First UK trans judge to take gender ruling to European rights court
LONDON:
The UK's first transgender judge on Monday said she plans to take the British government to the European Court of Human Rights for its policies on trans rights following a divisive Supreme Court ruling.
Victoria McCloud, a retired High Court judge, said she would bring "one or more cases" against Prime Minister Keir Starmer's government, accusing it of breaching the European Convention on Human Rights.
Earlier this month, Britain's top court handed down a landmark ruling that gender and sex were defined by a person's sex at birth in the country's anti-discrimination laws.
The government has embraced the ruling and said trans women should use men's facilities and vice versa, with Britain's equality watchdog announcing interim guidance along the same lines.
McCloud told
AFP
in a statement that the ruling and official response "is a serious infringement of the Convention Rights of EU and UK citizens, including in relation to sex, sexual orientation, and privacy".
"I intend firmly to re-assert my convention rights and other rights under the convention," added the former judge, who now works as a litigation strategist.
The UK Supreme Court ruling also threw into confusion the validity of gender recognition certificates, which allow trans people to gain legal recognition in their chosen gender.
McCloud has a gender change certificate but according to the ruling she would be defined as a man under the Equality Act, leaving her with "two sexes at once", she alleged.
The court's decision was a victory for gender critical activists who brought the appeal to London after losing previous cases in Scottish courts.
McCloud said she and one other trans applicant were not allowed to present arguments to the Supreme Court during its hearing last year.
The UK apex court hears appeals on points of law "of the greatest public importance", and can choose to hear arguments from "interveners" at its discretion.
"The court heard no members of the trans community and did not give reasons," said McCloud.
The UK's Equality and Human Rights Commission said in interim guidance issued that trans women "should not be permitted to use the women's facilities" including in workplaces, shops and hospitals.
Instead, it suggested the use of unisex toilets for trans people.
However, McCloud argues there is no easy way to determine the biological sex of a person.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Important to keep on telling stories: Journalist after being shot at LA protest
An Australian journalist who was struck by a rubber bullet while covering immigration raid protests in Los Angeles, US, shared a message after the incident that stood Tomasi, Nine News' US correspondent, found herself in the middle of chaos outside the Metropolitan Detention Centre in downtown LA, where demonstrators had gathered to protest against US President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown. Things took a sharp turn when the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) and National Guard forces clashed with reporting live from the scene, Tomasi described the mounting tension: 'After hours of standing off, this situation has now rapidly deteriorated,' she said. 'The LAPD moving in on horseback, firing rubber bullets at protesters.' Seconds later, she was hit. The footage showed an officer apparently aiming directly at Tomasi and her camera operator. The impact made her cry out in pain and reach for her calf. Despite the obvious injury, she stayed calm and assured those nearby, 'I'm good.'Later in a post on X, Tomasi addressed the incident and reassured viewers. 'Hey there. Thanks for all your messages – I'm a bit sore, but I'm okay. Important we keep on telling the stories that need to be told,' she wrote, along with the broadcast from that a look at the post here:advertisementIn a statement, Nine News backed their reporter and highlighted the importance of journalistic safety: 'Lauren Tomasi was struck by a rubber bullet. Lauren and her camera operator are safe and will continue their essential work covering these events.'Australia's Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said that all journalists should be able to work safely and that the country supports media Australian lawmakers spoke out and called the shooting unacceptable. Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young urged Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to take up the issue with the US, insisting that the first thing he should say to President Trump at the upcoming G7 meeting is: 'Stop shooting at our journalists.'Nationals Senator Matt Canavan acknowledged the seriousness of the situation but urged for a full investigation. Greens Senator Nick McKim, meanwhile, demanded that the government express its displeasure 'at the highest possible level.'The Guardian also reported that this wasn't an isolated incident. A day earlier, British photojournalist Nick Stern was injured during a similar protest in the LAPD had declared the protest site an 'unlawful assembly' zone and issued an advisory to the media to maintain a distance from active operations. Still, geolocation data confirmed Tomasi was shot near the ICE field office, one of the key flashpoints of the protest.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
In Brief: KPSC notification for recruitment quashed
Karnataka Administrative Tribunal Karnataka Public Service Commission road safety curriculum In a major setback to the state government, the(KAT) annulled the's (KPSC) February 26, 2024,notification for recruiting 384 Gazetted Probationers, citing a violation of the Supreme Court's 50% reservation cap, and also struck down the government's December 2022 order that raised quotas to 56% without legislative approval. The tribunal, led by Chairperson Justice RB Budihal and member Raghavendra Auradkar, ruled in response to a petition by BN Madhu of Channapatna, challenging the legality of the increased quota based on the 2022 ordinance issued by the Basavaraj Bommai-led BJP government, which raised SC/ST reservation from 18% to 24%.While allowing KPSC to issue a fresh notification within legal limits, the verdict disrupts the recruitment process, affecting thousands of aspirants, and the state government is now expected to challenge the ruling in the High a rare and significant find, historian and researcher Dr B Ramachari has unearthed a 233-year-old edition of the prestigious British newspaper 'The Mail' or 'Claypoole's Daily Advertiser', which contains a detailed account of Tipu Sultan's valour during the Third Anglo-Mysore newspaper, published in 1792, had a series of letters written by British officer Lord Cornwallis to the then Governor-General. These letters vividly describe the events of the war and provide compelling insights into Tipu Sultan's military strategies and to the report, Tipu Sultan, accompanied by a formidable army of 30,000 soldiers, was advancing from Arcot toward the Carnatic region, camping near Bengaluru and Srirangapatna. Lord Cornwallis, in his letters, had expressed concern to the Governor-General about the possible consequences of engaging Tipu Sultan in Police Department's proposedhas not yet been incorporated into the state school syllabus. The Education Department has decided to bring this matter to the attention of the textbook committee chairperson for necessary Department had prepared a detailed curriculum on road safety and requested the Department of State Education Research and Training (DSERT) to integrate it into various grade-level syllabi. DSERT officials forwarded this proposal to the Karnataka Textbook Society (KTBS).In response, KTBS managing directors informed that any addition or removal of topics requires approval from a textbook revision or creation committee appointed by the government. Once such a committee is formed, the Police Department's prepared road safety curriculum will be formally presented for consideration.
India Today
2 hours ago
- India Today
US-China trade talks resume in London amid rare earth supply concerns
LONDON, June 10 (Reuters) - Top US and Chinese officials will resume trade talks for a second day in London on Tuesday, hoping to secure a breakthrough over export controls for goods such as rare earths that have threatened a global supply chain shock and slower economic are hoping that the two superpowers can improve ties after the relief sparked by a preliminary trade deal agreed in Geneva last month gave way to fresh doubts after Washington accused Beijing of blocking exports that are critical to sectors including autos, aerospace, semiconductors and talks come at a crucial time for both economies, with customs data showing that China's exports to the U.S. plunged 34.5% in May, the sharpest drop since February 2020, when the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic upended global trade. While the impact on US inflation and the jobs market has so far been muted, the dollar remains under pressure from U.S. two sides met at the ornate Lancaster House in the British capital on Monday to discuss disagreements around the Geneva deal, and are due to resume talks early on Tuesday before both sides are expected to issue U.S. side is led by US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, while the Chinese contingent is helmed by Vice Premier He inclusion of Lutnick, whose agency oversees export controls for the US, is one indication of how central rare earths have become. China holds a near-monopoly on rare earth magnets, a crucial component in electric vehicle did not attend the Geneva talks at which the countries struck a 90-day deal to roll back some of the triple-digit tariffs they had placed on each often erratic policymaking on tariffs has roiled global markets, sparked congestion and confusion in major ports, and cost companies tens of billions of dollars in lost sales and higher second round of meetings between the two sides comes four days after Trump and Xi spoke by phone, their first direct interaction since Trump's January 20 the call Trump said Xi had agreed to resume shipments to the US of rare earths minerals and magnets, and Reuters reported that China has granted temporary export licenses to rare-earth suppliers of the top three US tensions remain high over the export controls, after factories around the world started to fret that they would not have enough of the materials they need to keep InTrending Reel
