AI tool put to test sifting public views on botox and fillers
Chris Vallance
Senior Technology Reporter Getty Images
An artificial intelligence (AI) tool has been used to sort through comments about botox and lip fillers, that were submitted as part of a public consultation, in what officials said was the first use of this kind in the UK.
Officials set the tool to work sifting responses to a Scottish government consultation on regulating non-surgical cosmetic procedures.
They found it came up with 'nearly identical' results, when compared to humans set the same task.
It is hoped the tool, dubbed 'Consult', will spare civil servants from similar time-consuming tasks in future, and save taxpayers an estimated £20m.
Consult is one of a planned set of government AI-powered tools that have collectively been dubbed 'Humphrey' after the wily senior civil servant, Sir Humphrey Appleby, from the classic 1980s sitcom Yes, Minister. The series often took aim at excessive bureaucracy in government.
In this trial the AI tool examined 2,000 submissions. But public consultations, which gather the views of UK citizens on issues under consideration by ministers, can generate tens of thousands of responses.
It was able to identify themes amongst the responses, and counted and catalogued answers accordingly – with human experts checking its work at both stages.
Consult's findings were then examined to see how they compared to a team of human experts working in parallel.
Technology secretary Peter Kyle said the initial success of the trial meant that Consult would be used across government 'very soon'.
'After demonstrating such promising results, Humphrey will help us cut the costs of governing and make it easier to collect and comprehensively review what experts and the public are telling us on a range of crucial issues,' he wrote.
The government hopes £45bn can be saved by wider public sector use of AI technology. 'Humans in the loop'
The government says that Consult is currently still in its trial stage and more evaluation will take place before any final decision to roll it out more widely.
There would always be 'humans in the loop' checking Consult's work, the government added.
Officials have also sought to address some of the persistent concerns about AI systems.
One is that they sometimes invent information – a failing known as 'hallucinating'.
Because the AI was only being asked to carry out a relatively limited task, officials said hallucination would not be a major problem.
Such AI tools, built using what are known as 'large language models' have also displayed bias, as they adsorb the prejudices inherent in the human-generated data on which they are trained.
But experts who worked with Consult had found it reduced bias overall, the government said, by removing opportunities for individual human analysts to 'project their own preconceived ideas'.
Consult has also been tested to check it can handle language containing spelling mistakes and other errors.
However, for now it only works in English, and responses in other languages spoken within the UK such as Welsh would need to be translated into English first.
READ SOURCE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
15 minutes ago
- New York Post
Port of Los Angeles sees sharp drop in cargo ships, West Coast dockworkers sit idle
Shipping activity at major West Coast ports has plummeted, with the Port of Los Angeles averaging just five ships a day — down from a typical dozen — and job orders for dockworkers falling by nearly 50%, according to port officials. On a typical June day, the Port of Los Angeles would be buzzing with activity — about a dozen ships arriving from Asia, containers being unloaded, and cargo moving quickly across the country. But lately, things have been eerily quiet. Advertisement 4 Shipping activity at major West Coast ports has plummeted, with the Port of Los Angeles averaging just five ships a day — down from a typical dozen. Getty Images 'We've averaged about five ships a day,' Gene Seroka, executive director of the Port of Los Angeles, told Bloomberg News. 'Job orders for our dock workers are down nearly 50%.' That drop isn't just a temporary blip. It's part of a larger slowdown linked to President Donald Trump's trade war with China — a policy shift that's been quietly wreaking havoc on West Coast port cities like Los Angeles, Long Beach, Oakland, Seattle and Tacoma. Advertisement While most of the attention around tariffs has focused on rising prices and stock market swings, the economic damage to these cities has gone under the radar. These ports depend heavily on trade with Asia, especially China. And now, because of increased tariffs and uncertainty in US-China relations, the flow of goods has slowed dramatically — with real consequences for jobs, businesses and local economies. Advertisement Even a recent truce between the two countries has done little to reverse the trend. Data released Monday by the Chinese government showed that exports to the US tumbled 35% in May compared to the year before — the steepest drop since COVID lockdowns froze trade in early 2020. 4 A container ship is docked at the Port of Los Angeles. Job orders for dockworkers fell by nearly 50%, according to port officials. Getty Images That followed a 21% drop in April. While China's shipments to places like Southeast Asia and Europe are on the rise, they haven't been enough to balance out the loss in US-bound cargo. All told, China's overall exports rose just 4.8% last month, well below forecasts. The effects of the slowdown in Chinese exports are being felt across the Pacific. Advertisement Long Beach — along with Los Angeles — operates the biggest port complex in the US. Roughly 60% of its trade is with China. In 2022 alone, the ports pumped about $300 billion into the Los Angeles County economy and brought in $93 billion in tax revenue. One in five jobs in the region — from truck drivers to warehouse workers — is tied to the ports. More than 70% of dockworkers live within 10 miles. But with fewer ships arriving, the impact is spreading. The Port of Oakland saw cargo volumes fall 15% in April. Los Angeles has already had 17 ship cancellations in May, and another 10 were scrapped in June. New government data also shows a sharp nationwide drop in imports. Mayor Rex Richardson of Long Beach told Bloomberg News that his city, home to about 450,000 people, is especially vulnerable. 4 President Trump initiated a trade war with China and other nations after introducing tariffs. REUTERS Advertisement He fears that trade-related companies near the port won't hire as they normally do this summer. 'We need certainty,' Richardson said. 'We need long-range trade policy. We don't think that is a controversial idea.' But certainty is in short supply. Trump recently accused China of violating trade agreements and slapped even higher tariffs on steel and aluminum — now up to 50%. Advertisement Meanwhile, West Coast leaders like Seroka say their attempts to engage with the federal government have gone nowhere. Despite serving on an advisory panel for the US Trade Representative's Office, Seroka says his calls to the Trump administration have been ignored. Instead, he's been holding regular press conferences to sound the alarm. On Wednesday, he stood alongside Los Angeles City Council member Tim McOsker, who represents the port district. McOsker didn't hold back, saying: 'This is a mistake for absolutely no reason. There's no one who can describe why we're going through this.' 4 Trump is seen left with Chinese President Xi Jinping in 2019. Chinese exports have plummeted. REUTERS Advertisement Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass was also critical of the tariffs, saying: 'It's a tax on individuals and their families.' Seroka warned that the pain won't stay confined to California. Since ports are on the front line of the economy, they feel shocks early — before the ripple effects hit stores, factories and households across the country. Advertisement 'As the Ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach go,' Seroka said, 'so goes the US economy.' The Post has sought comment from the White House.
New York Post
15 minutes ago
- New York Post
It's ‘a small part of LA' is latest media refrain to minimize violent mobs
Get ready for the 2025 version of 'mostly peaceful protest.' It's 'a small part of the city.' Even liberal media knows it looks bad when Mexican flag-waving punks are wearing skull masks and setting fire to cars. It's hard to paint President Trump as a fascist when protesters from another country are inciting violence and looting. They're desperate to minimize what's going on, to suggest that it's Trump who is inflaming the situation and not the rioters themselves. Advertisement A burnt US flag is seen on the ground amid clashes with law enforcement. AFP via Getty Images When the George Floyd riots descended into mayhem, the constant refrain on CNN was 'a mostly peaceful protest.' A few bad apples burned that police station, yes, but that's not the full story. This time around, they're going geographic. 'Federal agents clashed with protesters in the Los Angeles area for a third day, and hundreds of National Guard troops were deployed,' The New York Times wrote. 'But much of the sprawling city operated as usual.' Advertisement The Times even wrote a story, 'Life goes on in the city,' remarking on all the parades and events happening in the 18 million person Los Angeles area at the same time as the clashes, as if that was even relevant. The framing is spreading, as these things usually do. Monday morning's Axios report said, 'The clashes between police and protesters were centered in several blocks of downtown — a small slice of the city.' Ah, a small slice. Guess shutting down the 101 Freeway and burning Waymo cars isn't that big a deal — everything's fine in Santa Monica! Advertisement Demonstrators wave flags from atop a wrecked car, standing beside burning Waymo vehicles, as protesters clash with law enforcement in the streets surrounding the federal building during a protest following federal immigration operations in Los Angeles, California, on June 8, 2025. AFP via Getty Images Imagine if all news was treated this way. Murder in Queens, but in Brooklyn, life goes on. Hurricanes in Florida, but that's just a small slice of the United States. The motives are so transparent they are laughable. The media wants to diminish and distract, but for the rest of us, reality goes on.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Czech court sentences Colombian to 8 years for arson attack which officials think is tied to Russia
PRAGUE (AP) — A court in the Czech capital sentenced a Colombian national to eight years in prison on Monday for an arson attack and planning another one, in a case which authorities believe may be linked to Russia. Prague's Municipal Court also ordered Andrés Alfonso de la Hoz de la Cruz to pay damages worth 115,000 koruna ($5,300). The court approved a plea agreement between prosecutors and the defendant, who pleaded guilty. The 26-year-old Colombian was arrested a year ago after setting ablaze three Prague public buses at a depot at night. The court said that he recorded what he did and left. Local workers managed to extinguish the fire. The court said the man received orders on the Telegram messaging app and was promised $3,000. He was also planning one more attack, possibly at a movie theater in Prague. Czech Prime Minister Petr Fiala previously said the failed arson attack was likely part of Russia's hybrid war against his country. Czechia, which is more widely known in English as the Czech Republic, is a staunch supporter of Ukraine in its fight against Russia's full scale-invasion. Western officials have accused Russia and its proxies of staging dozens of attacks and other incidents across Europe since Moscow launched all-out war on Ukraine on Feb. 24, 2022, according to data collected by The Associated Press. They allege the disruption campaign is an extension of Russian President Vladimir Putin's war, intended to sow division in European societies and undermine support for Ukraine. ___ Follow the AP's coverage of the war at
