Harvard doctors sue Trump administration over censoring LGBTQ+ terms
Two doctors and professors from Harvard Medical School are suing the Trump Administration over the removal of two research articles from a government website because they included the words 'LGBTQ' and 'trans(gender).' The two doctors describe the move as censorship and say it is antithetical to their mission as health care providers and could harm the transgender community.
Keep up with the latest in + news and politics.
The plaintiffs, Gordon Schiff and Celeste Royce are described in the lawsuit as 'two doctors and Harvard Medical School professors who refused to censor their medical conclusions to bend to this political fiat,' adding they filed the suit 'to defend the integrity of medical research and the safety of patients from the government's dangerous, arbitrary, and unconstitutional censorship.'
They sued over the removal of two articles from the government-run Patient Safety Network (PSNet). 'Endometriosis: A Common and Commonly Missed and Delayed Diagnosis' was co-authored by Royce, and 'Multiple Missed Opportunities for Suicide Risk Assessment in Emergency and Primary Care Settings' was co-authored by Schiff. Both articles contained a sentence referencing the transgender, gender-nonconforming, or LGBTQ+ community.
PSNet is run by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), which is part of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).
According to the lawsuit, Schiff received an email from Patrick Romano, a co-editor of PSNet, saying the articles were being removed from the site in response to an email directive from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) ordering the removal of any content that might be in non-compliance with the White House's executive order on gender identity.
Romano provided further explanation of the decision in a follow-up email to the Editor-in-Chief of the Bellevue Literary Review.
'Per this memo, AHRQ staff were given until 5pm ET Friday to 'Take down all outward facing media (websites, social media accounts etc.) that promote or inculcate gender ideology.'' Romano wrote. 'Based on guidance provided to AHRQ staff, this instruction from OPM was interpreted to include anything with the words 'transgender,' 'nonbinary,' or 'gender identity.' The phrase 'LGBTQ' is problematic because it includes that letter T for 'transgender.'
The doctors are represented by the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts and the Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic at Yale Law School.
'Good doctors serve and advocate for their patients, whoever they are,' Royce said in a statement. 'We cannot uphold an oath to Do No Harm if our training and research are politicized.'
'This type of wholesale, non-evidence-based removal endangers everyone's safety,' Schiff said in a statement. 'Censoring information about transgender people or anyone a politician does not like, who have documented increased risks of negative health outcomes, is antithetical to the very mission of public health.'
'Our clients were given an impossible choice between removing their article from PSNet entirely or censoring parts of it,' Rachel Davidson, a staff attorney at the ACLU of Massachusetts, said in a statement. 'This is an intentional erasure of knowledge, an attack on the integrity of scientific research, and an affront to the public's need for accurate, adequate health information.'
The suit argues that the government violated the First Amendment free speech rights of the doctors and the Administrative Procedure Act for removing articles without cause. The OPM, AHRQ, and HHS are named as defendants in the suit.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Julianne Hough documents egg freezing process
Julianne Hough has undergone egg freezing treatment for the third time. The Dancing With the Stars co-presenter - who revealed in 2008 she has endometriosis, a condition where tissue grows outside of the womb lining - thinks it is important to be transparent about her fertility journey in the hope she can help other women. She wrote on Instagram: "I just want to take a moment to say thank you to Dr. Carolyn Alexander and the incredible team at SCRC. Navigating fertility is never simple, especially with endometriosis and my own personal timeline and hopes around having children… but with them, I've always felt safe, supported, and fully informed. "This is my third round of egg freezing and I know it's not always the most comfortable thing to talk about, let alone share publicly. But I've realized how important it is to open up about these things. Women all over the world are quietly walking into doctors' offices, making huge, brave decisions about their bodies and their futures. It's one of the most vulnerable experiences… physically, emotionally, and for sure hormonally. "If sharing just a small piece of my journey helps someone feel less alone, or inspires them to ask questions and explore what's right for them, then I feel like it's worth it. I truly couldn't be more grateful for this team who's been with me since my second endometriosis laparoscopy surgery back in 2017… they've been like family ever since [yellow heart emoji] (sic)" The 36-year-old dancer accompanied the post with a video documenting the process, which included her injecting her stomach to stimulate her folicles to produce more eggs, and also a "trigger shot" to release them. On the sixth day of the process, she said: "Just woke up, hormones are kicking in, my boobs are getting bigger, everything is happening." She also showed her bloated stomach, a side effect from the treatment. She said: "Look. It's like a little pregger belly. Cutie."
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
GPs receive new training to help endometriosis diagnosis
GPs are receiving new training to help improve early diagnosis. The scheme focuses on endometriosis, a condition affecting one in 10 women in Wales, and is part of the Welsh Government's Women's Health Plan, launched six months ago. The expert-led programme is delivered by Health Education and Improvement Wales (HEIW) and has already led to a 43 per cent increase in GP knowledge about endometriosis, boosting confidence in discussing symptoms and treatment options. Sarah Murphy, minister for mental health and wellbeing, said: "Women have told us that they feel they are not heard, and their symptoms are ignored. "This training ensures women's voices are central to their healthcare experience, and it helps GPs support their patients more effectively. "Endometriosis can have a huge impact on a woman's quality of life, their work and their relationships. "I am determined our Women's Health Plan will drive real improvements in women's health outcomes and reduce inequalities." Dr Mirka Slavska, an obstetrics and gynaecology consultant at Aneurin Bevan University Health Board who delivered the training, said: "I was delighted to deliver this training with Health Education and Improvement Wales. "The session covered differential diagnoses, referral pathways, novel diagnostic and treatment options, and introduced the Endometriosis Cymru symptom reporting tool. "The excellent feedback we received reflects the value of equipping healthcare professionals with current, practical knowledge to improve care for those living with endometriosis." Endometriosis is one of eight priority areas in the Women's Health Plan, published in December. Since its launch, key achievements include plans for a women's health hub in every health board area by March 2026, the creation of Wales' first women's health research centre, and a focused call for research into women's health communication. Dr Helen Munro, clinical lead for Women's Health in Wales, provided an update on the health hubs at the Everywoman Festival in Cardiff. She said: "Meeting women's needs across their life course will be at the heart of the new women's health hubs. "This is where healthcare professionals will join up with existing services to provide women's health services within our communities."
Axios
3 days ago
- Axios
Detroit dines later than most cities
Earlier dinner reservations are trending, but many Detroit diners still prefer to eat after 8pm. The big picture: Detroit's on par with the national share of reservations made in the 5 o'clock hour, but we're making more dinner plans for 8 o'clock and later, Resy data shared with Axios shows. Nationally, dinner times have shifted earlier since the pre-pandemic years. By the numbers: More than 17% of Detroit Resy reservations were made between 8-10pm in 2024. The national figure in that time slot is less than 14%. Zoom out: Detroit is among a handful of big cities with more than 5% of reservations made in the 9 o'clock hour. Others include Miami (9.9%), Atlanta (5.2%) and Pittsburgh (5.5%). On the other end, few diners in Denver (1.6%) and Nashville (1.8%) plan to eat past 9. What they're saying: Eating earlier in the day supports your body's natural clock — boosting metabolism and improving sleep, experts say. If you have a later dinner, but eat the same amount, "that by itself leads to an increase in cravings, changes in appetite hormones and fewer calories burnt across the waking hours," Frank Scheer, Harvard Medical School professor and Medical Chronobiology Program director, tells Axios. Eating earlier can also lead to earlier bedtimes — which unlock even more health benefits. Even during simulated night shifts, eating during the day could benefit heart health, per a new study co-authored by Scheer. Studies show sleep loss slows your reaction time — even if you think you're OK. And research suggests that the cognitive and motor impairments from lack of sleep can be similar to — or even worse than — being drunk. The intrigue: Sleep-deprived people "lose the ability to judge how well they're doing," Karin Johnson, a sleep medicine specialist and professor of neurology at UMass Chan School of Medicine-Baystate, told Axios.
