logo
Riefenstahl proves that the best documentary subjects are monsters

Riefenstahl proves that the best documentary subjects are monsters

Independent14-04-2025

I don't want to talk about it,' Leni Riefenstahl used to say when she was asked about her past. The German director was happy to discuss her pioneering cinematic techniques, her trailblazing credentials and her redemptive later work with the Nuba people of Sudan. But there was one pesky subject that she preferred to give a wide berth: her role as the ultimate Nazi propagandist. Riefenstahl would go on to survive the Third Reich by nearly 60 years, dying in 2003 at the age of 101. That's six decades of deflection, distortion and avoidance. 'I don't want to talk about it' practically became the woman's catchphrase.
If you thrill to the sight of animals being cornered and criminals run to ground, there is much to relish in Riefenstahl, Andres Veiel's new documentary on the original cancelled artist. It's an exhaustive and surely definitive portrait, combing Riefenstahl's personal archive, filling in the blanks, and presenting its subject warts and all. Veiel isn't remotely interested in hosting a hatchet job here. He acknowledges Riefenstahl's intuitive artistry and technical prowess and shows how Olympia – her 1938 film on the Berlin Olympics – advanced the medium in leaps and bounds. But he also dismantles the great director's defence. Time and again Riefenstahl would protest that she was an artist and not a politician, that her films were pure and peace-loving affairs and that she never had much interest in Nazism anyway. The one thing she was guilty of was her complete and utter innocence.
The evidence, no surprise, tells a rather different story. History records that Riefenstahl was dazzled by Hitler and overjoyed to work as the Reich's official myth-maker. Moreover, although she claimed to have no knowledge of the Holocaust, investigators later found that she may have indirectly caused a massacre by ordering Jewish workers to be removed from a street scene she was filming. At one point in Veiel's documentary, a TV interviewer asks whether it's true that she used to visit the cinema with Joseph Goebbels (an estimated 10 times, according to Goebbels' diary). Riefenstahl is incandescent and promptly explodes with rage. She doesn't want to talk about it.
In the best possible way, Riefenstahl is a monstrous subject. She's unsympathetic and drags dark history behind her. She's a fake and a liar, constantly batting up against the hard glass of reality and prone to fly off the handle whenever she's held to account. All of which is to say that she's a documentary-maker's dream. Every film is a collaboration between the director and their subject. The latter provides the raw meat and draws the basic story arc. But they also leave gaps to be filled and falsehoods to unpick. They're telling one story and the director is telling another, and it is this tension – this friction – that's a recipe for good drama. It almost doesn't matter that Riefenstahl is long dead and can't be questioned in person by Veiel. She's left incriminating letters, false statements and a trove of car-crash TV interviews for us all to peruse.
On balance, I prefer documentaries in which the subject doesn't want to talk than the ones in which they do. I like it when they have to be chivvied into facing inconvenient truths, or where their chatter is a distraction, or a puzzle to solve. Andrew Jarecki's true-crime investigation The Jinx famously ended with its chief suspect – accused killer Robert Durst – caught on a hot mic and apparently confessing his crimes. But in films, as in life, smoking guns are a rarity. The truth is elusive; friction is a given. Most good documentaries are an ongoing squabble between two or more points of view.
It's the director's decision how much of this squabble they show. Filmmakers such as Nick Broomfield or Louis Theroux lift the bonnet and expose the engine, effectively casting themselves as co-stars in the drama. Others maintain a lower profile and like to keep the ugly negotiations backstage. The cartoonist Robert Crumb hated the idea of appearing in a documentary, but his good friend Terry Zwigoff begged and pleaded for his permission (legend has it that Zwigoff intimated that he might shoot himself if the film didn't happen). The director then whipped up a gloriously dark and twisted picture – Crumb (1994) – which painted the Crumbs as the most dysfunctional American family this side of the Mansons. The cartoonist, on seeing the finished work, was horrified.
The Oscar-winning director Errol Morris is known for his down-the-barrel interrogations of controversial US figures (Steve Bannon, Donald Rumsfeld, Holocaust-denier Fred A Leuchter). But his finest achievement remains The Thin Blue Line (1988), a forensic examination of a policeman's murder in Dallas. Morris's documentary gives us not just one unsympathetic subject, but scores of them; an unstable rogues' gallery of false witnesses and outright liars, casual incompetents and wall-eyed crazies. The Thin Blue Line brilliantly navigated this minefield of untruths. It identified the real killer and freed an innocent man from death row. But the dust had barely settled when the film's hero – the wrongly convicted Randall Adams – promptly sued the director for the sole rights to his story. Adams wanted to tell it his way and earn some money on the side. He didn't want to be the subject of someone else's masterpiece.
Towards the end of Veiel's documentary, we see Riefenstahl steeling herself for a final TV grilling. She studies her face in the mirror, checks the camera angles and prepares yet again to duck and block her way out of trouble; to present herself and her work in the most flattering light. This is about the only time in the film that I felt some sympathy for the woman, if only because it's a grander, grimmer version of what we all do every day. We frame our lives as a story and cast ourselves as the hero, even when the evidence suggests otherwise. Good documentaries tell outlandish tales about unusual subjects. But the great ones, I think, spotlight a commonplace human frailty. They show us that everyone in the end behaves in much the same way, whether they're successes or failures, Nazi sympathisers or not. We tell the truth as we see it and pray that our listeners won't interrupt. We love to talk about certain subjects. Other ones, not so much.
'Riefenstahl' is in cinemas from 9 May

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Cruz Beckham post heartbreaking family snap after brother Brooklyn tells them he ‘wants no contact'
Cruz Beckham post heartbreaking family snap after brother Brooklyn tells them he ‘wants no contact'

Scottish Sun

timean hour ago

  • Scottish Sun

Cruz Beckham post heartbreaking family snap after brother Brooklyn tells them he ‘wants no contact'

Brooklyn was understood to be unhappy at discovering his father's knighthood in the press cruz control Cruz Beckham post heartbreaking family snap after brother Brooklyn tells them he 'wants no contact' CRUZ Beckham has shared a throwback family snap amid the ongoing family feud between the Beckhams. The youngest son of David and Victoria appeared to be looking back at happier times in the family as he shared an old snap of the three brothers with their mum after she had just given birth to daughter, Harper Seven. 5 Cruz has shared a throwback snap of his family amid the ongoing feud Credit: Instagram 5 The family are locked in a feud Credit: Instagram/victoriabeckham The snap, believed to be taken in 2011, showed the three boys beaming down the lens of the camera as they snuggled up to their mum. Victoria tenderly held her daughter in the heartwarming picture. Cruz's decision to upload the image is very telling amid ongoing tension in the family after Brooklyn decided he no longer wanted contact with his famous family. Cruz did not add any captions nor did he tag his family members in the snap. Earlier today, it was revealed that Brooklyn is refusing to reply to messages amid the bitter feud, according to reports. The 26-year-old, who lives in LA with wife Nicola Peltz, 30, has no desire to speak to his parents or siblings after only learning about his dad's knighthood in the press, an insider has told Page Six. The sourced said: "Brooklyn told his family he wants no contact and he's not responding to those that try to connect.' However, a source close to Brooklyn denied this and said, "this seems to be another deliberate attempt to misrepresent the truth, and it only serves to distract from this honor being bestowed on Brooklyn's father." The Sun has contacted representatives for Brooklyn and the Beckhams for comment. England legend David will be knighted as part of King Charles' birthday honours. Peltz-Beckham's respond to reports of family feud It's a title he has coveted for some time and it means Victoria will be come Lady Beckham. David was first put forward for a knighthood in 2011 after helping to secure the London 2012 Olympics. But he was blocked from getting the title by the Honours Committee after becoming caught up in a tax avoidance scheme, along with many other stars. His finances were cleared by the taxman at least four years ago - paving the way for him to finally get the coveted honour. Just weeks ago we revealed how David and Victoria feel there might be no way to reconcile with their eldest child. Brooklyn, who was a no-show at David's star-studded 50th birthday celebrations last month, shared a video of himself and Nicola riding on his motorbike and wrote: 'My whole world. I will love you forever. I always choose you baby.' Those close to the Beckhams said the message seemed 'very pointed'. A source added: 'It shows how much this situation with his family has escalated. 5 Brooklyn has cut all contact with his family Credit: Getty 5 Brooklyn has been going through a difficult time Credit: Getty "It's very sad for everyone involved, especially David and Victoria who love him very much. This isn't the Brooklyn his family knows and loves. 'This post was like a dagger to their hearts but they will always be there for Brooklyn.' Tensions became public when Brooklyn did not publicly acknowledge fashion designer Victoria, 51, on Mother's Day. He then failed to show at any of David's 50th birthday parties. His mum and dad have continued to acknowledge him on social media, but pals of Brooklyn and Nicola suggested that was for show. The Sun revealed that the couple recently had dinner in California with the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, who were 'very empathetic'.

Brooklyn Beckham locked in trademark war with Becks just weeks after family feud is laid bare
Brooklyn Beckham locked in trademark war with Becks just weeks after family feud is laid bare

Scottish Sun

time3 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Brooklyn Beckham locked in trademark war with Becks just weeks after family feud is laid bare

BROOKYLN Beckham has another row brewing with a Becks — but this time it's not his famous father. The eldest son of David and Victoria wants to expand his hot sauce brand so applied to trademark 'Becks Buns' in the US. Advertisement 5 Brooklyn Beckham (pictured with wife Nicola Peltz) is facing a trademark battle over the name of his hot sauce Credit: Getty 5 Brooklyn is currently locked in a feud with his famous family Credit: instagram 5 Brooklyn snubbed his dad's 50th birthday celebrations Credit: Getty But the company that makes Beck's beer is set to challenge it. It comes after the Beckham family feud was blown open last month when Brooklyn, 26, missed all of David's 50th birthday celebrations. A source said: 'It's one thing after another for Brooklyn. "First his row with his dad blows up — and now he's got another Beck's looking like it's going to become a bit of a headache.' Advertisement Brooklyn applied in January to use the name 'Becks Buns' within his Buster Hot Sauce Inc company. However, the beer's German parent firm Brauerei Beck & Co has opposed it and been granted an extension until next month to file documents. The company is part of alcohol giant AB InBev, which produces one in four lagers sold worldwide, including Stella Artois and Budweiser as well as Beck's. Brooklyn launched his first hot sauce, Cloud 23, last year and said: 'It's been a passion project of mine for the last 2½ years, something I've literally put everything into. I've never worked so hard on anything in my life.' Advertisement His parents attended the launch event in LA. However, insiders said their relationship has 'never been more fractured'. Those close to Brooklyn — who is married to US actress Nicola Peltz, 30 — insist he made a private attempt to meet his dad ahead of his 50th. But that was vehemently denied by sources close to the former England captain. Advertisement It was also claimed Nicola, who has been accused of 'controlling' her husband, had hired a PR guru. Those close to her believe she is being 'unfairly blamed' for the issues. KICK? NO HE'LL EDIT FOOTIE icon David Beckham is to guest edit Country Life mag in October. Editor-in-chief Mark Hedges said: 'David told me he reads every issue from cover to cover.' David, who lives in a £12million manor in Oxfordshire, said: 'I am really looking forward to working with the team to produce an issue that will celebrate the countryside.' Mr Hedges said the October edition will feature David's 'favourite view and his best-loved recipe'. 5 Brauerei Beck & Co, who make Beck's beer, are set to challenge the trademark Credit: Alamy 5 David Beckham is set to guest edit Country Life mag in October Credit: Getty Advertisement Unlock even more award-winning articles as The Sun launches brand new membership programme - Sun Club.

Thomas Tuchel names the England ace he'll take fashion tips from… then reveals he might not even pick him
Thomas Tuchel names the England ace he'll take fashion tips from… then reveals he might not even pick him

Scottish Sun

time7 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Thomas Tuchel names the England ace he'll take fashion tips from… then reveals he might not even pick him

ALEXANDER McQUEEN Thomas Tuchel names the England ace he'll take fashion tips from… then reveals he might not even pick him Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THOMAS TUCHEL has revealed he'd happily take fashion advice from Trent Alexander-Arnold if he were stuck in a jam. The Real Madrid newboy has developed a reputation for being a fashionista in recent years, with his outfits being copied by youngsters up and down the country. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 England boss Thomas Tuchel is well known for being a dapper chap Credit: PA 5 But the German has revealed he'd taken fashion tips from defender Trent Alexander-Arnold Credit: PA 5 Alexander-Arnold is one of England's best-dressed players and recently inked a deal with American brand Guess Credit: GETTY Alexander-Arnold's unique dress sense recently bagged him an ambassador role with American fashion brand Guess, which he was dressed from head to toe in at the Spanish Grand Prix earlier this month. The defender caught the eye as he walked along the paddock with his England team-mates by donning cream dungarees with a white vest. And his garbs that day made a lasting impression on England boss Tuchel, who admits he'd turn to the former Liverpool star if he was in need of a short-notice outfit. During an appearance on talkSPORT: "I would say Trent Alexander-Arnold was very well dressed when we attended the Formula One READ MORE ON TUCHEL TUCH TO TAKE Tuchel suggests Toney will not get more playing time due to 'specialist' role "That was a style that also suits an older person, I would say, and would not be totally crazy. "If you go to some of the younger lads, they looked amazing, but it would just not be for me." Tuchel further praised Alexander-Arnold's F1 fit by saying: "It was very classic, very stylish and suited him perfectly. "He looked amazing, much better than I would've looked." JOIN SUN VEGAS: GET £50 BONUS 5 Trent Alexander-Arnold's fashion sense has been copied by youngsters galore Credit: Alexander-Arnold's dress sense may impress Tuchel, but it won't guarantee him a place in the German's starting XI. The former Kop star was an unused substitute in Tuesday's shock defeat to Senegal and has been warned by his manager that he'll only play if his Real form shows that he's capable of fitting into his system. Trent Alexander-Arnold breaks down in tears and kisses badge as he gets emotional send-off from Liverpool fans When asked about the possibility of dropping the 26-year-old, Tuchel said: "That would be a hard choice, then it depends completely on us. "If we have a similar structure and similar players, because we desperately want to have him in the team. "He gives us something unique and can make connections with teammates and boost chemistry, then we will try to use him. "If he gives us something unique, then we will make sure that he has his place - But that applies to any player. "If not, then we will always value the team more than individual quality. "In the end, at international level, it's so important that we arrive with the right team and that everyone in the team knows before, first that we have to quality. "[And] that everyone knows their role, why he is there, and what they have to give to the group and from there we go."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store