
AI tool put to test sifting public views on botox and fillers
Chris Vallance
Senior Technology Reporter Getty Images
An artificial intelligence (AI) tool has been used to sort through comments about botox and lip fillers, that were submitted as part of a public consultation, in what officials said was the first use of this kind in the UK.
Officials set the tool to work sifting responses to a Scottish government consultation on regulating non-surgical cosmetic procedures.
They found it came up with 'nearly identical' results, when compared to humans set the same task.
It is hoped the tool, dubbed 'Consult', will spare civil servants from similar time-consuming tasks in future, and save taxpayers an estimated £20m.
Consult is one of a planned set of government AI-powered tools that have collectively been dubbed 'Humphrey' after the wily senior civil servant, Sir Humphrey Appleby, from the classic 1980s sitcom Yes, Minister. The series often took aim at excessive bureaucracy in government.
In this trial the AI tool examined 2,000 submissions. But public consultations, which gather the views of UK citizens on issues under consideration by ministers, can generate tens of thousands of responses.
It was able to identify themes amongst the responses, and counted and catalogued answers accordingly – with human experts checking its work at both stages.
Consult's findings were then examined to see how they compared to a team of human experts working in parallel.
Technology secretary Peter Kyle said the initial success of the trial meant that Consult would be used across government 'very soon'.
'After demonstrating such promising results, Humphrey will help us cut the costs of governing and make it easier to collect and comprehensively review what experts and the public are telling us on a range of crucial issues,' he wrote.
The government hopes £45bn can be saved by wider public sector use of AI technology. 'Humans in the loop'
The government says that Consult is currently still in its trial stage and more evaluation will take place before any final decision to roll it out more widely.
There would always be 'humans in the loop' checking Consult's work, the government added.
Officials have also sought to address some of the persistent concerns about AI systems.
One is that they sometimes invent information – a failing known as 'hallucinating'.
Because the AI was only being asked to carry out a relatively limited task, officials said hallucination would not be a major problem.
Such AI tools, built using what are known as 'large language models' have also displayed bias, as they adsorb the prejudices inherent in the human-generated data on which they are trained.
But experts who worked with Consult had found it reduced bias overall, the government said, by removing opportunities for individual human analysts to 'project their own preconceived ideas'.
Consult has also been tested to check it can handle language containing spelling mistakes and other errors.
However, for now it only works in English, and responses in other languages spoken within the UK such as Welsh would need to be translated into English first.
READ SOURCE
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Car drives through anti-ICE protesters as Chicago joins nationwide anti-ICE unrest amid Trump crackdown
A car drove through a crowd of demonstrators Tuesday night as hundreds of anti-ICE protesters gathered in Downtown Chicago. The protests in Chicago come as Los Angeles has faced days of unrest. Advertisement Protests in LA started on June 7, with rioters burning cars, throwing objects and fireworks at police, smashing the windows of the LAPD's headquarters and looting stores. Tuesday's footage from FOX 32 Chicago shows what appeared to be a woman driving through the Chicago demonstrators walking with signs and biking on Wabash and Monroe. A police officer attempted to hit the window of the moving vehicle in an apparent attempt to get the driver to stop, but it kept moving, FOX 32 reported. It is unclear if anyone was injured during the incident. Advertisement The Chicago Police Department told Fox News Digital on Tuesday evening that they were waiting to hear from responding officers when asked if the car's driver would face charges for driving through protesters. While most Chicago protesters were peaceful on Tuesday, some demonstrators clashed and vandalized police vehicles, and public transportation was temporarily suspended downtown, FOX 32 reported. 6 Anti-ICE protesters gathered in Downtown Chicago blocking traffic from getting around the city streets. SkyFOX 6 A driver drives a car through a protest that took over a street in Chicago on June 10, 2025. Advertisement Chicago Alderman Raymond Lopez noted on X that multiple police cars had been vandalized. 'I guess we haven't learned,' he wrote in one Tuesday evening post. 'I'm so sick of anarchy apologists and their 'It's not violent, just property damage bro' bull—-,' he said in another. 6 Footage from shows what appeared to be a woman driving through the Chicago demonstrators walking with signs and biking on Wabash and Monroe. SkyFOX Advertisement 6 Police detain a protester in the Loop on June 10, 2025. Getty Images 6 Protesters take over a street and march through the Loop of Chicago on June 10, 2025. Getty Images An earlier protest Tuesday was part of a campaign called 'From LA to Chicago: ICE Out!' according to FOX 32. 'I just think it's not right what's going on right now … people are being snatched off the street, so you just gotta do something about it,' Benjamin Rose, one of the protesters, told the outlet. Demonstrations have been popping up across the country, from Asheville, North Carolina, to Chicago to Los Angeles, where unrest broke out over the weekend following a raid. The Department of Homeland Security said ICE raids in LA over the weekend resulted in 'hundreds of illegal aliens [being] arrested by ICE officers and agents,' including 'many with a criminal history and criminal convictions.' 6 An earlier protest Tuesday was part of a campaign called 'From LA to Chicago: ICE Out!' AFP via Getty Images Advertisement DHS listed more information about 19 suspects that ICE Los Angeles arrested on June 7 who are accused of crimes ranging from robbery to second-degree murder to rape. 'America's brave ICE officers are removing the worst of the worst from LA's streets, while LA's leaders are working tirelessly against them,' DHS said in a Sunday statement as riots continued through the weekend.


Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
In Photos: Strawberry Moon Skims Horizon In Once-In-A-Generation Event
The most southerly full moon for 19 years — the strawberry moon — rose late at night into twilight skies on Tuesday, June 10, 2025. The rare occurrence won't happen again until 2043. Here are all the best full moon photos from around the world. The full strawberry moon rising over Cardiff, Wales, on Tuesday, June 10, 2025. On Tuesday, June 10, the full strawberry moon appeared on the southeast horizon during dusk, as seen around the world. It turned 10% full at 3:45 a.m. EDT on Wednesday, June 11, 2025. The sixth full moon of 2025 rose farther to the southeast than at any time since 2006, skimming the southern horizon and setting in the southwest. It was the first full moon of meteorological summer in the Northern Hemisphere and of fall in the Southern Hemisphere. However, astronomical summer and winter, respectively, doesn't begin until the solstice on June 21, 2025. June's strawberry moon is named after the ripening of the berries in the Northern Hemisphere, though it's also called the flower and rose moon. The moon can be seen over the Schluchsee. A rare celestial phenomenon appears in the night from June ... More 10 to 11: the strawberry moon Photo: Philipp von Ditfurth/dpa (Photo by Philipp von Ditfurth/picture alliance via Getty Images) The strawberry moon rose so far south because of an 18.6-year cycle called 'major lunar standstill' or 'lunistice.' Across a period of about a year, it sees the moon's path through the sky at its maximum tilt relative to Earth, so at its furthest extreme north and south. In 2025, the strawberry moon was at its most southerly moonrise point since 2006 and until 2043. The strawberry Moon rises in the sky behind the 5th century B.C. Parthenon temple at the ancient ... More Acropolis hill, in Athens, on Tuesday, June 10, 2025. (AP Photo/Petros Giannakouris) In the eastern sky before sunrise on Monday, June 23, 2025, a slender waning crescent moon will be positioned within half a degree of the Pleiades, an open cluster of stars also known as the Seven Sisters and M45. Venus will shine brightly nearby. The full Strawberry Moon rises behind the Empire State Building in New York City on June 10, 2025, ... More as seen from Weehawken, New Jersey. (Photo by) In the western sky after sunset on Friday, June 27, 2025, the planet Mercury — rarely seen by skywatchers — will appear to the lower-left of a 9%-lit waxing crescent moon. It's hard to see from Earth because it's so close to the sun, so it's mostly lost in its glare. The full moon, also known as the Strawberry Moon rises over St Mary's Lighthouse in Whitley Bay. ... More Picture date: Tuesday June 10, 2025. (Photo by Owen Humphreys/PA Images via Getty Images) In the western sky after sunset on Sunday, June 29, 2025, Mars will be in a very close conjunction with a 23%-lit waxing crescent moon. The two planetary bodies will be just a fifth of a degree apart. For context, a degree in the sky is the width of a little finger held against the sky at arm's length. People photograph the full Strawberry Moon rise behind the skyline of midtown Manhattan and the ... More Empire State Building in New York City on June 10, 2025, as seen from Weehawken, New Jersey. (Photo by) June's full moon is the sixth of 12 full moons in 2025, three of which will be supermoons (in October, November and December). September's full moon will be a 'blood moon' total lunar eclipse, though it won't be visible in North America. The full strawberry moon rises on Tuesday, June 10, 2025, over Cardiff, Wales. The next full moon will occur on Thursday, July 10. Known as the buck moon, it will be the first full moon of astronomical summer in the Northern Hemisphere and fall in the Southern Hemisphere.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Call for supporters' trusts to be recognised by law
A football supporters' trust leading a drive for fans to "play a meaningful part in decision making at their clubs" has been backed by a national campaign group. Fair Game has joined a coalition of 22 fan groups, led by Northampton Town Supporters Trust who are calling on the government to ensure "the unique status of trusts to be recognised and enshrined in law" as part of its Trusts First campaign. Niall Couper, chief executive of Fair Game, said the campaign was "about giving those communities a real voice in the game they love" The Department of Culture, Media and Sport has been approached for comment. The coalition of clubs, from all levels of the English game, intends to lobby government to "guarantee primacy for Trusts and other democratically-constituted supporter groups" in the forthcoming Football Governance Bill. The legislation, which is passing through parliament after being reintroduced by the Labour government in October, will hand power to a body independent from government and football authorities to oversee clubs in England's top five divisions. The Trusts First group includes supporters' trusts from Barnsley, Birmingham City, Blackburn Rovers, Bradford City, Doncaster Rovers, Exeter City, Fulham, Leicester City, Leyton Orient, Manchester United, Morecambe, Northampton Town, Plymouth Argyle, Reading, Scunthorpe United, Southend United, Swansea City, Swindon Town, Torquay United and Wolverhampton Wanderers. Mr Couper said: "It's time to ensure that meaningful fan engagement isn't just a slogan, but a reality." Andy Roberts, the chair of the Northampton Town Supporters' Trust, said: "The trust movement was founded in 1992, the year the Premier League was introduced, yet many fans up and down the country continue to be disenfranchised and marginalised by club owners pursuing their own vested interests. "We now have a clear opportunity to get all mandated supporter groups front and centre of fan engagement, not just those who are cherry picked by clubs to sit on their panels and boards. "We feel this should form part of the legislation and not be left to the discretion of the Independent Football Regulator." Fair Game said a meeting will be held with democratically-elected supporter groups next week to hear their concerns for the future of football first hand. Follow Northamptonshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X. Government's football regulator chair choice faces inquiry NTFC Supporters' Trust Fair Game