logo
No stay on opening of financial bids in Thane-Bhayandar tunnel and elevated road project: Bombay HC, denies relief to L&T

No stay on opening of financial bids in Thane-Bhayandar tunnel and elevated road project: Bombay HC, denies relief to L&T

Time of India20-05-2025

Bombay HC
MUMBAI: The Bombay High Court vacation bench on Tuesday granted no relief to construction major Larsen & Toubro, one of the bidders in the Thane-Bhayandar Tunnel and elevated road project.
The division bench of Justices Kamal Khata and Arif Doctor did not stay the opening of the financial bids that were scheduled for May 13, originally. However, the HC stated that after opening the financial bids and communicating the decision to the winning bidder, the financial bids are to be preserved in a sealed cover for two weeks to enable L&T to appeal to the Supreme Court.
The tunnel, 5 km, and the elevated road, 9.8 km, together make it the second-longest road project after the almost 22 km long Atal Setu and is being undertaken by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (
MMRDA
).
The project cost is estimated at over Rs 14,000 crore.
Earlier, as an urgent interim order, the HC initially stayed the opening of the financial bids—the final stage of the bidding process—for a day and then, during the hearing, asked the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), which is executing the two projects, not to open the bids until it passes orders. The reasoned judgment copy will be made available later during the day.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Ative sua licença do antivírus agora
McAfee.com
Clique aqui
Undo
However, when L&T's senior counsel Janak Dwarkadas, in one of the two petitions—separate petitions were filed for the two bids for the tunnel and elevated road—sought to request the presence of the company's representatives at the opening of the financial bids, the HC was not inclined and orally said it was held in his petition that the bidder came to court after suppressing material.
Last Thursday, the HC closed for orders a petition filed by construction major Larsen & Toubro (L&T) to challenge the opening of financial bids without its presence as a bidder for two projects, one a tunnel and the other an elevated road from Thane-Ghodbunder to Bhayander.
Earlier, L&T played a lead role in the construction of the Mumbai Trans Harbour Link (Atal Setu), also an MMRDA project.
The High Court vacation bench of Justices Kamal Khata and Arif Doctor sought written submissions from both sides. On Wednesday, it requested MMRDA not to open the bids until Thursday when it concluded the hearing and extended the stay against the opening of the financial bid—which is the last stage of the tendering process.
Senior counsel
Mukul Rohatgi
, logging in via video conferencing from Delhi and appearing for MMRDA, as did Solicitor General
Tushar Mehta
, said not just L&T, there were two other bidders in one of the projects and one more in the second project, who were found non-responsive when technical bids were opened. Under the terms of the tendering process, they will be intimated once the bidder is finalised after the opening of financial bids. There were around five bidders overall, the court was informed.
Rohatgi argued that the petitioner suppressed bid conditions and clauses which clearly enable MMRDA not to disclose its decision on the technical bid round to the bidders during the process but entail intimation after the winning bid is selected.
For L&T, which filed two separate petitions for the tunnel and elevated road projects, senior counsel AM
Singhvi
and
SU Kamdar
appeared on Thursday, arguing how the non-intimation after the opening of technical bids—the second stage of the bidding process—flouted even State guidelines and various fundamental rights, including equality, the right to trade, and the right to life, in tenders for public projects, entailing public funds.
Rohatgi and
Mehta
cited the Mumbai-Ahmedabad high-speed rail (bullet train) project judgment of the Supreme Court, termed the '
Montecarlo
' case, after the bidder whose technical bid was held non-responsive went to court and was unsuccessful before the apex court. In large public projects, the bid documents are made to ensure there is no litigation during the tendering process, as delay would not augur well, Mehta argued.
L&T counsel argued that the bullet train is foreign-funded and the SC carved a distinction, but MMRDA cannot be allowed to turn the settled principles of transparency and fairness long held by the courts as the foundation of the tendering process for public projects on its head.
MMRDA said the tender terms were the same in the bullet train project, hence L&T's petition ought to be dismissed. The SC in the Montecarlo matter held, 'Even while entertaining the writ petition and/or granting the stay which ultimately may delay the execution of the Mega projects, it must be remembered that it may seriously impede the execution of the projects of public importance and disable the State or its instrumentalities from discharging the constitutional and legal obligation towards the citizens.
Therefore, the High Courts should be extremely careful and circumspect in the exercise of its discretion while entertaining such petitions.'
The Elevated Road Project is an extension to the Mumbai Coastal Road Project: envisages a 9.80 km bridge passing along the Vasai Creek. It is estimated at approximately ₹6000 crore,
The tunnel is 5 km long from Gaimukh to Fountain Hotel Junction on Thane Ghodbunder Road; estimated at Rs 8000 crore with the largest diameter of 14.6 m.
L&T invoked PWD guidelines casting obligations on communicating the list of qualified/disqualified bidders after the technical round, which the MMRDA argued was not mandatory as held earlier in a matter by the HC., MMRDA argued that the guidelines were not mandatory as held earlier in another matter by the HC

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sebi to launch UPI IDs for Sebi-registered entities that collect funds
Sebi to launch UPI IDs for Sebi-registered entities that collect funds

Economic Times

time6 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

Sebi to launch UPI IDs for Sebi-registered entities that collect funds

Synopsis The new ecosystem will enable a secure and transparent payment system for investors to transact with registered intermediaries. Nikita Papers IPO opens on May 27, price band set at Rs 95-104 per share Nikita Papers IPO opens on May 27, price band set at Rs 95-104 per share Why gold prices could surpass $4,000: JP Morgan's bullish outlook explained Why gold prices could surpass $4,000: JP Morgan's bullish outlook explained Cyient shares fall over 9% after Q4 profit declines, core business underperforms Cyient shares fall over 9% after Q4 profit declines, core business underperforms L&T Technology Services shares slide 7% after Q4 profit dips L&T Technology Services shares slide 7% after Q4 profit dips Trump-Powell standoff puts U.S. Rate policy in crosshairs: Who will blink first? Trump-Powell standoff puts U.S. Rate policy in crosshairs: Who will blink first? SEBI warns of securities market frauds via YouTube, Facebook, X and more SEBI warns of securities market frauds via YouTube, Facebook, X and more API Trading for All: Pi42 CTO Satish Mishra on How Pi42 is Empowering Retail Traders API Trading for All: Pi42 CTO Satish Mishra on How Pi42 is Empowering Retail Traders Security, transparency, and innovation: What sets Pi42 apart in crypto trading Security, transparency, and innovation: What sets Pi42 apart in crypto trading Bitcoin, Ethereum, or Altcoins? How investors are structuring their crypto portfolios, Avinash Shekhar explains Bitcoin, Ethereum, or Altcoins? How investors are structuring their crypto portfolios, Avinash Shekhar explains The rise of Crypto Futures in India: Leverage, tax efficiency, and market maturity, Avinash Shekhar of Pi42 explains NEXT STORY

PM Modi-led Cabinet approves two big Indian Railways projects: Koderma–Barkakana, Ballari–Chikjajur doubling gets nod; check details
PM Modi-led Cabinet approves two big Indian Railways projects: Koderma–Barkakana, Ballari–Chikjajur doubling gets nod; check details

Time of India

time14 minutes ago

  • Time of India

PM Modi-led Cabinet approves two big Indian Railways projects: Koderma–Barkakana, Ballari–Chikjajur doubling gets nod; check details

The railway expansion projects span across seven districts in Jharkhand, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh. (AI image) Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi-led Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) has given its approval for two Indian Railways projects, with a combined expenditure of Rs. 6,405 crore. The first project involves doubling the Koderma-Barkakana track (133 kms), which runs through Jharkhand's primary coal-producing region. This route also provides the most direct and efficient railway connection between Patna and Ranchi. The second project is the doubling of the Ballari-Chikjajur line (185 kms), extending across Karnataka's Ballari and Chitradurga districts, and Andhra Pradesh's Anantapur district. The railway expansion projects span across seven districts in Jharkhand, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, adding approximately 318 kilometres to the existing Indian Railways network. The multi-tracking initiatives will benefit roughly 1,408 villages, serving a population of about 28.19 lakh residents. These routes are crucial for transporting various commodities including coal, iron ore, finished steel, cement, fertilisers, agricultural products, and petroleum items. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Buy Brass Idols - Handmade Brass Statues for Home & Gifting Luxeartisanship Buy Now Undo The enhanced capacity will accommodate additional freight traffic of 49 MTPA (Million Tonnes Per Annum). As railways provide an environmentally sustainable and energy-efficient transport solution, these developments will support climate objectives and reduce national logistics expenses. The project will decrease oil consumption (52 Crore Litres) and CO2 emissions (264 Crore Kg), equivalent to planting 11 Crore trees. These infrastructure enhancements will boost the Indian Railways' operational capacity, leading to better efficiency and reliability in service delivery, according to CCEA press release. The multi-tracking initiatives aim to optimize railway operations and reduce traffic congestion. The initiatives stem from the PM-Gati Shakti National Master Plan, which focuses on multi-modal connectivity. Through coordinated planning, these initiatives aim to establish uninterrupted connectivity for the movement of people, goods and services. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now

IIT Madras BS degree convocation marks milestone in democratizing tech education
IIT Madras BS degree convocation marks milestone in democratizing tech education

Time of India

time16 minutes ago

  • Time of India

IIT Madras BS degree convocation marks milestone in democratizing tech education

MUMBAI: On a day marked by quiet revolutions and roaring applause, the Indian Institute of Technology Madras held its Convocation and Certificate Distribution Ceremony for the BS Degree programmes on 8 June 2025—a moment that didn't just honour graduates but redefined who gets to be called one. In an auditorium humming with possibility, 867 students from across India and abroad received their scrolls—some holding three-year BSc degrees, others the first-ever batch to earn the four-year BS degrees in Data Science and Applications or in Electronic Systems. Among them were students from remote villages, urban sprawls, and even foreign cities. Some were just 18, others over 80. 'This is not just a graduation. It's a declaration,' said Prof. V. Kamakoti, Director, IIT Madras. 'That knowledge belongs to all. That no income bracket or geography or prior degree should keep someone from accessing world-class education.' Of the graduating cohort, nearly 150 come from families earning less than Rs 1 lakh annually. Another 100 come from households earning less than Rs 5 lakh. These degrees were not easy. Delivered online but assessed rigorously in person at exam centres across India and abroad, they are as academically demanding as any other degree from IIT Madras. They come with projects, labs, capstones—and grit. More than half the students (52%) are juggling this programme alongside another undergraduate degree. While 72% come from engineering or technical fields, a significant 22% come from arts, commerce, or sciences—each drawn by the programme's promise to rewire careers and reimagine futures. Among those honoured was Dr. Sadineni Nikhil Chowdary, an MBBS doctor from AIIMS Delhi, who not only graduated with a CGPA of 9.82 but also topped the GATE Data Science and AI exam. He now plans to pursue MTech at IIT Madras, showing that medicine and machine learning are not parallel tracks but converging ones. 'Three of the top 10 ranks in GATE DA were secured by our BS students,' noted Prof. Kamakoti. 'That speaks volumes of the academic depth this programme fosters.' The day also underscored a larger vision. With over 38,000 active learners and growing, this hybrid BS programme is IIT Madras' blueprint for Sustainable Development Goal 4: universal access to quality education. Whether it's a diploma, a BSc, or a full BS degree, students have flexible exits—and for some, even free rides, thanks to CSR support. 'We're not just building coders or data scientists,' said Prof. Andrew Thangaraj, Coordinator of the BS Program. 'We're shaping informed problem-solvers who understand both complexity and context—who can write code, but also ask the right questions.' Chief Guest Mr. Aravind Krishnan, Managing Director and Head, Southeast Asia Private Equity, Blackstone, described the programme as 'a global model for accessible, future-ready education,' adding that 'the ability to extract insights from complexity is now among the most valuable skills of our time.' Today, more than 4,800 students are studying tuition-free thanks to philanthropic support. Over 10,000 students from extremely low-income families receive up to 75% scholarship. Some have already secured admission into institutions like IISc, IITB, IITD, ISB, University of Michigan, and Texas A&M. What started as a bold experiment is now a quiet revolution. In a world obsessed with exclusivity, IIT Madras is building a new kind of legacy—one where excellence is not rarefied, but reachable.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store