Every day stress is being wrongly labelled as mental health issues, say majority of GPs
The majority of doctors believe the ups and downs of life are too readily diagnosed as mental health disorders, new research has suggested.
A poll of 1,001 GPs showed that 84 per cent of doctors think normal reactions to life's stresses and strains are being wrongly seen as medical problems.
The survey, conducted as part of a report by the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ), revealed doctors' concerns that this has led to an abundance of unnecessary prescriptions. In total, 83 per cent of GPs polled said they feared antidepressants were being handed out when alternatives would be more suitable.
Almost a fifth of adults in England are now taking antidepressants, according to the CSJ. The think tank warned that the mounting
'Misunderstood mental ill-health is the leaky bucket draining the nation,' the report said.
It comes after Sir Tony Blair, the former Labour prime minister, warned earlier this month against the trend for self-diagnosing mental health problems.
'I think we have become very, very focused on mental health and with
'And I think we need a proper public conversation about that because I think it's a very, very difficult question.
'We're spending vastly more on mental health now than we did a few years ago. And it's hard to see what the objective reasons for that are.'
Philippa Perry, the psychotherapist and bestselling author, made similar remarks this week as she warned that a 'reality crisis' means too many people are misdiagnosing their feelings as mental health conditions.
In an
'We're in a reality crisis, meaning that people think their feelings are so real now that they're not worried about facts at all,' she said.
'It's very normal to have painful, uncomfortable feelings in response to our experience of the world. If you haven't got enough money, why wouldn't you have anxiety? Or shyness — we used to have shyness. It was normal to go into a party where you don't know anyone, and feel it. But now 'you have social anxiety disorder'.
'There's no other illness that has to sell itself by putting 'disorder' on the end. You don't have cancer disorder, or diabetes disorder.'
Ms Perry, author of the 2019 bestseller The Book You Wish Your Parents Had Read (and Your Children Will be Glad That You Did), said diagnoses appear to have rocketed in recent years as people try to make sense of their lives in a period of religious decline.
'It's a narrative that makes sense of how they feel. Human beings are made of stories — it's what makes us different from cats. We used to have religion to give us a story, and now the current trend for making sense of your feelings is a diagnosis,' she said.
'The diagnosis is a story that makes sense of your life, so no wonder you'd cling on to that. And it's nice to begin with because you feel, 'Oh, it's not my fault that I leave my keys in the fridge.' But it takes away from your self-agency, and I think it's got out of hand.'
Other experts have claimed the pandemic and multiple national lockdowns catalysed a mental health crisis among young people that has failed to improve.
The number of working-age people on health-related benefits has risen by a million since 2019 to 4.2 million, according to a study last year by the Institute for Fiscal Studies.
Impact of social media
Meanwhile, an NHS survey of children and young people's mental health found that 20 per cent of children aged 8 to 16 had a probable mental disorder in 2023, up from 12 per cent in 2017. The figure rose to 23 per cent among those aged 17 to 19, up from 10 per cent in 2017.
Some have pointed to social media as helping fuel a rise in young people self-diagnosing mental health conditions. A recent report by insurer AXA Health suggested around 30 per cent of Britons aged 16 to 24 declared themselves to be suffering from issues such as anxiety or depression before consulting a professional.
Labour ministers have signalled that they hope to bring down the spiralling welfare bill, but are yet to reveal specific plans.
The Telegraph reported earlier this month that No 10 and Treasury figures think
The annual cost of support payments for people with disabilities and health conditions is forecast to soar from £22 billion to £35 billion by 2029 – a 60 per cent increase.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Western Telegraph
an hour ago
- Western Telegraph
Starmer hints he will back assisted dying Bill ahead of crunch vote
The result of Friday's expected vote could see the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill either progress to the House of Lords or fall completely. Sir Keir Starmer, who voted yes in November and also supported a 2015 attempt to legislate for assisted dying, said his position on the issue is 'long-standing and well-known' – giving no suggestion his mind had changed on the matter. Friday will be the first time the Bill has been voted on in its entirety since last year's historic yes vote, when MPs supported the principle of assisted dying for England and Wales by a majority of 55. MPs are entitled to have a free vote on the Bill, meaning they decide according to their conscience rather than along party lines. While supporters of the Bill say it is coming back to the Commons with better safeguards after more than 90 hours of parliamentary time spent on it to date, opponents claim the process has been rushed and that changes to the Bill mean it is now weaker than it was when first introduced. This week, dozens of Labour MPs opposed to the Bill urged a delay to the vote. Asked whether he thought they were wrong to do so, Sir Keir told reporters in Canada: 'It is a matter for individual parliamentarians, which is why I've not waded in with a view on this publicly, and I'm not going to now it's coming to a conclusion. 'There has been a lot of time discussing it, both in Parliament and beyond Parliament, and quite right too. It's a really serious issue. 'My own position is long-standing and well-known in relation to it, based on my experience when I was chief prosecutor for five years, where I oversaw every case that was investigated.' While the Prime Minister is among the high-profile supporters of the Bill, both Health Secretary Wes Streeting and Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood voted against it in November. Meanwhile, Dame Esther Rantzen's daughter said she is 'really hopeful' the Bill can pass the major vote, as she warned against 'scaremongering' by opponents. Dame Esther Rantzen has been an outspoken campaigner on the assisted dying Bill (Esther Rantzen/PA) Rebecca Wilcox, the daughter of the terminally ill broadcaster and Childline founder Dame Esther, said: 'We are really hopeful that we have the numbers (in the Commons). 'We obviously want people to keep writing to their MP, saying that they support the Bill, because we know that nationally the numbers are with us.' Ms Wilcox described the Bill as a 'really safe, clever piece of law' and insisted its safeguards would ensure it is not extended beyond its current scope of terminally ill adults while it would improve on the 'cruel status quo that exists at the moment'. Responding to warnings from opponents around those with depression or eating disorders being more vulnerable to being caught up in a new law, Ms Wilcox urged people against 'scaremongering'. She said: 'Yes, you may be depressed because you have a terminal diagnosis, but that's not to do with it. You can't just be depressed. You can't just have an eating disorder. 'And this is an example of some of the scaremongering that has been going on on the other side of the debate, and I completely understand that they are desperate to stop it, but if you are desperate to stop it, please don't exaggerate the truth. Please don't exaggerate a lie.' Speaking during a debate on amendments to the Bill last week, Labour MP Rupa Huq warned that 'in a cost-of-living crisis, assisted dying could be quite attractive', as she pledged to be a 'voice of the voiceless'. She said while she probably would have supported such a Bill in her younger years, '10 years of being an MP has exposed me to coercion, duress, the millionaire price of London property and elder abuse'. She added: 'We know that Esther Rantzen wants this. We know Jonathan Dimbleby wants this. But our role is to be the voice of the voiceless as well.' Asked about her mother – who has terminal cancer and has been outspoken in campaigning for a change in the law – Ms Wilcox said Dame Esther is 'coping' as she nears her 85th birthday this weekend. She told Sky: 'She's coping. This has been a long slog, and we're hoping that we can maybe have a rest this weekend, particularly as it is her birthday on Sunday. 'So we are so grateful and so appreciative of all the time that we have with her, particularly as she turns 85 looking rather fabulous.' Gordon Macdonald, chief executive of opposition campaign group Care Not Killing, said their polling had suggested the public 'is deeply concerned that this Bill could put pressure on vulnerable people to end their lives prematurely'. He added: 'These problems will be compounded if Parliament continues to rush this legislation, fails to restore safeguards such as the scrutiny of the High Court and fixing palliative and end-of-life care in the UK, which is in crisis. 'This is why, day by day, more and more disabled people, doctors, nurses, lawyers and campaigners are urging MPs to kill the Bill, not the sick and vulnerable.' As it stands, the proposed legislation would allow terminally ill adults in England and Wales, with fewer than six months to live, to apply for an assisted death, subject to approval by two doctors and a panel featuring a social worker, senior legal figure and psychiatrist.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Keir Starmer signals support for assisted dying as MPs prepare for crunch vote
Keir Starmer said his position on the highly sensitive issue of assisted dying 'is long-standing and well-known' after he voted in favour of changing the law last year Keir Starmer has suggested he backs a bid to change the law on assisted dying as MPs prepare to cast their final vote. Tensions have been mounting in Parliament over the landmark bill, as more than 50 Labour MPs urged Commons Leader Lucy Powell at the weekend to intervene to delay the crucial third reading vote to allow for more scrutiny. MPs voted by 330 to 275 in favour of legalising assisted dying in November - but it is unclear whether some MPs will switch sides when they vote on the bill in full. The Prime Minister said his position on the highly sensitive issue "is long-standing and well-known" but he stressed it was a matter for individual MPs as the government remains neutral. At November's historic 'yes' vote, when a majority of 55 supported the principle of assisted dying in England and Wales, Mr Starmer voted in favour. The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill has since gone through line-by-line scrutiny in tense debates in the Commons chamber. Spearheaded by Labour MP Kim Leadbeater, the Bill proposes to allow terminally ill adults with less than six months to live to apply for an assisted death. It is expected MPs will hold a key vote on Friday which could either see the legislation progress to the House of Lords, or fall. Speaking to reporters, Mr Starmer said: "It is a matter for individual parliamentarians, which is why I've not waded in with a view on this publicly, and I'm not going to now, it's coming to a conclusion. "There has been a lot of time discussing it, both in Parliament and beyond Parliament, and quite right too it's a really serious issue. My own position is long-standing and well-known in relation to it, based on my experience when I was chief prosecutor for five years, where I oversaw every case that was investigated." His comments came as the ex-Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown urged MPs to reject the Bill, saying it had "fundamental flaws". Mr Brown said: "It has become clear that whatever views people hold on the principle, passing the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) bill into law would privilege the legal right to assisted dying without guaranteeing anything approaching an equivalent right to high-quality palliative care for those close to death." But the daughter of terminally ill broadcaster Dame Esther Rantzen said England and Wales must "catch up with the rest of the world" in changing the law. Rebecca Wilcox told Sky News: "We need to show that we are an empathetic country that appreciates choice at the end of your life." She added: "It's a Bill for the terminally ill. It's a Bill for adults, and in every jurisdiction where they've had a similar Bill with such strict safeguards it is not extended to anybody else. It has not widened the scope of it. The slippery slope doesn't exist. "So what we have here, what Kim Leadbeater has brought forward and has pushed through Parliament so gracefully and so carefully and empathetically, is a really safe, clever piece of law that will stop the cruel status quo that exists at the moment where nobody knows what they can do, where people are dying in agony every single day."
Telegraph
4 hours ago
- Telegraph
Labour welfare reforms threaten to backfire as benefit claims hit record high
Disability benefits have surged by 200,000 claims ahead of Labour's plan to scale back eligibility rules, official figures show. Figures published by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) show there were 3.74 million people in England and Wales claiming personal independence payment (Pip) as of April this year. Pip is the main non means-tested benefit for those with disabilities, with payments of up to £9,500 a year to help people with living costs. Around £3bn a year of the support is paid to people with mental health conditions, such as ADHD. The figures come as Liz Kendall, the work and pensions secretary, is expected to announce cuts to Britain's ballooning benefits bill which continues to hit record levels. The number of successful Pip claimants has jumped by 2pc since the start of the year, 5.6pc in the past 12 months and 77pc since 2019. The benefit has spiralled since lockdown, and is on course to climb from £15bn in 2019-20 to £36bn in real terms by the end of the current Parliament. Official figures show mental health conditions have driven a substantial share of the increase in claims since lockdown, with one in four working age Britons now classed as disabled. Claims for mental health problems is set to cost taxpayers £3.5bn this year. The bill has alarmed ministers and officials, who are poised to introduce a £5bn welfare cut on Wednesday in the face of mounting criticism from backbench Labour MPs. It comes after it emerged face-to-face assessments for disability benefit claims have collapsed to a record low under Labour. Official figures show that more than 80pc of Pip assessments conducted before the pandemic were in person. However, this dropped to a record post-Covid low of less than 2pc in September last year, when just 1,270 of 74,000 assessments were carried out face-to-face. Ms Kendall said last month: 'With Pip caseload and costs forecast to continue rising, reforms are needed now to make the system sustainable, while supporting those people with the greatest needs.' The changes to the welfare system include stricter eligibility for claiming Pip, and reducing payments for new claimants of the health element of Universal Credit. The age group most likely to claim Pips is the 60 to 64 age bracket, with 514,392 successful claimants, according to the DWP. In a report published earlier this year, the DWP reported that £6.5bn of its total benefits outlay was lost to fraud last year. Government figures show that 2,235 benefit payments were sent abroad. Elsewhere, new figures show the number of benefit claimants provided with cars from the Motability scheme has rocketed by 97,000 in the past year. Motability Operations, which previously admitted to finding thousands of cases of abuse of the taxpayer-subsidised scheme, provides cars to disabled people in exchange for a portion of their benefits. The scheme, which is not run by the Government, has come under intense scrutiny amid concerns about its spiralling cost. It accounted for one in five of all new cars bought in the UK last year, with the customer base now standing at 860,000.
