logo
Riefenstahl proves that the best documentary subjects are monsters

Riefenstahl proves that the best documentary subjects are monsters

Independent14-04-2025

I don't want to talk about it,' Leni Riefenstahl used to say when she was asked about her past. The German director was happy to discuss her pioneering cinematic techniques, her trailblazing credentials and her redemptive later work with the Nuba people of Sudan. But there was one pesky subject that she preferred to give a wide berth: her role as the ultimate Nazi propagandist. Riefenstahl would go on to survive the Third Reich by nearly 60 years, dying in 2003 at the age of 101. That's six decades of deflection, distortion and avoidance. 'I don't want to talk about it' practically became the woman's catchphrase.
If you thrill to the sight of animals being cornered and criminals run to ground, there is much to relish in Riefenstahl, Andres Veiel's new documentary on the original cancelled artist. It's an exhaustive and surely definitive portrait, combing Riefenstahl's personal archive, filling in the blanks, and presenting its subject warts and all. Veiel isn't remotely interested in hosting a hatchet job here. He acknowledges Riefenstahl's intuitive artistry and technical prowess and shows how Olympia – her 1938 film on the Berlin Olympics – advanced the medium in leaps and bounds. But he also dismantles the great director's defence. Time and again Riefenstahl would protest that she was an artist and not a politician, that her films were pure and peace-loving affairs and that she never had much interest in Nazism anyway. The one thing she was guilty of was her complete and utter innocence.
The evidence, no surprise, tells a rather different story. History records that Riefenstahl was dazzled by Hitler and overjoyed to work as the Reich's official myth-maker. Moreover, although she claimed to have no knowledge of the Holocaust, investigators later found that she may have indirectly caused a massacre by ordering Jewish workers to be removed from a street scene she was filming. At one point in Veiel's documentary, a TV interviewer asks whether it's true that she used to visit the cinema with Joseph Goebbels (an estimated 10 times, according to Goebbels' diary). Riefenstahl is incandescent and promptly explodes with rage. She doesn't want to talk about it.
In the best possible way, Riefenstahl is a monstrous subject. She's unsympathetic and drags dark history behind her. She's a fake and a liar, constantly batting up against the hard glass of reality and prone to fly off the handle whenever she's held to account. All of which is to say that she's a documentary-maker's dream. Every film is a collaboration between the director and their subject. The latter provides the raw meat and draws the basic story arc. But they also leave gaps to be filled and falsehoods to unpick. They're telling one story and the director is telling another, and it is this tension – this friction – that's a recipe for good drama. It almost doesn't matter that Riefenstahl is long dead and can't be questioned in person by Veiel. She's left incriminating letters, false statements and a trove of car-crash TV interviews for us all to peruse.
On balance, I prefer documentaries in which the subject doesn't want to talk than the ones in which they do. I like it when they have to be chivvied into facing inconvenient truths, or where their chatter is a distraction, or a puzzle to solve. Andrew Jarecki's true-crime investigation The Jinx famously ended with its chief suspect – accused killer Robert Durst – caught on a hot mic and apparently confessing his crimes. But in films, as in life, smoking guns are a rarity. The truth is elusive; friction is a given. Most good documentaries are an ongoing squabble between two or more points of view.
It's the director's decision how much of this squabble they show. Filmmakers such as Nick Broomfield or Louis Theroux lift the bonnet and expose the engine, effectively casting themselves as co-stars in the drama. Others maintain a lower profile and like to keep the ugly negotiations backstage. The cartoonist Robert Crumb hated the idea of appearing in a documentary, but his good friend Terry Zwigoff begged and pleaded for his permission (legend has it that Zwigoff intimated that he might shoot himself if the film didn't happen). The director then whipped up a gloriously dark and twisted picture – Crumb (1994) – which painted the Crumbs as the most dysfunctional American family this side of the Mansons. The cartoonist, on seeing the finished work, was horrified.
The Oscar-winning director Errol Morris is known for his down-the-barrel interrogations of controversial US figures (Steve Bannon, Donald Rumsfeld, Holocaust-denier Fred A Leuchter). But his finest achievement remains The Thin Blue Line (1988), a forensic examination of a policeman's murder in Dallas. Morris's documentary gives us not just one unsympathetic subject, but scores of them; an unstable rogues' gallery of false witnesses and outright liars, casual incompetents and wall-eyed crazies. The Thin Blue Line brilliantly navigated this minefield of untruths. It identified the real killer and freed an innocent man from death row. But the dust had barely settled when the film's hero – the wrongly convicted Randall Adams – promptly sued the director for the sole rights to his story. Adams wanted to tell it his way and earn some money on the side. He didn't want to be the subject of someone else's masterpiece.
Towards the end of Veiel's documentary, we see Riefenstahl steeling herself for a final TV grilling. She studies her face in the mirror, checks the camera angles and prepares yet again to duck and block her way out of trouble; to present herself and her work in the most flattering light. This is about the only time in the film that I felt some sympathy for the woman, if only because it's a grander, grimmer version of what we all do every day. We frame our lives as a story and cast ourselves as the hero, even when the evidence suggests otherwise. Good documentaries tell outlandish tales about unusual subjects. But the great ones, I think, spotlight a commonplace human frailty. They show us that everyone in the end behaves in much the same way, whether they're successes or failures, Nazi sympathisers or not. We tell the truth as we see it and pray that our listeners won't interrupt. We love to talk about certain subjects. Other ones, not so much.
'Riefenstahl' is in cinemas from 9 May

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

R Kelly's lawyers accuse prison officials of ‘soliciting inmate to kill him'
R Kelly's lawyers accuse prison officials of ‘soliciting inmate to kill him'

Metro

timean hour ago

  • Metro

R Kelly's lawyers accuse prison officials of ‘soliciting inmate to kill him'

R Kelly's lawyers are fighting to get him released from jail after claiming his life is in danger. The American singer and producer, real name Robert Sylvester Kelly, was once credited as 'the King of R&B', releasing 18 albums and having over 75 million albums and singles, as well as working on albums by Michael Jackson, Britney Spears, Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey, Justin Bieber and Mary J. Blige. He won Grammy, Billboard and American Music Awards, but his career abruptly ended in 2019 following his arrest and subsequent sentencing for racketeering and sex trafficking charges involving the sexual abuse of minors. Kelly, 58, is currently serving a 31-year combined sentence at a prison in North Carolina. However, his legal team have now filed an emergency motion calling from his immediate release from federal custody to home detention. In a filing made on Tuesday, reviewed by Variety, his attorney Beau B. Brindley claims that the team had 'explicit evidence that officials solicited an inmate to murder him while in custody'. His counsel provided a sworn declaration from Mikeal Glenn Stine, a terminally ill inmate, who said that officials 'offered him freedom in his final days in exchange for Kelly's murder'. Stine, a member of the neo-Nazi prison gang Aryan Brotherhood, claimed that he was told Kelly and his attorneys were planning to expose damaging information, as with the filing alleging that officials violated attorney-client privilege by intercepting personal correspondence. He also stated that officials told him he would be charged with Kelly's murder, but that evidence would be mishandled and there would be no conviction. After arriving at Kelly's unit in March, Stine said he was prepared to kill the rapper but changed his mind and ended up telling the rapper that 'Bureau of Prisons officials directed him to carry out his murder'. Kelly's lawyers have claimed that last month they were told a second member of the Aryan Brotherhood who was told by officials to kill both Kelly and Stine. They have said Kelly is in danger remaining in custody with other members of the Brotherhood. 'The threat to Mr. Kelly's life continues each day that no action is taken,' they wrote in the filing. 'More A.B. members are accumulating at his facility. More than one has already been approached about carrying out his murder. 'One of them will surely do what Mr. Stine has not, thereby burying the truth about what happened in this case along with Robert Kelly.' More Trending In 2023 Kelly was sentenced to 20 years in prison for child sex crimes in Chicago while already serving a 30-year prison sentence over sex trafficking and racketeering charges in New York. The judge ruled he could serve 19 years at the same time, meaning the child sex crimes only added one year to his existing sentence. His convictions included three counts of coercing minors into sexual activity and three of producing sex tapes involving a minor. Metro has contacted the U.S. Attorney's Office for comment. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: Taylor Swift fans convinced she's secretly married Travis Kelce MORE: It's been 20 years since Brad Pitt 'left' Jennifer Aniston for Angelina Jolie – have we learned anything? MORE: Beyoncé giving away free concert tickets to London shows after 'poor sales'

SXSW London 'kicked off biggest month for business in London'
SXSW London 'kicked off biggest month for business in London'

Evening Standard

time6 hours ago

  • Evening Standard

SXSW London 'kicked off biggest month for business in London'

Ayesha Qureshi MBE who was instrumental in the London 2012 Olympics working across community engagement and planning compare the event to the Games, saying, 'Just like the Olympics, SXSW London has sown the seed that it can be a catalytic event for the UK. The festival has had a tremendous impact in its first year alone and represents a huge opportunity for us in this country to be global innovation leaders. On the ground it also injected new diverse global audiences to buildings and venues in East London who desperately need the revenue streams. I walked up and down Brick Lane and spoke to local businesses who told me that they had experienced exponential increase in footfall. The promise of SXSW London as a ten-year stint also means we can continue to grow the halo effect the festival can have across the whole of the UK – marking the UK as unique leaders in global innovation.'

Yoshitomo Nara at Hayward Gallery: punk rock art for your inner child
Yoshitomo Nara at Hayward Gallery: punk rock art for your inner child

Evening Standard

time8 hours ago

  • Evening Standard

Yoshitomo Nara at Hayward Gallery: punk rock art for your inner child

The scowling children in his sketches — you can see the German neo-expressionism picked up from his art student days in Düsseldorf — become increasingly large in his paintings, always alone, popping out from their flat backgrounds, heads growing bigger, eyes wider, the expressions increasingly complicated. Sleepless Night (1997) has a kid in a onesie with animal ears, sitting on a stool against a dark background, straight out of Where The Wild Things Are, both boy and trickster sprite. What is he up to? Next to him is Dead Flower (2020), where a little girl is malevolently turning to grin at us, having beheaded a flower with a serrated knife. Just a flower, but her mouth and knife drip with blood and 'f*** you' is scrawled on her jacket. The fact a lightbulb hangs above suggests fantasy evil in a bedroom rather than the real deed, punk posturing over criminality.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store