US envoy says Hamas response to ceasefire proposal 'unacceptable'
Hamas announced that it had replied to a US-backed Gaza ceasefire proposal, but the main negotiator for the US has criticised the response as "totally unacceptable".
The Palestinian militant group said its response was positive while emphasising the need for a permanent ceasefire - long a sticking point for Israel.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu echoed US envoy Steve Witkoff's assessment that the response was "unacceptable", accusing Hamas of clinging "to its rejectionism".
Israel earlier warned Hamas to either accept the deal and free the hostages held in Gaza "or be annihilated".
In a statement, Hamas said it had "submitted its response... to the mediating parties".
"As part of this agreement, ten living prisoners of the occupation held by the resistance will be released, in addition to the return of 18 bodies, in exchange for an agreed-upon number of Palestinian prisoners," it added.
A source within the group's political bureau said it had offered "a positive response to Mr Witkoff, but with emphasis on guaranteeing a permanent ceasefire and full Israeli withdrawal" from Gaza.
Mr Witkoff said the response by Hamas was "totally unacceptable and only takes us backward", urging the group to "accept the framework proposal we put forward".
"That is the only way we can close a 60-day ceasefire deal in the coming days in which half of the living hostages and half of those who are deceased will come home to their families and in which we can have... substantive negotiations in good-faith to try to reach a permanent ceasefire," he added in a post on X.
Hamas alleges negotiation 'bias'
A member of Hamas's political bureau, Bassem Naim, later told AFP the group "responded positively and responsibly" to Mr Witkoff's proposal.
He alleged there was a "complete bias" in the negotiating process in favour of Israel, accusing it of disagreeing with "provisions we had agreed upon" earlier with the US envoy.
Hamas has long maintained that any deal should lay out a pathway to a permanent end to the war.
Israel has balked at that prospect, insisting on the need to destroy the group to prevent a repeat of the October 2023 attack that sparked the war.
It recently stepped up its campaign in Gaza in a bid to defeat Hamas.
"While Israel has agreed to the updated Witkoff framework for the release of our hostages,
Hamas continues to cling to its rejectionism," Netanyahu's office said in a statement, adding the group's reply was "unacceptable and sets the process back".
"Israel will continue its efforts to bring our hostages home and to defeat Hamas."
A breakthrough in negotiations has been elusive ever since a previous ceasefire fell apart on 18 March with the resumption of Israeli operations.
US President Donald Trump had said that the parties were "very close to an agreement".
Two sources close to the negotiations said Mr Witkoff's proposal involved a 60-day truce, potentially extendable to 70 days.
It would include the release of five living hostages and nine bodies in exchange for a number of Palestinian prisoners during the first week, followed by a second exchange the following week, the sources said.
Gaza 'hungriest place on Earth'
Of the 251 hostages taken during Hamas's 7 October 2023 attack, 57 remain in Gaza, including 34 the Israeli military says are dead.
"After 603 days of war, we wish to remind everyone that war is a means, not an end in itself," the main group representing the hostages' families said in a statement.
Israeli society was "united around one consensus", bringing home all the remaining hostages "even at the cost of ending the war", the Hostages and Missing Families Forum added.
Israel has come under increasing international criticism over the dire humanitarian situation in the Palestinian territory, where the United Nations warned in May that the entire population was at risk of famine.
A spokesman for the UN humanitarian agency has called the territory "the hungriest place on Earth".
Aid is only trickling into Gaza after the partial lifting by Israel of a more than two-month total blockade, and the UN has recently reported looting of its trucks and warehouses.
The World Food Programme has called on Israel "to get far greater volumes of food assistance into Gaza faster", saying desperation was "contributing to rising insecurity".
The health ministry in Hamas-run Gaza said on Saturday that at least 4,117 people have been killed in the territory since Israel resumed its offensive on March 18, taking the war's overall toll to 54,381, mostly civilians.
Hamas's attack on Israel resulted in the deaths of 1,218 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
25 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Israeli soldiers bar media from West Bank villages on tour by Oscar winners
Israeli soldiers have barred journalists from entering villages in the West Bank on a planned tour organised by the directors of the Oscar-winning movie No Other Land. The directors of the film, which focuses on settler attacks on Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied territory, said they had invited the journalists on the tour on Monday to interview residents about increasing settler violence in the area. In video posted on X by the film's co-director Yuval Abraham, an Israeli soldier tells a group of international journalists there is 'no passage' in the area because of a military order. It's clear they don't want the world to see what is happening here Basel Adra, a Palestinian co-director of the film who lives in the area, said the military then blocked the journalists from entering two Palestinian villages they had hoped to visit. 'They don't want journalists to visit the villages to meet the residents,' said Mr Adra, who had invited the journalists to his home. 'It's clear they don't want the world to see what is happening here.' Some of the surrounding area, including a collection of small Bedouin villages known as Masafer Yatta, was declared by the military to be a live-fire training zone in the 1980s. About 1,000 Palestinians have remained there despite being ordered out, and journalists, human rights activists and diplomats have visited the villages in the past. Palestinian residents in the area have reported increasing settler violence since October 7 2023, when Hamas attacked Israel and sparked the war in the Gaza Strip. Israeli soldiers regularly move in to demolish homes, tents, water tanks and olive orchards — and Palestinians fear outright expulsion could come at any time. Mr Adra said the journalists were eventually able to enter one of the villages in Masafer Yatta, but were barred from entering Tuwani, the village where he lives, and Khallet A-Daba, where he had hoped to take them. This is one of the main villages you saw in No Other Land. Today it was destroyed by the Israeli army. — Yuval Abraham יובל אברהם (@yuval_abraham) May 5, 2025 He said settlers arrived in Khallet A-Daba on Monday and took over some of the caves where villagers now live, destroying residents' belongings. The military demolished much of the village last month. No Other Land, which won the Oscar this year for best documentary, chronicles the struggle by residents to stop the Israeli military from demolishing their villages. The joint Palestinian-Israeli production was directed by Mr Adra, Hamdan Ballal, another Palestinian activist from Masafer Yatta, and Israeli directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor. The film has won a string of international awards. Israel captured the West Bank in the 1967 Middle East war, along with the Gaza Strip and east Jerusalem. The Palestinians want all three for their future state and view settlement growth as a major obstacle to a two-state solution. Israel has built more than 100 settlements, home to over 500,000 settlers who have Israeli citizenship. The three million Palestinians in the West Bank live under seemingly open-ended Israeli military rule, with the western-backed Palestinian Authority administering population centres.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Irish woman detained by Israeli forces in West Bank ‘fighting deportation order'
The son of an Irish woman detained by Israeli police in the West Bank on Saturday claims she was targeted for standing in solidarity with Palestinian people.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Ukraine and Russia meet in Turkey for peace talks after trading major attacks
Delegations from Russia and Ukraine are holding a second round of direct peace talks in just over two weeks, although expectations are low for any significant progress on ending the three-year war. The meeting in Istanbul comes after a string of major attacks over the weekend. Ukraine said on Sunday that it had launched a spectacular surprise attack on five Russian air bases, ranging from targets close to Moscow to Russia's Arctic, Siberia and Far East. The talks are being held at the Ciragan Palace in Istanbul (Emrah Gurel/AP) The targets were more than 4,300 miles from Ukraine. More than 40 Russian warplanes were destroyed, Ukraine claimed, in what President Volodymyr Zelensky called a 'brilliant operation' that involved more than a year of planning. Also on Sunday, Russia launched its biggest number of drones — 472 — on Ukraine since the full-scale invasion in February 2022, Ukraine's air force said, in an apparent effort to overwhelm air defences. US-led efforts to push the two sides into accepting a ceasefire have failed. Ukraine accepted that step, but the Kremlin effectively rejected it. The Institute for the Study of War, a Washington-based think tank, assessed late on Sunday that 'Russia is attempting to delay negotiations and prolong the war in order to make additional battlefield gains'. Members of the Russian delegation arrive at the Ciragan Palace (Emrah Gurel/AP) Recent comments by senior officials in both countries indicate they remain far apart on key conditions for stopping the war. The first round of talks on May 16, also in Istanbul, ended after less than two hours. While both sides agreed on a large prisoner swap, there was no breakthrough. The Ukrainian delegation in Istanbul for Monday's meeting is led by defence minister Rustem Umerov, according to Heorhii Tykhyi, spokesman for the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry. Moscow's delegation, headed by Vladimir Medinsky, an aide to Russian leader Vladimir Putin, arrived on Sunday evening, Russian state media reported. Turkish foreign minister Hakan Fidan is chairing the talks at the city's Ciragan Palace and gave an opening speech to mark their start. Fierce fighting has continued along the roughly 620-mile front line, and both sides have hit each other's territory with deep strikes. Ukrainian drones struck near Rylsk in the western Kursk region of Russia (Alexander Khinshtein/AP) Russian air defences downed 162 Ukrainian drones over eight Russian regions overnight, as well as over the annexed Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea, Russia's Defence Ministry said on Monday. Ukrainian air defenscs damaged 52 out of 80 drones launched by Russia overnight, the Ukrainian air force said. Two ballistic missiles struck a residential neighbourhood in the north-eastern Ukrainian city of Kharkiv on Monday morning, including one that hit near a school, the city's mayor said. One missile landed near an apartment building, while the second struck a road near the school, Ihor Terekhov said in a statement with a photo of a wide crater. 'Standing next to the crater, you realise how different it all could have been,' he wrote. 'A few more metres — and it would have hit the building. A few more minutes — and cars, buses would have been on the road.' No casualties were reported.
