
Iwis oppose expansion of NZ's largest gold mine
Oceana Gold's Macraes mine showing the underground pit, front left, processing plant, front right, and open cast pit right rear. PHOTO: STEPHEN JAQUIERY
Local Māori have opposed the expansion of New Zealand's largest gold mine, north of Dunedin, saying not enough is known about its long-term or cumulative effects on the environment.
Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka ki Puketeraki, Te Rūnanga o Moeraki, and Te Rūnaka o Ōtākou — submitting as Kā Rūnaka — said OceanaGold's application to expand its Macraes Gold Mine did not adequately address "the magnitude, severity and ongoing impact" of the effects arising from their plans.
"Furthermore, the conclusions contained in the application regarding the effects arising from the application have been reached without an assessment of the cultural impacts of the project endorsed by Kā Rūnaka," the submission said.
"It is not possible for the applicant to conclude that the effects are of an acceptable level without cultural input into their assessment."
OceanaGold applied to the Otago Regional Council, Waitaki District Council and Dunedin City Council for consent for the site-wide expansion of mining activities at Macraes, requesting public notification.
Seven submissions were published on the regional council website yesterday.
A hearing is set down for July.
Kā Rūnaka's counsel said the mining company's application lacked detailed information on the proposed expansion's effect on a range of matters including the mine's cumulative effects on water quality, the provision for appropriate and meaningful management of long-term environmental effects and the ongoing and long-term nature of its effects.
Questions remained about the expansion's cultural effects, its land restoration requirements, and its economic impact on Kā Rūnaka.
More needed to be known about the "durability and sustainability" of the offsets and mitigation measures proposed, the submission said.
The applications also lacked a "credible long-term environmental management plan".
"Kā Rūnaka has little choice but to oppose the consents sought."
Forest & Bird also opposed the application and said the proposed expansion would result in significant adverse effects on indigenous plants, animal habitat, wetlands and freshwater ecosystems.
The environmental organisation called upon the regional council to decline the application in full.
Or, if the council was of a mind to approve the application, to include "significant changes to effects management, mitigation and compensation" to account for the significant effects on indigenous species and habitats.
Otago Fish & Game also called for consideration of the long-term effects of the mine.
"Fish & Game submits that the decision-maker should be very certain that there is an extremely robust mechanism to ensure any proposed rehabilitation work — including future adaptive management actions which are not now currently known — will actually be undertaken.
"With that said, Fish & Game is not clear exactly how this could be achieved on a project which spans hundreds of years and into perpetuity, affecting countless future generations."
"In the face of such dramatic uncertainty, it may be that adopting the precautionary principle would be a helpful place to begin," Otago Fish & Game said.
Fire and Emergency NZ submitted a neutral submission but called for assurances there would be an adequate water supply available for firefighting activities as well as emergency vehicle access.
The Department of Conservation noted the application was missing an ecological enhancement area management plan as well as the cultural impact assessment.
"This means that at the time of lodging this submission there can be no certainty that the combination of conditions and management plans will be able to adequately address effects on the environment," the department's submission said.
One neighbour opposed the expansion, citing concerns about noise, air, water and light pollution.
Another raised concerns about what he described as historic consent breaches.
OceanaGold has been approached for comment.
hamish.maclean@odt.co.nz

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Otago Daily Times
6 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Clear direction for Shotover wastewater plant, says ORC
The Shotover wastewater treatment plant. Photo: Stephen Jaquiery A clear indication had been given to what needs to be done to the Shotover wastewater plant, the Otago Regional Council says, after the Environment Court released its decision. The regional council said in a statement it welcomed yesterday's decision from the court, which approved an application for an Enforcement Order over the Shotover Wastewater Treatment Plant. In January, the regional council sought an enforcement order from the Environment Court to address current compliance issues at Queenstown Lakes District Council's Shotover treatment plant, which followed the issuing of two abatement notices and 10 infringement notices. 'The decision paves the way to begin a plan of action so QLDC is able meet its consent obligations and achieve compliance against the Court's Orders,' council chief executive Richard Saunders said in a statement. The order gave a clear indication of what was required to operate, remedy and upgrade the wastewater plant, he said. The court said the treatment plant upgrades currently being undertaken, being the installation of a new Modified Ludzak-Ettinger (MLE) plant, clarifier and supporting infrastructure so that the new MLE plant and clarifier are operational, and resource consent RM2008.238 by the end of the year. The respondent must construct a calamity pond for treated wastewater at the treatment plant and to have the calamity pond available for use by the end of 2027. The Enforcement Orders cover off operations and management manual, staff training, sampling and monitoring, repairs and improvements to the wastewater plant, upgrades to the plant and a new Disposal Field solution; the latter requiring a consent application be made for a new disposal system by May 2026, which must be implemented by December 2030.


Scoop
21 hours ago
- Scoop
Westpac NZ And Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau Support Rotorua Whānau Into Homes
Press Release – Owhata Kohanga Rakau The first stage of the development opened in December last year, when 16 whnau moved into affordable rental properties. Last month local kaumtua moved into 20 affordable rental properties that were set aside specifically for them in the heart … Westpac NZ and Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau Housing are celebrating a partnership which will see the delivery of a major new housing development on Māori land in Rotorua, with the latest milestone the unveiling of a new monument sign for the community's entrance. The Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau development will deliver 93 mixed tenure homes to local Rotorua whānau through social housing, affordable rentals and shared home ownership arrangements (also known as progressive home ownership). Westpac has provided funding for the project – where 36 affordable rental homes have been completed and a further 30 homes are under construction. Westpac is also providing mortgages to help whānau purchase properties through Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau's shared ownership pathway on leased land. Jason Rogers, Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau Chairman, says the entrance sign's unveiling is a significant event for the iwi with whānau and kaumātua now living in the affordable homes. 'Ultimately this community will comprise 93 new, well designed warm homes on whenua Māori. Our goal has been to bring stability in housing outcomes for our people and the sign is a milestone that will strengthen that sense of connection to the whenua. This is a significant undertaking and the project will deliver much needed housing for our people and the community,' Mr Rogers says. 'Having Westpac on board as a bank partner has meant we've been able to work quickly to begin delivering the next stage of homes and we're grateful for their support. We'd also like to acknowledge the support of the Ministry for Housing and Urban Development and Armillary Private Capital, who acted as financial advisors and undertook the financial modelling for the project.' Reuben Tucker, Westpac NZ General Manager Institutional & Business Banking, says Westpac is pleased to be able to play a role in the development. 'As a bank, we're committed to supporting more New Zealanders to find a place to call home,' Mr Tucker says. 'The range of different housing options available through the Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau development is hugely significant, especially since it is on whenua Māori. We're excited to support the aspirations of everyone involved.' The first stage of the development opened in December last year, when 16 whānau moved into affordable rental properties. Last month local kaumātua moved into 20 affordable rental properties that were set aside specifically for them in the heart of the new community. The full development is scheduled for completion next year. What is shared home ownership? These are arrangements such as shared equity, leasehold or rent to buy in which a third party – usually a Community Housing Provider, including charitable trusts and Iwi Māori groups – contributes equity or land towards a customer's first home purchase, reducing the size of the deposit they need and the size of repayments. In the case of shared equity, the model used at Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau, the customer then pays the provider back their portion of equity at a manageable rate over time until they own the home outright. A key barrier for first home buyers is saving for the traditional 20% deposit to qualify for a home loan. Shared equity and leasehold arrangements can help buyers qualify for lending with as little as 5–10% deposit and a smaller loan to service, bringing home ownership and the benefits it provides closer within reach. At Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau, a shared home ownership model is being used to support whānau with whakapapa (ancestral connection) to the Ōwhata and Rotorua area, helping them establish long-term security in a new home of their own. Westpac is able to provide standard residential home loans to customers participating in shared equity or leasehold arrangements.


Scoop
a day ago
- Scoop
Westpac NZ And Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau Support Rotorua Whānau Into Homes
Press Release – Owhata Kohanga Rakau The first stage of the development opened in December last year, when 16 whnau moved into affordable rental properties. Last month local kaumtua moved into 20 affordable rental properties that were set aside specifically for them in the heart … Westpac NZ and Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau Housing are celebrating a partnership which will see the delivery of a major new housing development on Māori land in Rotorua, with the latest milestone the unveiling of a new monument sign for the community's entrance. The Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau development will deliver 93 mixed tenure homes to local Rotorua whānau through social housing, affordable rentals and shared home ownership arrangements (also known as progressive home ownership). Westpac has provided funding for the project – where 36 affordable rental homes have been completed and a further 30 homes are under construction. Westpac is also providing mortgages to help whānau purchase properties through Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau's shared ownership pathway on leased land. Jason Rogers, Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau Chairman, says the entrance sign's unveiling is a significant event for the iwi with whānau and kaumātua now living in the affordable homes. 'Ultimately this community will comprise 93 new, well designed warm homes on whenua Māori. Our goal has been to bring stability in housing outcomes for our people and the sign is a milestone that will strengthen that sense of connection to the whenua. This is a significant undertaking and the project will deliver much needed housing for our people and the community,' Mr Rogers says. 'Having Westpac on board as a bank partner has meant we've been able to work quickly to begin delivering the next stage of homes and we're grateful for their support. We'd also like to acknowledge the support of the Ministry for Housing and Urban Development and Armillary Private Capital, who acted as financial advisors and undertook the financial modelling for the project.' Reuben Tucker, Westpac NZ General Manager Institutional & Business Banking, says Westpac is pleased to be able to play a role in the development. 'As a bank, we're committed to supporting more New Zealanders to find a place to call home,' Mr Tucker says. 'The range of different housing options available through the Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau development is hugely significant, especially since it is on whenua Māori. We're excited to support the aspirations of everyone involved.' The first stage of the development opened in December last year, when 16 whānau moved into affordable rental properties. Last month local kaumātua moved into 20 affordable rental properties that were set aside specifically for them in the heart of the new community. The full development is scheduled for completion next year. What is shared home ownership? These are arrangements such as shared equity, leasehold or rent to buy in which a third party – usually a Community Housing Provider, including charitable trusts and Iwi Māori groups – contributes equity or land towards a customer's first home purchase, reducing the size of the deposit they need and the size of repayments. In the case of shared equity, the model used at Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau, the customer then pays the provider back their portion of equity at a manageable rate over time until they own the home outright. A key barrier for first home buyers is saving for the traditional 20% deposit to qualify for a home loan. Shared equity and leasehold arrangements can help buyers qualify for lending with as little as 5–10% deposit and a smaller loan to service, bringing home ownership and the benefits it provides closer within reach. At Ōwhata Kōhanga Rākau, a shared home ownership model is being used to support whānau with whakapapa (ancestral connection) to the Ōwhata and Rotorua area, helping them establish long-term security in a new home of their own. Westpac is able to provide standard residential home loans to customers participating in shared equity or leasehold arrangements.