Pub ordered to pay Irish family €88,000 after false 'dine and dash' accusations
A UK pub which falsely accused an Irish family of running off and not paying £150 (€176) for their food bill has been ordered by a court to pay £75,000 (€88,000) in damages. A Facebook post from bosses at the Horse and Jockey in Tideswell, Derbyshire, condemned the behaviour of Peter and Ann McGirr who had been dining with their adult children.
The post claimed the group of four ate two £27 (€32) 10oz ribeye steaks with all the trimmings and two £15.25 (€18) Derbyshire gammon steaks, and drank real ales and lagers. The post included CCTV images and was picked up by the media and used in press reports where they were referred to as 'dine-and-dashers'.
It later emerged that the family did pay the bill in full, and a mistake by a staff member meant it was not rung through the till. At Belfast Crown Court the family from Co Tyrone sued the pub, saying they had suffered significant embarrassment and reputational damage, Mirror UK reports.
The family's barrister Peter Girvan told the court: "These articles contained serious and defamatory accusations that the plaintiffs had engaged in dishonest and criminal conduct by deliberately absconding without settling a bill of approximately £150 (€176). The allegations were entirely false. The plaintiffs had not engaged in any such conduct, and the statements made by the defendants had no factual basis."
The pub accepted there was "no basis whatsoever" for the allegations and apologised, the court heard. It agreed to pay £75,000 (€88,000) in damages as well as the family's legal costs, as part of a settlement agreement.
Reading a statement outside court, the family's solicitor, Darragh Carney, said the McGirr's had been "vindicated". He added they were "very satisfied with the settlement" as compensation for "defamation of their character".
A statement issued by the pub in July last year read: "We want to sincerely apologise to the people involved because we have now learnt that they did in fact pay for their meal. There was no dishonesty involved from our staff, it was an honest mistake but we have dismissed the member of staff responsible for the error."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
I'm the famous Peru Two drug mule – this is my warning to Brit tourists… and how gangs know EXACTLY who to target
PERU Two drug mule Michaella McCollum has warned Brit tourists about how trafficking gangs lure young girls into their criminal operations. The infamous drug trafficker 8 Peru Two drug mule Michaella McCollum has warned Brit tourists about how trafficking gangs lure young girls into their criminal operations Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 8 Brit Bella May Culley was arrested in Tbilisi airport, Georgia, with a suitcase packed with drugs Credit: Facebook 8 Charlotte May Lee, 21, former TUI flight attendant from Coulsdon, was allegedly recruited to smuggle drugs into Sri Lanka Credit: Shutterstock Editorial Since being freed from a hellhole jail in Lima, McCollum transformed her life and is now a mum and public speaker. Part of her work includes exposing how foreign drug operations try and recruit British mules. The 31-year-old appeared on Good Morning Britain this morning to speak on the increasing danger of Brits being preyed upon abroad. It comes after a spate of young women being arrested on trafficking charges including read more in Brit drug mules McCollum told Susanna Reid that people are often picked by drug chiefs specifically due to how vulnerable they appear. She explained: "That's what they do these organisations, they have people that are pickers and their job is to pick people to become mules. "They'll target vulnerabilities which might be age because at 19 or 20 you're incredibly naive, you're easy to manipulate. "Then women as well as obviously women tend to be groomed and coerced in situations a lot more. Most read in The Sun "Then whether you have a drug addiction as that could also be a vulnerability." McCollum was aged 19 at the time of her first being recruited with her Peru Two partner Reid being only 20. Charlotte May Lee fears being locked away for 20yrs over £1.2m Sri Lanka drugs bust – & is 'aware' of Bella Culley case She has also been open about her drug habits around the time of her arrest as she believes this contributed to her recruitment. Bella Culley - the teen arrested in Georgia last month - was Michaella also revealed that the drug kingpins ordering young women to become traffickers are masters at manipulation. She says that when she was first coerced into taking a suitcase of cocaine across the border her bosses convinced her that everything would be okay. Michaella was made to feel like a "little girl" when she questioned the dangers of smuggling, she said. Her concerns were always met with simple solutions, she added. She recalled once asking about how they would get the drugs through the airport before being told the airport staff is in cahoots with the operations being carried out and allow them. By the time she realised the answers were a lie, Michaelle said she was already in handcuffs. 8 Michaella McCollum entering the Sarita Colonia jail with a police escort in October, 2013 Credit: EPA 8 McCollum told Susanna Reid that people are often picked by drug chiefs specifically due to how vulnerable they appear Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 8 Michaella McCollum is now a mum-of-two and author Credit: Instagram/@Michaella_McCollum She continued: "You have to understand that the level of manipulation that goes on behind it as it's not just overnight, it can be weeks of manipulation. "They ended up making me believe that this was totally fine. I was being dramatic, I was being naive to question it. "So I was so scared to say no and men know they can manipulate women to do things and I was so scared to just say no." Both Peru Two mules became friends when holidaying in Ibiza in August 2013 and were soon coerced into cocaine trafficking. But in October, they were arrested as they stepped off a lane in Lima, Peru. McCollum and Reid were convicted of drug smuggling and sentenced to six years and eight months in a dismal Ancon 2 prison. At the time, the pair's horror trip led them to becoming household names as they both admitted to being used by the gangs. In recent weeks, a string of British women have faced similar worrying experiences after being A couple claiming to be tourists from Thailand were busted with more than 33kg of cannabis in their suitcases at a Spanish airport in May. Why Brit backpackers are prime targets, Thai cop reveals By Patrick Harrington, Foreign News Reporter Police Lieutenant Colonel Arun Musikim, Deputy Inspector of the Surat Thani province police force, said: 'Cases involving British nationals smuggling cannabis have been around for a while. 'There is a lot of cannabis grown on Thailand's islands in the south because the climate is suitable and it is legal. A lot of gangs are attracted to this. 'There are now various smuggling methods that we have seen. Some carry it themselves, some hire backpackers, and some send it via mail. 'This year, there have been many cases we have intercepted. Most involve British and Malaysian nationals. 'It's easy for British citizens to travel as they can enter Thailand and return to the UK without needing a visa. 'Most of the smugglers are people hired to carry the cannabis, similar to how tourists might smuggle tax-free goods. 'They're usually unemployed individuals from the UK. The gangs offer them flights, pocket money and hotel stays, just to come and travel and take a bag back home with them. 'These people often have poor social standing at home and are looking for ways to earn quick money. They find them through friends or on social media. 'Many will go to festivals or parties while they are here, just like they are having a normal trip abroad. 'They are told that it is easy and they will not be caught. Then the amount the organisers can sell the cannabis for in the UK is much higher than it costs in Thailand. 'Police suspect that there are multiple employers and groups receiving the drugs on the other end. The cannabis then enters the UK market. 'We are being vigilant to ensure there are no routes out of the country.' A allegedly smuggling nearly £200,000 worth of Thai cannabis into Spain. But the two largest and most concerning cases covered Bella and Charlotte. Bella sparked a massive international search operation in early May after she was reported missing while holidaying in Thailand. However, it was later revealed that the teen, from Billingham, County Durham, had been She was allegedly carrying 30 pounds (14kg) of cannabis into the ex-Soviet nation. Around the same time, 21-year-old Charlotte Lee May, from Coulsdon, south London, was also The former flight attendant is now facing up to 25 years in prison if convicted. 8 Bella pictured in court in Tbilisi after she was detained at a Georgian airport Credit: East2West 8 Charlotte, a former TUI flight attendant from Coulsdon, seen after she appeared in court in Colombo, Sri Lanka Credit: Enterprise
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Irishman allegedly tried to assist wanted drug dealer escape Australia
Stephen Roche spent almost four months behind bars The Irish man is accused of helping Hussein Chamas (pictured) to escape An Irishman who allegedly tried to assist a wanted drug dealer escape Australia has been released on bail. Stephen Francis Roche was arrested in January after it was alleged he travelled 4,700km across Oz with the fugitive hidden in his campervan. He was charged before the courts in February. The Irish man is accused of helping Hussein Chamas (pictured) to escape News in 90 Seconds - 09 June 2025 Last week, he was released from jail on bail after spending 123 days on remand at Darwin Correctional Centre. Roche's barrister Richard Bryson told a court in Darwin that his 46-year-old client was at risk of being 'prejudiced' by his time behind bars, NT News reports. He added that Roche's daughter was living in Queensland, and that his brother would be providing him with financial support as he returned to the community. The prosecution did not oppose bail, but Judge Sally Ozolins imposed strict conditions, including a curfew and daily check-ins at the Darwin Police Station. Roche is also barred from applying for a passport and cannot own more than one mobile phone or SIM card. He is unable to use any encrypted devices or applications. Stephen Roche is accused of driving Hussein Chamas, a wanted fugitive who escaped from a rehabilitation clinic in New South Wales, more than 4,600km to the Northern Territory. Chamas was in the facility on bail after he was charged with illegally possessing a firearm, drug trafficking, and conspiracy to import a commercial quantity of methamphetamine. He allegedly showed fake court documents to security guards at the facility before he fled in the van with Roche on January 8th. He was arrested 18 days later aboard a yacht in the Arafura Sea. Australian Federal Police allege the 35-year-old is a member of a syndicate which was behind the importation of drugs into Australia. A man suspected to be fugitive Hussein Chamas is arrested on board the yacht The syndicate was busted as part of Operation Ironside, an international police sting that intercepted millions of messages sent through the supposedly secure smartphone-based proprietary messaging app Anom. Chamas was charged with drug offences and breaching a firearms prohibition order in July 2023 and placed in rehab after he was arrested at Sydney Airport. The AFP were alerted of his escape on January 15, and a warrant was issued for his arrest when he failed to appear at the Downing Centre Local Court on January 20. Chamas was arrested after a member of the public alerted Australian Border Force (ABF) officers that a man was seen flashing a torch to a yacht at East Woody Beach in Nhulunbuy. ABF and Australian Federal Police officers who had been conducting covert surveillance on the vessel watched as the yacht's crew were also seen flashing a torch back to the man. AFP officers intercepted the yacht, and Chamas, who was identified as a passenger, was taken into custody under the NSW arrest warrant. Two crew members of the yacht, Thomas Goertz (51) from Germany, and Jade Sui Ying Ormiston (42) from the UK, were also charged but later released on bail. Stephen Roche is due before the court again for a hearing on July 22nd.
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Tributes paid to ‘kind' man after body recovered from canal
Peter Dinnegan died in the early hours of Sunday morning Tributes have been paid to Peter Dinnegan, whose body was recovered from the banks of the Royal Canal in Mullingar on Sunday morning. Emergency services discovered the 55-year-old after they were called to the scene just after 6am. Mourners took to social media to pay their respects, and share condolences. 'Rest in peace to my old friend Peter Dinnegan, I'm so sorry for all the family lost he was a very nice man and he was kind and we will all miss him,' one person wrote. 'Rip Peter Dinnegan, may god watch over the family,' another shared. A third added: 'Condolences to all the Dinnegan family on the passing of Peter at this sad time.' Meanwhile, a family member said: 'Peter I'll never understand why. God may give you best bed in heaven your back with Willie, Michael, Patrick and Lily. 'Mind nanny and grandad and all the family get through this it's to much for them to lose 5 within 4 year please god look down on them. 'Gowan my uncle Peter Dinnegan fly high you legend.' Stock photo Today's News in 90 Seconds - 09 June 2025 Gardaí are awaiting the results of a post-mortem which they say will determine the course of their investigation. 'Gardaí were alerted to the discovery of a body in the Royal Canal, Mulingar, shortly after 6am on Sunday 08th June 2025,' a spokesperson for An Garda Síochána said. 'The deceased male was recovered from the canal by the Fire Service. 'His body has been transferred to the morgue, where a post-mortem examination will take place in due course. The results of the examination will determine the course of the Garda investigation. 'Investigations are ongoing.' Funeral details are yet to be announced.
