Government, online companies spar in Supreme Court on GST over games of skill, chance
The Supreme Court on Monday (May 5, 2025) saw the government and online gaming companies spar on whether games of skill such as rummy, chess and bridge will 'metamorphosise' into games of chance, and their earnings be subject to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime.
Appearing before a Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, Additional Solicitor General N. Venkataraman, for the government, said games of skill would continue to be what they were until bets or wagers were placed on them.
'Then it will become gambling, in spite of being a game of skill... Betting on a game of skill is statutorily considered gambling,' Mr. Venkataraman argued.
He contended that betting or wagering on any kind of game, whether chance or skill based, was gambling.
Senior advocate A.M. Singhvi, appearing for one of the companies, said the 'fundamental issue' in the case was about an 'ancient exception' given to games of skill.
Mr. Singhvi submitted that five judges and seven judge Benches of the constitutional courts have consistently held that games of skill were per se not categorised as chance-based.
'Is the government saying that in chess, the moment I put money on it, the game metamorphosises from a game of skill into a game of chance? The character of a game cannot be so changed,' Mr. Singhvi objected to the government's line of argument.
In January, the apex court had stayed the operation of show-cause notices worth ₹1.12 lakh crore issued under GST proceedings against online gaming companies. About 50 online gaming companies are before the apex court.
The core dispute in the case concerned the interpretation of GST applicability on online gaming. The government has argued that 28% GST must apply to the total contest entry amount, effectively taxing the entire prize pool.
However, gaming companies contended that GST should only be levied on their platform fees or commission, as many of these games involve skill rather than chance.
Last year, the top court had transferred to itself 27 writ petitions, pending across nine State High Courts, challenging the levy of 28% GST on all forms of online real-money gaming.
The petitions were tagged with a pending case concerning a decision of the Karnataka High Court, which had quashed a GST show-cause notice of ₹21,000 crore while holding that online or electronic or digital Rummy played on Gameskraft, a gaming platform, was not taxable as a betting or gambling activity.
In January 2024, the top court had issued notice to the Centre on a plea filed by the e-gaming federation against the levy of 28% GST.
The GST Council had in 2023 recommended that online gaming along with casinos and horse racing must be taxed at a uniform rate. It had decided against having any distinction between 'games of skill' and 'games of chance'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
44 minutes ago
- Mint
Sitharaman to review ease of doing business, trade and refunds with top tax officers
Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman will meet senior officials of direct and indirect tax administrations later this month to discuss measures to improve the ease of doing business, support trade and reduce the time taken to address grievances, said a person informed about the development. Sitharaman will meet principal chief commissioners in the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) on 20 June; and their counterparts in the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) on 23 June, the person said on condition of not being named. She will review the performance of field formations handling Goods and Services Tax (GST) and customs at the meeting with CBIC officers. Export refunds, cargo delays in focus The minister is expected to lay special emphasis on timely tax refund processing, especially in export and special economic zone or SEZ-linked categories, the person said. 'Delays beyond 60 days will be scrutinised and zones may be asked to explain pendency and rejection trends with detailed analytics." Sitharaman will also review the dwell time of cargo clearance across ports and airports. Also Read: Govt to launch nationwide drive to return unclaimed bank deposits, dividends Data on automated clearances of shipments based on their low risk profile, interdictions and the time taken for shipment examination will be reviewed across different zones such as Delhi and Mumbai, the person said. High pendency in Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) investigations, especially those pending over 180 days, are likely to draw critical attention, the person said. Sitharaman is expected to stress time-bound vigilance action, accountability in physical verification outcomes, and use of technology for process efficiency, highlighting the government's dual focus on compliance and trade facilitation, according to the person quoted earlier. I-T review to track refunds, cases The minister's interaction with principal chief commissioners of the Income Tax Department on 23 June will focus on improving taxpayer service delivery, litigation management, and systems accountability. The minister will review age-wise pendency of appeals and push for faster disposal of legacy cases to reduce the litigation burden on the system. Delays in issuing refunds, including those held up due to non-processing of returns under preliminary assessment, and rectification cases impacted by system-related issues, will be reviewed. Also Read: Reform push: Insurance amendment bill heads to Parliament Field officers are expected to present data on pending queries raised with the department's Centralised Processing Centre in Bengaluru, average disposal times and unresolved grievances raised in an online portal. The minister is likely to question zones with vigilance cases pending beyond permissible timelines and disciplinary matters not acted upon for months, the person quoted above said. Sitharaman is also expected to appreciate best practices adopted by select regions and reiterate the need for a taxpayer-centric, tech-enabled, and transparent ecosystem across the department. Queries emailed to the finance ministry, the CBDT and to CBIC on Friday seeking comments remained unanswered at the time of publishing. Both the apex tax policy-making bodies recently finalized their strategies for the current financial year. Also Read: E-way bills shoot up to 122.7 million in May, the second-highest on record CBDT set revenue targets for its different zonal offices to meet the full year direct tax target of ₹25.2 trillion and urged its officers to follow a trust-based approach, Mint had reported on 3 May. CBIC also has laid down its plan for a supportive, people-focused and tech-driven tax administration for FY26, chairperson Sanjay Kumar Agarwal informed officers in a communication, Mint reported on 9 June.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
TV anchor not liable for panellist's statement: Supreme Court
Supreme Court (Photo: ANI) NEW DELHI: Putting a premium on the right to free speech and expression, Supreme Court on Friday ordered the release of Sakshi TV anchor K Srinivasa Rao, who was held by Andhra police for abetting alleged derogatory and defamatory statements by a panelist on his live show on Amaravati. Justices Mishra and Manmohan said, "Rao has not made the statement. His journalistic participation in a live TV show deserves to be protected, so as that of his fundamental right to free speech. Rao shall be released on bail on conditions to be imposed by the trial court." Guest called Amaravati 'capital of sex workers' On June 6, political analyst V V R Krishnamraju had appeared as a panelist on a show anchored by Rao on Sakshi TV, considered a mouthpiece of opposition YSR Congress Party which while in govt had abrogated previous TDP dispensation's Amaravati capital project, and referred to the capital as 'capital of sex workers". Appearing for the 70-year-old Rao, senior advocate Siddharth Dave told a bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Manmohan that he was only hosting the TV show and that the statement is not attributed to him but to a panellist over whom he had no control. Opposing the plea challenging the arrest, senior advocates Mukul Rohatgi and Sidharth Luthra said that when the offending and derogatory statement was made against women of Andhra Pradesh, the TV anchor, instead of stopping the panellist, was seen encouragingly laughing. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play Chess on Your PC, Free Play Classic Chess Install Now Undo The bench sought the AP government's response to his petition seeking the quashing of the FIR against him. However, it cautioned Rao not to involve himself in any defamatory statement or allow any panelist to make such a statement in live TV shows.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Showdown Like Never Before: 4.5L+ New Voters Upend NMC Arithmetic
1 2 3 Nagpur: With the Maharashtra govt clearing the way for long-delayed elections to the Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) setting a deadline for ward formation, political parties are bracing for a contest unlike in the past — driven largely by a steep surge in voter numbers over the past decade. Between the 2012 municipal polls and the 2024 Assembly elections, the number of registered city voters jumped from 19.09 lakh to 23.65 lakh — a rise of nearly 24%. This addition of over 4.5 lakh voters is expected to dramatically impact poll outcomes across wards, forcing parties to redraw campaign strategies and reconnect with a vastly expanded electorate. As the state gears up for ward delimitation under a Supreme Court-mandated four-month schedule, the voter roll from the 2024 assembly elections is likely to form the basis for redrawing ward boundaries, despite the court's instruction to use the 2011 Census for population data. This has generated intense political interest in how wards will be structured — with voter increase, caste equations, and geographic spread all expected to influence the final layout. Speaking to TOI, former corporators, many of whom are eyeing a return to the fray, say the new numbers have altered the ground realities. "In my ward, there were about 45,000 voters in 2017. Now it's closer to 60,000. You can't rely on the old networks anymore," said a former corporator from south Nagpur. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo "Ten thousand new voters can completely swing the result if you're not in touch with the ground." Another ex-corporator from North Nagpur noted, "Many of the new voters are first-timers who have no memory of our previous work. This means we have to start from scratch — explain who we are and why we matter." In 2022, when the MVA govt initiated a ward restructuring exercise, the total number of voters stood at 22,33,866. By 2024 assembly elections, the figure climbed to 23,65,998 — an increase of 1,32,122 in two years. According to political observers, this growth translates to an average increase of 10,000 to 15,000 voters per ward — in some areas even more — significantly raising the bar for candidate outreach and visibility. During the eight-year gap between civic elections, Nagpur witnessed two Lok Sabha and two Vidhan Sabha polls. Yet, the absence of an elected civic body since March 2022 weakened the direct connect between former corporators and residents. While a few leaders stayed active by raising local issues or joining party-led protests, many drifted into political obscurity. With the civic elections now firmly on the horizon, parties are scrambling to revive their ground presence, but are also increasingly aware that the electoral map they knew is no longer the same. "The voter increase isn't just a statistic — it's a warning," said a senior BJP functionary. "If you can't talk to these new voters, someone else will." "One thing is clear: this will be a very different election — not only because of delayed timing or ward changes, but because the city's electorate itself has grown, diversified, and changed in ways that will test even the most seasoned of politicians," said political pandits. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .
