Labour ‘comfortable' with private firms providing assisted dying
Labour is 'comfortable' with private firms providing assisted dying to patients, a health minister has revealed.
Stephen Kinnock, the care minister, said assisted dying could be provided on the NHS and be free at the point of use, but that would not 'preclude the use of independent contractors'.
The minister, who voted in support of Kim Leadbeater's Terminally Ill Adults Bill, sits on the committee that is examining it to represent the views of the Department of Health and Social Care.
Ms Leadbeater 's legislation seeks to enable those with fewer than six months to live to receive medical assistance to end their lives.
The Government is neutral on assisted dying, but Mr Kinnock and Sarah Sackman, a justice minister, appear on the Bill committee to advise on the workability of its proposals.
The care minister told The House magazine: 'Kim has said that she wants this service to be an integral part of the NHS, meaning free at the point of use.
'Certainly the advice that we as ministers have given her is we've clearly understood that that is her wish, and that is a wish that can be delivered and carried out.
'Now, free at the point of use doesn't preclude the use of independent contractors to deliver the service. So, yeah, we're comfortable with that.'
His remarks are the first time that a minister has publicly expressed support for the use of private firms offering assisted dying in England and Wales as part of plans to legalise it.
Critics have voiced concerns about the use of private companies in the provision of assisted dying as it would allow firms to profit from the system.
'Money-making enterprise'
Danny Kruger, a Conservative MP on the Bill committee who opposes the legislation, said last week: 'It would be a money-making enterprise, quite a lucrative one. There have been estimates given of between 5,000 to 17,000 assisted deaths per year, depending on how it's estimated.
'If the charges employed by Dignitas, which is in a sense the model being proposed here, if they are anything to go by, this could be up to the region of £5,000 to £10,000 per patient.
'So even a small proportion of that would be… a significant multi-million pound business would be possible under this Bill.'
The Times reported earlier this month that there could be a limit on the profits that private companies could make from providing the service through the NHS.
Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, has previously warned that providing assisted dying on the NHS would have 'resource implications'.
The Cabinet minister, who opposes a change in the law, told Times Radio in November: 'There would be resource implications for doing [assisted dying]. And those choices would come at the expense of other choices.'
Mr Kinnock also told The House that he believed there would be 'ample opportunity for scrutiny' for the legislation in Parliament.
The Department of Health and Social Care has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
'Unregulated' beauticians risking lives selling bloodletting amid NHS shortage
Bloodletting, which involves drawing large quantities of blood from the body, was discredited in the 19th century - but beauticians claim the procedure can cure multiple health conditions 'Unregulated' beauticians are risking customers' lives by selling bloodletting services promising to cure a myriad of conditions, it has been revealed. The procedure, which involves drawing large quantities of blood from the body, was discredited in the 19th century. But beauticians with no medical qualifications are now offering to let blood, falsely claiming it can cure a myriad of health issues from chronic fatigue to hormone imbalance, migraines and burnout. So-called experts are plugging the quack treatment, called venesection, on social media with photos of blood being taken. One provider was seen advertising their services in a Facebook group, offering £80 per session. The Facebook page says: 'When the blood is heavy, stagnant or full of waste, oxygen can't circulate properly. By removing that old, sluggish blood, you create space for fresh, oxygen-rich blood to flow freely again. This isn't just a detox, it's a full body reset.' Another claims: 'The procedure can improve blood circulation [and] help reduce workload on the heart.' But doctors warn the procedure can worsen some conditions and lead to life-threatening infections and uncontrolled bleeding." Dr Sue Pavord, president of the British Society for Haematology, said: 'There is absolutely no evidence for the health benefit claims these people are making. Done without medical guidance, it could make conditions worse, particularly chronic fatigue syndrome because it makes iron deficiency worse. For every pint of blood taken, you lose 250mg of iron, which is a big quantity.' Doctors have criticised beauticians for taking blood amid a national blood shortage. The NHS last week called for 200,000 more donors to step up after issuing an amber alert over stocks last year. Dr Pavord continued: "Blood donation, at a blood donor centre, is a gift of life and it is critical right now due to the national shortage. And crucially, before the blood is collected, patients are tested for anemia - whereas in these unregulated places there are no quality assured tests so it can be very harmful indeed - this makes me so worried." Prof Adele Fielding, of the Centre for Blood Research at the University of York, added: 'If anyone is interested in bloodletting, it can be done safely – and for free – at a place called a blood donation centre.' Ashton Collins, of the government-backed register of approved aesthetics practitioners, has received numerous reports of dodgy bloodletting services in the past two months. She said: "I am deeply troubled by the alarming resurgence of bloodletting, now being offered by unqualified individuals across the UK. "Bloodletting is not only an outdated and ineffective practice but also poses severe health risks, including life-threatening infections and uncontrolled bleeding. Within the past two months alone, we have received numerous complaints about practitioners conducting this procedure in highly unsuitable environments, where the risk of infection is already considerable. "Additionally, there are grave concerns about the improper disposal of blood. I strongly urge anyone considering this procedure to reconsider - any treatment where the risks far outweigh any potential benefits should be avoided, and bloodletting is undoubtedly among those best left in the past." Bloodletting, which first became popular in ancient Greece and was carried out globally until the late 1800s, is based on the belief that removing blood will restore balance in the body.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Now doctors say: 'We don't trust Neil Gray'...as pressure grows on the Health Secretary to quit after fresh 'Limogate' scandal
Health Secretary Neil Gray faced mounting pressure to quit last night after Scots doctors launched an unprecedented attack saying they don't trust him. In an extraordinary row with under-fire Mr Gray over pay talks, the British Medical Association Scotland accused the minister of 'an egregious breach of trust.' The organisation - which represents 16,000 NHS staff - said: 'When you look someone in the eye, shake hands and then do something completely different, it inevitably raises real questions of trust.' The BMA's outburst comes just days after it was revealed the beleagured minister had been chauffeur-driven to a pub, despite official records stating he had been taken to a 'personal address'. The Scottish Government was forced to admit Mr Gray's trip to the Brig O'Don pub, in Aberdeen, was for a 'personal engagement,' rather than any duties related to his government role. It is the latest twist and turn in a scandal that has dogged Mr Gray in recent months and one that saw him apologise twice over his use of ministerial cars. Critics, who have called for him to resign in the wake of the pub trip revelations, said the scathing comments from BMA Scotland is further proof of why he is not up to the job. Scottish Conservative health spokesman Dr Sandesh Gulhane MSP said: 'This just shows that Neil Gray has lost all credibility. 'If he can't be trusted to honour his word to the BMA, why should we believe him when he says he has a plan to fix our NHS?' The party has already said his position is 'untenable' due to the scandal and have urged him to resign. The furious medics said Mr Gray assured them during a face-to-face meeting that their concerns about a below-inflation salary increase would be addressed. However, despite shaking hands and looking the medics 'in the eye', Mr Gray went on to issue a statement just hours later indicating the matter was settled. In a scathing joint statement, BMA Scotland representatives Dr Alan Robertson and Dr Sine Steele, said Mr Gray's actions had left them 'with considerable anger and frustration'. The medics, who say the health service in Scotland is 'collapsing', have also accused Mr Gray and the SNP administration of 'an egregious breach of trust'. Scottish Labour health spokesperson Jackie Baillie said: 'Neil Gray has found himself embroiled in one scandal after another - but the worst scandal of all is his mismanagement of our NHS. 'It is clear from his shambolic and dishonest approach to negotiations that Neil Gray cannot be trusted to do right by doctors or deliver for our NHS. 'Hardworking NHS staff and long-suffering patients cannot keep paying the price for SNP failure.' The BMA Scotland statement said the actions of Mr Gray and the Scottish Government had 'undermined the discussions' and 'resulted in considerable damage to our relationship' As such, they said they had written to the health secretary 'to leave him in no doubt of our anger and dissatisfaction'. The discussion with medics concerned pay negotiations for 1,300 speciality and associate specialist doctors (SAS) in Scotland, who work in areas including A&E, cancer care, GP clinics, and also as dentists. Last month the Doctors' and Dentists' Remuneration (DDRB) pay review body, DDRB recommended that pay for SAS medics be increased by 4 per cent. However, the BMA argues that years of pay erosion and a failure 'to keep up with inflation compared to other public sector workers and similar professions' means the offer should be higher. Pointing out that vacancies for SAS doctors stand at 1 in 4 and that more than 14 per cent of consultant posts are empty, the BMA representatives warned: 'The NHS is collapsing around us.' They added: 'These actions will no doubt further erode what little confidence many SAS and consultants have in the Government's approach to us as senior members of vital NHS services up and down the country.' They added: 'To do so without even informing us in advance and in direct contradiction to what has just been said in a meeting is, in our view, an egregious breach of trust.' Two days after the contentious meeting with BMA Scotland, Mr Gray made headlines yet again over his chauffeur-driven trips. Last year, it emerged Dons fan Mr Gray had been chauffeured to and from nine football matches involving Aberdeen FC or Scotland in the period between 2022 and 2024. He went on to apologise to parliament in November for giving 'the impression of acting more as a fan and less as a minister' but reassured MSPs the matches were not junkets and that officials had made a record of business meetings at the games. However, in January, he was forced to apologise again and admit he had misled parliament after it was revealed there was no such written record of discussions he was involved in when he attended the 2023 Scottish League Cup Final between his favourite team, Aberdeen, and Rangers. One of the trips, ahead of Aberdeen FC's pivotal match against Livingston last year, stated he had been driven to and from a 'personal address, Aberdeen'. It was this account that had to be corrected this week after it emerged he had in fact been driven to the city's Brig O'Don watering hole and then to Pittodrie.
STV News
2 hours ago
- STV News
PM announces national inquiry into grooming gangs scandal
Sir Keir Starmer has announced the government will launch a national inquiry into the grooming gangs scandal, despite resisting calls for one for months. It comes after the government commissioned a review into the scandal by Baroness Louise Casey, which has recommended a national inquiry and is due to be published in full next week. The prime minister told reporters as he travelled to the G7 summit in Canada: 'I have read every single word of her report and I am going to accept her recommendation. That is the right thing to do.' Since the scandal became a point of fierce political discussion earlier this year, the government has repeatedly insisted there was no need for a national inquiry, instead launching five locally-led investigations. The prime minister had previously argued another inquiry would delay justice for the victims of the scandal, saying the government wanted to get on with implementing the recommendations of a 2022 inquiry into child sexual exploitation. Baroness Louise Casey was commissioned to carry out a 'rapid' national audit on the scandal. / Credit: James Manning/PA 'From the start I have always said that we should implement the recommendations we have got,' the PM told reporters. 'I have never said we should not look again at any issue – I had wanted to be assured that on the question of any inquiry, that's why I asked Louise Casey, who I hugely respect, to do an audit.' Pressed on the detail of the inquiry, the PM said: 'It will be statutory under the inquiries act, that will take a bit of time to sort out exactly how that works and we will set that out in an orderly way.' Debate around tackling grooming gangs raged earlier this year after tech billionaire and X owner Elon Musk began attacking Sir Keir Starmer and his government, accusing them of being 'complicit' in the scandal. Both the Conservatives and Reform UK have repeatedly called for a national inquiry into the scandal. Starmer previously accused Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch of 'jumping on the bandwagon', by calling for a national investigation. The Conservatives had tabled an amendment to the Crime and Policing Bill that was due to be voted on in Parliament next week, calling for the government to set up a national statutory inquiry within three months. In response to the announcement on a statutory inquiry Badenoch said: 'Keir Starmer doesn't know what he thinks unless an official report has told him so. 'Just like he dismissed concerns about the winter fuel payment and then had to u-turn, just like he needed the Supreme Court to tell him what a woman is, he had to be led by the nose to make this correct decision here. 'I've been repeatedly calling for a full national inquiry since January. It's about time he recognised he made a mistake and apologise for six wasted months.' The government had previously argued that there had already been a national inquiry into the grooming gangs, referring to the 2022 Jay Inquiry into child sex abuse. Debate around grooming gangs was reignited this year after tech billionaire Elon Musk attacked Starmer and his government. / Credit: AP The Jay inquiry described the sexual abuse of children as an 'epidemic that leaves tens of thousands of victims in its poisonous wake'. It looked into abuse by organised groups following multiple convictions of sexual offences against children across the UK between 2010-2014, including in Rotherham, Cornwall, Derbyshire, Rochdale and Bristol. In November last year, Professor Jay said she felt 'frustrated' that none of the probe's 20 recommendations had been implemented more than two years after its conclusion. Reports in The Times newspaper suggest the Casey review will say that white British girls who were targeted by grooming gangs were 'institutionally ignored for fear of racism'. The Casey audit was originally due to take three months from when it was announced in January. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
