Senedd debates Labour's record as election looms
SENEDD Members debated the Labour Welsh Government's record over the past four years, with the next election looming in 12 months.
Rhun ap Iorwerth accused Labour of failing to stand up for Wales and live up to promises made at the start of this Senedd term.
The Plaid Cymru leader told the Senedd: 'Everywhere you look – whether it's the NHS, our economy, schools or society more broadly – the situation is worse now.'
The would-be First Minister pointed to long NHS waiting lists, a 'stagnant' economy, child poverty rates and 'deteriorating' education standards.
But others accused Plaid Cymru of 'gesture politics' after 'propping up' the Labour Welsh Government for most of the past four years.
Leading the debate on a Plaid Cymru motion on May 7, exactly one year before the next election, Mr ap Iorwerth directed his ire at the 'disgraceful' legacy left by the Tories.
He said: 'It's no wonder they suffered a slaughter electorally in Wales last summer and the opinion polls for the Senedd election suggest they are increasingly irrelevant.
'But the excuses are far harder to bear now the Labour Party is in government in Westminster, something that was pledged time and time again by Labour members for years prior to the election would lead to change for the better.'
The former broadcast journalist criticised UK Government decisions to slash the welfare budget and restrict winter fuel allowance – 'cuts even George Osborne would wince about'.
Mr ap Iorwerth accused the Welsh Government of spending all its energy over the past year managing 'internal chaos', including three First Ministers and 'reshuffles galore'.
Paul Davies argued Plaid Cymru should be held accountable for the Welsh Government's record due to the now-collapsed cooperation agreement between the two.
Conservative MS Paul Davies
The Conservative said: 'Plaid Cymru has been instrumental in propping up the Welsh Government and voting through its policies… they've done it on and off for years.'
The deputy leader of the opposition added: 'Plaid should be embarrassed they're calling for more powers. They haven't been able to help Labour use the powers they currently have.'
Mr Davies warned Wales has 'languished' at the bottom of league tables for years whether it's NHS performance, educational standards or economic activity.
He accused Welsh ministers of 'doing nothing' in response to UK Government changes to inheritance tax for family farms and winter fuel allowance.
Jane Dodds, Welsh Liberal Democrat leader and the party's sole Senedd Member, also pointed out that Plaid Cymru had a seat at the table as part of the three-year budget deal.
Jane Dodds MS, leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats
She said: 'You've helped to steer the ship and you don't get to act surprised about the destination when you have actually been holding the map.'
Ms Dodds, who struck a £100m deal with ministers to pass the latest Welsh budget, urged Plaid Cymru to take ownership of achievements such as free school meals.
The former social worker criticised the Conservatives' 'shameful' amendment for failing to acknowledge the party's part in causing child poverty.
'Spare us the crocodile tears, please,' she said. 'To claim that a Conservative Welsh Government would do better for our communities is, frankly, insulting.'
Labour's Julie James said the party has been forced to govern in the context of 'deep austerity, mismanagement and short-termism' from a Conservative UK Government.
Julie James MS, counsel general and minister for delivery
The minister told the Senedd that the Welsh Government has 'stood unwavering' despite 14 years of the worst financial climate in the history of devolution.
Ms James raised examples including free prescriptions, universal free school meals in primaries and the education maintenance allowance for disadvantaged young people.
She pointed to 'tangible progress' on health, with waiting lists falling three months in a row.
Criticising 'posturing, gesture politics' from Plaid Cymru, Ms James said: 'Wales deserves fair funding and this Labour government, led by Eluned Morgan, will keep demanding it until we get a settlement that reflects our needs and respects our nation.'
Senedd Members voted 35-11 against the Plaid Cymru motion. Conservative and Labour amendments also fell. With the final vote deadlocked at 23-23, deputy speaker Dai Rees used his casting vote against the Welsh Government's amendment in line with convention.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
14 minutes ago
- STV News
Voters urged to ‘call time on SNP failure' as by-election looms
Voters in Lanarkshire have been urged to 'call time on SNP failure' as a Holyrood by-election campaign enters its final days. Voters will go to the polls in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election on Thursday with the SNP, Labour and Reform hoping to win the seat vacated by former government minister Christina McKelvie. The SNP and Labour were initially seen as the frontrunners but a surge by Nigel Farage's party has made a second place finish seem possible, though leaders have publicly said they believe they can win. As the final week of campaigning begins, Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie urged voters in the seat to 'chart a new direction for the whole of Scotland'. 'After almost two decades in charge, the SNP has left public services at breaking point – almost one in six Scots are on an NHS waiting list, violence is rife in our schools, and high streets across Scotland are struggling,' she said. 'We cannot risk a third decade of SNP government and only Scottish Labour can beat them. 'Ignore the desperate spin of Reform and the SNP – this by-election is a direct fight between Scottish Labour and the SNP. 'We have three days to put this failing SNP government on notice and start the journey towards a better future for Scotland.' Baillie added that the Labour Government had spent its first year in office 'working to clean up the mess left behind by 14 years of Tory chaos'. But Scots are 'still not feeling the benefit of these changes' because of the Scottish Government. 'SNP inaction means we still have sky-high NHS waiting lists, a low-pay, low-growth economy, and a devastating housing emergency,' she said. 'It's time for John Swinney and the SNP to take responsibility for their failures and admit that the blame for Scotland's biggest challenges lies squarely at the door of Bute House.' An SNP spokesperson said: 'The SNP is taking action on what matters to people – creating 100,000 additional GP appointments, 150,000 extra NHS appointments and procedures, scrapping peak rail fares, investing £186.5 million to increase teacher numbers and keeping key costs like water bills lower. 'That's what it means to put Scotland first. We recognise that times are still too tough for too many, and we are doing something about it. 'Meanwhile, Labour are letting down Scots – taking away the winter fuel payment from 900,000 Scottish pensioners, cutting £5 billion of support for disabled people and presiding over a £150 increase in energy bills. 'That's the reality of Labour in power – broken promises and Scotland treated as an afterthought – and even they know they've lost with a candidate who is running scared of hustings and debates. 'This contest is a straightforward fight between the SNP and Nigel Farage's Reform UK, and the only way to stop Farage on June 5 is by voting for Katy Loudon.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Daily Mirror
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Keir Starmer to put UK on war footing amid 'new threats' in 'dangerous world'
Keir Starmer will this morning announce a huge expansion of the UK's submarine fleet as he warns the country needs to be on a war footing. A long-awaited strategic defence review will be published today, with the Government commiting to build 12 new nuclear-powered attack submarines and invest £15billion in its warhead programme. Defence minister Luke Pollard told BBC Breakfast the world is now "more dangerous" and ominously stated: "We're certainly not at war at the moment, but it's also true that we're certainly not at peace." Mr Starmer will give a speech in Scotland at around 10am to outline the plans, which will be released this afternoon. Defence Secretary John Healey said last night that Britain "must act decisively to face down Russian aggression". Defence minister Luke Pollard has said the UK is "certainly not at war at the moment, but it's also true that we're certainly not at peace". He said action was needed to prevent conflict, telling BBC Breakfast: I think all your viewers will have seen the appalling scenes from Ukraine over recent years. They'll be aware that the world is more dangerous. They'll be aware that to secure our freedom and our economic prosperity, we have to invest in our national security. "It's the first duty of any government to keep our country safe, but it's also the first mission of this Labour Government to grow our economy by investing in defence. We're creating jobs in every single part of United Kingdom." He went on: "I don't want us to go to war. I want us to deter aggression. That is precisely what the defence review sets out to do today." In response to the Strategic Defence Review, the Government's commitments will include: Getting the armed forces to a stage where it would be ready to fight a war Boosting weapons and equipment stockpiles and making sure there is capacity to scale up production if needed in a crisis or war £1.5billion to set up at least six munitions factories Buying up to 7,000 UK-built long-range weapons in a move due to support 800 defence jobs Setting up a new cyber command and investing £1billion in digital capabilities More than £1.5billion of additional funding to repair and renew armed forces housing Boosting recruitment for Britain's armed forces - with the number of cadets increasing by 30% A minister has again refused to guarantee that the Government will spend 3% of the UK's economic output on defence in the next Parliament. Labour frontbencher Luke Pollard said the commitment would be dependent on the state of the ecomomy. It comes after Defence Secretary John Healey yesterday could not confirm that the Treasury would fund the plan to bring spending up to 3% of GDP by 2034. Asked on Monday morning whether the 3% commitment remained a guarantee, defence minister Luke Pollard told Times Radio: "Well, we've set out that we are spending 2.5% by April 2027, with the ambition to spend 3% in the next parliament, when economic conditions allow." Pressed about the commitment, Mr Pollard added: "Well I've got no doubt that we will get to 3% in the next parliament, as I've said a number of times." The defence minister said the strategic defence review, a wide-ranging investigation into the UK's defence being published on Monday, is the "biggest transformation of our armed forces in 100 years".He said: "It seeks to learn the lessons from the war in Ukraine, refresh our capabilities, invest in our people, and underscore that increased defence spending up to 2.5% of our GDP by April 2027 is an engine for growth." Keir Starmer will today announce major plans to almost double the UK's nuclear-powered submarine fleet. The Prime Minister will set out the building of 12 new attack submarines as part of the AUKUS programme, a security partnership between Australia, the UK and the US. He will also announce a major £15billion investment in the UK's nuclear warhead programme. The PM will make the announcements as he unveils the Government's new Strategic Defence Review (SDR). The externally-led review is expected to recommend the Armed Forces move to warfighting readiness to deter the growing threats faced by the UK. The UK currently has five Astute class attack submarines, which are on track to become a fleet of seven warships in the near future. These will be replaced one by one with the new SSN-AUKUS attack submarines from the late 2030s. A further five new submarines will take the total to 12. A major expansion of the industrial capabilities at Barrow and Raynesway, Derby, will see a new submarine built every 18 months in the future. These will all be built by the UK and operated by the Royal Navy. Click here for the full story
The Herald Scotland
26 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Virtue signalling from Bearsden Bolsheviks won't beat curse of racism
Calling everyone scum and horrible people might evoke cheers and feet-stamping from the Bearsden Bolsheviks, but it merely deflects our gaze from how complicit the political elites of Scotland and the UK have been in driving working-class people into the arms of Reform. 'All parties in Scotland and the UK have massively let down working class people,' Mr Kerr tells a full-house of 250. 'You see it every day when you walk the streets of this city and see the state it's in. You see it in my constituency where people can't get houses and in the state of the houses of the people who can.' The event was aimed at tackling the rise of right wing politics (Image: Gordon Terris)He cites the scourge of private landlordism 'who are taking the absolute piss out of our economy. And not only wrecking our economy but soaking up investment capital and wrecking lives in the process. That's the root. That economic need and neglect has always been fertile ground for the far right. 'But I'm not going to say that everyone who votes for Reform is a fascist. There's a vacuum which Reform fill.' He reminds us of how many working-class people recently voted for Reform in Clydebank and Easterhouse. 'We have a job to go into these communities and fill that gap which Reform are seeking to fill.' He dismantles First Minister John Swinney's fatuous £10k summit which recently brought together the troughers and frauds of the Scottish civic elite under the pretence of opposing extremism. 'That was manna from heaven for Reform,' Said Mr Kerr. 'It was entirely the wrong tactic. That looked like the Scottish establishment all sitting down together: it was a gift to Reform.' As the others vied with each other to express horror at the prospect of Reform rising, this Glasgow councillor was telling them what voters in Larkhall were telling me the previous day: they're sick of being gas-lit by a class of superannuated professionals telling them how to behave; how to speak; how to eat; how to raise their children and then cancelling them if they fail to comply. Even so, it's good to be here at the Boardwalk events venue in Brunswick Street in the heart of Glasgow's Merchant City. The previous day, I'd walked a while with Reform's candidate in the Hamilton, Stonehouse and Larkhall by-election. I'd needed to understand why many of Scotland's everyday working people feel drawn to Nigel Farage and a party which preys on their fears and their exasperation and channels them towards something ugly. Read more But I also needed to be confirmed in my own core beliefs that the scourge of racism erodes this country's health and averts our gaze from that which causes most damage to our society and those who profit from it. Among them the predations of unfettered capitalism; the low wages; the tax avoidance of our largest corporations; the health inequality and the instincts of a Labour Government to build a multi-billion-pound war economy intended to soften us to the inevitability of war with Russia. We needed to be reminded that Scotland's legal and political establishment, lobbied by the Scottish Police Federation, have spent years and a lot of money seeking to undermine the public inquiry into the death of Sheku Bayoh, who died in police custody in Kirkcaldy ten years ago. And how this has been accompanied by a campaign to defame him and destroy his family. Aamer Anwer, his family's lawyer, claimed they had 'treated his colour as a weapon'. We all needed to be reminded about the Park Inn Incident on June 26, 2020 in Glasgow. This was the mass stabbing by asylum-seeker Bahreddin Adam which left six people wounded. He was eventually killed by police, the first time they'd shot and killed anyone since 1969 in Scotland. Bahreddin Adam had made 72 calls to various social services before he snapped. This was in the midst of the Covid pandemic where asylum seekers were detained in hotels, isolated, neglected and treated like caged animals by a liberal political administration who talk big about racism but which pay a suite of private facilities companies millions to take these poor people off their hands. At conferences such as these there are always workshops and the trick is to separate the genuinely interesting ones from those organised by groups which seek to hitch their own questionable agendas to something virtuous: in this case the good fight against racism. On Saturday, I dropped into one featuring a documentary called 72 Calls: The Park Inn Incident, in which survivors of the attack spoke with compassion about Bahreddin Adam and the mental despair that they and he had endured while being moved around like livestock. It also exposed Britain's inhumane asylum system whose main purpose seems to be to dehumanise and degrade other human beings so much that it will send a message to other poor souls. The conference featured debates and workshops (Image: Gordon Terris) These people are expected to live on a daily allowance of £9 which hasn't risen in 25 years. Their often-remote locations seemed designed to deter connecting with local communities and the prospect of being ordered to move location at a few minutes' notice disrupts children's education. Far Right groups target communities where asylum hostels are known to exist to spread lies and disinformation about their luxury conditions. And when a Labour Prime Minister makes speeches about Britain being an "island of strangers" they're emboldened. This event is happening in the middle of a district which bears the names of the countries and communities that Britain ransacked and then sold into slavery. Our continuing wars of adventure throughout the last two centuries have literally caused the geopolitical upheaval that brings many of these people to our shores. I'd welcome them all and call it restorative justice. Someone has to pay for what we did to their countries. And if we're that generation then so be it. I heard, Sabir Zazai, Chief Executive of the Scottish Refugee Council, speak much more softly and authentically about how to combat racism than most of the sloganeers waving their fists for likes in the opening session. Mr Zazai cited the race riots in Southport and north England as what can happen when you dehumanise an entire race on their colour country of origin. 'Women wearing scarves are now feeling unsafe,' said Mr Zazai. 'They ask us the dreaded question: 'is it safe for us to go out' or 'will my accommodation be attacked'. This is new.' Read more Refugees and migrants ran small businesses and added to Scotland's arts and culture with their food and music, he reminded us. 'We need to fight back with love and compassion. Let's get to know each other better. Offering people sanctuary and protection can be unifying and uplifting for a community. Treat them as fellow human beings. Tell them that Scotland is as much their home as ours.' Earlier, Matt Kerr rebuked his own party leader for his Enoch Powell rhetoric. 'I'll tell you something,' he said. 'We need to refuse to be strangers by talking to the person next to you and holding their hand. You pick them up when they need it. That's life. That's the antidote to all of this. That's where it begins. You start in your community. You have the conversations with your family, with your friends and it'll be difficult but have courage and stand together.' It's just that, in the hands of a political and trade union class who have dehumanised working-class feminists and who are mocking once more the practice of Christianity, the anti-racism message rings hollow. The Stand up to Racism campaign has never been more important, but some of its loudest and entitled messengers are its worst ambassadors. Kevin McKenna is a Herald writer and columnist and is Scottish Feature Writer of the Year. This year is his 40th in newspapers. Among his paltry list of professional achievements is that he's never been approached by any political party or lobbying firm to be on their payroll.
