Appeals Court dismisses appeal by Hydroshoppe, Menara KL for ad interim injunction
PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today dismissed an appeal by the former operator of the Kuala Lumpur Tower and its subsidiary to obtain an ad interim injunction to stop the award of the KL Tower concession to LSH Service Master Sdn Bhd.
The decision was delivered by a three-member bench comprising Justices Datuk Collin Lawrence Sequerah, Datuk Dr Choo Kah Sing and Datuk Wan Ahmad Farid Wan Salleh.
Justice Sequerah, who delivered the court's unanimous decision, said Hydroshoppe Sdn Bhd and its subsidiary Menara Kuala Lumpur Sdn Bhd failed to meet the legal threshold for the grant of an ad interim injunction.
'We are of the view that there is no status quo to maintain as the fifth supplementary agreement has lapsed on March 31, this year,' he said.
Justice Sequerah ordered Hydroshoppe and Menara KL to pay legal costs totalling RM30,000 to the respondents.
The respondents were the Ministry of Communications, its minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil, the government, LSH Service Master Sdn Bhd, LSH Best Builders Sdn Bhd and Service Master (M) Sdn Bhd.
The appeal was against the decision of the High Court in April, this year which had similarly dismissed the application for the ad interim injunction.
Hydroshoppe and Menara KL had filed a breach of contract suit against the respondents, claiming that LSH and its units had induced a breach of contract that the companies (Hydroshoppe and Menara KL) had agreed to with the government in an Aug 2022 meeting.
They claimed that LSH Capital and its units had committed dishonest assistance, and want the award of the KL Tower concession to LSH Service Master to be declared void and unlawful.
They are also claiming an estimated RM1 billion in damages, and for the concession of the iconic Kuala Lumpur landmark building to be transferred back to them.
The High Court will hear the interparte injunction on June 9. It will also hear on June 5, an ex parte contempt application filed by the companies.
In the proceedings before the Court of Appeal today, lawyer Vinayak Sri Ram represented Hydroshoppe and Menara Kuala Lumpur, Senior Federal Counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly@Arwi for the Ministry of Communications, Fahmi and the government.
Lawyer Datuk Malik Imtiaz Sarwar represented LSH Service Master, LSH Best Builders and Service Master.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sinar Daily
3 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
Delay use of commercial LPG, burdens small traders
Rosol also stressed that any subsidy restructuring must be carried out cautiously, with clear communication and appropriate support incentives. The government is urged to postpone the mandatory use of 14-kilogramme commercial LPG cylinders for small traders. Inset: Rosol – Stock photo KUALA LUMPUR – The government has been urged to postpone the mandatory implementation of the use of 14-kilogramme commercial liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) cylinders for small traders, which took effect on May 1. Hulu Terengganu Member of Parliament Datuk Rosol Wahid said the move not only caused operational costs to surge by up to threefold but also put pressure on small traders already struggling to stay afloat. 'Many food business owners have complained to me that they previously spent around RM2,600 a month on gas, but now they are forced to bear costs reaching RM7,000 after being directed to use commercial LPG,' he said in a statement on Thursday. The former Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs (KPDN) deputy minister said the situation worsened as many traders became targets of Op Gasak over the past three weeks, with some fined and their gas cylinders confiscated by the authorities. 'I sympathise with the plight of small traders who are not only burdened by the high cost of living but are now facing pressure from a hastily implemented policy by the Madani government,' he said. Rosol also stressed that any subsidy restructuring must be carried out cautiously, with clear communication and appropriate support incentives. 'The chain reaction from this cost increase will ultimately be borne by consumers. Don't be unjust to the people,' he added. Therefore, he urged the government to postpone the implementation until a targeted aid plan and suitable support measures are introduced for small traders. 'At the very least, the government must have a dedicated plan to ease the cost burden so that end users do not have to bear the sudden impact,' he said.
New Straits Times
4 hours ago
- New Straits Times
NST Leader: Closing the 'leak' in gas subsidy abuse
IT comes as no surprise that retailers are once again manipulating subsidies. This time, large commercial kitchens and hawkers have been found misusing the supply of subsidised liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) cylinders meant for household cooking. Following this discovery, the government, effective May 1, prohibited restaurants and eateries, including hawkers, from using the subsidised LPG cylinders, priced at RM26 a unit. Instead, they were ordered to use purple 14kg cylinders at RM70 per unit. Additionally, kitchens must apply for an annual permit if they need more than three cylinders. From May 1 to 20, Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry enforcement officers seized RM883,000 worth of goods from eateries found to be violating the directive. Why the ban? In exploiting an illegal loophole, these commercial kitchens bought the subsidised cylinders in bulk by deceiving mobile gas sellers into delivering them to homes under the false pretence of household use. The cylinders are then transferred to the commercial kitchens. The lower gas price leads to higher profit margins for these eateries, allowing them to sell dishes at RM28 or more, when the same dish might cost only RM8 to RM10 at food stalls. Commercial kitchens had been exploiting this loophole for years, but the current enforcement only partially addresses the problem. Previously, operators rarely absorbed spiked operating costs and instead passed them on to consumers. In this case, commercial kitchens have conveniently "blamed" the higher cost of their cuisine on the government's "subsidy withdrawal", which did not happen. Food and beverage industry trade representatives are appealing for understanding, requesting time to adjust to the new commercial LPG prices while also contesting the ongoing seizures. While this is happening, what actions can curb rising eatery costs? Food businesses could adjust menu prices, optimise cooking practices and explore alternative energy sources. Waste reduction and efficient supply chain management can also reduce costs. Crucially, any price adjustments should be communicated to customers. Commercial kitchens could also strategise by bulk purchasing, negotiating better supplier rates and optimising deliveries, especially e-hailing orders. They could use customer loyalty programmes and discounts to encourage repeat business during inflationary periods. While the food business overhaul incurs costs, the government could assist by setting commercial LPG prices to start at the RM30 to RM50 range, then gradually raise them. Also, government subsidies or programmes related to LPG and other energy sources should be easily available. If commercial kitchens can cleverly source cheaper LPG cylinders, they can apply similar creative skills to reduce fuel costs, ultimately keeping delicious cuisines affordable.
The Sun
8 hours ago
- The Sun
Putra Heights fire: SPNB to rebuild, repair 17 houses from next week
KEPALA BATAS: Syarikat Perumahan Negara Berhad (SPNB) will rebuild and repair 17 houses affected by the April 1 gas pipeline explosion in Putra Heights, Selangor, starting next week. SPNB chief executive officer Mohd Jamil Idris said this is an initial project involving 11 homes that were completely destroyed and six houses for renovation under the government allocation previously approved, namely a maximum of RM300,000 for rebuilding and RM150,000 for repairs. 'We have entered the area, and our contractors issued appointment letters to the affected residents this week. So, starting next week, they (the contractors) will start work at the site (of the affected houses). If we look at the data we have, so far, there are 17 houses... and this data may change,' he said. He told reporters this when met at the Urban Community Sustainability Programme (PKKB) and SPNB Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Programme in Taman Desa Kuala Muda here today, which was officiated by SPNB chairman Datuk Mohd Azmi Mohd Lila. The gas pipeline fire on April 1 caused flames to rise more than 30 metres high, with temperatures reaching over 1,000 degrees Celsius, causing 81 homes to be completely destroyed, with structural damage exceeding 40 per cent, 81 homes partially damaged, 57 homes affected but not burned, and 218 homes left unaffected. Meanwhile, Mohd Azmi said SPNB will build a total of 5,450 houses under the Rumah Mesra Rakyat (RMR) project nationwide this year, with an allocation of RM504 million, to help B40 and low-income groups own homes. He said they have also implemented about half of the target as of May and aim to complete it all by the end of this year. 'We build these houses quite fast, in three months, mostly using conventional methods as well as IBS (Industrialised Building System), but there may be issues in terms of slight delays (for certain applications) because (there are) necessary processes,' he said. Mohd Azmi said the eligibility criteria for owning an RMR home include a household income not exceeding RM5,000, not currently owning a house and having their own land. 'The construction cost for each house is RM75,000, namely RM20,000 in the form of a government subsidy and the remaining RM55,000 as an interest-free loan. The monthly repayment is RM300 for about 16 years,' he said, adding that a total of 73,279 RMR units have been built nationwide since 2002. As for today's programme, the Ministry of Housing and Local Government (KPKT) contributed RM38,950 while SPNB chipped in with RM10,000. In addition, SPNB and Progressive Impact Technology Sdn Bhd also contributed a 4kWp solar panel system worth RM18,540 to educate the community about electricity savings, environmental friendliness, renewable energy, green technology adoption and promoting a healthier environment.
