Public's ‘gut instinct' should count in reviewing criminal cases, says Tice
The deputy leader of Reform UK will be introducing 'Lucy's Bill', which would allow people to mount mass appeals against punishments they deem to be too severe or lenient.
It comes after Mrs Connolly, the wife of Conservative councillor Ray Connolly, was jailed last year for 31 months for inciting racial hatred, a sentence which has been criticised as being too harsh.
The Bill will be introduced to the House of Commons on Wednesday and would mean campaigners could get the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) to reconsider cases deemed unduly harsh.
Speaking outside HMP Peterborough, where he visited Connolly on Tuesday, Mr Tice said she was a 'political prisoner'.
He said: 'I genuinely fear that she is actually being treated as a political prisoner for political purposes.'
Mrs Connolly posted on X: 'Mass deportation now, set fire to all the f****** hotels full of the bastards for all I care … if that makes me racist so be it,' in the wake of the Southport stabbings.
An appeal against her sentence was dismissed at the Court of Appeal last month.
Mr Tice claimed Mrs Connolly had bruises on her wrists which he said were from handcuffs but that she was calm and wanted to see through her sentence and rebuild her life.
He said he hoped the Bill would enable a 'treble check' on sentences.
'The whole point about justice is it has to have the confidence of the British people,' Mr Tice said.
'We're not calling into dispute the brilliance of our legal system and our judges.
'What we're just saying is, sometimes, however good you are, you might not quite get it right, and it's not unreasonable to have a treble check of the sentence itself.'
He said that the number of people required to sign the petition could be up for debate.
He added: 'To get 500 signatures on a form is not an easy thing. You've got to explain it to 500 people, and they've got to be convinced.
'You can always say at the margin something might be abused. That doesn't mean you shouldn't talk about it.'
When asked why the public should get a say in legal cases, Mr Tice said: 'Never underestimate the common sense of the Great British public and their gut instinct for where something is fair or not fair. We're all human, judges can get things wrong, and sometimes there can be political pressure.
'In this situation, we had a prime minister that effectively ordered the judges to give very strict sentences, and people have very serious concerns about that.
'There's a lot of concern amongst the British public that Lucy Connolly and others were the victims of two-tier justice.'
Under the Bill, campaigners would need to get 500 people to sign a petition against a punishment handed down in Crown Court.
Those cases would be considered for eight weeks by the CCRC, which may refer them to the Court of Appeal for a decision.
Mr Tice said of choosing the CCRC over the Attorney General: 'The Attorney General is a busy person and ultimately a political person, whereas the (CCRC) should not be that.
'It could potentially be extra work but it wouldn't be very many cases a year. It might be an opportunity for the CCRC to say 'We actually need to relook at our competences, how we operate, our procedures. Are we getting it right? Can we improve ourselves?'.
He did not say how much the proposal could cost the taxpayer but added: 'I want to have the debate and the discussion and give the British people the ability to have ever more confidence in our justice system.
'If you lose that confidence, if you lose that trust, that's a very bad place to be.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
39 minutes ago
- Reuters
UK to purchase fighter jets capable of carrying tactical nuclear weapons
THE HAGUE, June 24 (Reuters) - The British government said on Tuesday that it would purchase a dozen F-35A fighter jets capable of firing tactical nuclear weapons in what it described as the biggest expansion of its nuclear deterrent in a generation. The purchase of the Lockheed Martin jets would allow Britain's air force to carry nuclear weapons for the first time since the end of the Cold War, Downing Street said. "In an era of radical uncertainty we can no longer take peace for granted, which is why my government is investing in our national security," Prime Minister Keir Starmer said in a statement. Britain is increasing defence spending and upgrading its military forces, including its submarine fleet, as it faces increasing hostility from Russia and as the United States retrenches from its traditional role as a defender of European security. The British government said the purchase of the jets would allow it to contribute so-called dual-capable aircraft to NATO to carry nuclear weapons in the event of a conflict. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said "this is yet another robust British contribution to NATO". Britain's nuclear deterrent currently rests solely on the Trident submarine-based system, which misfired during a test last year, the second successive test failure after one veered off course in 2016. The last time Britain possessed an independent air-launched nuclear capability was in 1998 when the WE-177 free fall bomb, opens new tab was withdrawn from service, according to Britain's parliament. Tactical nuclear weapons are intended for battlefield use, as opposed to strategic weapons designed to be fired across vast distances. By purchasing the F-35A fighter jets, Britain would be able to diversify its military options and align more closely with NATO allies such as France, and the United States, which maintains land, sea, and air-based nuclear capabilities. The F-35A fighter jets are capable of carrying U.S. B61 tactical nuclear weapons. Britain would likely need the United States to supply those weapons for use on the planes, said one British official who declined to be named. The United States withdrew its last nuclear weapons from Britain in 2008, in a sign at that time that the threat of conflict following the end of the Cold War was receding. Downing Street said buying the new jets would support about 20,000 jobs in Britain and underline its commitment to NATO. The government has pledged to boost overall defence and security spending to 5% of economic output by 2035 to meet a NATO target and said on Tuesday it must "actively prepare" for war at home for the first time in years.
The Herald Scotland
41 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
PM to announce ‘biggest strengthening of UK nuclear posture in a generation'
The jets, a variant of the F35Bs the UK already uses, can carry conventional weapons, but can also be equipped with nuclear bombs. Sir Keir said: 'In an era of radical uncertainty we can no longer take peace for granted, which is why my government is investing in our national security, ensuring our armed forces have the equipment they need and communities up and down the country reap the benefits from our defence dividend.' The decision represents a victory for the Royal Air Force, which has long pushed for a return of its nuclear capabilities since the last British air-dropped nuclear weapon was withdrawn from service after the end of the Cold War. Sir Keir Starmer has travelled to The Hague for a Nato conference, where leaders are expected to commit to spending 5% of GDP on defence and security. (Ben Stansall/PA) Since then, the UK's nuclear deterrent has been carried exclusively by the Royal Navy's submarines, which the Government has also promised to invest in renewing with four new vessels. Sir Keir added: 'Supporting 100 businesses across the country and more than 20,000 jobs, these F35 dual capable aircraft will herald a new era for our world-leading Royal Air Force and deter hostile threats that threaten the UK and our Allies.' Defence Secretary John Healey said the decision followed a strategic defence review that 'confirmed we face new nuclear risks, with other states increasing, modernising and diversifying their nuclear arsenals'. The review, published earlier this month, recommended beginning discussions with the US and Nato on 'enhanced UK participation' in the alliance's nuclear mission, and raised the possibility of acquiring F35As. Nato's nuclear mission involves allied aircraft being equipped with American B61 bombs stockpiled in Europe. Nato secretary general Mark Rutte welcomed the announcement as 'yet another robust contribution' from the UK to the alliance. (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Seven nations currently contribute so-called 'dual capability aircraft' to Nato's nuclear mission, but a the use of nuclear weapons would require the authorisation of the alliance's nuclear planning group as well as the US president and British prime minister. The alliance's secretary-general Mark Rutte welcomed the announcement, saying it was 'yet another robust British contribution to Nato'. Alongside the nuclear announcement, the UK is set to provide 350 air defence missiles to Ukraine as Sir Keir and Mr Healey push for Nato to provide Kyiv with further support. The delivery will be funded by £70 million raised from the interest on seized Russian assets. Sir Keir said: 'Russia, not Ukraine, should pay the price for Putin's barbaric and illegal war, so it is only right we use the proceeds from seized Russian assets to ensure Ukraine has the air defence it needs.' Wednesday is also expected to see Nato allies formally sign up to a target of spending 5% of the GDP on defence and security. The figure includes 3.5% on 'core' defence spending, with another 1.5% being spent on wider security and resilience measures such as critical infrastructure, border security and intelligence. On Tuesday, the UK committed to reaching the new 5% target from 2035, but the Prime Minister declined to say how the Government would pay for the increase from its current target of spending 2.5% of GDP on defence from 2027.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Government report's 13 terrifying warnings for Brits to 'actively prepare' for war
A chilling National Security Strategy lists a string of dangers facing the UK including our adversaries working closer together. The British public has been told it must "actively prepare" for war on UK soil - along with a string of chilling warnings - in a long-awaited UK Government report. The National Security Strategy, published this afternoon, highlights a string of fears as the Government gets on a war footing. Keir Starmer has pledged to bring security spending up to 5% by 2035 as the country faces a number of growing threats. These include war breaking out between major powers, nuclear weapons falling into the wrong hands, terrorists working with hostile states and despots seeking control in outer space, reports the Mirror. In the forward to the document Mr Starmer said: "It is an era of radical uncertainty, and we must navigate it with agility, speed and a clear-eyed sense of the national interest." The report warns of deeper co-operation between Russia, China and North Korea and highlights the risk of key British infrastructure from foreign attack. Here we look at some of the key takeaways from the strategy. Brits must 'actively prepare' for war on UK soil The British public is warned that war on UK soil is a possibility in the coming years. It states: "For the first time in many years, we have to actively prepare for the possibility of the UK homeland coming under direct threat, potentially in a wartime scenario." Danger of nuclear weapons 'more complex than during Cold War' It said: "The threat to the UK and our allies from nuclear weapons is once again growing. "Tackling this challenge is likely to be more complex than it was even in the Cold War, with more states with more nuclear weapons, the further proliferation of nuclear and disruptive technology, and the failure of international arms control arrangements to keep pace." Likelihood of UK getting involved in military conflict 'growing' One paragraph that makes uneasy reading states: "The likelihood of contingencies in which we may be asked, or choose, to confront threats by the use of military force is growing. "We have seen groups like the Houthis threaten the essential principle of freedom of navigation with attacks on civilian shipping in the Red Sea, as well as on the allied navies there to protect them (leading to UK military action). "Elements of the UK's armed forces have been shifted into a state of heightened readiness on a number of occasions in different theatres." Hostile states may join forces with criminals and terrorists It says: "It may become more difficult to identify hostile state activity as they make use of terrorist and criminal groups as their proxies. Our reliance on data centres and other forms of digital infrastructure will also increase vulnerabilities to cyber attack." War between major powers is 'an active possibility' The strategy states that this is now an "active possibility" - citing tensions between India and Pakistan. It says: " Warfare between major powers, an international security crisis, or a situation with multiple-contingencies across different regions, is an active possibility." Such conflict will have a major impact at home, it says. The report states: "We have seen direct military conflict between Israel and Iran. This follows years of aggressive and destabilising activity by the Iranian regime which has included activity specifically targeted against UK interests at home and overseas. "Significant escalation in any of these theatres would have a profoundly negative impact on our energy security, the cost of living and our ability to grow our economy." Russia and China seeking superiority in sea, online and outer space It states: "Global commons are being contested by major powers like China and Russia, seeking to establish control and secure resources in outer space, cyberspace, the deep sea, and at the Arctic and Antarctic poles. There will be less scope for agreement on mechanisms which protect fair trade, set controls on science and technological developments and mitigate the effects of climate change, as multilateral institutions decline in influence." Critical infrastructure is a target for UK's enemies The report says: "Meanwhile, critical national infrastructure – including undersea cables, energy pipelines, transportation and logistics hubs – will continue to be a target." WW2-style spirit needed The document says: "The years ahead will test the United Kingdom... The direction it takes – and the decisions we take – will reverberate through the decades. "We will need agility and courage to succeed, but we should be optimistic. We remain a resolute country, rich in history, values and in our capabilities. But most of all, there is the determination of the British people themselves. After all, we do not need to look too far into our history for an example of a whole-of-society effort, motivated by a collective will to keep each other safe. "We can mobilise that spirit again and use it both for our national security and the rebuilding of our country." UK's adversaries are working closely together Referencing North Korea's support for Russian forces in Ukraine, the strategy said hostile nations are more willing to work together. "As our adversaries and competitors engage in further military modernisation, issues like technology transfer and sanctions enforcement are going to become increasingly important," the strategy states. AI and technology will 'change the character of conflict' The document also sounds the alarm about new chemical and biological weapons. The strategy states: "Technology will also create new vulnerabilities and change the character of conflict. "New chemical and biological weapons may be developed and proliferate. Hypersonic missiles and AI-enhanced systems will be supplemented by mass-produced, low sophistication capabilities like drones. "Some of these technologies will be available to a wider range of threat actors, posing new challenges to traditional concepts of deterrence and escalation." Climate change will add to pressures It says: "We will have to contend with the effects of climate change a nd potential ecosystem collapse, biological threats, demographic shifts, continued urbanisation, threats to human health, slow economic growth, inequality, and competition for basic resources, including food and water. "Increased migration and population displacement will continue to place pressure on borders, infrastructure and public services, and potentially increase distrust and disinformation." Overseas instability will feed UK extremism The strategy states: "Ungoverned spaces in the Middle East and North Africa will accentuate these challenges, along with illegal migration. Terrorism – from Islamist and Extreme Right Wing ideologies– will remain a persistent, and diversifying threat." And it warned: "The number of vulnerable young people who are desensitised, exploited and radicalised online is likely to increase, alongside more individuals who are fixated by extreme violence." Authoritarian states are going all-out It said: " Authoritarian states are putting in place multi-year plans to out-compete liberal democracies in every domain, from military modernisation to science and technology development, from their economic models to the information space. Since 2022, for example, Russia has massively increased defence spending, not just to prosecute war against Ukraine but also to replenish its defence industrial base and threaten others in its neighbourhood." And it warned that China's military programme "has potentially huge consequences for the lives of British citizens".
