logo
Gauteng government setting ‘terrible example' by owing City of Ekurhuleni R382.3m

Gauteng government setting ‘terrible example' by owing City of Ekurhuleni R382.3m

The Citizen29-04-2025

ACDP said it's not fair that government departments are treated differently to residetns when it comes to paying municipal bills.
City of Ekurhuleni signs near the Germiston Civic center, 10 October 2022. Picture: Neil McCartney / The Citizen
The African Christian Democratic Party (ACDP) in Ekurhuleni says it is 'shocked' that the Gauteng government owes the municipality R382.3 million for water and electricity.
ACDP councillor Palesa Yates told The Citizen on Tuesday that R41.1 million of the amount owed has been owed for more than three months.
'The ACDP recently asked a question in council on the matter and was shocked to discover that various departments of our provincial government owe the City of Ekurhuleni R382.3 million.
'The Gauteng provincial government must pay its water and lights accounts on time,' Yates said.
Government departments that do not pay their municipal bills on time set a 'very bad example to residents' who have their electricity cut off for non-payment, she added.
'It is not fair that government departments should be treated differently from ordinary residents,' she said.
ALSO READ: City of Ekurhuleni and its R1.6 billion Eskom debt – How will it affect residents?
More government entities owe the municipality
Written replies to questions in council revealed that other state entities also owe the municipality.
'According to question responses tabled in council, the South African Revenue Services (Sars) owes R1.6 million, the Department of Correctional Services owes almost R17.6 million, and the Department of Infrastructure Development owes almost R170 million in rates,' she said.
Yates said it is difficult to cut off municipal services for government departments and entities.
'The city forces residents to pay by cutting off their water and lights; but this can be a challenge when it comes to some government departments like basic education or health, for example.
'It would be wrong to cut off water to a hospital, for example, because patients will suffer. Different tiers of government, however, have platforms where they can engage. Robust engagements need to happen,' she said.
Ekurhuleni's debt collection campaign
Last year, the City of Ekurhuleni launched a campaign to recoup more than R26 billion from residents and businesses who have defaulted on their municipal accounts.
During the launch of this campaign, the MMC of Finance, Jongizizwe Dlabathi, told The Citizen that residents who owe the municipality for services should pay or have their lights cut off.
He advised that those struggling to pay should contact the city.
What is the importance of paying for rates and services?
Meanwhile, Yates said if metros and municipalities are not paid for services, they will run out of money to do maintenance work like fixing potholes and dealing with power outages.
'All users of municipal services must pay – unless they are indigents,' she said.
The Citizen contacted the Gauteng provincial department for comment about its debt to the City of Ekurhuleni.
However, the provincial government's spokesperson, Vuyo Mhaga, referred the media enquiry to the Gauteng Department of Infrastructure Development (DID). No response was received from DID at the time this article was published.
NOW READ: The race to save Johannesburg: Who has the best plan to rescue the city?

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘No justification for tampering with the constitution': MK party and DA slug it out over no-confidence motion limits
‘No justification for tampering with the constitution': MK party and DA slug it out over no-confidence motion limits

The Citizen

timea day ago

  • The Citizen

‘No justification for tampering with the constitution': MK party and DA slug it out over no-confidence motion limits

Have motions of no confidence become political weapons? The uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) party has rejected a proposal by the Democratic Alliance (DA) to amend the Constitution of South Africa, making it difficult to bring numerous motions of no confidence against the executive in all three spheres of government. The DA believes that over the years, motions of no confidence have been used for political point scoring, destabilising the work of governance and threatening the consistency of service delivery. The City of Johannesburg has been a victim of such motions of no confidence abuses. While not all mayors in this City were removed through motions of confidence, the city has elected more than eight mayors since 2016. How many motions of no confidence are enough? On Wednesday, MK party spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela said that the amendment would make it difficult to hold the executive accountable. This proposal constitutes a direct challenge to parliamentary oversight and represents a desperate attempt to shield the executive from scrutiny and accountability. 'It is a reactionary and democratic manoeuvre disguised as reform. Under the guise of creating stability, the amendment would tie parliament's hands for 12 months at a time, even in the face of ethical collapse, public outrage, or constitutional violations. 'This effectively grants political immunity to underperforming or compromised leaders,' he said. DA not prepared to withdraw Ndhlela said there are existing parliamentary rules that already allow the speaker of the National Assembly or presiding officers to reject frivolous or repetitive motions. He said there is 'no justification for tampering with the constitution' to solve 'a problem that doesn't exist'. 'The MK party rejects this amendment in its entirety. It is redundant, regressive, dishonest, unnecessary and dangerous. 'Parliament's power to hold the executive accountable must be expanded, not neutered. We call on the DA to withdraw this embarrassing and authoritarian stunt before further damaging what remains of its credibility,' he said. Speaking to The Citizen, DA spokesperson Willie Aucamp said the party is proposing two bills related to this matter. 'We cannot allow the kind of instability that we have seen in municipalities,' he said. Aucamp said the party will not withdraw the proposed bills. ALSO READ: Zuma point man touted to replace Shivambu as MK party SG Analyst weighs in Meanwhile, Theo Neethling, a political analyst from the University of the Free State (UFS), told The Citizen that limiting motions of no confidence in legislatures would reduce political grandstanding and make the submission of a motion of no confidence more meaningful. 'Personally, I would support restrictions on these motions only once every 12 months to the date of the last motion. The reason is that this could help reduce political grandstanding and reduce institutional instability,' he said. However, Neethling said he was not sure if other parties would support the DA's proposal. Former Minister of Co-operative Governance Thembi Nkadimeng had proposed a set of reforms aimed at stabilising coalition government while she was in office. This included introducing a cooling-off period after a motion of no confidence vote in councils. NOW READ: Did Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla's faction dribble Shivambu out of power?

Here's how much government paid capped, sick leave to employees in the public service
Here's how much government paid capped, sick leave to employees in the public service

The Citizen

time2 days ago

  • The Citizen

Here's how much government paid capped, sick leave to employees in the public service

Capped leave is expected to grow in costs. A South African flag flies against a backdrop of flowering jacaranda trees outside the Rosebank police station. Picture: Michel Bega/The Citizen The cost and broader impact of leave taken by public service employees over a four-year period have come under scrutiny. Officials from the Department of Public Service and Administration, alongside the Public Service Commission (PSC), presented these findings to Parliament during a meeting on Wednesday. PSC commissioner Vusumuzi Mavuso explained to the Portfolio Committee on Public Service and Administration that data was collected from the Personnel and Salary Administration System (Persal) for the period between 2020 and 2023. ALSO READ: How many ghost workers are there in government? This data focused on various types of leave, including study and sick leave. Information gathered included the gender, age, and salary levels of personnel from all national and provincial departments, with the exception of the Department of Defence and the State Security Agency (SSA). 'It was quite necessary to collect the data and making sure that we have a sense as to what is happening within the public service, specifically looking into sick and study leave from Persal and to establish whether there is any excessive utilisation of such leave,' Mavuso told MPs. Capped leave in public service PSC Director of Employment Management, Renel Singh, reported that as of December 2023, the government spent R16 billion on 9.2 million days of capped leave. This applied to 189 039 employees out of a total of 1 387 391 in the public service, with about 122 000 of them from the education and health sectors. Public sector employees appointed before 1 July 2000 retained their capped leave – pre-2000 audited leave converted to working days – which is only paid out in the event of death, retirement, or medical boarding. READ MORE: Will review of public sector doctors working in private hospitals lead to better healthcare or brain drain? Singh said capped leave is expected to grow in costs. 'The costs go up on the basis of cost-of-living adjustments and factors such as promotions and notch upgrades.' 'Capped leave is a moving target, and it is a contingent liability for the state. It is something that the state has to pay to the public servant who chooses to retire,' she said on Wednesday. Alongside the anticipated future payout costs, there are growing concerns about the potential loss of experienced personnel from the public service sector. 'The health sector has 26 524 officials who have capped leave, and education has 96 096 people who have capped leave, and that raises future concerns in terms of the skills deficit that we may encounter.' Watch the meeting below: PSC recommendations on capped leave Given that capped leave is a 'quite expensive cost' for government, the PSC made several recommendations. Among these was for the National Treasury to perform a detailed cost-based analysis of expected payouts over the next five to ten years. 'There has to be recommendations that need to be made by the National Treasury together with the Department of Public Service and Administration specifically in relation to the negotiation of this particular practice of leave to ascertain what the future costs would be.' 'And it would be feasible for the state to actually incur that cost now or wait for people to exit the system, which could considerably be a higher cost in the future,' Singh explained. READ MORE: Corruption 'not government's responsibility alone' but taxpayers fork out millions for suspensions Another proposal involves allowing employees to convert capped leave into extra pension benefits, in line with Government Employee Pension Fund (GEPF) rules. 'The GEPF offers the option to purchase additional pension and will result in improved retirement benefits.' This would require the Department of Public Service, the GEPF, and the Government Pensions Administration Agency (GPAA) to explore the option from a cost-benefit perspective. The PSC also urged the department to initiate human resource planning exercises to prepare for the loss of experienced staff due to retirement. Sick leave for public service employees Singh presented data showing that the number of public service employees taking sick leave in national departments ranged from 224 649 to 266 445 over the four-year period. In provincial departments, the range was between 14 041 and 145 301. 'In 2022, there was a spike, but it was the new sick leave cycle, which is the reloading of the 36 days of sick leave over a three-year period,' she remarked. READ MORE: Almost 90% of foreign government employees in health and education sectors, says DPSA Between 2020 and 2023, public servants took between 5.4 million and 7.6 million days of sick leave, with a peak in 2022. The cost of this leave rose from R8 billion in 2020 to R11.5 billion in 2022, before slightly dropping to R10.1 billion in 2023. 'When we look at costs, we are looking at it from a perspective of employees not being in the office. They are not operating. They are getting paid their salaries, but they are not actually in office.' Incapacity leave Temporary incapacity leave peaked in 2021, with 43 878 employees taking 1.4 million days of leave. This figure decreased in 2022 but rose again in 2023 to 1.3 million days. The cost reached R2.38 billion in 2023. 'Temporary incapacity leave is employee-initiated,' Singh told the committee. In terms of permanent incapacity leave, which is employer initiated, the police had the highest number of cases, with 696 between 2020 and 2023. The highest cost of permanent incapacity leave for all government employees was R31.18 million in 2020. 'The costs were relatively far lower than your temporary incapacity leave.' To address the escalating costs and potential misuse of sick leave, the PSC suggested annual audits by all government departments to identify instances of excessive use and possible misuse by employees. Departments should also strictly monitor medical certificate submissions to verify sick leave applications. Finally, the PSC recommended that the Department of Public Service consider placing a cap on temporary incapacity leave. NOW READ: Parliamentary 'ghostbusters' target Casper – the unfriendly public service ghost

24 hours in pictures, 4 June 2025
24 hours in pictures, 4 June 2025

The Citizen

time2 days ago

  • The Citizen

24 hours in pictures, 4 June 2025

24 hours in pictures, 4 June 2025 Through the lens: The Citizen's Picture Editors select the best news photographs from South Africa and around the world. This aerial photograph shows a stork with two chicks on a nest installed on a high voltage line mast in Bouee, western France, on June 3, 2025. (Photo by Loic VENANCE / AFP) Wiaan Mulder and Ryan Rickelton of South Africa pictured during a warm up match between South Africa and Zimbabwe ahead of the ICC World Test Championship Final 2025 on June 04, 2025 in Arundel, England. (Photo by Matthew Lewis-ICC/ICC via Getty Images) A train arrives at a station in Colombo on June 4, 2025. (Photo by Ishara S. KODIKARA / AFP) A person places electric candles at a vigil commemorating the Tiananmen Square protest, in Taipei, Taiwan, 04 June 2025. Many people were injured or killed during the protests in Tiananmen Square in Beijing in 1989. Picture: EPA-EFE/RITCHIE B. TONGO The 'Simpecado' float of the Brotherhood of El Rocio of Seville-El Salvador departs Seville on its pilgrimage to the El Rocio hermitage, located in the village of Almonte, Spain, 04 June 2025. Approximately one million people from across Spain make the journey to pay homage to Our Lady of Rocio each year. Picture: EPA-EFE/RAUL CARO A woman wearing big sunglasses with inscriptions reading '1 Lee Jae-myung' watches the inauguration ceremony of South Korea's President Lee Jae-myung outside the National Assembly in Seoul on June 4, 2025. (Photo by Pedro Pardo / AFP) Police and community members look on at a body in the Zamimpilo informal settlemen, 4 June 2025. It is suspected that the victim was killed in crossfire, during a shootout between the police and suspects the day before. Picture: Nigel Sibanda/The Citizen Soldiers of the guard battalion are reflected in a bass horn during a welcome ceremony for Singapore President Tharman Shanmugaratnam (not pictured) with military honors at Bellevue Palace in Berlin, Germany, 04 June 2025. Picture: EPA-EFE/FILIP SINGER Community members march from Main Reef to the home of a 14-year-old Lukhona Fose in Durban Deep, Roodepoort, west of Johannesburg, 4 June 2025, after her mutilated body was found near her home. City of Johannesburg Speaker Nobuhle Mthembu visited Fose's family. Picture: Nigel Sibanda/The Citizen Pope Leo XIV waves from the popemobile as he arrives for his weekly General Audience in St. Peters Square, Vatican City, 04 June 2025. Picture: EPA-EFE/FABIO FRUSTACI People ferry cattle on a vehicle ahead of the Muslim festival of Eid al-Adha in Karachi on June 3, 2025. (Photo by Rizwan TABASSUM / AFP) A man swims to cool off at Marina Beach on a hot summer day in Chennai on June 4, 2025. (Photo by R. Satish BABU / AFP) A follower in a prayer posture is photographed during a 'Long Life Offering Ceremony' for the Tibetan spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama (unseen), at the Tsuglagkhang temple at McLeod Ganj, in Dharamshala, India on June 04, 2025. Long Life Offering Ceremonies are conducted as a gesture of deep gratitude and heartfelt wishes for the continued health and longevity of the Dalai Lama. Typically held at the Main Tibetan Temple, these ceremonies include prayers, ritual offerings, and communal celebrations, reflecting devotion and reverence. Picture: Matrix Images / Sanjay Baid Aerial view of 'Interceptor 006' a giant fence to catch thousands of tons of plastic at Las Vacas River in Chinautla, Guatemala on June 3, 2025. The Dutch NGO The Ocean Cleanup, seeks to trap thousands of tons of plastic that each year flow into the Caribbean Sea at Las Vacas River, a tributary of Motagua River. (Photo by JOHAN ORDONEZ / AFP) French soldiers carry coffins during a burial ceremony of six French soldiers who died fighting for France in the World War I, in the National Necropolis of Notre-Dame-de-Lorette in Ablain-Saint-Nazaire, northern France on June 3, 2025. Six young French soldiers from the World War I, who died in 1914 and 1915 but whose bodies have been discovered in recent years, were buried on June 3, 2025, in the National Necropolis of Notre-Dame-de-Lorette (Pas-de-Calais), as witnessed by an AFP photographer. (Photo by Sameer Al-DOUMY / AFP) MORE: 24 hours in pictures, 3 June 2025

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store