EU changes to sustainability law risk company lawsuits, legal scholars say
BRUSSELS - The European Union's plans to cut back sustainability reporting rules could expose European companies to more climate change-related lawsuits, 31 legal scholars said in a letter published on Friday.
The European Commission in February proposed loosening corporate sustainability rules for businesses in Europe, responding to criticism that EU red tape hinders competitiveness with rivals in China and the United States.
Among the changes, the EU would delete a requirement in its due diligence law for large companies to put into effect a "transition plan" to ensure they comply with the EU's targets to cut greenhouse gas emissions. Companies would still need to have such a plan, but would not be legally obliged to put it into practice.
"Mere paperwork, instead of good faith action, would suffice in meeting the obligation," the legal scholars said in the letter.
"The absence of a binding regulatory framework will correspond directly with increased liability risks for private actors," they said, referring to potential court cases from plaintiffs citing risks to the environment and public health.
The letter's 31 signatories included Thom Wetzer, Associate Professor of Law and Finance at the University of Oxford, Christina Eckes, Director of the University of Amsterdam's Centre for European Law and Governance, and Wolf-Georg Ringe, Director of the Institute of Law and Economics at the University of Hamburg.
The academics cited said court cases highlighted the climate-related legal risks businesses already face, citing pending cases against companies including TotalEnergies and Eni, from plaintiffs demanding the firms align their corporate actions with climate goals.
A European Commission spokesperson declined to immediately comment on the letter.
The Commission has previously said its proposals would make life easier for businesses while keeping the EU on track for its targets to cut CO2 emissions. The plan must be negotiated by the European Parliament and member states - a process that can take more than a year.
European businesses have long said strict regulations hampered their ability to compete globally, with U.S. President Donald Trump's aggressive deregulation drive increasing calls for Brussels to act. Campaigners have criticised the EU plans to soften sustainability rules as gutting corporate accountability. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
US troops make first detentions in Trump border military zones
FILE PHOTO: A Texas National Guard soldier stands near the wall on the border between Mexico and U.S. during a sandstorm, as seen from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico March 6, 2025. REUTERS/Jose Luis Gonzalez/File Photo U.S. troops have made their first detentions inside military areas set up on the U.S.-Mexico border as part of the Trump administration's crackdown on illegal immigration, the U.S. Army said. The unprecedented military areas along 260 miles (418 km) of border in New Mexico and Texas were declared extensions of U.S. Army bases by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, allowing troops to temporarily detain migrants and other civilian trespassers. Three 'illegal aliens' were detained by troops in the New Mexico area near Santa Teresa on June 3, before being handed to U.S. Border Patrol, Army spokesperson Major Geoffrey Carmichael said in an email. "This marks the first time Department of Defense personnel have recorded a temporary detainment within either National Defense Area," Carmichael said. U.S. presidents have long used active-duty and reservist troops on the international boundary in support roles to U.S. Border Patrol such as surveillance and construction. President Donald Trump took military use a step further by giving troops the right to hold trespassers they catch in the zones until civilian law enforcement assumes custody. Federal troops can also search people and conduct crowd control measures within the areas, according to the Army. Designation of the zones as military bases allowed troops to detain migrants without the need for Trump to invoke the Insurrection Act. The 1807 law lets a U.S. president deploy federal troops domestically to suppress events like civil disorder. Prosecution of dozens of migrants caught in the zones has faced setbacks in court after judges in New Mexico and Texas dismissed trespassing charges, and acquitted a Peruvian woman, ruling they did not know they were entering restricted areas. The primary role of troops in the zones is to detect and track illegal border crossers, with around 390 such detections so far, the Army said. News of the detentions inside military areas came as Trump deployed state-based National Guard troops to Los Angeles during protests over immigration raids. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
China's copper boom under threat as miners test bargaining power
[BEIJING] The unrelenting expansion of Chinese copper processing capacity over the past few years has now become a global headache, as smelters scramble to secure the ore they need to produce the vital industrial metal. Output in the world's top producer of the refined metal has ballooned to a record this year, even in the face of trade tensions wars that are clouding the outlook for demand. The resulting competition has handed bargaining power to some of the world's largest miners. Copper treatment charges, typically a key earner for processors, have plunged deep below zero on the spot market. Chilean miner Antofagasta has proposed negative charges for contracted supplies to smelters in the second half. The fraught situation for smelters worldwide is fuelling expectations of cuts – Glencore shut a facility in the Philippines in February. It's also focusing market attention on the surprising resilience of China's output, and raising the question of how long that can last. Analysts and industry executives say China's output is more resistant to financial pressures because it is now dominated by state-owned producers and by relatively large, efficient and low-cost smelters. Three major new plants were opened just last year, more than offsetting the pain felt by more modest operations. But there's also a still-substantial segment of China's market that is made up of smaller, privately owned smelters with more exposure to a tightening spot market. CRU Group says those plants account for about a quarter of the country's output. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'Even if you have very deep pockets and are willing to operate at a loss, at the end of the day you might have to cut production because you simply cannot get the copper concentrate,' said Craig Lang, principal analyst at CRU Group. The stakes are high for the global copper smelting industry. With all high-cost facilities facing losses, every ton that resists financial pressure in China means more pain for those elsewhere. Spot treatment charges to process concentrate fell to negative levels in December, and reached minus US$60 a tonne last month. The fees are deducted from the cost of concentrate and ordinarily make up a large chunk of smelter revenues. Term supplies are now threatening to slide into negative territory too, meaning smelters are effectively paying more for copper ore than the value of the metal contained in it. In February, when fees were less punitive than they are now, Glencore chief executive officer Gary Nagle said he wouldn't keep open loss-making copper plants. The company mothballed a smelter in the Philippines and is cutting costs at plants in Canada. Older European copper smelters could be at risk, while Japanese plants may be sheltered due to their parent companies' stakes in Chilean mines, said Grant Sporre, an analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence. 'It's going to be a tough battle for survival.' Outlook worsening Granted, the plunge in fees is partly due to relatively slow growth in mine output worldwide – but it's primarily driven by the rapid increase in smelting capacity. China's refined copper output is set to rise 10 per cent in the first half of this year and nearly 5 per cent for the full year, according to researcher Shanghai Metals Market. The argument for China's resilient output rests largely on the belief that state-owned plants are protected because local governments want to safeguard jobs and the economy. 'This is a consequence of an economic model that is less responsive to prevailing market conditions as plants can run on very thin margins – or even make losses – for extended periods of time,' Savant, a joint venture by Marex Group and geospatial analysis company Earth-i, said in a note last month. Although cutting overcapacity across the Chinese economy has become a more important policy priority for Beijing recently, so called 'future-friendly' industries such as copper, a metal required for electrification and so for the energy transition, are being given more leeway than sectors seen to be in structural decline, such as oil refining. For producers outside China, there is no such cushion. The suspension of Ivanhoe Mines' Kakula copper mine in central Africa has been a blow to ore supply – and at the same time developments such as the ramp-up of Freeport McMoRan's Manyar smelter in Indonesia are adding more refining capacity to the market. Big smelters may still be able to maintain production for now, following some years of healthy cash flow, said Yongcheng Zhao, an analyst at Benchmark Minerals Intelligence. The less-efficient ones, though, are at risk. BLOOMBERG
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
Freedom Flotilla Coalition says aid vessel approaching Gaza-bound ship left
The British-flagged Madleen boat is currently off the Egyptian coast, heading slowly towards the Gaza Strip. PHOTO: REUTERS CAIRO - A vessel that was approaching Freedom Flotilla Coalition's Gaza-bound charity ship the Madleen has left, the coalition said early on June 9, after an alarm was sounded on the ship warning of a possible interception. Hours earlier, the Israeli Defence Minister Israeli Katz said he told the military to stop the boat carrying activists including Sweden's Greta Thunberg and a symbolic quantity of aid, including rice and baby formula, to Gaza in defiance of an Israeli blockade. The coalition posted on its Telegram account a voice memo of Mr Thiago Avila, one of the activists onboard, saying "we have been surrounded by many lights all at once; they were circling our boat but in the end they kept going their own way." Operated by the pro-Palestinian Freedom Flotilla Coalition, the British-flagged Madleen boat is currently off the Egyptian coast, heading slowly towards the Gaza Strip, which is besieged by Israel. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
