French lawmakers divided over PM Bayrou child abuse hearing
As abuse claims shake France, PM Bayrou denies wrongdoing, but a divided parliament questions his integrity and future in office.
France's Prime Minister Francois Bayrou arrives for a hearing by a parliamentary enquiry commission on claims of widespread physical and sexual abuse at the Notre-Dame de Betharram school in southwestern France between the 1970s and 1990s, at The National Assembly, France's lower house parliament, in Paris on May 14, 2025. (Photo by ALAIN JOCARD / AFP)
French politicians were divided on Thursday over the marathon hearing of Prime Minister Francois Bayrou, who was grilled by lawmakers about claims of sexual abuse at a Catholic school.
Some deputies were outraged at the way Bayrou was questioned for five and a half hours on Wednesday, one of them comparing the hearing to a 'Stalinist' trial.
Others accused the 73-year-old premier of obfuscation.
Even the two co-rapporteurs of the inquiry were divided, with one claiming Bayrou had admitted to 'lying' and the other saying she believed him.
On Wednesday, Bayrou faced one of the most delicate moments of his five months in office when he sought to defend himself before a committee investigating widespread claims of abuse at a school in southwestern France.
During the tense hearing, Bayrou, who served as education minister between 1993 and 1997, struck a defiant tone and said he only knew of allegations of sexual abuse from media reports.
ALSO READ: Global markets rattled as Trump's tariff blitz sparks trade war
He accused the commission, and particularly one of the co-rapporteurs, a lawmaker with the left-wing France Unbowed party (LFI), of seeking to 'bring down' the government.
'Moscow trial'
'I tend to give credence to the prime minister's public words,' said far-right National Rally party vice-president Sebastien Chenu, adding that the hearing made him uncomfortable.
'For me it was more like a Moscow trial,' he told broadcaster TF1.
He particularly criticised the behaviour of the LFI co-rapporteur, Paul Vannier, regretting what he called an 'exploitation of a tragedy'.
Marc Fesneau, a Bayrou ally, was even more outspoken, describing 'this way of treating people as pretty disgusting'.
'It's Stalinism,' he told broadcaster Radio J.
ALSO READ: France mourns Mayotte victims amid uncertainy over government
But Boris Vallaud, the head of Socialist lawmakers, described the prime minister's tactics as 'smoke and mirrors'.
'At the end of this hearing, do the French people, the victims, feel that they have been enlightened about what happened?' Vallaud said.
'I don't think so.'
'Best defence is good offence'
Bayrou has faced opposition claims that he knew of widespread physical and sexual abuse over many decades at the Notre-Dame de Betharram school.
Several of Bayrou's children attended the school and his wife taught religious studies there.
Centrist Bayrou, the sixth prime minister of President Emmanuel Macron's mandate was named head of government in December and given the task of hauling France out of months of political crisis.
ALSO READ: Suspense mounts as Macron expected to name new French PM
He has managed to survive a no-confidence vote in a divided parliament but the Betharram affair has damaged his credibility and his approval rating has been declining.
Vannier, the LFI co-rappourter, said Thursday the prime minister had admitted having 'lied' in February when questioned in parliament for the first time.
He told broadcaster franceinfo the committee would carefully study Bayrou's latest statements, pointing to 'one important lesson — yes, Francois Bayrou lied to the National Assembly' in February.
Speaking to reporters later in the day, he said it was 'too early to say' if Bayrou had lied on Wednesday.
His co-rapporteur, centrist Violette Spillebout, disagreed, saying Bayrou had offered an 'extremely vigorous defence' following months of attacks by Vannier.
'And I believe him,' she said.
ALSO READ: Macron seeks to salvage power after France vote upset
They are expected to deliver their conclusion in June.
Analysts say the scandal could embolden the prime minister's enemies.
'Francois Bayrou's hearing on the Betharram affair turns into a political confrontation,' said French daily Le Monde.
Left-leaning Liberation said those who had expected to hear the truth would be disappointed.
'The prime minister made it clear from the outset: the best defence is a good offence,' the newspaper added.
The hard left ramped up their pressure on Bayrou.
ALSO READ: Cabinet countdown for Bayrou: Racing to build unity in France before Christmas
'Can we accept a prime minister who lies to MPs when they are exercising their constitutional prerogative of overseeing the government's action?', LFI national coordinator Manuel Bompard said on X.
'For us, the answer is no!'
– By: © Agence France-Presse
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
an hour ago
- eNCA
Shooter kills nine people at Austrian school
An attack on a school in southeastern Austria by a former student has left nine people dead, authorities said Tuesday, in a rare case of deadly gun violence in the Alpine country. Heavily armed police, a helicopter and paramedics descended upon the school in Graz, where 10 people including the alleged lone shooter were killed, regional police said. Six of the victims were female and three male, authorities later confirmed without specifying their ages. Twelve people suffered severe injuries. Police said the situation was "secure" and support was being provided to witnesses and those affected. The suspect acted alone and took his own life in the school toilet, police said, adding his motive remained unknown. Later on Tuesday, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker declared three days of national mourning to remember the victims, saying the country had witnessed "an act of unimaginable violence". According to the police, the alleged perpetrator is a 21-year-old Austrian from the wider Graz region. The perpetrator used two weapons he had owned legally to carry out the attack. The suspected shooter was a former student at the school, but had not finished his studies, Interior Minister Gerhard Karnert told reporters. "It's a disaster, simply terrible. After all, it's about children," Hasan Darsel, a restaurant owner in the area, told the newspaper Kronen Zeitung. - 'Deeply shocked' - After arriving in Graz, Stocker described the shooting as "a national tragedy", adding that it was "a dark day" for Austria. AFP | Alex HALADA Condolences poured in from across Europe. The European Union's top diplomat Kaja Kallas said she was "deeply shocked" when she heard about the shooting. "Every child should feel safe at school and be able to learn free from fear and violence," Kallas posted on X. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said "our thoughts are with our Austrian friends and neighbours and we mourn with them" after the school shooting he called "horrific". Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban offered his "deepest condolences to Chancellor @_CStocker and the people of Austria" via social media. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said "the news from Graz touches my heart" while Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni expressed her sympathies to the families of the victims following the "tragic news". Attacks in public are rare in Austria, which is home to almost 9.2 million people and ranks among the 10 safest countries in the world, according to the Global Peace Index. School shootings are also much more uncommon in Europe than in the United States but in recent years Europe has been shaken by attacks at schools and universities, that were not connected to terrorism. In France on Tuesday, a teaching assistant was killed at a school in Nogent in the east following a knife attack. In January 2025, an 18-year-old man fatally stabbed a high school student and a teacher at a school in northeastern Slovakia. In December 2024, a 19-year-old man stabbed a seven-year-old student to death and injured several others at a primary school in Zagreb, Croatia. In December 2023, an attack by a student at a university in central Prague left 14 people dead and 25 injured. A few months earlier that year, a 13-year-old gunned down nine fellow classmates and a security guard at an elementary school in downtown Belgrade. By Julia Zappei With Kiyoko Metzler In Vienna
eNCA
4 hours ago
- eNCA
Ukraine says Russian strikes hit Kyiv, Odesa, killing three
KYIV - Russia launched fresh drone and missile attacks on the Ukrainian capital, Kyiv, and port city of Odesa early on Tuesday, killing three people and hitting a maternity hospital, Ukrainian officials said. Moscow has escalated its bombardments of Ukraine and Kyiv has retaliated with strikes deep inside Russian territory. Talks in Turkey last week failed to yield a breakthrough towards ending the three-year war. Aside from an agreement to exchange prisoners, progress has stalled and Russia has repeatedly rejected calls for an unconditional ceasefire. After the overnight barrage of more than 300 drones and seven missiles, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky urged Kyiv's Western allies to respond with "concrete action". "Action from America, which has the power to force Russia into peace. Action from Europe, which has no alternative but to be strong," Zelensky wrote in a post on social media. He added that two of the missiles fired in the latest wave attacks were made in North Korea. AFP | Ihor SHVYDCHENKO Russia's defence ministry said it had targeted "Ukrainian aviation, missile, armoured vehicle and ship-building facilities in Kyiv" with a "group strike". "The goal of the strikes was achieved. All designated objects were hit," the ministry said. But residential and hospital buildings were struck in Odesa, where two people were killed and at least nine others were wounded, Governor Oleg Kiper said. "The enemy massively attacked Odesa with strike drones," Kiper wrote on Telegram. "The Russians hit a maternity hospital, an emergency medical ward and residential buildings," he said, adding that the maternity hospital had been evacuated in time. - Prisoner swap - In central Kyiv, an AFP journalist heard at least a dozen explosions, anti-aircraft fire and the buzzing of drones. City officials said one woman was killed and four people were wounded. The mayor said strikes hit at least seven districts, setting buildings and cars on fire. Russia's 2022 invasion of its neighbour triggered the biggest European conflict since World War II, forcing millions to flee their homes and decimating much of eastern and southern Ukraine. Ukrainian cities are targeted by Russian air strikes almost daily. AFP | Tetiana DZHAFAROVA Russia launched a record 479 explosive drones at Ukraine overnight into Monday morning, the Ukrainian Air Force said. Kyiv has responded with attacks on Russian territory, targeting transport and weapons production infrastructure. Russia's transport agency Rosaviatsia said on Tuesday that flight operations had been temporarily restricted at more than a dozen Russian airports -- standard procedure during Ukrainian drone attacks. In the city of Belgorod near the border with Ukraine, Russian emergency services said one person was killed in a Ukrainian drone attack on a petrol station. Russia's defence ministry said it had intercepted 102 Ukrainian drones overnight. Despite pressure from US President Donald Trump to reach a ceasefire agreement, peace talks are at a standstill. The only concrete agreement reached at talks in Istanbul last week was a large-scale prisoner exchange and the repatriation of dead soldiers' bodies. - Demands - Russia and Ukraine swapped a first group of captured soldiers on Monday and Zelensky announced the exchange would "continue in several stages over the coming days". The deal should see the freeing of all captured soldiers under the age of 25, as well as those who are sick or severely wounded. But Zelensky said last week it was "pointless" to hold further talks with the current Russian delegation -- who he previously dismissed as "empty heads" -- since they could not agree to a ceasefire. Russian forces meanwhile are making steady advances across the front line. Over the weekend Moscow said it had pushed its offensive into the Dnipropetrovsk region for the first time, marking a significant territorial escalation. "Time for everyone to finally accept the fact that Russia understands only strikes, not rational words," Zelensky's top aide, Andriy Yermak, said on Tuesday, in a thinly veiled criticism of the Trump administration. AFP | Tetiana DZHAFAROVA It has also rejected a proposed 30-day unconditional ceasefire sought by Kyiv and the European Union, arguing that this would allow Ukrainian forces to rearm with Western deliveries. Ukraine is demanding a complete Russian withdrawal of from its territory and security guarantees from the West. bur-mmp/jbr/gil
eNCA
4 hours ago
- eNCA
Pupil stabs to death assistant at French school
PARIS - French President Emmanuel Macron on Tuesday condemned a "senseless wave of violence" after a teaching assistant stabbed by a 15-year-old pupil outside a school in the east of the country died of her wounds. The secondary school student was arrested after attacking the 31-year-old assistant with a knife during a bag search in Nogent in eastern France, officials said. France has in recent years seen a series of attacks on teachers and pupils by other schoolchildren. "While protecting our children, a teaching assistant lost her life, the victim of a senseless wave of violence," Macron wrote on X, commenting on the latest in a spate of such incidents at French schools. "The nation is in mourning and the government is mobilised to reduce crime," he added. Education Minister Elisabeth Borne was on her way to Nogent "to support the entire school community and the police." "I commend the composure and dedication of those who acted to subdue the attacker and protect the students and staff," she said on X. The pupil is 15 years old and did not have a criminal record. The teaching assistant received several knife wounds just as classes were starting, and the alleged attacker, who was overpowered by gendarmes, "appears to be a student at the school," education officials said. - 'Have had enough' - In March, French police started random searches for knives and other weapons concealed in bags at and around schools. The teaching assistant was "simply doing her job by welcoming students at the entrance to the school", said Elisabeth Allain-Moreno, secretary general of the SE-UNSA teachers' union, expressing "immense pain". Allain-Moreno said that the attack "shows that nothing can ever be completely secure and that it is prevention that needs to be focused on." Jean-Remi Girard, president of the National Union of Secondary Schools, added: "It's impossible to be more vigilant 24 hours a day. "We can't say that every student is a danger or a threat, otherwise we'd never get out of bed in the morning." French far-right leader Marine Le Pen denounced what she called the "normalisation of extreme violence, encouraged by the apathy of the authorities." "Not a week goes by without a tragedy striking a school," Le Pen said on X. "The French people have had enough and are waiting for a firm, uncompromising and determined political response to the scourge of juvenile violence." At the end of April, after a fatal attack at a school in Nantes, the education ministry reported that 958 random bag checks in schools had led to the seizure of 94 knives. After that knife attack, which left one person dead and three injured, Prime Minister Francois Bayrou called for "more intensive checks around and inside schools".
