Google persuades US appeals court to overturn $20 mln Nest patent verdict
May 22 (Reuters) - Google (GOOGL.O), opens new tab on Wednesday convinced a U.S. appeals court to overturn its $20 million trial loss to energy-management company EcoFactor in a patent lawsuit over Google's Nest smart thermostats.
Following a rare full-court review, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit said, opens new tab that Google was entitled to a new trial to determine how much it owed EcoFactor in damages. A three-judge Federal Circuit panel had upheld the award in a split decision last year.
Spokespeople for EcoFactor did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the decision. Google spokesperson Jose Castaneda said the company was pleased with the decision and looked forward to presenting its case in district court.
EcoFactor, based in Palo Alto, California, sells smart home energy-efficiency services. It sued Google for patent infringement in Waco, Texas, federal court in 2020, arguing that Nest thermostats use EcoFactor's patented method for automatically reducing energy usage during peak demand.
A jury determined in 2022 that Google infringed one of the patents and awarded EcoFactor just over $20 million in damages. The Federal Circuit upheld the verdict in a 2-1 ruling last June, rejecting Google's argument that the proposed damages rate from EcoFactor's expert was "plucked out of nowhere."
The full Federal Circuit overturned the panel's damages ruling on Wednesday. It said the Texas court "gave no rationale for ruling that the expert testimony was admissible" and that the expert's opinion was "not based upon sufficient facts or data."
Google's argument drew support in court briefs from other tech giants including Apple, Tesla and Intel.
The case is EcoFactor Inc v. Google LLC, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, No. 23-1101.
For EcoFactor: Reza Mirzaie of Russ August & Kabat
For Google: Robert Van Nest of Keker Van Nest & Peters
Read more:
Google hit with $20 million verdict in Nest thermostat patent trial
Google loses bid to overturn $20 million Nest patent verdict
Google convinces US appeals court to reconsider Nest patent verdict
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
15 minutes ago
- Reuters
US aluminium tariffs threaten scrap clash with European Union
LONDON, June 9 (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald Trump's move to double tariffs on aluminium imports heightens the risk of a full-blown scrap war with the European Union. Although they are supposed to be blanket tariffs with no exceptions or exemptions, there is one significant gap in the tariff wall. Aluminium scrap is explicitly excluded on the grounds it constitutes a key raw material for U.S. manufacturers. The Trump administration's decision to lift aluminium tariffs to 25% effective the start of March has already caused U.S. imports of recyclable material to rise. This week's doubling of the tariff rate to 50% could turn the import flow into a flood. The European Union, which is mulling export duties on aluminium recyclables to stop what it terms "scrap leakage", is coming under pressure to move sooner rather than later. The U.S. Midwest aluminium premium has rocketed to a record $1,325 per metric ton after Wednesday's doubling-down on import tariffs. That's the price U.S. buyers will pay over and above the international price traded on the London Metal Exchange (LME), currently $2,430 per ton for cash metal. What once reflected the cost of transport to get metal to the U.S. Midwest manufacturing hub is now a tariff premium, capturing the fracture of the global aluminium pricing structure. U.S. consumers of aluminium goods will ultimately foot the bill but mid-stream processors are likely to do well. Fabricators converting raw metal to semi-finished goods such as can sheet were the prime beneficiaries of the first Trump administration's 10% tariffs, according to a report by consultancy Harbor Aluminum commissioned by the Beer Institute. Mid-stream processors passed on the tariff, even if the raw material was domestically sourced scrap, Harbor found. The new tariffs will incentivise fabricators not only to maximise their domestic purchases of scrap but to tap overseas markets, where U.S. buyers can now outbid just about anyone else for available material. U.S. imports of aluminium recyclable materials jumped to over 80,000 tons in March, the highest monthly volume since 2022. There were sharp increases in supply from Canada and Mexico, the two largest and nearest suppliers to the U.S. market. However, the tariff differential has started to draw material out of Europe, according to the European Aluminium association. Exports from EU countries to the United States spiked in the first quarter of the year, it said. They are only going to accelerate as the transatlantic price gap widens after this week's doubling of tariffs. The EU is facing a "full-blown scrap crisis", according to the association. Director General Paul Voss called on the European Commission to immediately impose a corresponding duty on scrap exports to the United States. The Commission has already identified high aluminium scrap exports as a key hurdle in its ambition to meet the bloc's "Circular Economy" targets. A March "Action Plan", opens new tab for both the aluminium and steel sectors promised a decision by the third quarter of this year on suitable trade measures, including reciprocal export tariffs on countries "that apply unfair subsidies" to their recycling industries. There's now a sense of urgency that some sort of defensive trade barrier will be required to stem export flows. Aluminium scrap is a highly globalised marketplace but that looks set to change as Europe figures out how to stop the loss of raw material to the United States. Caught in the middle of this tug-of-war is China, the world's largest aluminium scrap buyer. The country has imported 1.8 million tons in each of the last two years and although it sources much of its material from Asia, it is a significant buyer of both U.S. and European end-of-life scrap. Beijing last year relaxed the purity rules on imports of both copper and aluminium scrap to encourage greater domestic recycling. This is particularly important for China's aluminium sector, where production of primary metal is now close to the government's mandated capacity cap, meaning supply growth will have to come from recycling. Chinese buyers are facing the twin challenge of export restrictions in Europe and competition with U.S. players in their own Asian supply chain. The scrap wars have only just begun. The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters. Enjoying this column? Check out Reuters Open Interest (ROI), your essential new source for global financial commentary. ROI delivers thought-provoking, data-driven analysis of everything from swap rates to soybeans. Markets are moving faster than ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn, opens new tab and X, opens new tab.
Geeky Gadgets
16 minutes ago
- Geeky Gadgets
Master Dynamic Excel Formulas with Dot Operator in 2025
What if you could write Excel formulas that practically think for themselves—automatically adjusting to changes in your data without endless tweaking? With the introduction of the dot operator and the trim range function, Excel is stepping into a new era of formula creation. Gone are the days of dragging fill handles or manually fixing broken references. These tools promise to make your formulas not only more dynamic but also smarter and more error-resistant, saving you time and frustration. Whether you're managing massive datasets or just trying to keep things tidy, this shift is poised to transform how you interact with Excel. In this feature, Computergaga explains how these operators work and why they're a fantastic option for anyone who relies on Excel. You'll uncover how the dot operator trims away unnecessary cells, how trim range keeps your formulas clean and adaptive, and how complementary functions like drop and bycol take your efficiency to the next level. But it's not just about learning new tricks—it's about rethinking what's possible with Excel. By the end, you'll see how these innovations can transform your workflow, making your formulas not just functional but future-proof. After all, why settle for static when your data can be as dynamic as your ideas? Modern Excel Formula Tools What Is the Dot Operator? The dot operator is a versatile addition to Excel's formula toolkit, allowing you to dynamically trim unused cells—whether at the beginning, end, or both—within your data ranges. This functionality eliminates redundancy and minimizes the need for manual adjustments. For example, if you frequently work with datasets that change in size, the dot operator ensures your formulas automatically adjust to include only the relevant data. This tool works seamlessly across rows, columns, and ranges, making it an essential feature for modern Excel users. By simplifying the management of dynamic data, the dot operator helps you maintain cleaner, more efficient formulas that adapt to changes in your datasets. How the Trim Range Function Enhances Flexibility The trim range function complements the dot operator by dynamically adjusting ranges to include only the cells containing data. This prevents blank cells from being included in your calculations, which can otherwise lead to errors or inefficiencies. One of its most valuable features is its ability to auto-expand as new data is added. This ensures your formulas remain accurate and up-to-date without requiring manual intervention. If you work with datasets that grow or shrink over time, the trim range function is an indispensable tool for maintaining precision and adaptability in your calculations. Dot Operator will Change how you Write Formulas in Excel Watch this video on YouTube. Enhance your knowledge on Excel functions by exploring a selection of articles and guides on the subject. Streamlining Data with the Drop Function The drop function simplifies the process of excluding unwanted rows or columns from your formulas. Whether you need to remove header rows or eliminate unused columns, this function ensures your calculations focus only on the relevant data. For instance, when referencing entire columns or rows, the drop function allows you to exclude irrelevant cells, keeping your formulas clean and efficient. This is particularly useful when working with large datasets or preparing data for analysis, where clutter can slow down your workflow and increase the risk of errors. Bycol: Simplifying Column-Specific Operations The bycol function is designed to make column-specific operations more dynamic and efficient. It enables you to perform calculations across columns while making sure your formulas adjust automatically to changes in your dataset. When paired with the dot operator, bycol allows for precise range adjustments, making sure your formulas target only the necessary data. For example, you can use bycol to sum values across columns while automatically accounting for changes in the size or structure of your dataset. This function is particularly useful for tasks like aggregating sales data or analyzing trends across multiple categories, where column-wise precision is critical. Key Advantages of Modern Excel Techniques Modern Excel functions like the dot operator, trim range, drop, and bycol offer several advantages that can significantly improve your workflow. These include: Reducing the need for manual adjustments, such as dragging fill handles to update formulas. Creating dynamic, maintainable single-cell formulas that adapt to changes in your data. Enhancing compatibility with advanced tools like array formulas and lambda functions. Minimizing errors by making sure formulas automatically adjust to include only relevant data. By adopting these techniques, you can save time, reduce errors, and improve the adaptability of your formulas to evolving datasets. Practical Applications of Modern Excel Tools The practical applications of these modern Excel tools are extensive and can simplify a wide range of tasks. Here are a few examples: Automatically multiplying quantities by prices, making sure calculations update as new data is added. Summing data across rows or columns with auto-expanding ranges to accommodate changes in your dataset. Efficiently handling headers and unused cells, keeping your formulas focused and error-free. Streamlining data preparation for analysis by dynamically excluding irrelevant rows or columns. These features are particularly valuable when working with large, complex datasets or in scenarios where data is frequently updated, such as financial reporting, inventory management, or trend analysis. Maximizing Efficiency with Modern Excel The dot operator and trim range function, along with complementary tools like drop and bycol, represent a significant advancement in Excel's formula capabilities. By making formulas more dynamic, concise, and error-resistant, these tools empower you to manage data more effectively and efficiently. Whether you're handling simple calculations or complex datasets, these features provide the flexibility and precision needed to adapt to changing requirements. By incorporating these modern techniques into your workflow, you can streamline your processes, reduce errors, and enhance the accuracy and reliability of your Excel formulas. These tools are not just enhancements—they are essential for anyone looking to work smarter with data in Excel. Media Credit: Computergaga Filed Under: Guides Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
Geeky Gadgets
16 minutes ago
- Geeky Gadgets
This is IT: iOS 26's Last-Chance Leaks Before WWDC
The excitement surrounding iOS 26 continues to grow as leaks and rumors offer glimpses into what Apple's next operating system might bring. With a focus on refining the user experience, enhancing privacy, and introducing meaningful updates, iOS 26 is poised to deliver a blend of innovation and practicality. Here's an in-depth look at the potential features and improvements that could define this release in a new video from Brandon Butch. Watch this video on YouTube. Design Updates: Subtle Yet Impactful Changes Design has always been a cornerstone of Apple's operating systems, and iOS 26 is rumored to introduce a series of subtle yet impactful updates to its interface. These changes aim to enhance both the visual appeal and usability of the system, creating a more cohesive experience across devices. Redesigned app icons are expected to offer a fresh, modern aesthetic while maintaining Apple's signature simplicity. are expected to offer a fresh, modern aesthetic while maintaining Apple's signature simplicity. Updated widgets with expanded customization options could allow users to tailor their home screens to better suit their preferences. with expanded customization options could allow users to tailor their home screens to better suit their preferences. A dynamic lock screen that adapts to user preferences may provide a more personalized and interactive experience. These design updates are likely to focus on improving navigation and accessibility, making sure that the interface remains intuitive and visually appealing for all users. Personalized and Streamlined User Experience Apple appears to be prioritizing personalization and efficiency with iOS 26, aiming to deliver a more tailored experience that adapts to individual user needs. Several rumored features highlight this focus: Advanced Siri integration could enable smarter, context-aware assistance, making interactions with the virtual assistant more seamless and intuitive. could enable smarter, context-aware assistance, making interactions with the virtual assistant more seamless and intuitive. Improved multitasking capabilities may enhance productivity by allowing users to manage multiple tasks more efficiently. may enhance productivity by allowing users to manage multiple tasks more efficiently. Customizable Control Center options could provide quicker access to essential tools, giving users greater control over their device settings. Additionally, updates to accessibility features are expected, making sure that iOS 26 is inclusive and adaptable for users with diverse needs. These enhancements could make the operating system more versatile and user-friendly for a broader audience. Performance Boosts and System Efficiency Performance improvements are a hallmark of every iOS update, and iOS 26 is no exception. Apple is likely to focus on optimizing system efficiency to ensure devices run smoothly and reliably. Key performance enhancements may include: Faster app launch times and smoother animations, creating a more responsive user experience. and smoother animations, creating a more responsive user experience. Enhanced resource management to improve overall device performance, particularly on older models. to improve overall device performance, particularly on older models. Optimizations that could potentially extend battery life, allowing users to get more out of their devices throughout the day. These updates are designed to ensure that iOS 26 delivers consistent performance across a wide range of devices, maintaining Apple's reputation for reliability and efficiency. Strengthened Privacy and Security Features Privacy and security remain central to Apple's philosophy, and iOS 26 is expected to introduce new measures to protect user data. These rumored enhancements could further solidify Apple's position as a leader in safeguarding personal information: Advanced app tracking transparency tools may give users greater control over how their data is shared and used by third-party applications. may give users greater control over how their data is shared and used by third-party applications. Improved encryption protocols could enhance the security of data stored on devices and transmitted over networks. could enhance the security of data stored on devices and transmitted over networks. Greater control over app permissions might allow users to manage their privacy settings with more precision and confidence. These updates are likely to appeal to users who prioritize privacy, reinforcing Apple's commitment to protecting personal information in an increasingly connected world. Device Compatibility: Who Will Get iOS 26? As with every new iOS release, device compatibility is a key consideration. While Apple typically supports a wide range of devices, iOS 26 may phase out older models to focus on using the capabilities of newer hardware. Current rumors suggest: iPhone 12 and later models are expected to fully support iOS 26, making sure access to all new features and improvements. are expected to fully support iOS 26, making sure access to all new features and improvements. Older devices may lose compatibility, though official announcements will confirm the exact list of supported models. If you own a newer device, you're likely to benefit from the full range of features, while users of older models should stay informed about compatibility updates to plan accordingly. Beta Testing and Release Schedule Apple's beta testing program plays a crucial role in refining its operating systems, and iOS 26 is expected to follow a similar timeline to previous releases. The rollout is likely to include: Developer and public beta versions that will be available months before the official launch, allowing users to test new features and provide feedback. that will be available months before the official launch, allowing users to test new features and provide feedback. The final release, which is rumored to coincide with Apple's annual fall event, typically held alongside the unveiling of new iPhone models. For those eager to explore iOS 26 early, participating in the beta program could offer a valuable opportunity to experience its features ahead of the official release. Looking Ahead: What iOS 26 Could Deliver iOS 26 is shaping up to be a significant update, blending innovation with reliability to enhance the way users interact with their Apple devices. From refined design elements to robust privacy measures, the operating system promises to deliver meaningful improvements that cater to a wide range of user needs. While leaks and rumors provide an exciting preview, the full scope of changes will only be confirmed with Apple's official announcements. Stay tuned for updates as Apple unveils its vision for the future of iOS. Master iOS 26 with the help of our in-depth articles and helpful guides. Source & Image Credit: Brandon Butch Filed Under: Gadgets News Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
