Chignecto Isthmus case waste of Nova Scotia Court of Appeal's time: federal lawyer
The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal heard the second day of arguments in the Chignecto Isthmus case on Wednesday.
HALIFAX — Nova Scotia and New Brunswick's attempt to persuade a panel of judges to conclude Ottawa has responsibility for the infrastructure on the Chignecto Isthmus is a 'waste and abuse' of the court's time, a federal lawyer argued Wednesday.
Lawyer Lori Ward told a three-member Nova Scotia Court of Appeal panel that 'the ultimate issue despite all protestations to the contrary, is funding.'
'It's clear that Nova Scotia writ large designed this reference as a political pressure tactic to be used as ammunition in the political arena and as such we would argue that it's not just a waste of this court's time, it is an abuse of this court's time,' said Ward.
The isthmus has had large dikes since 1671, when Acadian settlers arrived, and there are currently about 35 kilometres of dikes that help protect roads, farms and communities.
Nova Scotia has long maintained that the federal government should pay the entire cost of upgrading protections for the isthmus -- currently estimated at $650 million -- but Ottawa has agreed to pay only half of the project.
In July 2023, the province asked the court to settle the constitutional question of whether the transportation, trade and communication links across the Chignecto Isthmus are within the exclusive legislative authority of parliament. The question of who should fund any upgrades was not part of the court reference.
Nova Scotia was joined in the court case by New Brunswick, while Prince Edward Island was also granted intervener status.
Ward pointed out that even if it's decided that Ottawa has sole jurisdiction over the low-lying, narrow strip of land that connects the two provinces, it would have no obligation to fund projects aimed at preventing catastrophic flooding.
'So what is the point of asking you to find exclusive jurisdiction?' she asked the court.
'Practically speaking things are unfolding as they should be, just like they did in the 1940s,' Ward said. 'Canada has agreed to pay 50 per cent of the cost and is working with the provinces.'
As she did in a hearing in March, Ward asked the court to decline to answer the question, but she added that if it does decide to rule on the merits of the case it should do so 'in the negative.'
The court reserved its decision on Wednesday.
The provinces maintain that Ottawa has the responsibility to protect rail, power and communication lines as well as inter-provincial trade from climate-change impacts, but federal lawyer Jan Jensen argued that this does not require Canada to protect the dikes.
Jensen argued that there was no evidence that the dikes alone are necessary to protect infrastructure such as the rail line.
'It's not clear at what level of sea level rise that the rail line's own embankments and bridges are not sufficient,' he said.
Daniel Boyle, a lawyer for Nova Scotia's attorney general, had argued during a hearing on Tuesday that an eight-metre storm surge would flow over the dikes and submerge the highway and the rail line. At 12 metres, he said 'Nova Scotia would effectively become an island.'
During his reply to the court on Wednesday, Boyle was asked by Justice David Farrar how he could 'divorce himself' from previous comments made by Premier Tim Houston, who recently wrote a letter to Prime Minister Mark Carney seeking confirmation that Ottawa would agree 'should the court decide that paying for the isthmus is a federal responsibility.'
'Counsel for Nova Scotia have consistently throughout this proceeding maintained and made clear that funding is not at stake,' Boyle said. 'Nova Scotia's position has been that the outcome of this proceeding could advance discussions. This is a reference opinion, it's an advisory opinion.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 21, 2025.
The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Alberta resumes buying U.S. alcohol and gambling machines, months after pause meant to fight tariffs
Alberta is buying American alcohol and gambling machines again, three months after Premier Danielle Smith announced restrictions aimed at fighting back against U.S. tariffs. Service Alberta Minister Dale Nally says the move signals a 'renewed commitment to open and fair trade' with the United States. Smith said in March that the province would no longer buy U.S. alcohol and video lottery terminals, or sign contracts with American companies. That came a day after U.S. President Donald Trump slapped heavy tariffs on Canadian goods and energy. Nally says the decision to resume buying U.S. alcohol and gambling machines 'sets the stage for more constructive negotiations' ahead of a renewal of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico trade agreement. Ontario, Manitoba reach internal trade agreement, promise alcohol sales deal by end of June The minister says Albertans are encouraged to continue supporting local producers, even as more U.S. options return to store shelves. Nally said in April that the province was pausing its policy around procurement from U.S. companies 'in the spirit of diplomacy.' He said since the province's retaliatory measures were first announced in early March, the Trump administration had put a hold on further tariffs.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Laval and police brotherhood sign ‘bold' new collective agreement
The City of Laval and the Police Brotherhood signed a new collective agreement for the Laval Police Service on Friday—a deal Mayor Stéphane Boyer described as 'fairly bold, fairly innovative compared to other police forces.' The agreement, in principle, was ratified by 78 per cent of the police brotherhood's members. It includes the transfer of certain administrative duties to civilian staff, freeing up 20,000 additional investigative hours for police officers—at a lower cost to the city. The new contract also introduces the deployment of cadets across Laval to manage traffic, representing another salary-saving measure for the municipality. In terms of compensation, the agreement includes salary increases totalling 22.2 per cent over five years. This figure combines base wage hikes with 'urban security premiums' tied to the unique challenges officers face in large urban centres. The city also aimed to boost police presence on the streets to strengthen residents' sense of safety. In an interview, Mayor Boyer said he was particularly proud of the deal. 'What we were looking for was greater efficiency and more officers on the streets. This agreement allows us to achieve that. And in my view, it's quite a bold and innovative deal compared to other police forces—recovering thousands of hours of investigation and street presence. We're really pleased with the outcome, and I think it's going to be a win-win, both for the officers and for the public,' said Boyer. Sylvain Tardif, president of the Laval Police Brotherhood, also welcomed the new agreement, saying it 'recognizes the dedication and professionalism officers bring to their work every day in keeping Laval residents safe.' 'The new contract offers working conditions that reflect the growing responsibilities of our officers, who work in a complex environment and are facing an evolving and increasingly sophisticated criminal landscape,' Tardif added. Pierre Brochet, director of the Laval Police Service, also noted that the new agreement will allow police to 'fight crime more effectively, while ensuring a stronger presence in the community.' The collective agreement will be in effect from Jan. 1, 2024, to Dec. 31, 2028. This report by The Canadian Press was first published in French on June 6, 2025. By Lia Lévesque, The Canadian Press
Winnipeg Free Press
2 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Alberta resumes buying U.S. alcohol, months after pause meant to fight tariffs
EDMONTON – Alberta is buying American alcohol and gambling machines again, three months after Premier Danielle Smith announced restrictions aimed at fighting back against U.S. tariffs. Service Alberta Minister Dale Nally says the move signals a 'renewed commitment to open and fair trade' with the United States. Smith said in March that the province would no longer buy U.S. alcohol and video lottery terminals, or sign contracts with American companies. That came a day after U.S. President Donald Trump slapped heavy tariffs on Canadian goods and energy. Nally says the decision to resume buying U.S. alcohol and gambling machines 'sets the stage for more constructive negotiations' ahead of a renewal of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico trade agreement. The minister says Albertans are encouraged to continue supporting local producers, even as more U.S. options return to store shelves. Nally said in April that the province was pausing its policy around procurement from U.S. companies 'in the spirit of diplomacy.' Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. He said since the province's retaliatory measures were first announced in early March, the Trump administration had put a hold on further tariffs. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 6, 2025.
