How Samsung and 20 others missed out on an ambitious incentives scheme
Jatin Grover The telecom products manufacturing scheme was expected to generate incentives claims of more than ₹ 12,000 crore. But that's not how it turned out. Top manufacturers such Samsung, HFCL Ltd, Netweb Technologies, Kaynes International, Optiemus unit GDN Enterprises and state-owned ITI Ltd have not claimed any incentives yet.
Gift this article
An ambitious scheme to boost local telecom manufacturing is still far from its target, four years after the government set aside ₹ 12,000 crore to get companies to build everything from network gear to set-top boxes. While beneficiaries of the scheme have sold goods worth over ₹ 80,000 crore during the period, incentive claims are still a fraction of the originalallocation.
An ambitious scheme to boost local telecom manufacturing is still far from its target, four years after the government set aside ₹ 12,000 crore to get companies to build everything from network gear to set-top boxes. While beneficiaries of the scheme have sold goods worth over ₹ 80,000 crore during the period, incentive claims are still a fraction of the originalallocation.
Top manufacturers such Samsung, HFCL Ltd, Netweb Technologies, Kaynes International, Optiemus unit GDN Enterprises and state-owned ITI Ltd have not claimed any incentives yet, as they either failed to start manufacturing or were unable to meet targets. The result: only a tenth of the incentives have been claimed by manufacturers so far.
A Right To Information (RTI) request found that the scheme disbursed ₹ 1,162.04 crore by the end of FY25, against the ₹ 12,195 crore approved for five years. While 42 companies were shortlisted, only half claimed incentives. The scheme was introduced in February 2021 to incentivize the local manufacture of equipment such as network switches, transmission gear and set-top boxes.
According to industry executives, the reasons include weak order book and demand, competition within the segment and the inability to meet set targets of investments and sales. 'Missed opportunity'
'The reason why many players missed the opportunity is owing to the market structure compared to that of smartphone PLI," a consultant who works with companies said. Telecom PLI serves the B2B market where the companies already have fixed clients, while the more successful smartphone PLI serves the B2C market, the consultant said on the condition of anonymity.
The smartphone PLI scheme has been among the government's most successful ones. On 17 April, electronics and IT minister Ashwini Vaishnaw said in a post on X that in FY25, smartphone exports reached a record ₹ 2 trillion. Exports grew 55% in FY25.
The telecom PLI scheme offers incentives of 4-7% of the incremental sales over the years. In the first, second and third years, MSMEs get a 1% higher incentive.
'Samsung has not started production and is meeting the equipment supplies to Indian telcos from imports," an industry executive aware of the matter said. The company did not respond to a query. HFCL's plan
In February, domestic gear maker HFCL had said it expects to start claiming PLI incentives from FY26.
PLI amount, we have still not been able to claim because…the amount of revenue we thought would come from telecom equipment, which will make PLI available to us would not be fulfilled during the current financial year. So, we expect to start claiming PLI from the next financial year," Mahendra Nahata, promoter and managing director of HFCL told analysts during an earnings call in February.
'If at all we are able to claim, this (PLI incentive) should be around ₹ 40-50 crore," Nahata added. On 1 November 2022, HFCL had said it would invest around ₹ 425 crore towards the development and manufacture of various eligible products under the PLI scheme. The company had said it was granted approval to avail of incentives up to ₹ 652.79 crore as part of the government's production-linked incentive (PLI) scheme from FY23 to FY27.
Companies approved under the scheme were allowed to choose a period of five consecutive years either from FY22 to FY26, or FY23 to FY27, to achieve the net incremental sales.
Queries sent to the Union communications ministry which administers the scheme, as well as HFCL, Kaynes, Samsung, Optiemus, Netweb Technologies and ITI remained unanswered. 'Successful'
A government official, however, claimed the scheme was successful.
'The targets are set by the firms themselves. If they have not claimed any incentives, they may not have met the sales or investment target. Despite that, they have contributed to the overall sales and exports of telecom equipment," the official said on the condition of anonymity, adding the government steadily disburses the amounts.
The ministry's PLI dashboard showed that the beneficiaries under the telecom scheme have invested ₹ 4,139 crore and generated sales of ₹ 80,927 crore as of March end. The companies have generated a cumulative employment of 26,345.
Tata Group company Tejas Networks, which designs and manufactures telecom equipment, won incentives of ₹ 345.27 crore for FY23, FY24, and FY25 so far, the highest among all the companies, the RTI document showed. The company has gained from BSNL's 4G rollout order, and also exports its products to 75 countries.
Jabil Circuit India, which contract-manufactures for Ericsson and Apple, was the second in the list, claiming incentives of ₹ 236 crore, the RTI document showed. Right strategies
Contract manufacturers such as Flextronics Technologies India, Foxconn's Rising Stars Hi-Tech and Syrma SGS, got incentives of ₹ 90.31 crore, ₹ 80.33 crore, and ₹ 53.3 crore, respectively. VVDN Technologies and Dixon Electro Appliances received incentives of ₹ 48 crore and ₹ 34.8 crore so far, according to the document.
Also read: After a new lifeline, Vodafone Idea searches for a new CEO
'The success under the PLI scheme also depended on the right sales and investment strategies, which most medium-size companies have been able to meet. The government gave the companies a free hand to decide on the targets which, maybe, were overestimated by some companies," said Paritosh Prajapati, chief executive officer and founder of Sweden-based GX Group. The company is manufacturing routers, switches and other telecom equipment under the scheme in India and has received incentives of ₹ 20.9 crore.
Prajapati said the focus will now shift to exports as companies have set up domestic bases. Exports
By the end of FY25, total exports under the telecom PLI scheme were at ₹ 14,838 crore. Nokia Solutions and Networks India exported equipment worth ₹ 4,487 crore, followed by Jabil at ₹ 4,356 crore.
Nokia, so far, has been able to get incentives of only ₹ 47 crore under the scheme. The company supplies 4G/5G equipment to telecom operators in the country and globally.
US-based Commscope, which provides network infrastructure solutions, exported telecom equipment worth ₹ 2,882 crore under the scheme. Domestic players such as VVDN Technologies exported products worth ₹ 1,293 crore, followed by Syrma SGS at ₹ 583 crore and Tejas at ₹ 420 crore.
Sanmina-Sci India, a subsidiary of US-based Sanmina Corp., exported ₹ 384 crore worth of telecom equipment. Notably, Jio is currently manufacturing its devices in India under Reliance Industries' joint venture with Sanmina.
The Department of Telecommunications (DoT) had notified the PLI scheme for telecom and networking products in February 2021 with an outlay of ₹ 12,195 crore. The incentives for eligible companies were in the range of 4-7% based on incremental sales of telecom and networking products manufactured. For MSMEs, a 1% higher incentive was there in year 1, year 2 and year 3 of the scheme.
In June 2022, the government amended the scheme to facilitate design-led manufacturing with an additional incentive rate of 1% over and above the existing incentive rates. A sum of ₹ 4,000 crore from the ₹ 12,195 crore was set aside for the same.
The government also extended the tenure of the scheme from five years (FY22 to FY26) to 6 years (FY22 to FY27).
Companies approved under the scheme were allowed to choose a period of five consecutive years either from FY22 to FY26, or FY23 to FY27, to achieve the net incremental sales for the incentive claim. Investments, however, are allowed till FY25 or FY26 depending on the base year chosen by the companies. The extension was given as many companies failed to achieve their production targets due to covid-related supply chain disruptions when the scheme came into effect. Topics You May Be Interested In
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
27 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Authorities decide to commence land acquisition for Sabari rail
Bringing renewed hope to more than 2,000 families across central Travancore whose properties have been marked for the long-pending Sabari rail project, the Revenue department has decided to resume land acquisition for the project. Official sources said an online high-level meeting convened by the State government on Wednesday has directed the District Collectors of Ernakulam, Idukki and Kottayam to proceed with acquiring the required land. As part of this renewed effort, the previously functional land acquisition offices at Perumbavoor and Pala will be reopened, while new offices are slated to be established in Muvattupuzha and Kanjirappally. 'Work on the project is expected to formally begin with the visit of a high-level team from the Indian Railways early next month,' sources said. The meeting also decided to retain the existing alignment of the rail line. The project is being planned in such a way that land acquisition and construction can proceed simultaneously. 24.4 hectares acquired So far, 24.4 hectares of land have been acquired for the project in the Angamaly–Kalady stretch. However, more than 200 hectares still need to be acquired across the three districts. In the first phase, land will be acquired from Kalady to Ramapuram. The second phase, covering the stretch from Ramapuram to Erumely, will follow completion of alignment surveys and a Social Impact Assessment (SIA). 'A special revenue team will be deployed for this purpose,' the sources added. As the initial notification for acquiring land for the project was issued prior to the introduction of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act in 2013, the government will have to restart the entire process in accordance with the new legislation. According to officials, a new government order (GO) for the land acquisition will be issued shortly to commence the proceedings. CM's meet The approval for the construction of the rail line connecting Angamaly and Erumely, the gateway to Sabarimala was announced after a meeting held between Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan and Union Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw in New Delhi recently. The 111.48-km line was proposed in the 1997-98 Budget.
Hans India
27 minutes ago
- Hans India
The Top 5 Most Active Commodities for Trading in India
India's dynamic commodity markets offer many opportunities for traders and investors, fueled by the nation's immense consumption, agricultural backbone, and burgeoning industrial sector. While the direct ownership of physical commodities can be impractical, financial instruments such as futures contracts and Contracts for Difference (CFDs) provide accessible avenues for speculating on price movements and gaining exposure to these vital markets. In India, commodity futures trading is predominantly facilitated by two major exchanges: the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX) and the National Commodity & Derivatives Exchange (NCDEX). The MCX leads the non-agricultural segment to trade commodities, encompassing precious metals, industrial metals, and energy, while the NCDEX specializes in agricultural commodities. This article will explore India's five most actively traded commodities, exploring their market dynamics. 1. Gold: The Eternal Safe Haven and Cultural Cornerstone Gold holds a unique and revered position in the Indian psyche, extending far beyond mere investment to encompass deep cultural and traditional significance. It is an indispensable part of weddings and festivals, and a crucial generational asset. This deep-rooted domestic demand and its global status as a safe-haven asset firmly establish gold as one of India's most actively traded commodities. Market Dynamics and Price Influencers: Cultural and Festival Demand: Indian festivals and wedding seasons consistently drive significant gold demand, notably influencing local prices. Global Economic Conditions: During economic uncertainty, geopolitical tensions, or inflationary pressures, investors flock to gold as a store of value, pushing prices higher. Conversely, a strong global economy and rising interest rates (making fixed-income assets more appealing) can exert downward pressure. During economic uncertainty, geopolitical tensions, or inflationary pressures, investors flock to gold as a store of value, pushing prices higher. Conversely, a strong global economy and rising interest rates (making fixed-income assets more appealing) can exert downward pressure. Central Bank Monetary Policies: Interest rate decisions by major central banks (such as the US Federal Reserve) significantly impact gold prices. Higher interest rates increase the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding assets like gold. US Dollar Strength: Gold is predominantly priced in US dollars. A stronger dollar makes gold more expensive for holders of other currencies, potentially dampening demand and vice versa. Inflation Expectations: Gold is widely regarded as a hedge against inflation. When inflation rises, a currency's purchasing power declines, prompting investors to seek refuge in assets like gold, which tend to retain their value. Gold is widely regarded as a hedge against inflation. When inflation rises, a currency's purchasing power declines, prompting investors to seek refuge in assets like gold, which tend to retain their value. Supply and Demand Fundamentals: Global mining output, recycling activities, and demand from jewelry manufacturers and industrial applications all influence price discovery. Global mining output, recycling activities, and demand from jewelry manufacturers and industrial applications all influence price discovery. Appeal for Traders: Gold's consistent liquidity, sensitivity to global macroeconomic factors, and traditional safe-haven appeal make it a popular choice for short-term speculative trading and long-term hedging against economic instability. 2. Crude Oil: The Global Economy's Energy Powerhouse Crude oil, often dubbed "black gold," is the lifeblood of the global economy. As a primary energy source for transportation, industrial production, and electricity generation, its price fluctuations have far-reaching implications. As a major oil importer, India is particularly sensitive to global crude oil price movements, making it an extremely active commodity for trading. Market Dynamics and Price Influencers: Global Supply and Demand Balance: The fundamental principle of supply and demand dictates crude oil prices. Economic growth fuels demand, while production levels from major oil-producing nations (OPEC+, US shale producers, Russia) directly influence supply. The fundamental principle of supply and demand dictates crude oil prices. Economic growth fuels demand, while production levels from major oil-producing nations (OPEC+, US shale producers, Russia) directly influence supply. Geopolitical Tensions: Conflicts and instability in key oil-producing regions (e.g., the Middle East) can disrupt supply chains and trigger significant price spikes. Conflicts and instability in key oil-producing regions (e.g., the Middle East) can disrupt supply chains and trigger significant price spikes. OPEC Decisions: The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and its allies (OPEC+) play a pivotal role in managing global oil supply through production quotas, directly impacting prices. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and its allies (OPEC+) play a pivotal role in managing global oil supply through production quotas, directly impacting prices. Key Economic Indicators: Industrial production data, manufacturing output, and global GDP growth forecasts all impact the outlook for crude oil demand. Industrial production data, manufacturing output, and global GDP growth forecasts all impact the outlook for crude oil demand. Currency Exchange Rates: The INR to USD exchange rate is a crucial factor for India. A weaker rupee makes imported oil more expensive in terms of local currency. The INR to USD exchange rate is a crucial factor for India. A weaker rupee makes imported oil more expensive in terms of local currency. Technological Advancements: Developments in extraction methods (like fracking) can increase supply, while advancements in renewable energy sources can influence long-term demand trends. Trading Avenues in India: Appeal for Traders: Crude oil's high volatility and sensitivity to a wide array of global events provide ample opportunities for speculative traders. Its direct impact on inflation and economic growth makes it a crucial commodity for macro-focused traders. 3. Silver: The Dynamic Industrial Precious Metal While often in the shadow of gold, silver firmly holds its own as both a precious metal and an industrial commodity. Its dual nature makes its price dynamics fascinating and frequently more volatile than gold. In India, silver is extensively used in jewelry, silverware, and various industrial applications, making it a prominent commodity in the trading landscape. Market Dynamics and Price Influencers: Industrial Demand: A substantial portion of silver's demand originates from industrial applications, including electronics, solar panels, the automotive industry, and medical devices. This makes its price highly sensitive to global industrial growth and technological advancements. A substantial portion of silver's demand originates from industrial applications, including electronics, solar panels, the automotive industry, and medical devices. This makes its price highly sensitive to global industrial growth and technological advancements. Investment Demand: Like gold, silver also functions as a safe-haven asset, attracting investment during economic uncertainty and inflationary pressures. Like gold, silver also functions as a safe-haven asset, attracting investment during economic uncertainty and inflationary pressures. Correlation with Gold Prices: Silver often moves in tandem with gold, though typically with higher volatility due to its smaller market size and significant industrial demand component. Silver often moves in tandem with gold, though typically with higher volatility due to its smaller market size and significant industrial demand component. Mining Output: Most silver is produced as a byproduct of mining other metals (such as lead, zinc, copper, and gold), making its supply somewhat inelastic to direct silver price changes. Most silver is produced as a byproduct of mining other metals (such as lead, zinc, copper, and gold), making its supply somewhat inelastic to direct silver price changes. Currency Fluctuations: Similar to gold, a stronger US dollar can make silver more expensive for international buyers, potentially impacting demand. Similar to gold, a stronger US dollar can make silver more expensive for international buyers, potentially impacting demand. Appeal for Traders: Silver's compelling combination of industrial utility and precious metal status makes it an attractive asset. Its higher volatility than gold can lead to larger profit opportunities, albeit with increased risk. 4. Natural Gas: The Evolving Transition Fuel Natural gas is an increasingly vital global energy source for electricity generation, industrial processes, and residential heating. Its clean-burning properties position it as a key transition fuel in the worldwide shift towards renewable energy. In India, growing domestic consumption and increasing industrial reliance on natural gas contribute significantly to its active trading on commodity exchanges. Market Dynamics and Price Influencers: Seasonal Demand: Natural gas prices are highly influenced by seasonal weather patterns, with demand typically peaking during colder winter months (for heating) and hotter summer months (for air conditioning, impacting electricity generation). Natural gas prices are highly influenced by seasonal weather patterns, with demand typically peaking during colder winter months (for heating) and hotter summer months (for air conditioning, impacting electricity generation). Supply Levels: Production levels from major gas-producing regions (e.g., US, Russia, Qatar), storage levels, and infrastructure developments (pipelines, LNG terminals) significantly impact supply. Production levels from major gas-producing regions (e.g., US, Russia, Qatar), storage levels, and infrastructure developments (pipelines, LNG terminals) significantly impact supply. Geopolitical Events: Disruptions to pipeline flows or political tensions involving major gas suppliers can cause significant price volatility. Disruptions to pipeline flows or political tensions involving major gas suppliers can cause significant price volatility. Inventory Reports: Weekly inventory reports from major consumer nations (like the US) provide crucial insights into supply-demand balances and often trigger short-term price movements. Weekly inventory reports from major consumer nations (like the US) provide crucial insights into supply-demand balances and often trigger short-term price movements. Competition from Other Fuels: The price of natural gas can be influenced by the competitiveness of other energy sources, such as coal and crude oil. The price of natural gas can be influenced by the competitiveness of other energy sources, such as coal and crude oil. Appeal for Traders: Natural gas offers substantial price volatility, particularly due to seasonal demand and geopolitical factors. This creates frequent trading opportunities for those who can accurately assess market sentiment and supply-demand dynamics. 5. Copper: "Dr. Copper" - The Economic Barometer Copper, often affectionately dubbed "Dr. Copper" due to its uncanny ability to predict economic health, is a critical industrial metal. Its widespread use in electrical wiring, construction, manufacturing, and emerging green technologies (electric vehicles, renewable energy infrastructure) makes its demand a strong indicator of global economic activity. India's accelerating infrastructure development and manufacturing growth contribute to the active trading of copper. Market Dynamics and Price Influencers: Global Economic Growth: Copper demand is a fundamental building block of modern economies, and it directly correlates with global GDP growth, industrial output, and construction activity. Copper demand is a fundamental building block of modern economies, and it directly correlates with global GDP growth, industrial output, and construction activity. Infrastructure Spending: Government and private sector investments in infrastructure projects (roads, railways, power grids) drive significant copper demand. Government and private sector investments in infrastructure projects (roads, railways, power grids) drive significant copper demand. Urbanization and Industrialization: Rapid urbanization and industrialization in developing economies, particularly China (the most significant consumer), are major drivers of copper demand. Rapid urbanization and industrialization in developing economies, particularly China (the most significant consumer), are major drivers of copper demand. Green Energy Transition: The increasing adoption of electric vehicles, solar power, and wind energy, which are highly copper-intensive, represents a significant long-term demand driver. The increasing adoption of electric vehicles, solar power, and wind energy, which are highly copper-intensive, represents a significant long-term demand driver. Supply Disruptions: Mining disruptions due to labor strikes, natural disasters, or geopolitical issues in major producing countries (e.g., Chile, Peru) can impact supply and prices. Mining disruptions due to labor strikes, natural disasters, or geopolitical issues in major producing countries (e.g., Chile, Peru) can impact supply and prices. Inventory Levels: Global inventory levels of copper in warehouses provide crucial insights into the immediate supply-demand balance. Global inventory levels of copper in warehouses provide crucial insights into the immediate supply-demand balance. Appeal for Traders: Copper's strong correlation with global economic health makes it an attractive commodity for traders seeking to capitalize on broad economic trends. Its integral role in the green energy transition also provides a compelling long-term outlook for potential price appreciation. Conclusion: Navigating India's Vibrant Commodity Market The Indian commodity market offers a wealth of opportunities for astute traders and investors. Gold, Crude Oil, Silver, Natural Gas, and Copper consistently stand out as the most active commodities, each possessing unique drivers and trading characteristics. Futures contracts on established exchanges like MCX and NCDEX provide regulated and highly liquid avenues for participation, offering transparency and robust trading infrastructure. Thorough research, robust risk management strategies, and a comprehensive awareness of domestic and international market dynamics are essential for success in India's dynamic commodity trading arena.
The Hindu
32 minutes ago
- The Hindu
First edition of Bengaluru Coin Exhibition 2025 set to enthrall numismatic enthusiasts
The first edition of the Bengaluru Coin Exhibition 2025, a gathering for coin collectors and history enthusiasts, is set to begin on June 13 at Shikshakara Sadana, Kempegowda Road, near Mysore Bank Circle, Bengaluru. The three-day exhibition, organised by numismatists and institutions from across the country, celebrates over 2,500 years of India's rich and diverse coinage history. From ancient punch-marked coins to the coinage of the Mughal and colonial eras, and from regional mints to modern commemorative issues, the event promises an unmatched showcase of India's monetary heritage. Notably, coins from the Ganga period are on display, offering a rare glimpse into Karnataka's ancient monetary systems. The event will also highlight Karnataka's own contribution to Indian numismatics, through displays of local and regional coinage. Among the highlights are coins dating back to the 6th century BCE, offering visitors a chance to explore the earliest forms of Indian currency. The collection spans an impressive historical timeline, including coins from the illustrious Vijayanagara empire and the royal Mysuru Wadiyar dynasty, showcasing the rich and layered narrative of South India's monetary legacy. Adding to the grandeur, a selection of gold coins once owned by kings from across the country has also been put on display, reflecting the artistry of royal Indian mints. In total, nearly one lakh coins are on display, making this one of the largest and most comprehensive exhibitions ever held in India's numismatic history. The highlight of the exhibition will be two major numismatic auctions — Falcon Auctions and Travancore Heritage Auctions — featuring rare and collectible coins, banknotes, and medals. More than 100 top exhibitors and dealers from across the country will participate, offering items for sale, trade, and display. Visitors can also benefit from free valuation services and guidance sessions for budding collectors. Expert lectures and knowledge sessions will be held alongside the exhibition. The event is free and open to all — students, families, researchers, and the general public. The exhibition runs from June 13 to 15 and promises to be an immersive cultural experience for anyone curious about India's past.
