logo
The Guardian view on Trump's foreign policy: an alarming new order takes shape

The Guardian view on Trump's foreign policy: an alarming new order takes shape

The Guardian05-02-2025

Nothing about Donald Trump's notion that Gaza should come under US control makes sense according to established laws and norms of international relations. But the current White House regime despises the old way of doing things and intends to reshape the world so drastically that restoration of a pre-Trumpian order will be impossible.
The absurd incoherence of Mr Trump's proposal that the US 'take over' Gaza doesn't make it any less sinister. The requirement that 2.2 million Palestinians be forcibly resettled in neighbouring Arab states amounts to unambiguous endorsement of a criminal atrocity – ethnic cleansing.
The idea that the land, having been requisitioned by the US government, will then be transformed into a Mediterranean 'riviera' is disturbing and grotesque in its detachment from reality. Mr Trump is treating a war zone at the centre of one of the world's most intractable conflicts as if it were a patch of derelict Manhattan real estate. He is toying with the lives of millions of people in the idiom of a corrupt property developer and with the methods and ethics of a mafia boss.
The inevitable consequence of handling complex international issues with cruel and bovine simplicity is to spread fear, uncertainty and instability. It adds gratuitous volatility at precisely the moment when the opposite approach is imperative to preserve the fragile ceasefire in Gaza.
Every government in the Middle East, except Benjamin Netanyahu's ultra-nationalist coalition in Israel, rejects Mr Trump's intervention as dangerous and counterproductive. That is also the view among the US's European allies – or the countries that two weeks ago considered themselves free-thinking allies of the US but now see that no such concept exists in the president's mind.
He recognises only clients, rivals and enemies. It is possible to move between those categories by deploying flattery and offering favours. But durable alignment based on mutual interest, legally binding treaty obligations and democratic values is a model that no longer has currency in the White House.
That is a tremendous boost to the geopolitical ambitions of Russia and China. It vindicates a vicious might-is-right approach to international relations. It legitimates the kind of imperialistic land grab that Vladimir Putin is pursuing in Ukraine. For Beijing, an age of American unreliability offers lucrative avenues of economic and strategic expansion. China sees a vacancy for itself as the world's most predictable superpower.
There is a common rationalisation that explains his recklessness as opening moves in a negotiation. His most outlandish ideas, like American appropriation of Gaza, are thus sanitised as the freewheeling improvisations of a 'transactional' businessman. He is cast as a master of brinkmanship who uses shock and chaos to wrongfoot opponents before settling, in the end, for more sober outcomes.
That analysis looks increasingly naive, even if it tallies with the president's self-image. He might think he is just doing 'deals', but others should be clear that the correct terms are coercion and extortion.
There are plenty of examples from history of capricious potentates spreading disorder in their own territories and abroad. There is no precedent for that happening to the world's most powerful democracy, and no playbook to guide that country's former allies in handling the situation. But one thing is now clear – hoping Mr Trump's America might be cajoled into following the old rules is not a safe strategy.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Musk: I apologise for some of my Trump posts
Musk: I apologise for some of my Trump posts

Telegraph

time36 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Musk: I apologise for some of my Trump posts

Elon Musk has apologised to Donald Trump for posting incendiary comments on social media during their public row. The tech billionaire, who worked with Mr Trump for 130 days as a special government employee, said on X that the US president should be impeached and claimed he was mentioned in the Epstein files. 'I regret some of my posts about President @realDonaldTrump last week. They went too far.' Mr Musk has said. Mr Trump said that Mr Musk had 'lost his mind' during the meltdown, which started with a disagreement over the government's 'big beautiful' spending bill. Since stepping down as the head of the US Department of Government Efficiency, Mr Musk has criticised Mr Trump's tax and spending bill, describing it as a 'disgusting abomination' that will increase national debt. In an interview with NBC News on Saturday, Mr Trump said he had 'no desire' to speak to Mr Musk and accused him of being 'disrespectful to the office of the President'. Asked if his relationship with the tech boss was over, he replied: 'I would assume so.' It came after JD Vance, the US vice president, said Mr Musk had made a 'huge mistake' in picking a fight with Mr Trump. Mr Vance said he hoped Mr Musk would 'come back into the fold', but acknowledged that might be difficult after he went 'nuclear' during the public spat with the president.

Elon Musk says he 'regrets' some posts he made about Donald Trump
Elon Musk says he 'regrets' some posts he made about Donald Trump

BBC News

time38 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Elon Musk says he 'regrets' some posts he made about Donald Trump

Billionaire Elon Musk has said he regrets some of the posts he made about US President Donald Trump during their war of words on social media. "I regret some of my posts about President Donald Trump last week. They went too far," he said on his platform X. The two were embroiled in a public fallout, after the Telsa owner called Trump's tax bill a "disgusting abomination". His post comes after Trump declared that their relationship was over, and that he had no interest in mending ties with Musk. The budget, which includes huge tax breaks and more defence spending, was passed by the House of Representatives last month and is now being considered by senators.

Elon Musk says he 'went too far' with posts about Donald Trump
Elon Musk says he 'went too far' with posts about Donald Trump

Metro

time38 minutes ago

  • Metro

Elon Musk says he 'went too far' with posts about Donald Trump

Elon Musk is walking back 'some' of his comments about Donald Trump – this is the latest twist in their public break-up. Tesla and Space X's CEO wrote on X this morning: 'I regret some of my posts about president Trumpweek. They went too far.' Got a story? Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ Or you can submit your videos and pictures here. For more stories like this, check our news page. Follow on Twitter and Facebook for the latest news updates. You can now also get articles sent straight to your device. Sign up for our daily push alerts here. MORE: Trump likens LA protests to foreign 'invasion' amid attempt to block him from using troops MORE: What is happening in LA right now? MORE: Full list of 12 countries on Donald Trump's travel ban that starts today

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store