Regional Covid-19 restrictions ‘did not change behaviour' during 2020
Regional restrictions did not change people's behaviour during the coronavirus pandemic despite rising numbers in Scotland, a study indicates.
Researchers from the University of Aberdeen examined adherence to restrictions including social distancing, mask-wearing, staying at home and handwashing, and found people in high or low restriction areas behaved no differently to each other.
The study, published in the US journal Translational Behavioral Medicine, looked at behaviour during the Covid-19 pandemic in Scotland from March to November 2020, with 1724 people interviewed at random to get a representative sample.
People did not alter behaviour to follow enhanced local restrictions during the pandemic, the study found, and the restrictions may have been more effective if based around factors other than just coronavirus cases according to new research.
The study compared people's behaviours before and after local restrictions, and compared behaviours of those living in areas with increased restrictions to those living in areas without.
People did not change their behaviour when restrictions were tightened, including social distancing and mask wearing, defying scientists' expectations, research showed.
It also found people in high or low restriction areas behaved no differently to each other, and examined 'intention and self-efficacy'.
Intention and self-efficacy related to keeping a 2.0 metre distance was assessed by asking: 'Do you intend to follow all the government instructions…' and 'How confident or not are you that you can follow the government instructions…' graded on a scale, according to the report.
The respondents answered questions about their behaviours from the past week, including if they had left home, had adhered to the social distancing rule, worn a mask in a shop or on public transport and if they washed their hands as soon as they got home.
Dr Chantal den Daas, senior lecturer in health psychology, in collaboration with the Covid Health and Adherence Research in Scotland (Charis) project, said the research 'can effectively influence public behaviour' in the future.
She said: 'When local restrictions were introduced in 2020 due to an increase in Covid-19 case numbers, we thought we would see a change in behaviour after they were implemented. But this was not what we found.
'It is really important to build an understanding of what could have been done differently and how we can effectively influence public behaviour in the future should we be faced with another public health crisis.
'This research provided insight on the type of information we should aim to collect in future pandemics, to see if we can find better measures to predict cases, examine the need for restrictions and the effect of any restrictions put in place.
'Future research in acute outbreaks should assess behaviour and beliefs about the virus, risk on an ongoing basis and identify the need for intervention even before cases rates start to go up.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Doctor shares six symptoms of new Covid strain sweeping UK with key warning
A doctor has outlined the key signs we need to look out for in the new Covid variant known as 'Nimbus' as cases spike across the UK, with the strain also been found in 21 other countries worldwide A new strain of coronavirus is sweeping across the UK, and symptoms vary, but some are 'not typical' of former Covid cases. The new variant, known as NB.1.8.1, has been named 'Nimbus' and is causing a spike in cases across the nation. As of yesterday, 13 cases of the virus have been confirmed in the UK, prompting concern from health professionals. According to the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA), it is making up a "growing proportion" of Covid cases worldwide, as China and Hong Kong have seen a surge in cases, with the strain also identified in 21 other countries. The symptoms of 'Nimbus' can vary and are largely consistent with previous forms of the virus, but there are six key signs to look out for. Director & Superintendent Pharmacist, Prescription Doctor, Mohamed Imran Lakhi, exclusively tells the Mirror:"People commonly report a severe sore throat, persistent fatigue, mild cough, fever, muscle aches, and nasal congestion. "Some also experience digestive issues like nausea or diarrhoea, which isn't always typical with Covid variants." With a spike in cases of the 'Nimbus' strain across the UK, Dr Lakhi explains how we can best protect ourselves. He said: "While it seems to spread more easily, there's no strong evidence so far that it causes more severe illness than previous versions. Vaccines, especially those updated for Omicron strains, still offer good protection against serious disease. "It's important to stay up to date with your vaccinations and follow basic precautions like hand hygiene and wearing masks in crowded spaces, particularly as this variant circulates. "If you or someone you know develops these symptoms, especially the sore throat and fatigue, it's wise to get tested and isolate until you know more. Early detection helps protect you and those around you." The World Health Organisation (WHO) added the new Covid strain to its official watch list, amid fears it could be more contagious than earlier forms of the virus. However, there's currently no proof that it leads to more severe illness. According to WHO, the strain first appeared in January and by late April it was responsible for around 10.7% of global infections, up from just 2.5% a month earlier. Ireland has witnessed a sharp increase in cases linked to this variant in recent weeks. According to data from the Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HPSC), the proportion of sequenced Covid samples linked to NB.1.8.1 jumped from 3.7% to 27.3% in the last five weeks, reports Dublin Live.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Kate Garraway admits she 'no longer felt safe' while caring for Derek
Kate Garraway has revealed the heartbreaking moment she felt it was unsafe for her and her family as they cared for Derek Draper following his health complications after contracting Covid Kate Garraway has candidly opened up on the struggles she faced while caring for late husband Derek Draper, saying it got to the point she no longer felt safe. Derek, a political lobbyist, died aged 56 in 2022 following a cardiac arrest after years of health implications from long Covid. Derek's health rapidly deteriorated after he contracted coronavirus in March 2020. He died four years later in January 2024. Throughout his struggles, Good Morning Britain presenter Kate was by his side and was his primary carer. However, she has revealed how she got so tired at one stage that she felt the situation was no longer safe for her or her kids. Speaking to the Sun, Kate described a three-week gap in care for her husband while the system tried to work out which agency would be best suited to helping the family with the care he needed. She said during that time she "had no choice but to try to get through looking after Derek 24/7 completely alone". Kate confessed: "By the end I was so sleep-deprived I was scared it was no longer safe — for me, for the children, let alone for Derek. In desperation I called health services again and this time refused to get off the phone until some answer was given. "In the end, the person on the other end of the phone, who was also clearly exhausted, told me, 'There is nothing I can do but — and this isn't official — you are not alone and what I always say to people is take him to A&E and leave him there, then they legally have to do something." Kate was stunned that this was what the stage it had gotten to, questioning how the best solution appeared to be to "abandon" someone who wasn't safe to be left alone. She praised family members who helped with the awful situation, but realises others may not be so lucky. Kate also she admitted she still has a "tsunami of sadness" as she regularly wakes in the middle of night panicking she hasn't given her husband his medicine. She previously revealed the touching last moments she and her two kids shared with Derek. According to Kate in a discussion last year, proud dad Derek told his children, Darcey and Billy: "You're the best children anyone could ask for. Look after mum, be good for her." This was sadly last time Derek saw his two children before going into a coma. Kate openly praised her kids for how they handled their dad's condition and passing. Speaking on Good Morning Britain in February 2024, Kate said: "It was one of those stop-the-clock moments, where you want the world to stop. "It swamps you. We now have 24 hours, [which] turned out to be more of a month, of fighting on and fighting on, following the prognosis that he won't make it through. For the children when they heard he won't make it through, they've heard it so many times. "They were so beautiful, the children, about that. They individually had time with him on his own and Darcey said, 'If, dad, you can't do this, it's okay. Don't worry about us'. And I had similar conversations, a chance to hold his hand and smell his skin and hold him all the way through, and some people don't get that.
Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'Covid left me in a blacked out room, then I was put in a mental health unit'
Brandon says the initial Covid virus wasn't too bad - but the symptoms after were 'terrifying' A man was locked in a psychiatric ward and accused of being delusional after developing a terrifying condition he believes was triggered by Covid. Brandon Green's symptoms included extreme sensitivity to light, hives and a range of allergies; he was eventually forced to spend 20 months living in a blacked-out room. The 37-year-old contracted Covid in 2020 and says that he was not particularly ill - but the experience was strange. 'The virus itself wasn't too bad' Brandon says, 'but it was weird. I could feel something in my brain. For weeks afterwards, my tongue would go numb, my foot would drop for a whole week, I couldn't speak for hours. I'd blank out mid-conversation. It was like I couldn't access my brain.' The next sign that something was wrong was when he used a supermarket sunscreen on his face and had an unusual reaction. 'By the end of the day, I was burnt all over,' he says. 'And the following days and weeks, every time I would go out in the sun, I would feel intense burning.' As time passed, Brandon's symptoms worsened. He developed extreme sensitivity to sunlight that felt like being burned by a blowtorch, hives on his skin and a bizarre sensitivity to metal. 'I couldn't sleep on a mattress because the springs would burn me, so I just moved to the floor,' he explains. He also developed an allergy to mould that left him struggling to breathe and severe sensitivity to electromagnetic radiation, which got worse week by week. By April 2022 he was forced to spend his days in a blacked out room with the curtains taped shut to ensure no light crept in. He was only able to venture out at night and jokes he lived for late night shopping on Thursdays. Brandon was terrified but trips to the doctors left him feeling hopeless. 'Doctors didn't know what to do and kept saying I was making it up,' he said. 'I once had a doctor laugh at me because I said I got relief from acupuncture.' He was ill, exhausted and incredibly frustrated when events took a turn for the worse. Worried friends had contacted a psychiatrist who appeared at his door in 2023 to talk to him. Later that night he had a phone call from the doctor, explaining that he thought he was suffering delusions and that a mental health team was on the way to assess him who then took him to a psychiatric ward. 'As soon as I arrived at the facility, I went out to the basketball court for fresh air, and saw a young guy trying to choke himself with his jumper, wrapping it around his neck and pulling on each end of it,' Brandon said. 'I ran and told the nurse and security. By the time they arrived he'd stopped what he was doing, seen me dob on him and the nurse and security weren't impressed with me - explaining that he was fine. I later got a mouthful from the guy.' Staff wanted to medicate him, but Brandon refused. 'They told me I was delusional, that I had schizophrenia. They wanted to pump me full of benzodiazepines and antipsychotics. I was scared,' he said. Locked up with patients with severe mental illness, his condition worsened and he was plagued with asthma attacks. 'I kept thinking, this is a place for people with mental illness, but I'm here because they think I'm crazy when really I'm sick.' After two days, he was allowed home, exhausted and bewildered - and with no answers about what was really wrong with him. A few months later there was finally progress. Brandon's doctor told him he had Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS), a condition where immune cells overreact and release excessive chemical mediators. He was prescribed Mast Cell Stabilising drugs. There have been multiple reports of people developed MCAS after having Covid and a number of specialists believe that the condition can be triggered by the virus. Over the next few weeks Brandon noticed gradual improvement and by December 2023 - after 20 months of living in the dark - he was finally able to tolerate more light. 'By Christmas Day I was fully out,' he says. 'A true Christmas miracle.' But despite significant improvements, he still struggles with debilitating symptoms that doctors are unable to explain. I want to get better. I want people to understand what I've been through,' he says. 'I've forgiven my friends and family; they were only trying to help. But I would hope the medical establishment would reflect on themselves and improve. We should be able to expect better from doctors and experts.'
