Dutch museum removes 'priceless' Benin Bronzes for return to Nigeria
The artefact is a "Benin Bronze", a priceless cultural object looted from modern-day Nigeria more than 120 years ago, now being removed from display and returned to its rightful home.
The Wereldmuseum (World Museum) in Leiden is restoring 113 of the ancient sculptures, the latest single return, as pressure mounts on Western governments and institutions to hand back the spoils of colonial oppression.
"These don't belong here. They were violently taken, so they need to go back," museum director Marieke van Bommel told AFP in an interview.
"This is a typical example of looted art," added the 50-year-old.
The story of the Benin Bronzes is one of violence and tragedy. It began when nine British officers were killed on a trade mission to the then independent kingdom of Benin, in the south of present-day Nigeria.
The British reaction was fierce. London deployed a military expedition to avenge its officers. The troops killed several thousand locals and torched Benin's capital city.
They looted the royal palace, stealing hundreds of artworks, including the Benin Bronzes.
Most of the ornate bronzes were then sold to finance the expedition, auctioned off or sold to museums across Europe and the United States.
This was in 1897 and 128 years later, Nigeria is still negotiating the bronzes' return around the world -- with mixed results.
The Netherlands has agreed to return 119 bronzes in total -- six more are coming from Rotterdam -- and Germany has also begun handing back its loot.
However, the British Museum in London has refused to return any of its famed collection.
A law passed in 1963 technically prevents the museum from giving back the treasures.
'Follow this example'
Museum director Van Bommel hopes the Dutch example will be picked up around the world.
"I think we all agree that this collection doesn't belong in European museums. We do hope that other countries will follow this example," she said.
The collection is priceless, said Van Bommel. "It's a cultural value, so we never put a price on it."
The museum in Leiden has also restored hundreds of pieces of colonial loot to Indonesia, a former Dutch colony, Mexico and a community in the United States.
Van Bommel said they had struck a deal to keep four of the bronzes on loan, so visitors can continue to learn their story.
"We want to talk about the expedition, but also about the whole subject of restitution," she said.
In the meantime, the museum will replace their collection with a display of contemporary art.
As for the bronzes, they will be shipped to Lagos in mid-June.
Former Nigerian president Muhammadu Buhari declared in 2023 that the returned works would be given to the Oba -- the traditional ruler -- and not to the Nigerian state.
There are plans to build a museum in Benin City in southern Edo state, where the bronzes will have pride of place.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
a day ago
- France 24
Devastation of war leaves Gazans unable to celebrate Eid
"Dad would buy us a sheep, but now we are alone," the 11-year-old said. Before the war, he said, "I loved Eid so much, I was excited for it each year, to be able to celebrate and wear new clothes," he said of the Eid tradition, looking weary in his patched-up shoes. Every day, the boy returns to the ashes and charred tarp, which are all that's left of the tent in which he once sheltered with his family. Dib said he wanted to remember his parents, who were killed in an Israeli air strike. This year, rather than celebrating, he is preoccupied simply with the thought of how he and his four sisters will find anything at all to eat. Not one order According to Muslim tradition, Eid al-Adha commemorates the sacrifice Ibrahim (known to Christians and Jews as Abraham) was about to make by killing his son, before the angel Gabriel intervened and offered him a sheep to sacrifice instead. In a normal year, Gazans would now be preparing for big family get-togethers, traditionally centred around the sacrifice and eating of a sheep. Markets would be busy with people shopping for sweets and pastries, while toy shops and those selling children's clothes would stay open late into the night for last-minute gifts. Even poverty and the years-long Israeli blockade of the Palestinian territory could not get in the way of the festivities. Yet 20 months of war between Israel and Hamas, sparked by the militant group's October 2023 attack, have brought an end to all that. With entire neighbourhoods levelled, almost all of the population displaced, often multiple times, and severe shortages brought on by a two-month blockade on aid, there is little possibility of celebration. "This time of year, I might receive up to 300 orders, including for calves and sheep, but this year I haven't had a single one," said Ahmed al-Zayigh, a butcher in Gaza City. Mohammed Othman, a 36-year-old displaced with his family to Deir el-Balah, said "One kilo of meat has become a dream... we just hope to find bread to feed our children on the day of Eid, and they will rejoice over flour as if it were meat". Many Gazans said they longed for a time when it was possible, as prescribed in the Koran, to share part of their meat with the less fortunate. 'It tastes of blood' "Tomorrow we will go to the Eid prayer," said Hamza Sobeh, 37, living in the Al-Mawasi displacement camp in southern Gaza. Sobeh was observing the fast ritual, which is believed to erase sins on the eve of the festival, and reciting takbirs -- prayers glorifying God -- with his children. "I want them to feel the joy of Eid, at least in a religious sense, so that they don't lose hope," he said, adding that he was considering buying them some date-filled pastries. However, the majority of people interviewed by AFP journalists said they would not be able to recreate even a sliver of the usual celebrations, and not just because it was unaffordable. "These are the hardest years we've lived in Gaza," he said.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Albania town where everything's coming up roses
"Here everything revolves around roses, from cooking with them to their medicinal virtues" -- everything is seen through rose-tinted glasses, joked biology teacher Ariana Nikolla. Since she was little, the 57-year-old has been delicately picking the petals of her favourite variety, "the Groom's Rose", named for its delicate scent. In Permet roses are a ritual -- the first gift to a would-be lover. And they have to be pink, symbolising love and fidelity. Every family cultivates dozens of rose varieties in their garden, including the highly perfumed Damask and Provence roses, making the town famous across the Balkans for its artisanal rose water. Yet it is almost impossible to buy -- it is just too valuable, say locals, who gift a few drops from time to time and jealously guard their reserves. 'Rose water is like love' "Rose water is like love, it must be carefully tended," said veteran maker Resmie Tuci. "The process of making high-quality rose water is difficult and meticulous. It requires very particular copper containers and you also have to use the right roses and select the ones with the most fragrant petals," said the 70-year-old. The traditional method, passed from one generation to the next, is listed in Albania's national inventory of intangible cultural heritage. First you stretch a cloth over a copper bowl laced with thread, itself placed inside a large, flat-bottomed basin filled with water. Then the hand-picked rose petals are carefully placed on the cloth and covered with a flat stone topped with hot ashes from a fire. The petals sweat underneath and yield up their precious rose water through condensation. "It's a process that takes hours," Tuci told AFP. "But every drop is precious," chimes in Nikolla, filling a small bottle with rose water, which she will put in a sunny spot for several weeks before it is ready. "It's as precious as gold," she added. - Sweet delights - Locals use it for its supposed benefits, from soothing irritated eyes to an anti-inflammatory cream to help calm itching. And, of course, in cooking. Eftali Qerimi, 63, swears by it. The almond rose water cakes she bakes in her workshop are unlike any other local "llokums". Made with only almond powder, sugar and rosewater, the rose-shaped fancies mark important events for families in the region. Considered lucky charms, they are served at birthdays, weddings and baby showers. With the women in her workshop, Qerimi produces up to 10 kilos of Turkish delights a day, which she sells at 50 euros a kilo. Occasionally she makes small ones shaped like baby feet -- a way, according to tradition, to wish newborns a long life. Between batches, the women make rose petal jam, its fragrance filling the workshop. "The rose is everything for us; it symbolises the heart, love and life's happiness," said Qerimi, who is hard at work with the tourism high season about to begin. "Tourists flock to the town and after the natural beauties" of the valley, with its famous gorges and natural park, "they also want to taste its culinary delights", she smiled.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Cuban students call boycott over mobile tariff hikes
Cubans say the tariff hikes implemented by state telecoms company Etecsa on May 30 will leave them with only a few gigabytes of data per month as purchasing additional data will be prohibitively expensive. Students have been particularly angered by the new pricing system, under which top-ups must be paid in hard-to-come-by-dollars or at a steep increment in Cuban pesos. While acknowledging "progress" in negotiations with Etecsa, student union president Jose Almedia told AFP: "We want more." On Tuesday evening, student leaders at the University of Havana's mathematics and informatics faculty called for a boycott of classes in order to try to force Etecsa to annul the tariff hikes. Fellow leaders of the union chapter in the philosophy, history and sociology faculty backed the boycott, as did some students from the arts department. It was not immediately clear how many students heeded the call for the protest. But an arts student who attended classes on Wednesday told AFP there were "practically no students" in the faculty. Eye-watering top-up costs Etecsa gave no forewarning of its new pricing structure, which it said was necessary to fund investment in infrastructure. Rafael Gomez, an 18-year-old student at the University of Havana, said the new tariffs left mobile users with the bare minimum in terms of data. "We were used to a certain system," where customers can top up their credit as often as they like, he told AFP. Now, they are limited to 6GB of data, which Gomez noted "is nothing and if you want to buy more, it costs over 3,000 pesos ($25), which you cannot afford on a regular Cuban salary," Gomez said. The average monthly salary on the communist island is 5,700 pesos, or $47. Faced with the outcry from students, President Miguel Diaz-Canel said Sunday that the government was looking at "options" for "the most vulnerable sectors, including our dear students." After talks with student bodies Etecsa on Monday announced that students would be allowed two monthly top-ups at 360 pesos ($3), compared with one for the rest of the population. Further top-ups have to be paid in dollars or at the eye-watering price of over 3,000 pesos. The concessions failed to assuage the anger of many students. Brian Gamez, a history student, told AFP he favored "peaceful protests" but was afraid that a mobilization could lead to vandalism. The Cuban government has been wary of stoking popular discontent since July 2021 when thousands of people took to the streets in a rare show of defiance to demonstrate over shortages of fuel, food, medicine and electricity.
