Illicit tobacco trade thrives as TTS fails to help curb violations
KARACHI: Inefficiency of the Track and Trace System (TTS) in the tobacco sector is causing huge losses to the tune of Rs400 billion to the national exchequer every year, industry experts said.
Sharing the Institute of Public Opinion Research's 2024 (IPOR) findings, they said the unchecked illicit tobacco trade thrives in Pakistani markets.
The study showed compliant brands follow all the requirements stipulated by the Government of Pakistan.
These requirements include having a Track and Trace Stamp, a graphical health warning, a printed retail price, an underage warning, and the manufacturer's name on the packaging.
These brands are also compliant with the Brand Licensing Regime of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) and are sold above the minimum legal price of Rs162.25.
The study further explored that locally manufactured duty-not-paid brands do not comply with one or more of the stipulated requirements by the government.
These brands also fail to comply with the Brand Licensing Regime of the FBR and are sold below the minimum legal price of Rs162.25.
Smuggled brands are completely non-compliant with the requirements. These brands do not have a Track and Trace Stamp and other guidelines lay down by the Government of Pakistan.
Regarding Track and Trace System (TTS) compliance at the point of sale, a total of 413 brands were found in the market. Out of these, only 19 brands had the TTS stamp in all areas. Thirteen brands were found both with and without the TTS stamp. Ninety-five of the brands were locally manufactured and did not have the TTS stamp. Additionally, 286 smuggled brands were found without the TTS stamp.
Industry expert Osama Siddiqi said the economic impact will further deteriorate if these illicit brands remain unchecked.
To solve this issue, he advised the authorities to ensure TTS coverage and routine inspections.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
FBR recovers Rs600bn as IHC vacates stay orders in 270 cases
ISLAMABAD: In the last few months, the Islamabad High Court (IHC) has vacated stay orders in 270 tax-related cases that had incapacitated Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to recover more than Rs600 billion. These 270 tax-related cases were pending in the IHC for over two decades. According to the details, three IHC division benches decided these tax-related matters. The division bench of Justice Mohammad Azam Khan and Justice Raja Inaam Ameen Minhas decided an overwhelming majority of 173 of tax cases involving Rs424bn. Another IHC bench comprising Justice Babar Sattar and Justice Sardar Ejaz Ishaq Khan cleared 94 cases in which over Rs150bn recoveries were stalled. A bench comprising acting IHC Chief Justice Sardar Mohammad Sarfraz Dogar and Justice Raja Inaam Ameen Minhas lifted the stay orders and decided three petitions that had in 2023 restrained the FBR to collect Rs36bn. A two-member division bench comprising Justice Mohammad Azam Khan and Justice Raja Inaam Ameen Minhas decided 125 cases related to Income Tax References, Sales Tax References and Foreign Exchange Regulations Act. The government's recoverable Rs290.51bn were stuck in 125 cases related to ITR. 36 STR cases involved recovery of Rs131.55bn while Rs3.16bn were recoverable in 12 cases related to FERA. In February this year the Prime Minister met with Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Yahya Afridi to discuss the agenda of the upcoming meeting of the National Judicial Policy Making Committee. During the meeting, the Prime Minister requested the CJP for expeditious disposal of tax-related cases. The IMF Governance and Diagnostic Assessment teams visited Pakistan to examine the governance structure of several ministries related to fiscal policy, tax policy, corruption, procurement, audits, and anti-money laundering. The NJPMC also advised for swift disposal of the tax-related matters, in its meeting held in April, asking the high courts to constitute special benches for expeditious disposal of tax-related cases. Following NJPMC's advice and directions issued by the apex court in the tax matters, the IHC Judicial Registrar put up a note before the acting CJ for consolidation of all the matters. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Direct taxes' share jumps to 48.7pc
ISLAMABAD: The share of direct taxes in overall tax collection of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) rose to 48.7 percent in 2024-25, merely due to increase in collection from advance taxes and withholding taxes. According to the Economic Survey (2024-25) issued on Monday, Pakistan's tax system is heavily reliant on indirect taxes. However, various efforts aimed at improving the share of direct taxes are underway and have started to yield significant results. Since 2021-22, the share of direct tax in total FBR revenues has consistently risen from 36.5 percent to 48.7 percent in 2024-25. In 2024-25, the increase in the share is primarily due to a 56.9 percent growth in advance taxes, followed by a 36.5 percent increase in withholding taxes, and a 35.8 percent growth in collections with returns. 1HFY25 direct tax collection rises 29.4pc YoY Direct tax has also witnessed a significant shift in its composition as the share of advance taxes increased from 29.8 percent to 33.8 percent, while there was a marginal decline in the contribution of withholding taxes from 61.4 percent to 60.5 percent in 2024-25. In contrast, the contribution of indirect taxes reduced from 63.5 percent in 2021-22 to 51.3 percent in 2024-25. The increase in direct taxes relative to indirect taxes reflects the government's commitment to make taxation progressive and equitable. The component-wise share indicates that sales tax accounted for 37.9 percent, FED 7.3 percent, and customs 12.3 percent in total FBR tax collection during 2024-25, the Economic Survey added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Tax relief costs kitty Rs5.84trn
ISLAMABAD: Total tax exemptions, concessions/reduced rates, zero-rating and special tax treatments to various businesses, sectors/industries, lobbies/groups and investors have cost the government Rs 5,840.2 billion in 2024-25 against Rs3,879.2 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs 1,961 billion. The Economic Survey (2024-25) released on Monday revealed that the cost of tax exemptions registered a growth of 50.55 per cent during 2024-25 as compared to tax expenditure in 2023-24. In 2023-24, the revenue loss on account of tax exemptions was increased by 73 percent against 2022-23. Tax exemptions, zero-rating cost kitty over Rs3.87trn The tax-expenditure report-2025 pinpointed that sales tax exemption to petroleum products, duty concessions on imports, reduced rates of sales tax and overall sales tax exemptions on imports and local supplies were major contributor to the increased revenue loss during 2024-25. The latest survey has not mentioned revenue loss on account of tax exemptions available to industrial units located in erstwhile tribal areas during 2024-25. This exemption will be withdrawn through the Finance Bill (2025-26) with revenue impact of nearly Rs 50 billion. Out of the total cost of exemptions of Rs 5,840.2 billion in 2024-25, sales tax exemption (SRO.321(I)/2022) on local supplies of petroleum products caused a massive revenue loss of Rs 1,496,124 million during the current fiscal year. The revenue loss due to sales tax exemption from imports and local supplies showed an increase of Rs 985 billion in2024-25. The Economic Survey (2024-25) disclosed that the sales tax expenditure remained highest during 2024-25 as compared to revenue loss on account of income tax and customs duty. All kinds of sales tax exemptions/concessions caused revenue loss of Rs 4,253,472 million; followed by income tax loss of Rs 800,821 million and customs duty revenue loss of Rs 785,871 million during 2024-25. The single-largest contributor to the surge in sales tax exemptions was the exemption from sales tax on petroleum products through statutory regulatory orders (SROs), showing a massive revenue loss of Rs1,496,124 million during 2024-25. The sales tax exemption on import of petroleum products caused revenue loss of Rs299,640 million during this period. The survey disclosed that the fixed sales tax regime on cellular mobile phones caused a revenue loss of Rs 87,950 million in 2024-25 as compared to Rs33,057 million in 2023-24, showing an increase of Rs 54,893 million. The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has suffered a revenue loss of Rs372 billion on account of sales tax exemption on imports during 2024-25 as compared to Rs214 billion during 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs158 billion. Sales tax exemption on local supplies caused a revenue loss of Rs613 billion in 2024-25 as compared to Rs461 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of over Rs152 billion. The cost of income tax exemptions amounted to 800.8 billion against Rs476.9 billion, showing an increase of Rs323.9 billion and the cost of customs duty exemptions was Rs785.8 billion in 2024-25 against Rs543.5 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs242.3 billion. The Economic Survey has not mentioned revenue loss on account of exempt business income granted to independent power producers (IPPs). Similarly, the survey has not mentioned any revenue loss from capital gains. The accumulative revenue loss on account of tax credits amounted to Rs101 billion in 2024-25 against Rs24.374 billion in 2023-24, showing an increase of Rs76.627 billion. The income tax exemption from special provisions of the Income Tax Ordinance has caused revenue loss of Rs52 billion during 2024-25 as compared to Rs 62.756 billion during 2023-24. The income tax exemption from total income has revenue impact of Rs 443.445 billion during the period under review. The income tax exemption available to the deductible allowances caused revenue loss of Rs 16.4 billion in 2024-25 against Rs 5.912 billion in 2023-24, showing an increase of Rs 10.488 billion. The reduction in income tax rates has revenue implications of Rs 45 billion during 2024-25 as compared to Rs25.492 billion in 2023-24, showing an increase of Rs19.508 billion. The FBR has suffered a massive revenue loss of Rs985.594 billion in 2024-25 as compared to Rs675 billion in 2023-24 due to sales tax exemptions available under the Sixth Schedule (Exemption Schedule) of the Sales Tax Act. The loss on account of sales tax exemption (import and domestic stage) has been increased by nearly Rs985 billion. The FBR has suffered a loss of Rs617.347 billion due to sales tax exemptions available under the Eight Schedule (Conditional Exemption/reduced rates) of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, during the period of 2024-25 against Rs357.997 billion in 2023-24. The revenue loss from conditional exemptions has been increased by Rs259.35 billion. The total revenue loss from the zero-rating facility granted to various sectors under the Fifth Schedule of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, amounted to Rs 683.429 billion during the period under review against Rs206.053 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs477.376 billion. The FBR has not specified any revenue loss to the exemptions within the federal excise regime, reflecting no loss occurred on this account. The cost of income tax exemptions was Rs800.8 billion in 2024-25 against Rs476.960 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs323.84. The cost of exemptions in respect of customs duty has been calculated at Rs785.9 billion in 2024-25 as compared to Rs543.521 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs242.379 billion. The exemption of customs duty available under Chapter-99 (special classification provisions) of the Customs Act has caused a revenue loss of Rs 33.481 billion in 2024-25 against Rs34.864 billion in 2023-24, reflecting a decrease of Rs 1.383 billion. The concessions under the Fifth Schedule of the Customs Act, 1969 caused a revenue loss of Rs 379.746 billion in 2024-25 against Rs190.688 billion in 2023-24, reflecting an increase of Rs189 billion. The FBR has suffered revenue loss of Rs 61 billion in 2024-25 against Rs44.107 billion in 2023-24 on account of tariff concessions and exemptions available under Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) and the Preferential Trade Agreements (PTAs). The revenue loss has increased by Rs 17 billion. Similarly, exemption of customs duty on the items by the automobile sector, exploration and production (E&P) companies, general concessions and the CPEC caused a loss of Rs 133.236 billion in 2024-25 against Rs146.598 billion in 2023-24, showing a decrease of Rs13.362 billion. The export-related exemptions cost revenue loss of Rs178.435 billion during 2024-25 against Rs127.264 billion during 2023-24, reflecting a massive increase of Rs51.171 billion. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
