‘Phule' review: Too much like textbook history
Writer-director Ananth Narayan Mahadevan bookends his 129-minute biopic on social reformers and educationists Jyotirao and Savitribai Phule with the events of 1897. Poona is devastated by the plague. Savitribai runs across parched land to bring an ailing child to a makeshift medical camp.
Before the doctors can pronounce a prognosis, events move back in time to 1848. Savitri was a child bride then, married to the slightly older Jyotirao Phule who, even as a teenager, was progressive enough to want his wife to be educated. This did not sit well with his conservative father (Vinay Pathak). Undeterred, Jyotirao continued to encourage not just his wife, but also the younger village girls, to learn.
Now older and more committed, the Phules' egalitarian practices and focus on social reform conflicted with the caste hierarchy of the time. The ire of higher-caste men, enraged that the 'untouchables' were stepping out of their lane, compelled the couple to move away from their family home.
Joy Sengupta plays the upper-caste Vinayak, Darsheel Safary is the adopted son Yashwant Phule, and Amit Behl plays the head priest. Sharad Kelkar serves as narrator, giving the staccato screenplay some cohesion.
The landed Phule was both businessman and social reformer. The film progresses through key life moments, almost as if visually and dutifully depicting Wikipedia entries for the Phules. From Jyotirao teaching his wife, to setting up schools for girls, taking a stand against widow discrimination, forming the Satyashodhak Samaj, encouraging Savitri and Fatima to become the first female teachers in India, and challenging the caste system—every landmark moment and action is perfunctorily depicted. Add to this a leaden cinematic language and basic storytelling (co-written by Muazzam Beg), which makes Phule feel like a rendition from a history textbook.
Phule reads and rereads Thomas Paine's 1791 book Rights of Man. Inspired by the writings, he stokes his own little revolution that includes enrolling Savitri (Patralekhaa) and his friend's sister, Fatima Shaikh (Akshaya Gurav), in a teacher training programme and galvanising barbers to reject age-old oppressive practices. While Fatima is barely given any speaking scenes, we do see Savitri's empowerment and confidence increase. Jyotirao encourages and supports her, and Savitri bravely leans into her agency, even when upper-caste Brahmins humiliate her. Patralekhaa Paul is forceful and spirited in those latter scenes—an energy that is missing from Jyotirao—yet Gandhi interprets this historical character with reverence and solemnity.
Mahadevan respectfully enforces Savitri and Jyotirao's rock-solid partnership, their mutual respect, and unfaltering commitment to a greater cause—one that still feels pertinent.
First Published: 26 Apr 2025, 04:54 PM IST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 hours ago
- Time of India
Criticism refines the actor in us: Sandeep Pradeep
Actor Sandeep Pradeep has had an eventful year so far, playing prominent roles in Alappuzha Gymkhana and Padakkalam, both of which earned him critical acclaim. The Falimy actor, who is currently filming Kishkindakandam fame Dinjith Ayyathan's new project, speaks to us about his films, evolving fanbase, and future prospects. Excerpts: 'There was a strong sense of team work behind Padakkalam' Padakkalam was Manu's (director Manu Swaraj ) first film. He had previously worked on Minnal Murali, so he had experience in the fantasy genre. He's also a comic geek, and the way he presented the story — with excitement and confidence —really impressed me. The content itself was something fresh and unexplored. I was struck by how, as a newcomer, he chose to tackle such a challenging genre. Manu had a clear vision for his film. There was a strong sense of teamwork behind the project, and I believe it's that collaborative spirit that helped elevate the film. 'Off-screen chemistry helped our performances' Falimy was a breakthrough for me as an actor, and I got to share the screen with Jagadeesh ettan. Now, working with Suraj ettan (Suraj Venjaramoodu) and Sharfikka (Sharafudheen), I truly appreciate how welcoming they are toward newcomers. It's hard to perform well if your co-actors don't create a comfortable working environment. If I were to be acting 20 years from now, I hope to treat newcomers with the same warmth they've shown me. This film also demanded a strong off-screen chemistry and communication between us, which really helped our performances. 'Khalid was upfront about the hardwork required' Khalid Rahman approached me for Alappuzha Gymkhana about a month after Falimy was released. He told me upfront that the role would be physically demanding — I'd likely be beaten up a lot — and that I should only commit if I was ready for it. I was already a big fan of his work, so I immediately agreed. It wasn't just me; everyone involved gave their 100% to the project. 'Had to balance my weight and build a boxer's build' My character in Alappuzha Gymkhana competes in the 65kg boxing category. I was informed early on that there would be a weighing scene, so I needed to maintain exactly 65kg. I was already at that weight, but I didn't have the physique of a boxer. The real challenge was maintaining the weight while building a boxer's frame. Our coaches played a crucial role in helping us achieve that balance. 'A good film is one that satisfies me personally irrespective of its success' Even when I first started dreaming of a film career, my motto was to never settle for just what comes my way. We need to actively seek what we truly want — only then can we reach our goals. Of course, I want to do good films. Before I had a Wikipedia page, I used to joke with friends that when I do have one, it should list a lot of kidilam (awesome) films. If we accept every offer without discernment, a misstep could define our careers. For me, a good film is one that satisfies me personally — not necessarily a box office hit. The film should make me happy, no matter its result. 'I value honest criticism ' My closest friends and family are honest critics of my work. They know me well — my personality and behaviour — so, sometimes, they'll point out when my real-life traits seep into my characters. That's why I always try to shed those traits when acting. I believe criticism helps refine us, and I'm always open to it. Check out our list of the latest Hindi , English , Tamil , Telugu , Malayalam , and Kannada movies . Don't miss our picks for the best Hindi movies , best Tamil movies, and best Telugu films .
India.com
2 days ago
- India.com
This 3 hour 2 minute movie broke all records, became highest grosser, earned Rs..., climax will blow your mind, lead actors are...
Some movies, when they are in the making, the makers often wish for them to become a blockbuster. However, sometimes the film either mints money at the box office or becomes a disaster. Today, we will talk about a film that has scored the 4th spot in the list of highest-grossing films. Made on a budget of Rs 550 crore, this film minted more than Rs 1,200 crore. With a stellar cast and power-packed performances, this movie created history after its release. If you are wondering which movie we are talking about, then it is RRR. Directed by S. S. Rajamouli, the movie features N. T. Rama Rao Jr. and Ram Charan in the lead roles. The Telugu-language epic action drama film was released in 2022 and created a stir upon release. RRR was based on the fictionalised versions of Indian revolutionaries Komaram Bheem and Alluri Sitarama Raju. Apart from these two leads, the movie also featured Ajay Devgn, Alia Bhatt, Shriya Saran, Samuthirakani, Ray Stevenson, Alison Doody, and Olivia Morris in supporting roles. The movie gives a tribute to the revolutionaries and how they fought against oppression. RRR Box Office Collection According to Wikipedia, RRR collected between Rs 1,253–1,387 crore, and with that, the film secured the fourth spot on the highest-grossing films' list. If you haven't watched SS Rajamouli's classic yet, then switch to OTT giant Netflix and enjoy!
India.com
2 days ago
- India.com
This 2 hour 19 minute mystery thriller will blow your mind, suspense starts from the first minute, beats Drishyam in climax, has 7.3 IMDb rating, lead actors are…, film is…
Aamir Khan has played all kinds of roles in his career. His films force people to think. But one of his films released in 2012 shook people's minds. Kareena Kapoor was seen in the lead role in this film. The mystery and especially the suspense of the film was such that by the end everyone's ideas failed. The name of the Aamir Khan film we are talking about is 'Talaash: The Answer Lies Within'. Aamir Khan, Kareena Kapoor Khan, and Rani Mukherji were seen in lead roles in the film. Rajkumar Rao also appeared in a small role in the film. Nawazuddin Siddiqui plays a pivotal role in this thriller. Aamir's film was a box office hit as soon as it was released. Especially the mystery thriller of the film is something people have not forgotten even today. The songs of this film, written and directed by Reema Kagti, were also liked a lot. According to Wikipedia data, this film, made in Rs 50 crore, did great business at the box office. The film collected Rs 174.21 crore worldwide. This film is still in the hearts of people. In this suspense thriller film, Aamir played the role of a police officer. He is investigating a case during which he meets Kareena Kapoor. But Aamir finally came to know that the girl Rosie, i.e. Kareena, whom he is looking for in the film, is dead. Aamir himself was shocked to know this truth in this film. People were left stunned after seeing the suspense of the film. Let us tell you that Rani Mukerji played the role of Aamir's wife in this film. People liked the film a lot. The film's massive earnings surprised even the makers. The suspense in the film starts in the first minute of the film and continues till the end.
