Farmers face 'new world' of extreme weather as scientists urge action on climate change
Scientists and politicians are warning big policy shifts are needed to mitigate extreme weather impacts, following what farmers describe as unprecedented flooding in the New South Wales Hunter and Mid North Coast regions last month.
Climate scientist and University of Melbourne Emeritus Professor David Karoly said a near-stationary high pressure system in the Tasman Sea had contributed to the high rainfall event, stalling a moist, easterly flow of air over the NSW coast.
Dr Karoly, who is a member of the Climate Council, said governments needed to take action on climate change to limit these types of extreme events.
He said a range of approaches were needed, including changes to farming practices.
"Farmers have to think about how they can reduce erosion associated with some of these increased rainfall extremes, but also need to think about how they can manage their farm dams because we're also seeing increases in the frequency of drought," he said.
Craig Emerton, whose family has been farming at Croki since 1856, described the May floods as "totally unprecedented", with water levels three times higher than he had experienced before.
However, the dairy farmer said he was not convinced climate change was the issue.
He pointed to geography for evidence of what happened before Australia was colonised and flood height records were started.
"When we look at the landform on this coastal flood plain, we can see that there's been big floods over the years where sediment has built up," he said.
"My dad spoke of six floods in six weeks … so we just happen to be in a very wet period."
At Dungong, fellow dairy farmer Sue McGinn shared his view.
"I believe the Australian climate has always been a land of droughts and floods," she said.
In March, ex-Tropical Cyclone Alfred crossed Ms McGinn's property, then what she described as a "rain bomb" dumped another 200 millimetres in just a few hours in the middle of the night on May 3.
She said it was the farm's most difficult season in 31 years, and she and her husband were exhausted by the repeated setbacks.
While both farmers are right that Australia has always had extreme weather events like this, what is changing is the frequency and intensity of those events.
The Climate Council said the recent flooding disasters are linked to human-led climate change caused by emissions from fossil fuels.
Chief executive Amanda McKenzie said a number of events combined to make the May floods more severe.
They included an increase in the amount of water vapour in the atmosphere, which reached a record high in 2024 at about 5 per cent above the 1991–2020 average, according to Climate Council data.
The Bureau of Meteorology said in its Special Climate Statement 77 in September 2023 that every 1 degree Celsius of warming could increase moisture in the atmosphere by 7 per cent, which could provide more energy for some processes that generated extreme rainfall events.
Ms McKenzie said Australia was experiencing 7 to 28 per cent more rain for shorter duration rainfall events and 2 to 15 per cent more rain for longer duration events.
Scientists can analyse whether single extreme events are linked to climate change.
Extreme weather research organisation ClimaMeter, funded by the European Union and the French National Centre for Scientific Research, has published a paper looking at the link between climate change and the May NSW floods.
It studied changes in weather patterns since 1950 and concluded that the extreme precipitation that caused the flooding was intensified by human-induced climate change, with natural variability playing a secondary role.
NSW Greens MP Sue Higginson is also a farmer in the Northern Rivers region.
Her property on the Richmond River near Lismore was impacted by the 2022 flood, and she puts the blame for such events squarely on climate change.
Ms Higginson said some farming practices were no longer viable and communities would need to adjust.
"In the north, we're looking at some of our very low-lying cane fields, we know they're no longer viable in the coming years," she said.
In some cases, Ms Higginson said farmers would have to move.
"When we get to the hard edges where we can't adapt to a changing climate, then yes, we have to retreat and relocate," she said.
She said governments must stop approving new fossil fuel projects.
"When I see the premier and the ministers out there on the frontline of the disaster zones … but then in the same breath on the same day we see the NSW government approving brand new coal expansions in the Hunter Valley … that sort of hypocrisy or not joining the dots I think is doing no-one any favours," Ms Higginson said.
Dr Karoly said while the link between climate change and extreme weather was well-known, Australia did not have a national climate adaptation plan.
"There was one due out before the last election, but it's been delayed," he said.
He said he wanted the government to stop approving fossil fuel developments and to increase taxes on the mining industry to fund projects that helped communities address repeat disasters.
Dr Karoly said Taree may need to consider levee banks, relocating houses, and drainage systems that could remove floodwater quickly.
"What we need are local plans for doing that effectively and rapidly," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Victorian drought devastates farmers, businesses and communities
The effects of drought creep insidiously into every corner of the Edenhope community. It is like many towns throughout southern Australia suffering greatly at the whim of the weather. Farmers, local businesses and sports clubs — none are immune to a prolonged dry as bad as any can recall. Parched paddocks and dry dams mean farmers are spending tens of thousands of dollars buying feed, carting water and sinking bores, or selling off livestock they can not afford to feed. The money bucket is not bottomless, and for some, the bottom is already being scraped. In a town like Edenhope, almost entirely reliant on surrounding farmers to inject money into the local economy, that means everyone suffers. Paul McDonald farms at Charam, not far from Edenhope. He recalled a time in recent, but fading memory, when it was so wet he could not get around his paddocks. "November, December 2023 you couldn't drive in the paddocks, so I ended up buying a new motorbike to get around," he said. "Well, that motorbike is still sitting in the shed with seven kilometres on the clock, unused because of the dry spell we've had since. He has measured just 50 millimetres of rain for the first five months of this year. The long-term average annual rainfall for his region is about 550mm. Paddock feed is non-existent and his grain reserves are gone. "I've started buying in grain from the next-door neighbour; I had 70 tonnes of grain on hand, but anyway, that's just how the dice rolls I suppose," he said. Mr McDonald said the effect on the town was obvious as farmers tightened their belts. "A lot of times you'd battle to get a car park out the front of the pub or the department store, but now you can just pull up anywhere," he said. "The activity's just not there at the moment. "You're down to the bare necessities." Nick Brahmbhatt, who has owned the local take-away shop for three years, moved to the town during more prosperous times. "When we started here, the lake was full and a lot of people were coming into town and bringing economic activity," he said. He said his income was down by about 20 per cent. "When there's no [rain], the farmers are going to hold back spending," he said. "They're struggling … and everybody just keeps looking at the sky and hoping for rain to come around." But despite the challenges, he said there was no other place he would rather be. Mental health is at the forefront during the drought. The Edenhope-Apsley Football Netball Club, where Liz Kealy is president, provides farmers a critical escape from the drudgery of drought. "Years like these people need the club more than ever — if they don't have that reason to go out, they won't," she said. "For my family, being active and being fit is, first and foremost, getting out and getting those endorphins pumping, being on the field or on the court. Ms Kealy said the conversation about mental health was much more open than during past droughts. "My father is a farmer and talks about the '06 drought and the ones before that and there was not as much support as there is now," she said. Like many in small towns, Ms Kealy wears several hats. She is also an accountant, working with farmers through the financial impacts of drought. She said some of her farming clients were spending $40,000 a week on bought-in feed. Some in the area, she said, would be forced to sell land to keep farming. Grampians Health rural outreach worker Murray McInnes works across a region with an elevated suicide rate. There has been a big increase in people referred to him for help, particularly from the farming community. "It is heavy because people are finding it difficult to leave their farms — they're isolating themselves because they're busy feeding and doing what they need to do and they're not taking time out," he said. Mr McInnes said a break in the drought would not fix everything, but it would certainly help. "It's like coming out of winter, the rain will immensely make people in this area a lot happier," he said. On another farm near Edenhope, Clayton Caldow and his brother Ashley were flat out feeding sheep when ABC Rural stopped by. "It's pretty bad, real bad," Mr Caldow said. He is no stranger to tough times — he lost his dad to suicide in 1984, when Clayton was only 17. "We never saw it coming … and it's still happening," he said. Grief struck his family again in 2016, when his wife Sophie died from breast cancer at 42. "The kids were 3, 7, 12 and 14, but I wasn't just going to sell out … we soldiered on and the support from my family and the town was phenomenal," he said. He has continued to soldier on, raising his children while battling drought. "The youngest one, Poppy, is 11, she's my little gate opener, she asks a lot of questions and she knows how tough it is," he said. He did not know what the future held for the next generation, and said farming was a tough sell in a drought. "You get times this tough — why would you want to do it," he said.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Tasmanian farmers are grappling with the driest conditions in 120 years
In the far north-west corner of Tasmania, beef farmer Stafford Ives-Heres has just harvested a bumper crop of wine grapes from his hobby vineyard. His hometown of Marrawah is beef and dairy country, relentlessly battered by the Roaring 40s, a powerful band of winds that circle the globe. Traditionally, it is far too gusty and wet for fussy crops like grapes. But despite welcome rain this weekend, the wider region has just experienced its lowest January to April rainfall levels since 1900, creating ideal wine grape growing conditions. It is one small hint at a changing climate that could have serious consequences for Australia's food production. The dry is likely a result of what climate researcher Tom Remenyi describes as a "post 2020" climate system, something scientists have been predicting for decades. "All of the modelling kind of suggested that, at about 2020 the globe would move away from a historical climate into a new climate, and all of the evidence is suggesting that that is happening," Dr Remenyi says. For Mr Ives-Heres, keeping an eye on the changing climate is crucial. He points out a couple of bulls in his paddock worth thousands of dollars, noting the loss of even one of them would be a financial gut punch. Despite the record dry, his family farm fared relatively well over the summer. It was a different story last year, when a more prolonged dry period left his family, along with thousands of other Tasmanians, scrabbling for hay, paying up to $250 a bale. "We probably had five really good years on the trot … you can become a bit complacent as farmers," he says. Down the road at Smithton, agricultural contractor Marcus Laing has a truckload of bales to deliver to local farms. Many farmers he comes across cut enough hay and silage last through spring to carry them through the dry at the start of the year, but are hoping for a dump of rain before the cold sets in. Over the years, Mr Laing has been involved in charity hay runs to other states, taking bales as far as drought-stricken Moree, about 630 kilometres north-west of Sydney. This year, despite devastating floods and droughts across multiple states, that is not looking likely. "They've had a hard run up there. They've probably lost crops and lost feed. But yeah, I don't think we're in a position really to help him this year," Mr Laing says. As sea and land temperatures rise, westerly rain-bearing fronts from the Southern Ocean that normally soak the state's western coast are being pushed further south between Tasmania and Antarctica, according to Dr Remenyi. Meanwhile, easterly systems hitting the other side of the state are travelling down more frequently, but with long, dry spells in between. Additionally, warmer temperatures drive evaporation rates up, meaning soil dries out faster than it used to. "We end up having longer dry spells everywhere, and then higher intensity rainfall when it does rain. "The dry days get drier, and the wet days get wetter," Dr Remenyi says. He says while emissions reduction is important, reframing traditional farming practices will be crucial for Australia's food production. "We need to recognise that we committed to this some decades ago, and this change is going to happen," he says. For Mr Ives-Heres, who, along with his family, runs beef, a seaweed business and a small vineyard, as well as off-farm jobs, diversity is the key to survival. Recently he started leasing a paddock in a different location, with hopes a different climate would provide a buffer against future weather events. "We already take enough risks as it is in agriculture with Mother Nature, so having off-farm income or diversity within your business is paramount going forward if you're going to be seriously long-term about farming," he said.
ABC News
6 hours ago
- ABC News
Australia has up to 80 tornadoes a year, but many go unseen
When most people think of tornadoes, it's probably the striking and terrifying images from Tornado Alley in the United States. But did you know Australia records anywhere between 30 and 80 tornadoes each year? The weather events are rarely caught on camera, but earlier this week, several people filmed a tornado as it cut a path across farmland near Frankland River in southern Western Australia. With winds of more than 120kph, it pinned a farm worker against a fence, flipping his ute and damaging a tractor. Bureau of Meteorology (BOM) meteorologist Jessica Lingard said there were two types of tornadoes, with one more violent. "The first are supercell tornadoes and those spawn from supercell thunderstorms, which are the most severe form of thunderstorms," she said. "They result in our warm season tornadoes [and] usually occur during summer months." These are the tornado types that appear in the United States, some of the largest and most damaging in the world. "The other type are non-supercell tornadoes, and these usually occur along the boundaries of two air masses, like a cold front or a sea breeze," Ms Lingard said. This week's tornado in southern WA was the latter type. "Australia experiences somewhere between 30 and 80 tornadoes each year, but it is possible that many more tornadoes occur in the more remote and unpopulated parts of Australia and therefore go unreported," Ms Lingard said. The BOM has recorded rare "tornado outbreaks" in Australia where multiple tornadoes spawn from a single weather system. On September 28, 2016, seven tornadoes hit South Australia, causing mass blackouts. "There's no area in Australia that's more prone to tornadoes, but we do experience different areas of Australia having tornadoes under different circumstances," Ms Lingard said. Supercell thunderstorms, which can produce tornadoes, are most common in New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria, and develop generally in late spring and early summer. The Enhanced Fujita scale ranges from EF0, the weakest, to EF5. The Frankland River tornado is believed to have been EF0. "Each category has a wind speed range and a list of typical damage patterns that we would expect," Ms Lingard said. She said most tornadoes recorded in Australia were rated between EF0 and EF1. Ms Lingard said a tornado that hit northern NSW in 1970 was considered the strongest on record. Known as the Bulahdelah tornado, it reportedly left a 22 kilometre trail of destruction more than 1.5km wide. "It wasn't officially rated but we estimate from the damage that it was likely to be an EF5 system," she said. "From all reports, it destroyed 1 million trees, and we also saw a 2-tonne tractor lifted up and thrown on its roof." The first tornado documented on camera in Australia was in 1911 near Marong in Victoria. It touched down near the property of a man who happened to have a camera — a rare piece of technology at the time. There are many kinds of tornado-like weather, and they are different. "A waterspout is a non-supercell tornado that occurs over water," Ms Lingard said. "Willy willies or dust devils form on clear days over hot, dry surfaces, and they are rapidly rising hot air, but they are not attached to a cloud over the top." A "cock-eyed" or "cockeye bob", while commonly thought to refer to a tornado or willy willy specifically, is actually Australian slang for any suddenly occurring storm. Ms Lingard said there was no evidence to suggest Australia was experiencing more tornadoes. But she said a growing population, armed with phone cameras, meant the storms that did happen were better documented. "Everyone's got a camera in their back pocket and access to social media to share these events," she said. This seems to be a frustration for meteorologists, with the term "mini tornado" often used in the media. "It's one of those terms that the media love to use. It either is a tornado or it isn't," Ms Lingard said. It may be surprising news, but Ms Lingard said in terms of tornadoes per square kilometre, the United Kingdom recorded the most. "Based on land size, the UK gets an average of about 33 tornadoes each year," she said. But in terms of sheer volume, tornadoes are most common in the US. "The US obviously holds the title of the country with the most overall tornadoes and the most intense, and they report well over 1,000 tornadoes a year," Ms Lingard said.
