Jeannot Esua crossed first time into a crowded penalty area where Hickey out-jumped Hayden Cann but sent his glancing header agonisingly wide of the post. Danny Mullen fired over the crossbar from a promising Derry attack as the game began to open up less than 10 minutes before the break. Mullen really should've put the home side in front on 38 minutes Todd sent Duffy through with a neat first-time pass but when the winger over-ran the ball inside the box, Mullen took it off his feet and fired high over the bar with his left footed strike from 10 yards. It was a real let-off for the Tribesmen and Derry players will have been scratching their heads wondering how they weren't out of sight at the interval. Neither side could create anything of note for the opening 20 minutes of a stuttering second half. Tiernan Lynch went to his bench in an attempt to galvanise his team with Liam Boyce, Paul McMullan and Diallo – making his first appearance in 13 games – entering the fray. From a corner kick deep into stoppage time Connolly won the ball and found Cann who turned and shot high and wide which summed up the second half display. Derry City: Maher; Cann, Connolly, Holt; R. Boyce (Diallo 76), Winchester, O'Reilly, Whyte (McMullan 64), Todd; Duffy (Thomas 85), Mullen (L. Boyce 76). Galway United: Watts; Essua, Buckley, Byrne, Slevin, Cunningham (Brouder 46), Hurley (46), Hickey, Borden (McCormack 56), McCarthy (Walsh 85); Dyer (Shaw 88), Referee: Declan Toland.
