Judge rules Biffa can continue with £160m case against Scottish Government
A judge has ruled that waste management company Biffa can proceed with suing the Scottish Government for about £160 million following the collapse of the deposit return scheme (DRS).
Lawyers representing the Government had attempted to have the case dismissed, but Lord Clark ruled it can go ahead at the Court of Session
Biffa's lawyers say Lorna Slater, the green co-leader who was a minister at the time, 'negligently misrepresented' the state of the scheme which led to the company investing significantly.
In their legal arguments, they highlighted a letter from Ms Slater to Biffa's chief executive in May 2022, which set out ministers' 'unwavering commitment' to deliver the DRS in August 2023.
However, the Scottish Government changed its plans when UK ministers used the Internal Market Act (IMA) to rule glass bottles could not be included.
A UK-wide DRS is not expected to begin before 2027.
Lord Clark said the date on which the Scottish Government sought an exclusion from the IMA is a 'matter in dispute between the parties'.
Circularity Scotland, which was set up to administer the Scottish DRS, fell into administration in June 2023 and Biffa's contract was terminated.
The company said it expected to make profits of £114.8 million over 10 years through the contract and it invested £51.4 million in assets like sorting machines as it prepared for the 'go live' date.
The Government's lawyers have previously said the decision by Biffa to start spending money on the scheme was a 'commercial risk' the company had 'chosen to take'.
They denied Ms Slater had made any 'negligent misrepresentation' and said ministers did not owe a duty of care to Biffa.
In his ruling on Tuesday, Lord Clark said the case would not be dismissed.
He said: 'On the first part of the claim, for the pursuer to succeed at the proof the court will have to be satisfied on the following points: there was an assumption of responsibility; the duty was not inconsistent with the statutory powers and duties of the defenders; the pursuer relied, and reasonably relied, upon the defenders' conduct; the breaches of duty occurred; and the loss was caused by the alleged breaches.
'On the alternative case on negligent misrepresentation, the pursuer mainly requires to prove that the pursuer's contention on the proper interpretation of the letter, when viewed in its full context, is correct, and that the pursuer relied, and reasonably relied, upon it, causing the loss of costs.
'Questions also remain in play about the amount of loss on costs and profit which the pursuer can establish.'
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government cannot comment on live litigation.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
33 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Former Top Starmer Aide Sue Gray to Join Advisory Firm Consello
Keir Starmer's former chief of staff, Sue Gray, will join global advisory firm Consello Group as its UK chair, moving into business 8 months after her departure from the prime minister's top team. The former political aide and senior civil servant, who departed Starmer's Downing Street in October, will lead Consello's expansion in the UK and will start immediately, people familiar with the appointment said, requesting anonymity discussing an appointment that hasn't been publicly announced yet. Other recent hires include former Manchester United soccer club captain Gary Neville, US National Football League legend Tom Brady, and 23-time tennis Grand Slam singles champion Serena Williams.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Xeinadin enhances London presence with KBSP acquisition
UK-based professional services company Xeinadin has announced its acquisition of KBSP, an accountancy firm situated in Swiss Cottage, North London. The deal is set to strengthen Xeinadin's footprint in the capital and offer clients a wider range of expertise. Xeinadin CEO Derry Crowley said: 'KBSP's longstanding reputation, strong client relationships and local insight make them an ideal fit for Xeinadin. 'Their focus on SMEs, commitment to client education, and adaptable service model reflect exactly the kind of firm we want to support and grow with. We're delighted to welcome them aboard.' Established in the 1960s, KBSP has been offering a variety of services, such as auditing, accounting, tax compliance, and consultancy. The firm has assisted numerous clients, ranging from local startups to well-known national companies, throughout their business development. The acquisition ensures the preservation of KBSP's identity, workforce, and location while merging its operations into Xeinadin's national framework, reported. This integration will allow clients to access specialists in fields like R&D tax credits, audit assurance, and sector-specific advisory services. As a result of this acquisition, KBSP's clients can now have access to more extensive, digital-first offering. The partnership aims to empower businesses at all stages of development, meeting the demand for customised and personal business support in an evolving market environment, the report added. KBSP partner David Myerson said: 'We're a partner led local firm. Our clients aren't looking for a revolving door of advisors. 'They want to speak to someone who knows their name, their business, and their challenges. That's what we've always offered, and it's what we'll keep offering – now with the extra tools and expertise that Xeinadin brings.' "Xeinadin enhances London presence with KBSP acquisition" was originally created and published by International Accounting Bulletin, a GlobalData owned brand. The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site. Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data
Entrepreneur
an hour ago
- Entrepreneur
Mistral Launches Magistral to Compete in the Reasoning AI Race
While Magistral puts Mistral in closer competition with well-known reasoning AI models, there are still doubts across the industry about how well current LLMs can actually "reason" Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own. You're reading Entrepreneur India, an international franchise of Entrepreneur Media. French artificial intelligence firm Mistral has announced the release of its latest large language model (LLM), Magistral, marking its entry into the growing space of "reasoning" AI models. The new model aims to improve the transparency and traceability of AI-generated outputs, particularly in tasks that require step-by-step logical processing. Unveiled on Tuesday during London Tech Week, Magistral is available through Mistral's platforms and the open-source AI repository Hugging Face. The company has released two versions of the model: Magistral Small, a 24-billion-parameter model licensed as open-source, and a more powerful, proprietary version, Magistral Medium, currently available in limited preview. Mistral describes Magistral as suitable for general-purpose use cases that involve more complex reasoning and demand greater accuracy. The model is designed to provide a visible "chain of thought," which the company says helps users understand how conclusions are reached. This feature may appeal to professionals in law, healthcare, finance, and public services where regulatory compliance and interpretability are key concerns. According to CEO Arthur Mensch, a key distinction of Magistral is its multilingual reasoning capability, especially in European languages. "Historically, we've seen U.S. models reason in English and Chinese models reason in Chinese," he said during a session at London Tech Week. Mensch noted that Magistral is initially focused on European languages, with plans to expand support to other languages over time. The launch comes as more AI companies shift their focus from building larger models to improving how existing models process and present information. Reasoning models are designed to handle more sophisticated tasks by simulating logical steps, rather than generating answers based solely on pattern recognition. This shift also responds to ongoing concerns about the interpretability of AI systems, which often function as black boxes even to their creators. Mistral claims that Magistral Medium can process up to 1,000 tokens per second, potentially offering faster performance than several competing models. It joins a growing list of reasoning-focused models released over the past year, including OpenAI's o1 and o3, Google's Gemini variants, Anthropic's Claude, and DeepSeek's R1. The release also highlights Mistral's continuing emphasis on open-source AI development. The company, founded in Paris in 2023, has received significant backing from investors including Microsoft, DST Global, and General Catalyst. It raised approximately USD 685.7 million million in a Series B round in June 2024, bringing total funding to over USD 1.37 billion and reaching a reported valuation of USD 6.63 billion. Despite its relatively short history, Mistral has seen considerable commercial traction. As per the media reports, the company has secured over USD 114.3 million in contracted sales within 15 months of launching its first commercial offerings. While Magistral puts Mistral in closer competition with well-known reasoning AI models, there are still doubts across the industry about how well current large language models (LLMs) can actually "reason." A recent research paper from Apple, titled The Illusion of Thinking, questions the belief that today's models truly have general reasoning abilities. The researchers found that these models tend to struggle or fail when tasks become too complex, revealing key limitations in their capabilities.
