‘Disgraceful' to suggest police wipe records of trans criminals
Angela Constance admitted the force had made an 'error' after a newspaper report claimed a transgender killer had their record 'scrubbed'.
The minister said she had asked Police Scotland to review its procedures in light of the incident.
Ms Constance said she had been assured by the force it was an isolated incident and not part of a wider issue within the justice system.
But a spokesman for Police Scotland said it would be 'inaccurate' to suggest the records in question had been 'wiped'.
Police Scotland will review its procedures following the error (Andrew Milligan/PA)
According to the Daily Record, a solicitor had requested a previous convictions disclosure from the Crown Office on prosecution witnesses in a case involving a conflict at HMP Greenock.
The newspaper reports killer Alex Stewart – who changed their name from Alan Baker – was separated from their criminal past, with the disclosure returning without any convictions under Stewart's new name.
At Holyrood on Tuesday, Conservative MSP Meghan Gallacher asked Ms Constance how many transgender prisoners have had their criminal records erased following changes to their birth name.
The Justice Secretary said: 'Let me be clear, a change of name does not under any circumstances alter a person's criminal record.
'All criminal records are maintained in accordance with established retention and sharing protocols and remain fully accessible to the justice system, including for disclosure in court proceedings where appropriate.
I will be asking a topical question later today on transgender prisoners having their criminal records wiped, as a result of changing their names.
Here are some thoughts below 👇🏻 pic.twitter.com/ASXHY4mG8B
— Meghan Gallacher MSP (@MGallacherMSP) June 17, 2025
'Police Scotland has acknowledged an error in one case reported in the media and acknowledges that should not have occurred.
'I have sought and received assurances from Police Scotland that this was an isolated incident and not reflective of broader issues in their recording practices.
'I have also asked Police Scotland to ensure that steps will be taken to review systems and procedures in light of the reported.'
She said it was an error 'in one case' around disclosure, not data recording systems. She said Stewart's crimes were still recorded in the killer's criminal history.
A spokesperson for Police Scotland said: 'We are aware of an issue relating to the previous convictions of a victim, which were omitted from a report submitted ahead of a case heard at Greenock Sheriff Court.
'The issue has been rectified and work is ongoing to prevent similar scenarios taking place in the future. Officers are continuing to liaise with the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS).'
They added: 'The criminal records referred to in this case have not been wiped – they remain in place.
'It would be inaccurate to suggest otherwise.'
Ms Constance insisted there could be 'no separation' between an individual and their criminal past, no matter how many name changes or changes to gender identity are made.
Ms Gallacher said the error should never have happened and raised concerns the records of killers and sex offenders could be erased.
Alba MSP Ash Regan claimed she had evidence that Stewart's case was not a 'mere administrative error' but was part of 'systemic data corruption' driven by 'years of unlawful self-ID policy'.
Ms Regan did not say what evidence she held.
Tory MSP Sharon Dowey described the situation as a 'shambles'.
She added: 'We know that dangerous male offenders have gamed the SNP system to serve their sentences in women's prisons, and now they are even getting their criminal records wiped.'
The Justice Secretary rejected Ms Dowey's claims, saying: 'It is utterly inaccurate and misleading and somewhat disingenuous, if not disgraceful, to suggest that Police Scotland wipe criminal records.
'Under no circumstances do Police Scotland wipe criminal records, and under no circumstances can anyone, irrespective of their name, status, whether they are male, female, transgender, can they escape from a criminal past – they cannot.'
A spokesperson for COPFS said: 'The previous conviction record for this witness was shared quickly once the error was identified and there was no risk to the public or impact on the criminal proceedings.
'We will support Police Scotland's review of their systems and consider if additional guidance for our staff is required.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
13 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Kneecap ‘plasters' London with message of support for group member due in court
Liam Og O hAnnaidh, who performs under the stage name Mo Chara, is accused of displaying a flag in support of Hezbollah at a gig in November last year. The 27-year-old is due to appear at Westminster Magistrates' Court on Wednesday following the alleged incident during a gig at the O2 Forum in Kentish Town, north London. The charge Og O hAnnaidh faces alleges he displayed a flag in a public place, 'in such a way or in such circumstances as to arouse reasonable suspicion that he is a supporter of a proscribed organisation' – namely Hezbollah. Kneecap described the prosecution as a 'witch hunt' in a post on X on Tuesday evening. The post including a short video which appeared to show a billboard that had been displayed in London with the words 'more blacks, more dogs, more Irish, Mo Chara'. The Metropolitan Police said the force had charged O hAnnaidh, who appears on the court list as Liam O'Hanna, after initially being made aware of a video from the gig at the O2 Forum which had been posted online. In a separate event shortly after the terrorism charge, O hAnnaidh could be seen in social media videos entering the stage with tape covering his mouth. The Met previously said the Belfast rap trio were under investigation after clips posted online appeared to show the band calling for the deaths of MPs and shouting 'up Hamas, up Hezbollah'. Kneecap said they have 'never supported' Hamas or Hezbollah, both of which are banned in the UK.
Western Telegraph
16 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Kneecap ‘plasters' London with message of support for group member due in court
Liam Og O hAnnaidh, who performs under the stage name Mo Chara, is accused of displaying a flag in support of Hezbollah at a gig in November last year. The 27-year-old is due to appear at Westminster Magistrates' Court on Wednesday following the alleged incident during a gig at the O2 Forum in Kentish Town, north London. The charge Og O hAnnaidh faces alleges he displayed a flag in a public place, 'in such a way or in such circumstances as to arouse reasonable suspicion that he is a supporter of a proscribed organisation' – namely Hezbollah. Kneecap described the prosecution as a 'witch hunt' in a post on X on Tuesday evening. The post including a short video which appeared to show a billboard that had been displayed in London with the words 'more blacks, more dogs, more Irish, Mo Chara'. The Metropolitan Police said the force had charged O hAnnaidh, who appears on the court list as Liam O'Hanna, after initially being made aware of a video from the gig at the O2 Forum which had been posted online. In a separate event shortly after the terrorism charge, O hAnnaidh could be seen in social media videos entering the stage with tape covering his mouth. The Met previously said the Belfast rap trio were under investigation after clips posted online appeared to show the band calling for the deaths of MPs and shouting 'up Hamas, up Hezbollah'. Kneecap said they have 'never supported' Hamas or Hezbollah, both of which are banned in the UK.
BBC News
18 minutes ago
- BBC News
Trade, a sudden exit, Middle East conflict - five takeaways from G7
Canada's G7 summit, under first-time host Mark Carney, had a carefully planned agenda. That programme was upended by the unfolding war between Israel and Iran and US President Donald Trump's early Carney said on Tuesday this summit "can begin a new era of co-operation that promotes long-term resilience over short-term efficiency".Here are five takeaways from the dramatic G7 in Kananaskis, Alberta. Trump's sudden exit The G7 nations - Italy, the US, France, Germany, the UK, Canada and Japan - were one leader short on Tuesday following the US president's surprise decision to abandon the summit early for Washington DC. World leaders put a positive spin on the abrupt departure. Prime Minister Carney said he fully understood the president's decision, while French President Emmanuel Macron called one reporter's question about whether the group was now a de facto G6 "disrespectful". Trump said he left because of the rapidly unfolding events between Israel and White House insisted the president had had a "great day" in Alberta and achieved much during the trip. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent stayed behind to represent the US. Trump's departure was not necessarily a bad thing, said Denisse Rudich, director of the G7 Research Group London. While he was there, it appeared that everyone was "on eggshells" with leaders smiling, but wary that "you don't quite know what is going to shift".They were more relaxed the next day, she said. "It didn't look forced. It looked a lot more natural."Still, it meant Trump missed planned bilateral meetings with Ukrainian President Volodomyr Zelensky, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum (though he spoke with her later by phone, the White House said.) Israel-Iran war sidelines agenda By Tuesday, much of the world's attention had shifted from the mountain resort in Canada's Rocky Mountains to the unfolding conflict in the Middle East and uncertainty as to the potential course of action by the US. Live updates: Iran and Israel at warG7 leaders urge 'de-escalation' but stop short of calling for Israel-Iran ceasefireThe conflict also overshadowed much of the first day of the summit as G7 leaders sought consensus on their response to tensions in the region. Eventually, all seven, the US, too, released a communique urging a "de-escalation of hostilities in the Middle East, including a ceasefire in Gaza" - though it stopped short of calling for a ceasefire between Israel and Iran. US moves 30 jets as Iran attack speculation growsTrump later accused the French president of "publicity seeking" with his suggestion that the US was working towards a Tuesday, Macron said it was Trump who discussing that option."I am not responsible for the changes of mind of the US administration," he that back and forth, the statement was a show of unity. Ukraine, India and diplomacy On Ukraine, Zelensky will leave this summit with new aid from Canada but notably no joint statement of were reports that Canada had dropped plans for a strong statement in the war over US on that, Carney denied a lack of consensus, and pointed to remarks on Ukraine in the summit chairman's summary statement. In that statement, the G7 "expressed support for President Trump's efforts to achieve a just and lasting peace in Ukraine" and pressed Russia to agree a also said they "are resolute in exploring all options to maximize pressure on Russia, including financial sanctions" - something Trump has outcome is likely to cause friction for Carney at home. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's attendance at the summit was a point of tension among Sikh office said India and Canada had agreed to restore diplomatic services after both countries expelled top envoys. This followed Ottawa's accusation that New Delhi government agents had been involved in the killing of a Sikh separatist leader on Canadian to a readout of the meeting between Carney and Modi, he raised "transnational crime and repression, security, and the rules-based order" in the Carney, a former central bank governor for Canada and the UK, went into his first G7 summit as prime minister and host with a focused agenda and left with joint statements on artificial intelligence and quantum computing, migrant smuggling, critical minerals and other approach was "concise, detailed, action-oriented - you can see the banker", said Ms complimented the "outcomes focused" approach to diplomacy, pointing to the example of an agreement to boost global co-operation on wildfires "without specifically making reference to climate change". Carney's trade agenda... One of the most watched moments of the summit was a sit-down between Trump and two countries were reportedly close to coming to a trade and security deal after talks launched last month to resolve their tit-for-tat tariffs said hurdles remained - he's a "tariff person", Carney "has a more complex idea".But those differences aren't insurmountable, according to a statement from Carney's office, which said the "leaders agreed to pursue negotiations toward a deal within the coming 30 days".On that deadline, the prime minister said he will pursue an agreement "in the best interests of certainly Canada and aligned with US interests". The G7 also gave Carney the opportunity to pitch multiple world leaders on trade with Canada. The prime minister has the lofty goal of making Canada's economy the strongest in the G7 while seeking to reduce his country's deep economic reliance on the US. On Tuesday, European officials said they were close to signing a defence procurement agreement with Canada, which also wants to reduce its dependence on American equipment. ....and Trump's Trump was open about one thing he wanted from the summit: trade Carney didn't walk away with one, British Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and the US leader were all smiles after bringing into force parts of a tariff agreement they sealed last picked up papers to avoid security stepping inStarmer to announce new sanctions targeting RussiaPlenty of other leaders in attendance were keen to pin down the president on his tariffs and Canada, Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba and Trump failed to reach a breakthrough but agreed to push ahead with trade talks. "We've been exploring the possibility of a deal down to the wire, but there are still points where our views remain divided," Ishiba told is some pressure on the US end as well - Trump has promised deals by his own 9 July deadline that marks the end of a 90-day pause on his "Liberation Day" Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said the ongoing trade talks between the US and the EU were "complex", but were "advancing", with the goal of a deal by July.
