
Furious West Lothian home owner ordered to tear down fence protecting her home
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
A Livingston woman has vowed to fight on against an order by councillors to tear down a fence she put up to protect her garden.
Dawn Gardner accused West Lothian Council's Development Management Committee of 'bullying' behaviour, and of ignoring a decision by Scottish ministers, which agreed the land belonged to her.
Mrs Gardener partially won an appeal to the Scottish Government last year and had to retrospectively apply for new permission to keep the fence.
She told the Local Democracy Reporting Service that the fence had been put up to stop persistent dog fouling and littering over the area of land beside her home.
The corner site is in her title deeds and she has to maintain it, as did the previous owner of the house in Waverley Crescent.
Before the fence was put up the land was frequently used as a shortcut by some, and the last straw for Mrs Gardner was seeing drunks urinating against a garden wall just feet from her back door.
Mrs Gardner paid thousands of pounds to have the area fenced off to create more privacy around her home. While most of the fence is low enough to be allowed as permitted development one section is just a few inches above the height permitted.
Council planning officers told a meeting of the DMC that, while they did not fully agree with the Scottish Government's Reporter's partial upholding of the appeal, they did recommend retrospective planning permission for the fence along with planning permission to build a double garage within the garden of the house be approved.
Eliburn Community Council complained last year about the enclosure of open space and it reiterated that when Steve Egan appeared before the committee.
He said: 'The community council's objection was to the loss of open space. Why have stated policies and not follow them. The officer's report is wholly silent on this.'
An agent for Mrs Gardner said Mr Egan had an 'unhealthy obsession' with the issue of open space around Mrs Gardner's home, adding she had fenced in land she owned to protect her home against criminal behaviour.
However, councillors did not not like the fence.
Councillor George Paul said 'the quality of finish is very poor. I don't think it's very aesthetic to the area.'
Councillor Pauline Stafford said: 'It appears that the fence is in breach of planning legislation; the height of the fence detracts from the streetscape which most other properties have quite an open aspect.'
Chairing the meeting, Councillor Tony Boyle said the fence was ' really intrusive'.
He added: 'I note there are no objections from neighbouring householders but that's beside the point.'
Having sought clarification from planning and legal officers, the DMC agreed to grant permission for the garage but refused permission for the fence.
After the meeting a furious Mrs Gardner told the LDRS: ' A new appeal goes in tomorrow.'
She added: 'The councillors took no notice of what the Scottish ministers said. They didn't even listen to the planning officer.'
Referring to the councillors she said: 'They were making really personal remarks. Some of the comments were very personal. There's nothing wrong with the fence.
'I thought it was bullying. There was not one decision based on fact; it was all personal opinion they didn't even look at what the ministers said.
Mrs Gardner said she had the support of surrounding neighbours who have told her the fence is better than the unkempt open ground there previously.
As for the objection, 'Eliburn Community council didn't even discuss it, it was never on their agenda,' she added.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Courier
an hour ago
- The Courier
No further action taken in Dundee dog cruelty probe
Animal welfare inspectors are taking no further action after concerns were raised over the treatment of dogs at a Dundee flat. The Scottish SPCA received several calls regarding the welfare of the animals in the Hilltown last month. The Courier told how officers were seen removing the dogs from the flat as part of their probe. A spokeswoman said at the time: 'We received several calls regarding the welfare of dogs at a flat in Dundee on Wednesday May 14. 'Our inspectors attended and removed the animals from the property. 'We are unable to comment further as this is a current investigation.' However, the Scottish SPCA has now told The Courier it has concluded its probe and no further action is being taken. The charity says the case is now closed. No further details have been revealed.


Edinburgh Live
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Live
Death of Scottish teenager Cole Cooper still unexplained five days after body found
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info The death of Scottish teenager Cole Cooper remains unexplained according to police, five days after a body was discovered. What is thought to be the body of the 19-year-old was discovered deceased in a wooded area near a Falkirk village on Friday, June 6, after vanishing nearly five weeks ago. Cole's last confirmed sighting was at 8.45pm on Wednesday, May 7, on Glasgow Road at the junction with Cumbernauld Road, Longcroft. Officers returned to the scene last Sunday engaging with over 150 individuals during their probe, and the analysis of the information gathered is underway. Police are determined to determine Cole's final movements between May 4 and May 7, urging locals with CCTV around the wider Banknock district, especially near A803 Kilsyth Road, to step forward, reports the Daily Record. They're imploring the community to recall that period and reach out if they remember seeing Cole around said areas, asking those yet to speak with the police to come forth. Over 2,000 hours of CCTV footage remain under review, while door-to-door checks continue in both Longcroft and Banknock. Chief Inspector Alex Hatrick spoke out: "Cole Cooper's disappearance and the circumstances leading up to it remain unexplained. We remain in regular contact with the family to ensure they are kept up to date with all aspects of the investigation. "We will continue to support them and provide them with updates as our enquiries progress. Extensive enquiries are ongoing to piece together Cole's last movements and find answers for his loved ones. "Anyone with any information, no matter how small it may seem, is urged to speak to police if they have not already done so." Cole,from Banknock, was last sighted on May 7 on the A803 near Cumbernauld Road in Longcroft, where he unsuccessfully sought a lift from a school mate. Before this event, unsettling ring doorbell footage captured him on the morning of Sunday, May 4 at around 6am in the Longcroft area attempting to get into his father's house, but failing to do so. He was officially reported missing on Friday, May 9. His body was eventually found just 15 minutes' walk from his last verified location. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages On Monday night, Cole's relatives released a statement asserting the youth "would have never walked away from his life", while vowing to seek out the truth. The statement, shared by his aunt, Aimee Tennie, said: "As his family, we know who Cole was. "He was deeply loved and would never have walked away from his life. Something happened - and we will not rest until we know what that was. "While we now have him back, the circumstances of his disappearance and death remain unexplained. This case is far from over - and we are determined to uncover the full truth of what happened to Cole." Folks with info are encouraged to contact Police Scotland on 101, citing incident number 828 of Friday, 9 May, 2025.


STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
Scots woman jailed for watching and sharing videos of monkey torture online
A Scottish woman has been jailed for watching and sharing videos online of monkeys being tortured as part of a global ring. Natalie Herron, 39, was sentenced to two years and three months at Airdrie Sheriff Court on Tuesday. She previously pled guilty on Tuesday, May 13 to charges of distributing and possessing obscene publications between December 2021 and September 2022. This is the first time someone has been sentenced in Scotland for cruelty that took place abroad. Officers said this was one of the most 'horrific' cases they had dealt with and the material was like 'nothing they had seen before'. Herron was arrested in September 2022 following intelligence from the National Crime Agency (NCA). As part of the wider investigation with the National Wildlife Crime Unit, two women were jailed at Worcester Crown Court in November 2024 for their part in a global monkey torture ring. One woman, aged 37, was sentenced to two years and the other, aged 55, was sentenced to one year and three months in prison. Detective Sergeant Karen Murray said: 'This was a long and complex investigation which involved a number of organisations including the National Crime Agency (NCA) and the National Wildlife Crime Unit (NWCU) and was the first of its kind in the UK. 'Thanks to the work of these organisations Herron will now face the consequences of her actions which led contributed to the cruel torture and immense suffering of a number of innocent animals. 'Through dedicated police work, the investigation team was able to show that Herron was watching and distributing this horrific material and I would like to take this opportunity to thank all who worked on it. 'This was one of the most disturbing and graphic cases we have worked on and we hope this sentence shows that even though the cruelty took place abroad, that these types of crimes will not be tolerated and we will use all the tools at our disposal to hold people accountable.' Detective Inspector Mark Harrison from the National Wildlife Crime Unit said: 'This investigation is truly shocking and unsettling. 'The people involved are not just motivated by money, this is also about getting some sort of gratification from watching animals being tortured and then sharing those images with others. 'It has been well documented in the media recently what impacts these sorts of online images can have on people, especially young people and there are proven links between those involved in animal cruelty and violence towards people, so we take it very seriously. 'This investigation is part of a larger transnational investigation that the NWCU has been assisting with and the NWCU would like to thank Police Scotland for their hard work and dedication on this case. It shouldn't be underestimated the impact that working on a case like this can have on those involved. 'Wildlife crime can occur in many forms and the NWCU will continue to work with partners from across the world to ensure that we have the expertise, resources, and skills to fight this type of crime however it may occur.' Anyone who has any concerns around this type of behaviour is asked to contact Police Scotland on 101. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country