Westpark Cemetery's impending closure sparks a shift towards cremation in Johannesburg
Westpark Cemetery in Johannesburg is expected to reach capacity for new burials by August 2025.
Image: Johannesburg City Parks and Zoo
As the Westpark Cemetery in Johannesburg faces imminent closure as it nears full capacity, some African families who previously did not believe in cremation are now seeing it as the way to go.
At least 38 of the 42 cemeteries operated by the Johannesburg City Parks and Zoo (JCPZ) in Gauteng are at full capacity.
This leaves the City of Gold with the Olifantsvlei Cemetery in the far south of Johannesburg, the Waterval Cemetery in Midrand, the Diepsloot Cemetery in the northern part of Johannesburg, and the Hamberg Cemetery in Roodepoort, which is set to be reactivated in June 2025, after previously being dormant.
The JCPZ has assured residents that there is sufficient burial space to meet the city's needs for the next 30 to 40 years, and this excludes future expansions and the activation of currently dormant cemeteries.
Westpark Cemetery, located in Randburg, will officially close at the end of August 2025, and it has been operational since 1942.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Debbie Mmusi, a Johannesburg resident, expressed her disappointment with the break-ins at cemeteries and now prepares to build a memorial wall in the backyard of her family home where they will deposit their ashes.
Mmusi said that she had initially wanted to buy four empty tombs at Westpark Cemetery, because she wanted all of her family members to be buried in the same site when they die. However, after seeing the desecration of ash walls at the Braamfontein Cemetery and the vandalism of tombstones in other cemeteries, she asked her family members about their thoughts on cremation, and they all didn't have a problem with it.
At that time, the JCPZ said an investigation found that over 4,000 ash walls, some over 50 years old, were either damaged due to fallen branches or deliberately desecrated and ransacked.
Mmusi said: 'I am going to build a wall of remembrance at the back of the family property; it will have pigeonholes the size of a brick to fit whatever we put the ashes in. Then we will seal it off and put a family name, the names of all the descendants of the family member, and a picture of the deceased loved one. In case we decide to sell the property later, we will move with our ashes.'
She added that putting the ashes in the remembrance wall in the backyard will ensure that the loved ones remain there with dignity, and the wall will be taken care of. Mmusi encouraged other families to consider cremation.
Her deceased loved ones are buried in at least five different cemeteries, she said.
'The thing is, at the cemeteries right now, tombstones are being destroyed, tombstones are left unattended, and people instantly forget where their relatives are buried,' she said.
However, the JCPZ said all cemeteries, including dormant and inactive sites, are supported by dedicated maintenance, security, and administrative teams. 'The JCPZ also collaborates with law enforcement and community safety partners to safeguard these spaces against vandalism and neglect.'
Muzi Hlengwa, spokesperson for the Unification Task Team of the Funeral Industry of South Africa (UTT), said the closure of cemeteries has dire consequences for the undertakers and pushes up the funeral expenses.
'Currently, there is a huge traffic jam at the cemeteries, and tombs are too close together. Even when the undertaker is done with the funeral, they struggle to get out of the cemetery due to the space limitations. You find that instead of spending 30 minutes at the gravesite, you end up staying for three hours because the exit is blocked by traffic from other family funerals. You lose time trying to enter, and also lose time trying to exit the cemetery,' Hlengwa said.
In a normal situation, he said, undertakers could use the same hearse to deliver the body for family A and return and deliver for family B, but now, because of the shortage of space resulting in traffic jams at the cemetery, undertakers cannot double-book the hearse anymore.
'Now, as the undertaking business, we have to have more fleet than we were supposed to. This leads to an increase in funeral expenses. If an undertaker is able to do two funerals with one hearse on the same day, the costs can be split between two families, resulting in lower expenses. Whereas, if it is one hearse for one funeral per day, the cost becomes high,' he said.
Jenny Moodley, spokesperson for the JCPZ, said a comprehensive, multi-faceted strategy is being implemented to address long-term burial space availability.
Interventions include phased out reduction of burials at Westpark Cemetery, reactivation of dormant cemeteries, promotion of alternative burial options, and the development of new cemeteries, she said.
Moodley added that the JCPZ is engaging traditional leaders, interfaith forums, funeral directors, and community organisations to ensure inclusive planning and culturally sensitive solutions. There are also public awareness campaigns and family support services.
'Families affected by the gradual closure of Westpark are being supported by cemetery staff, who assist with referrals to alternative cemeteries and advise on options such as reopening family-held graves for additional burials.
'JCPZ recognises the deeply personal and cultural importance of burial practices. We remain committed to delivering dignified, respectful, and sustainable end-of-life services for all Johannesburg residents. Our goal is to balance current demands with responsible long-term planning for future generations,' she said.
The annual average demand for burial space in Johannesburg currently ranges between 14,000 and 15,000 burials per year.
She said the burials at Westpark are being gradually reduced, with the cemetery expected to reach capacity for new burials by August 2025.
According to her, the JCPZ is exploring unused land in dormant cemeteries such as Hamberg and identifying infill opportunities within other dormant cemeteries, to be developed as funding allows.
'We have seen a growing number of residents, across faiths, opting for cremation or reopening existing graves; practices that promote sustainable use of cemetery land. Additionally, cemeteries such as Avalon, Westpark, and Alexandra are seeing increasing use of family grave reopenings, a positive trend in efficient land use,' Moodley said.
gcwalisile.khanyile@inl.co.za
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
6 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Race against extinction: Predation, noise pollution the next big threats to African penguins
The African penguin could become extinct in 10 years but environmental groups are trying everything they can to save them. The African penguins we know and love may not be around for much longer. Organisations like BirdLife South Africa, the Southern African Foundation for the Conservation of Coastal Birds (Sanccob), WWF and Cape Nature, however, are doing everything they can to arrest the decline. Their recent World Environment Day celebration at Stony Point Nature Reserve in Kogelberg — the site of one of the Cape's key penguin colonies — highlighted the continued efforts needed to prevent the extinction of the critically endangered African penguin and the benefits African penguins bring to local communities. African penguins are set to become extinct in 10 years, according to the International Union for Conservation of Nature. In 2024, the number of breeding pairs at Stony Point Nature Reserve dropped by half — leaving only 676 pairs. While the decrease in breeding pairs cannot necessarily be explained by death, Craig Smith, a senior marine specialist at the WWF, said: 'Penguins are an indicator species.' Penguins' decision not to breed — or to abandon their eggs — means we should have 'grave concern' for ecosystem health. Earlier this year, a landmark settlement agreement between conservation NGOs and the commercial fishing industry created 'no fishing zones' around five key African penguin colonies, including Stony Point, in an effort to protect penguins' food sources. Thus far, food resource competition between penguins and small pelagic fisheries for anchovies and sardines has been the greatest threat to African penguins. But even with the creation of no-fishing zones, the struggle is not over. According to Smith, the West Coast sardine stock is depleted. Anchovies are at their lowest on record. And it's hard to get these species to rebound. A Namibian small pelagic fishery with sardine and anchovy paused its operations to allow the species to recover, Smith said. But seven years had passed and the species had not recovered. If the prey conditions of these key small fish can improve, as long as commercial fisheries maintain reasonable exploitation rates, then it might be enough to mitigate resource competition, according to Alistair MacInnes, the Seabird Conservation Programme Manager at Birdlife SA. But even then, two key threats to penguins remain: noise pollution and predation. Noise pollution 'Since ship-to-ship bunkering… started in 2016, the closest (penguin) colony, St Croix, has suffered a dramatic decline. They've lost 85 to 90% of their population,' said Nicky Stander, the head of conservation at Sanccob. Ship-to-ship bunkering, also known as ship-to-ship fuel banking, is the process of transfer of petrol from one ship to another while at sea. It is a highly risky activity that can result in oil spills. This practice results in an enormous amount of noise because of the increased vessel traffic required for this practice, which can have a significant impact on penguin breeding. Currently, ship-to-ship bunkering is allowed at Agoa Bay. Predation Furthermore, land-based penguin colonies like those at Stony Point and Simon's Town face an added challenge, with threats from inland and from the ocean. Penguins are prey to sharks, seals, mongoose, and even wild dogs. 'If you remove one predator, it can simply get replaced by another,' said Alana Duffell-Canham from CapeNature on the difficulty of contending with predation as a threat. Further, conservationists must consider how 'predators are also important for maintaining ecosystem balances'. Even so, CapeNature had started to install camera traps and was looking for more funding to implement more predation monitoring at Stony Point, Duffell-Canham said. 'We are throwing everything we can at the species,' Sanccob's Stander said. This included blood transfusions, fracture repairs, and chick rescuing programmes. 'Because their status is so critical, we have to try everything possible to save each individual.' Following the court outcome, conservation groups will continue monitoring and evaluating the effectiveness of their efforts. Alistar MacInnes from Birdlife SA emphasized the need for every location to collect the same data. There would be formal evaluations — one in six years, and another in 10 years. The six-year evaluation was associated with when most young birds would breed for the first time since the first year of fishing closure. The 10-year evaluation was associated with the previously predicted extinction date for African penguins. If researchers saw improved foraging efficiency by that time, it would indicate a positive turn for the survival of African penguins. Change came slowly and 'the data needed for advocacy and policy change can only come in six years, given the natural cycle of penguins', said McInnes. Penguin conservation efforts had also created opportunities for young people in the nearby Mooiuitsig community. Young people served as WWF's Marine and Coastal Community Monitors, recording data, checking for pollution, and collecting and recording plastic waste. In the end, Smith from WWF asked: 'Penguins are a charismatic species. If we can't protect this species, then what can we protect?' DM
The Citizen
4 days ago
- The Citizen
Initiation season in South Africa: why state regulation clashes with customary laws
Criticisms of initiation schools also reflect negative attitudes towards indigenous laws. Initiates seen at a circumcision school in Mthatha, Eastern Cape. Picture: Gallo Images / City Press / Denvor de Wee It's nearly winter in South Africa, which means the opening of winter initiation schools is approaching. These rituals mark a transition to adulthood and are deeply ingrained culturally. But they're often the subject of headlines because of deaths and safety issues. Now government is looking to tighten its enforcement of the Customary Initiation Act of 2021. We asked Anthony Diala, a scholar of African customary law, to break down the issues. What is traditional initiation in South Africa? Traditional initiation is a cultural rite of passage. Millions of South Africans observe varying forms of initiation rites to mark significant events such as birth, puberty, adulthood, marriage and death. Initiation reflects important ancestral ties, values and cultural identity. These rites vary from community to community. Male initiation among the Xhosa people of the Eastern Cape province, for example, includes circumcision and seclusion in specially constructed lodges away from communities. Initiates learn survival skills, cultural traditions and social responsibilities from tribal elders. Some training involves rituals and dietary restrictions. ALSO READ: Gauteng man arrested for illegal initiation school and taking in children Female initiation prepares girls for social roles as wives, mothers and aunts. Initiation ceremonies by the Bantwane of Mpumalanga province, for example, teach appropriate social and sexual behaviour for very young girls through a six-week rite of passage. They include real and symbolic circumcision. (Symbolic circumcision means a slight cut or 'nick from a trained health worker' rather than full circumcision.) In traditional communities, initiation to adulthood reflects intimate connections between farming practices, seasonal changes and ancestral rites. It reinforces the relationship between human development and agricultural productivity. So, it typically coincides with critical farming seasons and crop cultivation cycles. Why are initiation practices regulated? From my research on the interaction of legal systems, I know the state is mandated to protect public wellbeing. The Customary Initiation Act of 2021 asserts the state has a 'duty to set norms and standards' for initiation practices. There are good reasons for this. Initiation practices are sometimes accused of violating bodily autonomy and other human rights. There's concern about the abduction of boys into initiation schools, questionable consent of initiates, the risk of physical injury through negligence, poor hygienic conditions and unqualified traditional practitioners. Since 1995, hundreds of male Xhosa initiates have died from complications. Thousands have suffered penis amputations due to practitioner incompetence. READ MORE: Traditional leaders warn initiation schools to toe the line This health risk is the strongest argument for state regulation. But criticisms of initiation schools also reflect negative attitudes towards indigenous laws. Some Africans condemn their own indigenous practices because they have embraced western culture and its notions of civilised behaviour. The Europeans who colonised South Africa used Christianity, Eurocentric education and new systems of work to alter the behaviour of their subjects. They created new cultural values for Africans, who went on to replicate these values. South Africa adopted a western-style constitution and uses its foreign values to regulate indigenous practices. What does the new regulation propose? The Department of Cooperative Government and Traditional Affairs recently invited comments on Draft Customary Initiation Regulations. These will regulate the enforcement of the Customary Initiation Act by clarifying the roles of the National Initiation Oversight Committee and provincial initiation coordinating committees. The Customary Initiation Act itself demands the registration of initiation schools and traditional surgeons. It requires written consent from parents or legal guardians for minors, and forbids initiation for children under 16. It even restricts initiation seasons to school holidays. How does regulation reflect a clash between customary and common law? Indigenous laws cherish communal welfare. Common laws prioritise individual wellbeing. While indigenous laws emerged in agrarian (farming) settings, the laws imposed by European colonisers developed in industrial societies. The clash of cultures has been intense in the courts. European colonial judges refused to enforce customs they considered contrary to public policy, natural justice, equity or good conscience. READ MORE: Boy runs away to join initiation school, family given list of items to secure his return This enabled them to 'civilise' African behaviour. Today, the 'civilising' role is performed by Africans themselves using the constitution's bill of rights. The Customary Initiation Act wants to transform initiation practices to reflect the values in the bill of rights. Sections 15, 30-31, 39(3) and 211 of the constitution recognise customary law and mandate courts to apply it. But the bill itself emerged from foreign ideas. Specifically, it came from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948. Western powers adopted this with zero input from indigenous Africans. So, state regulation of initiation practices continues to make European laws culturally superior to indigenous African laws. What's the way forward? Obviously, the state is obliged to protect everyone's human rights, including those of initiates. But traditional communities also have a constitutional right to practise their culture without undue state influence. Therefore, a balance needs to be struck between protecting teenagers and preserving culture. In striking this balance, everyone must keep in mind the agrarian origins of initiation rites and the colonial origins of the modern South African state. In the precolonial era, families and tribal leaders had the duty of protecting initiates. There is no reason why this should not continue. READ MORE: Initiation schools: Commission wants answers on why recommendations haven't been carried out State regulation should be limited to establishing minimum health standards and providing training for traditional practitioners. In my view, it should leave age participation guidelines and informed consent to traditional authorities. This would be a sign that the state respects indigenous law as a legitimate source of law in South Africa. To assuage health concerns, some initiation rites can be performed symbolically. Traditional practitioners can be trained to incorporate modern health knowledge without compromising cultural authenticity. This will improve health standards. Hopefully, it will also reduce negative perceptions of initiation practices. This article was republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article here.
TimesLIVE
6 days ago
- TimesLIVE
Africa Day 2025: online safety and African moderators' plight as human rights
With the 2025 Africa Day celebrations done and dusted in May, we must pause and reflect on the state of online safety on the continent and listen to the desperate plights of African digital platform workers, including content moderators in Kenya whose task is to keep the social media platforms clean and free from harm. This is relevant as the theme for this year's Africa Day held on May 25 was the Year of reparation and justice for Africans and people of African descent. These issues are the core of human rights, impacting on reparation and justice that we are striving for this year. ..
