The Association for Responsible Aquaculture Reports Allegations of Bid-Rigging in Nova Scotia Aquaculture Expansion
ARGYLE, Nova Scotia, May 13, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- The Association for Responsible Aquaculture (ARA) reports that the coastal community of Argyle is facing a political storm amid serious allegations of conflict of interest, bid-rigging, and a lack of public consultations related to the expansion of aquaculture facilities along the region's coastline.
Documents obtained through Freedom of Information requests suggest that municipal staff and local oyster operators worked behind the scenes to fix the locations of Aquaculture Development Areas (ADAs) -placing them adjacent to residential properties without engaging affected residents or conducting meaningful consultation.
The controversial site selection has prompted accusations of favouritism and secrecy, with constituents questioning why certain locations were chosen and who benefited. Despite repeated calls for transparency and accountability, the municipality has ignored these concerns.
'People feel betrayed,' said Susan Savriga, an Argyle resident. 'This wasn't a transparent process. It feels like the decisions were made behind closed doors to benefit a few, while the broader community was left in the dark.'
Further compounding the issue, The Nova Scotia Department of Fisheries and Aquaculture (DFA) is reported to have approved the contested ADA locations based on the municipality's recommendations-recommendations now mired in claims of improper influence.
During a June 2024 council meeting, the Municipality of Argyle confirmed that no meaningful public consultation had been conducted on the site selections-further fuelling community frustration.
Evidence and Escalating Concerns
Freedom of Information (FOIPOP) documents made public via the Argyle Municipality website provide evidence of collusion between select oyster farmers and municipal staff to secure ADA sites and discourage public consultation. (available at this link).
Six resident presentations outline detailed conflict of interest claims and are available for public viewing link.
At least ten formal complaints from local residents have been filed under Section 12 of the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act, demanding a full investigation.
Residents allege that municipal councillors and staff enabled specific oyster farmers to secure preferential treatment under the ADA program. In response, the municipality has hired an independent third-party investigator. Simultaneously, the Nova Scotia Ombudsman has launched a separate investigation into the municipality's failure to conduct proper consultation.
Despite these developments, the Municipality and DFA have refused to address or resolve the reported conflicts and continue to resist public calls for a reset of the ADA process to perform fair and open public consultations.
Rising Barriers to Transparency
In what residents describe as an attempt to stifle public oversight, the municipality has begun imposing excessive fees for FOIPOP requests. Additionally, it is invoking Bill 1, recently passed by the provincial government, to label certain information requests as 'trivial, frivolous, or vexatious,' potentially blocking further disclosures.
Community Voices Call for Accountability
"Seeing local councillors refuse to represent and listen to their constituents is extremely alarming,' said Lorelei Murphy, Former Liberal Candidate for MLA Argyle. 'Given the volume of concerns and perceived evidence presented by the residents throughout the area, I think it is council's obligation to hold an open and unbiased review of their decisions to this point and act accordingly moving forward."
'It's clear now that the farmers cheated,' said Chris Thibedeau, a member of the Argyle Residents Association (ARA). 'The email evidence shows individuals inside the municipality helped them. These are no longer perceived conflicts-they are real, and they must be investigated.'
'I've been respectful in all of my communications,' said ARA member Corey Clamp. 'Yet weeks go by with no reply from my councillor. People are watching. If you can't respond to your constituents, you should step down.'
As public pressure builds, residents are calling for a full halt to aquaculture approvals until an independent review is completed. The integrity of the municipal governance, they say is on the line.
About the ARA
The Association for Responsible Aquaculture (ARA) in Argyle is a community stakeholder group of over 400 residents concerned with the lack of transparency and fairness offered by the Aquaculture Development Area (ADA) Pilot led by the Municipality of Argyle and the NS Dept. of Fisheries and Aquaculture. While the ADA is a government led effort, the ARA represents the public and residents of Lobster Bay who seek fairness and a balance of realizing aquaculture expansion in non residential areas in a manner that promotes Tourism and the local harvesting of seafood. ARA is not anti-aquaculture. The goal is to make sure the ADA achieves balance and offers a win for all stakeholders including industry and the public. https://www.facebook.com/associationforresponsibleaquaculture
A photo accompanying this announcement is available at:
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Father in Brandon's manslaughter trial found guilty in infant 2016 death
A Manitoba father has been found guilty of manslaughter in the death of his two-month-old daughter nearly a decade ago. Keifer Mecas, 34, was home alone watching his 11-week-old Haelin Taylor on Jan. 4. 2016, when she went into medical distress in Sioux Valley Dakota Nation, about 40 kilometres west of Brandon, Man. Haelin was rushed to hospital in critical condition but died nearly three weeks later on Jan. 23. Police deemed her death a homicide. Both parents were initially questioned by police. Charges were laid against Mecas seven years later in 2023, after multiple witnesses came forward in 2022 alleging he had confessed to harming Haelin. The judge-only trial began in April. On June 4, Court of King's Bench Justice Scott Abel found Mecas guilty of manslaughter. In his oral decision, he cited witness testimony placing Mecas alone with his daughter when the injuries occurred, as well as medical expert evidence outlining the nature of Haelin's injuries. "I've determined that the cause of death was the application of significant force in an acceleration-deceleration event," Abel told the court. "The injuries were not progressive but rather were caused at the same time ... when the accused was the only adult in the residence with Haelin. "I am satisfied that the accused caused the injuries to Haelin by the significant application of force." While the case relied on circumstantial evidence, the judge ruled it was reasonable to infer that Mecas inflicted the injuries that led to Haelin's death. He ruled the Crown had proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Mecas's action – applying violent force – directly contributed to Haelin's death. The court found that Mecas had committed an unlawful act by assaulting the infant, using force that was well beyond what would be considered normal handling of a baby. The injuries were deemed dangerous and foreseeable, meeting the legal threshold for manslaughter, Abel said. At the trial, the defence suggested an alternative scenario in which Haelin had stopped breathing on her own, possibly due to choking. In a separate 2018 statement, Mecas told police Haelin had been vomiting and struggling to breathe, prompting him to perform CPR with light chest compressions, But, Justice Abel rejected that account stating it could not explain the severity of Haelin's injuries — including trauma to her brain, eyes and spinal cord. "Even if I were to accept that Haelin stopped breathing first and the accused shook Haelin to revive her that explanation still does not create a reasonable doubt regarding the cause of death," he said. Abel's decision repeatedly noted that medical experts testified that the injuries were consistent with significant acceleration and deceleration consistent with violent shaking. A doctor had also examined Haelin one month before the incident and confirmed she was a healthy baby at the time. "I accept their evidence that the cause of death was hypoxic-ischemic brain damage due to a traumatic brain injury," Abel said. "The trauma to Haelin's brain caused her heart to stop breathing resulting in a lack of oxygen and blood to her brain." Abel requested a Gladue Report — which explains an Indigenous person's history, their family's history and their community's history to the courts, in order to take the individual's unique circumstances and challenges into consideration — before Mecas is sentenced in July.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Assaults drive rise in crimes against the person in Montreal: annual report
Montreal police (SPVM) are investigating after a man, 30, was stabbed in Saint-Laurent on April 17, 2025. Another man, 40, was arrested. (Scott Prouse / CTV Montreal) The Montreal police service (SPVM) recorded a rise in overall crime last year, partly due to an increase of assaults and hate-motivated crimes, but say the force saw improvements when it comes to gun crime and vehicle thefts. The overall number of Criminal Code offences rose by 3.4 per cent last year, according to the 2024 SPVM annual report released on Monday. Comparing 2024 to the previous year, crimes against the person were up 7.3 per cent and property crimes rose slightly by 0.4 per cent. Compared to five years ago, the increase in crimes against the person is up nearly 28 per cent, while property crimes saw an increase of 19.4 per cent from levels seen in 2019. The biggest category driving the increase in crimes against the person was assault, a trend that predates the pandemic and has continued upward. The report highlighted that the increase last year can be attributed to level 1 assaults, which means little or no injury to the victim. Assaults rose another consecutive year in 2024, jumping to 19,159 (6.8 per cent) compared to the previous year. 'Although armed violence is still present in the Montréal landscape, it is contributing less to the current portrait than it did in recent years,' the SPVM noted in its report. 'One third of the homicides and attempted murders committed in SPVM territory in 2024 involved the presence or use of a firearm … while these weapons represented half of the homicides and 60% of the attempted murders committed in 2022.' For the first time since 2020, the force recorded a decrease in firearm offences after seeing a drop of 12.9 per cent in 2024. Gun crimes had been rising steadily over the last three years, reaching a five-year peak (518 incidents) in 2023. The SPVM report also showed that the number of crimes against persons involving the presence or use of a firearm in 2024 decreased 6.3 per cent compared to the average of the last five years, and 5.3 per cent compared to 2023. Firearm discharge events also decreased by 5.2 per cent compared to 2023. The SPVM expanded its ant-gun squad, EMAF, last year to all four regions of the city. 'With the mission to prevent individuals engaging in high-risk armed violence behaviours from doing harm (repressive aspect) while offering individuals and their circles alternatives to violence, drawing on the collaboration of community and institutional actors (preventive aspect), the SPVM's Collectives strategy has now been extended across the organization,' the report stated. Domestic violence, sexual assaults According to the report, 21 per cent of all crimes against persons reported in Montreal were related to domestic violence, while homicides remained stable at 31 again last year. Sexual assaults also increased 8.5 per cent from 2023, or 12.6 per cent compared to the average of the past five years. 'This increase is mainly related to an increase in cases of the non-consensual distribution of intimate images and sexual contact,' police said in the annual report. 'Interpreting the increase or decrease in the number of sexual offences is always difficult because they are among the offences least reported to police by the victims. The significant increase observed following the end of the pandemic shows that the population is more aware but also demonstrates a bond of trust between victims and the various players in the judicial system.' More hate crimes reported Meanwhile, there were more hate crimes and hate incidents last year, with increases of 6.2 per cent and 18.1 per cent, respectively, particularly those based on ethnicity, national origin, or skin colour, according to the report. Police noted that officers responded to 300 demonstrations and 630 'crowd control situations' related to the Israel-Hamas war. Marc Charbonneau, deputy chief of specialized service, told CTV News that Montreal police have forwarded more than 70 files to the Quebec Crown prosecution office since the start of the war in Gaza on Oct. 7, 2023. Police also say they are coordinating their response to the rise in extortion attempts targeting local businesses owners, including visits to hundreds of businesses urging them to report all extortion attempts. There has been a wave of firebombings and gun violence targeting restaurants in recent months, with gangs demanding protection money from owners. If the owners refuse to pay up, criminals threaten, firebomb, or shoot at their businesses. On May 30, six suspects broke into a cafe in Old Montreal and set fire to it, causing significant damage. Investigators believe the intended target was a bar next door. last week, police made 13 arrests related to extortion attempts. Charbonneau told CTV News that the SPVM has the resources it needs to combat this phenomenon, saying multiple units are involved in investigating this type of crime, from organized crime squads to patrol officers. 'We reach [out], we go to encounter, to meet all those [owners] that can be reached … and we ask them to talk to us,' he said Monday. 'We want them to be confident in us, and we will be with them to fight that. So what we ask for [owners] is not to answer the demands of those kinds of people.' The annual report also highlighted success when it comes to combating car theft, noting a drop of 25 per cent.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Eby says it's not him blocking Smith's oil pipeline, it's lack of money and proponent
B.C. Premier David Eby speaks during an announcement in Vancouver, on Monday, May 26, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck British Columbia Premier David Eby says it's not him standing in the way of Alberta counterpart Danielle Smith's longed-for oil pipeline from Alberta to B.C.'s north coast — it's that there's no proponent, no money and 'no project right now.' It's Eby's latest rebuff to the idea, coming after Smith said on Sunday she could convince him to allow such a pipeline. Eby says that if Smith succeeds in finding a proponent and funding, and assembles a project, then B.C. 'will certainly cross that bridge.' But he says there are already 'countless projects' that B.C. could work on with Alberta to create prosperity in Western Canada. Eby was speaking at a news conference on Monday from Seoul, South Korea, the final stop on a 10-day trade tour through Asia that has also included Japan and Malaysia. Asked about B.C.'s green light last week for a Prince Rupert gas pipeline, Eby said the province was not 'in the business of turning away investments' — but wouldn't speculate whether that applied to an oil pipeline from Alberta. Eby added that he understands Smith is 'keen' on such a project, just as Ontario Premier Doug Ford is 'keen on tunnel underneath the 401.' This report by Wolfgang Depner, The Canadian Press, was first published June 9, 2025.
