Gardaí under scrutiny over Evan Fitzgerald case amid claim court was ‘misled'
Gardaí
are facing fresh questions about the prosecution of Evan Fitzgerald, who
took his own life with a stolen gun
after discharging it repeatedly in a
Carlow
shopping centre last month, after the case was raised in both the Dáil and Seanad.
On Wednesday an Oireachtas committee was told that Mr Fitzgerald was awaiting trial for possession of illegal weapons, that had been supplied to him in a Garda operation, when he took his own life.
On Thursday, the Labour TD Alan Kelly and the independent senator Michael McDowell raised the case in the Dáil and Seanad respectively, asking about court reports which suggested that the gardaí had told the judge in the case that they were 'investigating' how Mr Fitzgerald and others acquired the guns.
'The guns were actually given to him by An Garda Síochána ... How could they say in court that they didn't know where the guns came from?' Mr Kelly said.
READ MORE
The guns referred to were not used by Mr Fitzgerald in the fatal incident in the shopping centre but rather were those for which he was facing trial for possession of.
The guns used in the Garda operation were two firearms that were in Garda stores and had been decommissioned.
In the Seanad, Mr McDowell said: 'I am also very deeply concerned that, by informing the court that the gardaí were still investigating by whom the weapons in question were sold, the court was actively misled.'
Earlier, Mr McDowell told the Seanad: 'It now appears that gardaí had previously met at least one of the three persons charged and without revealing their identity had made arrangements for the firearms and ammunition in question to be delivered to the three young men.
'It further appears that a controlled delivery took place using weapons already owned or seized by An Garda Síochána,' Mr McDowell said on the Seanad order of business this morning.
'Following the controlled delivery, other members of An Garda Síochána intercepted a car in which the three young men were travelling, arrested them under The Offences Against the State Act and the court was told that all three admitted possession of the firearms in question.'
[
Evan Fitzgerald case: How 'controlled deliveries' are used in Garda sting operations
Opens in new window
]
Mr McDowell went on to say: 'Media reports state that the court was informed that there was no suspected connection with organised crime or terrorism and that the guns were intended for target shooting 'in the woods'. The court was told the three young men were childhood friends and that one of them, the late Evan Fitzgerald had a 'fascination with firearms'.
'Very strangely, it appears from media reports that the court was also informed that gardaí were still investigating who had sold the firearms to the defendants, when the judge asked that question.
'I am deeply concerned that all of these events could have been avoided if diversion rather than entrapment and prosecution had been deployed by the gardaí.'
Mr McDowell said: 'I am also deeply concerned that the Garda watchdog, Fiosrú, has reportedly apparently indicated no concerns in relation to these events.'
He asked for a Seanad debate on the issue.
The Garda Press Office said it did not comment on 'third-party remarks nor on evidence provided in court'
.
However, a spokesman said that
'
without commenting on any specific case, An Garda Síochána uses a range of internationally recognised investigative techniques when tackling serious crimes such as drug dealing and procuring of firearms, either of which could then be used to cause significant harm to the public.
'One of these is controlled deliveries. In controlled deliveries any material used is made safe by the law enforcement agency before being used, ie firearms are deactivated.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
How a dog called Fern solved the mystery of where Cork woman Tina Satchwell had been hidden
When Fern made a positive detection for the presence of human remains in the home of Richard and Tina Satchwell, the dog helped unravel the mystery of where the missing woman had been hidden for more than six years. After Richard Satchwell was sentenced to life in prison for the 2017 murder of his wife, the role of Fern in the case and the absence of a cadaver dog in An Garda Síochána's dog unit has raised hackles, led to soundbites and sparked debate on why the Irish force had to rely on the PSNI's only cadaver dog. Use of Fern in October 2023 for the search of Ms Satchwell's Youghal home was not the only time the services of a cadaver dog were requested by gardaí during the probe into her disappearance. The first time was in 2018, when Ronnie, a dog from Britain, was brought to Castlemartyr for a woodland search after information led gardaí to concentrate on the area. Mick Swindells has worked on a number of other high-profile cases in Ireland, including a search of the Slieve Bloom mountains for Fiona Pender in 2014. Ronnie's handler, Mick Swindells, a former British police officer, recalls staying in Garryvoe during the 2018 search, and says the approach came from gardaí because of his work with the Independent Commission for the Location of Victims' Remains, set up to find the bodies of people murdered and secretly buried by republicans during the Troubles. He has worked on a number of other high-profile cases in Ireland, including a search of the Slieve Bloom mountains for Fiona Pender in 2014. She has been missing since 1996 and her case was recently upgraded to a murder investigation. He became involved in human remains detection in 1992 when working with the dogs section in Lancashire police. He has handled five cadaver dogs in his career, but also trained dogs in Britain as well as in the Malaysian and Spanish fire services, and Spanish police. He pointed out training dogs to find human remains in water is different to training them to find buried remains 'because they can smell scent coming through the water'. For land searches, probes are used to prod the ground to release any odours which could indicate if human remains are buried in the area. He stressed, however, that the manner of a person's death can have an impact on the scent, explaining: 'Somebody who has been poisoned will decompose differently to somebody who has shot or stabbed, if there is trauma. "Indeed, the size of a person and the type of soil they have been put in also changes decomposition — also, if there were clothes, or they were wrapped in a shower curtain or carpet or that kind of thing.' He said in most cases, people do not have time to bury remains very deep — although he acknowledged cases like the Tina Satchwell case were different. During the recent trial, the jury heard her body had been buried unusually deep for a 'clandestine burial', with 84cm depth to the bottom of the burial site. 'He [Satchwell] was in his own house so he controlled the environment, whereas when you are burying bodies in woods … even the IRA didn't bury bodies deep and they had control of the areas. In his own house, he could take his time, he wasn't going to be disturbed,' Mr Swindells said. In his work, cadaver dogs are trained on pigs. He explains why: 'If you train a dog to find Semtex and you hide a block of Semtex, it won't change. But, obviously, a dead body evolves and is always changing. So we have to try to train the dog to find a body from, for example, one day after death to 25 years after death when it is just pure skeletal. So you have to train the dog on every aspect of the decomposition and the only way you can do that is by using pigs. It is similar decomposition.' A pig dressed in a coat and placed in a grave. Mick Swindells says the coat has been put on the pig to simulate a real concealment, for the purpose of training a cadaver dog. He says pigs used for the purpose of training dogs to find human remains are buried in the ground for many years. 'We had a site in the UK where we buried pigs in 1992 and every so often we went back there with dogs if we are looking at a really old case to refresh them. Pigs are the closest thing to human because they are omnivores — pigs eat meat and vegetables the same as we do. They have the same skin type — the same number of layers of skin as we do, the same digestive system as we do.' He says the normal police course for training dogs to find human remains is eight weeks: 'The basic course is eight weeks but the dog is always learning after that.' The Search and Rescue Dog Association Ireland (North) currently has four specially trained cadaver dogs in Northern Ireland. The association's Clair O'Connor says: 'We would use archaeological bone or human blood in training. We get blood from donors.' The association, which was founded in 1978 by Cork-born Dr Neil Powell, began working in the area of human remains detection in the 1990s, after being tasked to a search for two cousins who drowned in a lake. Wexford-based Rachell Morris owns K9 Detect and Find Ireland. She and Clair O'Connor both say they have had requests to aid An Garda Síochána over the years with searches. 13/06/'25 Gardaí bring a cadaver dog into a house on Monastery Walk, Clondalkin, where they are continuing their search in the investigation into the death of American woman, Annie McCarrick, who disappeared in 1993. Picture: Colin Keegan/ Collins However, on Monday, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said there were no plans at the moment to acquire a cadaver dog for the force . He described such a dog as a very specialised resource which is not out every day working, as is the case for drugs, firearms or money dogs. He also said a cadaver dog has only been used by the force three times in the seven years he has been commissioner. It emerged at Tuesday afternoon's meeting of the Oireachtas justice committee that a cadaver dog was used in the search for Kerry farmer Mike Gaine in the early weeks of his disappearance. Mick Swindells believes the addition of a cadaver dog to An Garda Síochána's existing dog unit would not be a big cost. 'If you train them to forensics and blood and semen also, you are not restricting it to murders because you have got assault cases, rape cases, that they can be used for as well.' He rejected minister for justice Jim O'Callaghan's assertion that the working life of a cadaver dog was just three years. He said police dogs operate until they are no longer fit enough to work, with many having a work life of up to seven years, typically retiring at about nine years old. This was echoed by Clair O'Connor, who said: 'All of our search dogs would work until they are aged eight to 10 years old.' A Garda spokeswoman confirmed the force has never had its own cadaver dog. She said there were 28 dogs attached to the Garda Dog Unit, inclusive of the Southern and North Western Dog Units. There are currently four dogs in training. The statement said: 'The Garda Dog Unit has dogs trained in three distinct disciplines, namely general purpose, drugs/cash/firearms detection, and explosive detection. Dogs are trained in one discipline.' In relation to cadaver dogs, the statement said: 'The operational demand for victim recovery dogs is currently sufficiently provided for through third-party contractors or through mutual assistance with the Police Service of Northern Ireland with whom An Garda Síochána has excellent working relations.' Read More Review of Tina Satchwell case to include if cadaver dog should have been used in 2017 search — Harris
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gardaí arrest man in his 20s in Finglas after seizing drugs worth an estimated €119,000
A man in his 20s was arrested after gardaí seized drugs with an estimated value of €119,000 in west Dublin on Friday. Gardaí from the Dublin Crime Response Team carried out a search in Finglas as part of a continuing operation targeting the sale and supply of controlled drugs. During the course of the search gardaí seized cannabis herb valued at €114,940, cocaine with an estimated value of €3,010, and ketamine valued at €1,500. Gardaí also seized €9,500 in cash, believed to be the proceeds of crime, along with drugs paraphernalia. READ MORE A man, aged in his 20s, was arrested and is currently being detained under section two of the Criminal Justice (Drug Trafficking) Act 1996 at a Garda station in Dublin. The seized drugs will be sent to Forensic Science Ireland for examination and analysis. Investigations are continuing.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘I 100% didn't do this', Dublin firefighter accused of rape tells Boston court
The Dublin firefighter on trial for rape over St Patrick's Day weekend last year told a Boston jury on Friday, 'I 100 per cent didn't do this. I've done nothing wrong.' Terence Crosbie (38) took the stand as the concluding witness on the fifth day of trial. The complainant, a 29-year-old attorney, claims she was raped by Mr Crosbie while his Dublin Fire Brigade colleague Liam O'Brien slept in a separate bed in a shared hotel room. She says she had consensual relations with Mr O'Brien after meeting him at the Black Rose bar in Boston. She later fell asleep in a separate bed but then says she awoke to Mr Crosbie raping her. READ MORE Mr Crosbie denied this allegation on Friday. 'There was nobody in my bed, my bed was empty,' he told the court. 'I had no physical or sexual contact with her at all.' Mr Crosbie said that he 'said hello' to the complainant at The Black Rose and was in the hotel room when she and Mr O'Brien first entered. He stated that Mr O'Brien gave him a 'look' and that he 'read between the lines and left the room'. Approximately two hours later he returned. 'I knocked on the door and got no answer and I knocked a second time and still no answer,' he said. He claimed that he 'shouted' and called for Mr O'Brien two more times and 'heard no reply.' He said that the room was dark and 'even darker' after he shut the door and that he did not see Mr O'Brien or the complainant. Shortly after he got into bed he heard someone 'rummaging around the room'. The complainant previously stated that the bathroom light was on when Mr Crosbie returned. When she broke free from underneath Mr Crosbie and escaped to the bathroom to dress, he 'was jiggling the handle' after she locked the door. Under cross examination, defense attorney Daniel C Reilly had asked the complainant if she noticed if the assailant 'had body marks or tattoos.' 'I was trying not to look,' the complainant replied. On Friday, the defense submitted photos of tattoos on Mr Crosbie's upper arms and legs. Jurors previously heard that Mr Crosbie was arrested while boarding an early flight back to Dublin after being questioned by police. On Friday Mr Crosbie said that his 'head was spinning' and that he was 'scared like a rabbit in the headlights.' He stated that he reported the police interview to his superiors at the fire brigade and that when he returned to his hotel room, he found that the door was left open and packed his suitcase. 'I didn't like the fact that someone had been in my room and the nature of the allegations being made,' he stated. Mr Crosbie also denied insulting Mr O'Brien, claiming that he would not have used the word 'friend' as the complainant alleged. 'I would say mate or buddy,' he stated. Under direct questioning, Mr Crosbie stated he would not have used the word 'loser' either, as the complainant alleged he called Mr O'Brien. 'That's not an Irish term or anything I would use,' he said. 'Does the word 'stop' mean the same thing in Ireland as it does in the United States,' Suffolk County district attorney Erin Murphy asked Mr Crosbie under cross examination. 'Yes,' Mr Crosbie said. Dublin Fire Brigade member Terence Crosbie (right) with his defence lawyer Daniel C Reilly during his trial in a Boston court. Photograph: Susan Zalkind/The Irish Times Jurors previously saw video of Mr Crosbie with his head close to an unidentified blonde woman at The Black Rose bar, prior to the alleged assault. The state used this image to identify Mr Crosbie and a Dublin Fire Brigade emblem on his jumper. Mr Crosbie had previously stated he was married and has two daughters. 'What were you doing at the precise moment the [prosecution] decided to zoom in,' Mr Reilly asked Mr Crosbie in direct examination. 'I was kissing another woman,' he said. 'Is that what you're charged with in this case?' Mr Reilly asked. 'It's not, no,' said Mr Crosbie. Jurors previously saw video of the complainant leaving room 610 of the Omni Parker hotel 20 minutes after Mr Crosbie returned in the early hours of March 15th, 2024. Two minutes later she texted a friend: 'I woke up and a guy was inside of me.' In the text she alleged the perpetrator told her she 'wanted it' and that his 'friend' was 'pathetic.' The complainant reiterated this allegation on the stand, stating that she woke up to a man raping her and that Mr Crosbie called Mr O'Brien 'a loser'. Hours later she went to the hospital to report an assault. Jurors previously heard that in her initial reports the woman did not recall Mr O'Brien's name and did not recall meeting Mr Crosbie previously. Jurors also heard from an analyst who testified two male DNA profiles were collected from the complainant. Mr O'Brien was identified as one of the males. Jurors heard that it was unclear if the second set of male DNA was that of Mr Crosbie. The defense previously called Dr Chris Rosenbaum, the director of medical toxicology for Newton-Wellesley Hospital, as an expert witness. Dr Rosenbaum testified that the complainant reported a 'prior history of binge drinking' in her medical documents and that her blood alcohol level at the time she reported the assault the next morning can 'correlate with memory loss and impairment.' Mr Crosbie has been detained in the Nashua Street Jail since his arrest. Jurors will hear closing arguments on Monday.
