logo
Family of man crushed by machine disappointed at fine imposed on business

Family of man crushed by machine disappointed at fine imposed on business

The family of a man killed after being crushed by a machine whose safety features had been modified against expert advice has expressed disappointment at the 'low' fine imposed on the owner of a sand and gravel business in Kildare over his death.
N & C Enterprises Limited of Kilmeague, Co Kildare, was fined €75,000 at Naas Circuit Criminal Court after the company pleaded guilty to three breaches of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 over its failure to provide a safe working environment for its staff.
Louie Borges (41) a father of two from Churchview, Kilmeague, Co Kildare was fatally injured at the quarry operated by the accused in Kilmeague, Co Kildare on February 15, 2019.
The court heard Mr Borges was crushed by a machine whose safety features had been modified without the approval of the manufacturer of the equipment whose staff had expressed shock and disgust at the alterations during a visit to the quarry in April 2018.
Mr Borges, a Portuguese national, was killed instantly in an unwitnessed incident when he was crushed by a robotic arm of the machine which was used for wrapping sand and aggregate in plastic after entering an enclosed area.
An inspector with the Health and Safety Authority, Vincent Darcy, gave evidence the equipment was designed to automatically shut down once an access gate was opened.
However, Mr Darcy said two other gates which by-passed the safety mechanism had been added after the machine was first installed in 2017 to allow easier access to clean up material after plastic wrapping was bursting after getting caught in the equipment.
The HSA inspector said an engineer with the equipment's manufacturer had placed locks on the retrofitted gates when he inspected them in October 2018.
Evidence was heard that staff were under pressure to increase productivity and a record 6,000 bags had been packaged on the day before the fatal incident when the normal daily volume was 4,000.
The court heard that the packing facility had subsequently been sold to Kilsaran, while the quarry had been converted to a landfill site, while staff numbers have fallen from 43 to eight.
In a victim impact statement, the deceased's long-term partner, Laura Murphy, expressed concern at how the company had disregarded safety measures at the quarry.
She also claimed N & C Enterprises had shown disrespect as her family had been met with 'utter silence' when none of the company's directors had gone to Mr Borges funeral.
'That hurt more than you will ever know,' said Ms Murphy.
The victim's brother, Nuno Borges, said his brother had taken the difficult decision to leave his son in Portugal to come to Ireland to make a better life for them.
Mr Borges said his family felt 'anger, despair and disbelief' and his elderly parents no longer visit Ireland as it 'hurts too much.'
He said they were very angry with the company and its directors as they had shown no remorse or compassion and had made no offer to support them with funeral costs.
At a hearing of the case last January, counsel for N & C Enterprises, Ronan Kennedy SC offered the company's deep and profound regret for what happened.
Mr Kennedy said one of the firm's directors, Clement Gavin, had been extremely moved by the victim impact statements.
'There is not a day goes by that he wishes he was not more persistent in being more proactive in intervening to address issues flagged to the company,' he added.
He explained that Mr Gavin had not attended the funeral because he was suffering severe mental health issues at the time which had resulted in his absence from work for a lengthy period.
Mr Kennedy said he was instructed to make no excuses for what had happened.
However, he observed that the strained relationship between Mr Gavin and his brother and fellow director, Joe who exited the company had unquestionably contributed to such an unfortunate tragedy.
At a sentencing hearing on Monday, Judge Martina Baxter, said it was a reflection of the deceased's character that he was 'willing to get stuck in' with helping at work.
The court heard he had not been trained on the machine and had been advised by a colleague not to go near it.
Judge Baxter noted that the company had been warned before the fatal incident about concerns how the additional gates by-passed the automatic shutdown safety mechanism.
'It was an accident that had clearly been anticipated and pointed out,' she remarked.
The judge also acknowledged that Mr Gavin had saved the company from a perilous financial situation after his brother had wanted to sell the business.
However, she accepted the company was now a scaled-down version of the business at the time of Mr Borges' death.
Judge Baxter said nobody could not but be moved by the victim impact statements of the deceased's relatives.
'Their loss is monumental and they will never recover. He was a man beloved by all and a vital cog in his family unit,' she added.
The judge said she accepted the remorse and apology of Mr Gavin was sincere and genuine as well as the fact that no disrespect was intended by him towards Mr Borges' family.
Imposing a fine of €75,000 on the company, Judge Baxter noted Mr Gavin had saved it from insolvency but it was a small firm and any financial sanction should not cause undue hardship.
The maximum fine allowed under legislation is €3 million.
'It is vital for companies to ensure they continuously assess and monitor safety features in the workplace,' the judge added.
She allowed N & C Enterprises three months to pay the fine as well as the prosecution's legal costs of €4,057.
Outside the court, Ms Murphy expressed disappointment at the low level of the fine and the prosecution being limited to a corporate entity.
'There were plenty of e-mails and visits that told them they should not be altering anything but they went ahead and kept making it unsafe,' said Ms Murphy.
Her brother-in-law shared the same view, adding: 'What we really wanted was someone to be found responsible and brought to court – not just a company.'
Commenting on the proceedings, HSA assistant chief executive, Mark Cullen, said the fatal incident was 'entirely foreseeable and preventable.'
Mr Cullen said employers needed to ensure employees were not put in danger by unsafe work practices which bypass crucial safety devices.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Explosive Sun Madeleine McCann doc reveals bombshell new evidence and why Christian Brueckner is prime suspect
Explosive Sun Madeleine McCann doc reveals bombshell new evidence and why Christian Brueckner is prime suspect

The Irish Sun

time15 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

Explosive Sun Madeleine McCann doc reveals bombshell new evidence and why Christian Brueckner is prime suspect

EXPLOSIVE new Madeleine McCann evidence can finally be revealed in a bombshell documentary. The Sun's world exclusive doc lifts the lid on gripping new information and reveals why 6 Madeleine McCann disappeared in Praia da Luz, Portugal in May 2007 Credit: AFP 6 Christian Brueckner, prime suspect in the case, is in jail in Germany but due to be released in September Credit: Dan Charity 6 The recent search for DNA evidence failed to turn up any clues Credit: Dan Charity Our compelling investigation unveils the horrors found at his abandoned factory lair - and his The dossier of overwhelming circumstantial evidence includes exclusive images of We also reveal how cops found a mask, guns and child kidnap stories where read more on the documentary Our film reveals the existence of an And it also placed Breuckner at the key Maddie search location of the Arades Dam, in Portugal. A document puts the suspect at the location where he allegedly confessed by supposedly saying ' We also reveal sick child kidnap stories where Breuckner wrote: 'A very small girl enters the room. She's definitely not older than five. Most read in The Sun 'Blonde, long hair tied in pigtails bounces cheekily back and forth as she comes towards me. I feel like I'm in paradise right now." Madeleine McCann cops call off search as trawl of Brueckner's 'rat run' turns up nothing Online messages we uncovered from Brueckner He even threatened it wouldn't matter 'if the evidence is destroyed afterwards' and gleefully added: 'I'll make a lot of films... hehe.' Our documentary on the police files represents the biggest leap forwards in understanding of the case since German police revealed Brueckner as a suspect in 2020. It contains an interview with Germany last year. Hear from experts at The Sun and in Germany about the ongoing race against time to stop dangerous Brueckner being released in as little as three months. 6 A hidden hard drive with photos taken in Portugal convinced police Madeleine died soon after vanishing 6 Cops found 75 youngsters' swimming costumes at childless Brueckner's bolthole in Neuwegersleben Credit: Dan Charity 6 Children's toys and bikes were found at the suspect's lair Credit: Dan Charity And learn more about fears he could potentially take hopes for the McCann case to ground with him. Christian Brueckner refuses to answer police questions or provide an alibi, but has never been formally charged over the disappearance of murder of Madeleine McCann. He has German and Portuguese police used JCB-type machines and ground-penetrating radar, but found "nothing of consequence" - dashing hopes of pinning Brueckner with DNA evidence. TIMELINE OF EVENTS Here's a timeline of the case which has gripped the world. May 3, 2007 January 15, 2016 Neighbour reports a possible 'grave' at Brueckner's abandoned factory in East Germany. Cops find disturbing February 16, 2016 Christian Brueckner is convicted for abusing a girl of five in a park after images found on his laptop. He was sentenced to 15-months behind bars but was already on the run by then. May 3, 2017 Around this time, He reports an alleged confession by Christian Brueckner. September 27, 2018 On-the-run Christian Brueckner is arrested over outstanding drugs claims in Italy. He is extradited to Germany the following year. December 16, 2019 Christian Brueckner was convicted, in Germany, for the 2005 rape of an American woman in Praia da Luz, Portugal, after his DNA was matched to a hair found on her bed. He was sentenced to seven years behind bars. June 4, 2020 German prosecutors reveal to the world they have a suspect in custody under investigation for the abduction of Madeleine McCann. For the first time they claim German media later name him as June 23, 2023 In his first interview, witness Helge B alleges to German newspaper Bild that Christian Brueckner all-but-confessed the Madeleine abduction to him, by allegedly saying 'she didn't scream' as they talked about the case, at a music festival, in Spain. February 16, 2024 Brueckner goes on trial accused of none-McCann allegations of rape and sex assault, in Braunschweig, Germany. Prosecutors hope for a conviction to keep him behind bars permanently and lead to McCann charges. October 8, 2024 Prosecutors launch an appeal, however. Decision pending. September 17, 2025 Date on which Prosecutors require an arrest warrant for a retrial over claims from last year - or over the McCann case.

Irish woman ‘in fear' ahead of release of Madeleine McCann suspect Christian Brueckner
Irish woman ‘in fear' ahead of release of Madeleine McCann suspect Christian Brueckner

Dublin Live

time16 hours ago

  • Dublin Live

Irish woman ‘in fear' ahead of release of Madeleine McCann suspect Christian Brueckner

Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info An Irishwoman who alleged she was raped at knifepoint by the main suspect in the disappearance of toddler Madeleine McCann says she fears he will seek her out following his release from prison. Christian Brueckner, 48, is due to be freed from a German jail in September after completing his sentence for the rape of a 72-year-old US woman in Praia da Luz, Portugal in 2005. Hazel Behan, 41, who has waived her right to anonymity, said she fears the German man will "hunt her down". Brueckner was acquitted by a German court in relation to the charge of violent rape of Ms Behan at her apartment in Praia da Rocha in Portugal's Algarve. She told The Sun: "His sentence may be ending but mine never did. I have lived with fear every day for 21 years. "Fear that I'll see him. Fear that he'll find out where I live and hunt me down. I also have fear that he'll do to someone else what he did to me. "I've called him out in a public forum and I have genuine concern he could confront me. "I wouldn't put anything past a person like him. "If he is released, I will worry for every woman and child who, like me, believes the justice system is protecting them. "A leopard doesn't change his spots." Later this year Ms Behan expects to discover the outcome of her High Court appeal in Germany against his acquittal for raping her, another woman and a girl in Portugal in 2004. (Image: Phil Harris) Ms Behan has accused the Portuguese authorities of alleged "inaction" in identifying and prosecuting Brueckner. In April, she lodged an application to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) against the Portuguese authorities over their handling of her attack. Ms Behan also expressed her sympathy and support for the Leicestershire-based family of Madeleine who went missing in Praia da Luz while on holiday with her family in 2007 when she was three years old. (Image: PA) "As a parent, I cannot begin to imagine what they have gone through and continue to go through every day for the past 18 years," she said. German and Portuguese police and firefighters carried out a three-day search of an area near Praia da Luz last week in the latest efforts to find out what happened to the missing child. Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice . For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage .

Irish woman 'in fear' ahead of release of main suspect in Madeleine McCann probe
Irish woman 'in fear' ahead of release of main suspect in Madeleine McCann probe

Irish Daily Mirror

timea day ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Irish woman 'in fear' ahead of release of main suspect in Madeleine McCann probe

An Irishwoman who alleged she was raped at knifepoint by the main suspect in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann fears he will seek her out after his release from prison. Christian Brueckner, 48, is due to be freed from a German jail in September after serving his sentence for the rape of a 72-year-old woman in Portugal in 2005. Hazel Behan, 41, who has waived her right to anonymity, said: 'His sentence may be ending but mine never did. I have lived with fear every day for 21 years. 'Fear I'll see him. Fear he'll find out where I live and hunt me down. I also have fear that he'll do to someone else what he did to me. 'I wouldn't put anything past a person like him. A leopard doesn't change his spots.' Brueckner was acquitted by a German court over the violent rape of Ms Behan at her apartment in Praia da Rocha in Portugal. Later this year she will discover the outcome of her German High Court appeal against his acquittal for raping her, another woman and a girl in Portugal in 2004. Ms Behan accused the Portuguese authorities of 'inaction' in identifying and prosecuting Bruckner. In April, she lodged an application to the European Court of Human Rights against over their handling of her attack. Ms Behan also expressed her sympathy and support for Madeleine's family. Maddie was just three years old went missing in Praia da Luz while on holiday with her family in 2007. Ms Behan said: 'I cannot begin to imagine what they continue to go through every day.' German and Portuguese police and firefighters carried out a three-day search of an area near Praia da Luz last week in the latest fruitless efforts to find out what happened to the missing child. Ms Behan also spoke about Brueckner's impending release in an exclusive interview with this newspaper earlier this year. She said 'He knows who I am. Well, he always knew who I was, I just didn't know who he was. 'But I suppose now, at this stage, he knows me a lot better as this person that I am now. But I can't live in that fear, if you know what I mean? 'I have to remind myself all the time that, you know, I am not that kind of person. 'I don't live that kind of lifestyle at all like, in fact, quite the opposite, thankfully. 'But I can't allow for him to take any more from me than he already has and I'm not going to give him that. 'Like, is there a fear in the back of my mind? 100 per cent. But my fear isn't just, as I said, about me. It's bigger than that. I mean, if he wants to come at me again, he better put his boxing gloves on because I'm ready for him this time. I'm not 20 anymore. I'm not a baby and I will kick ten shades of sh*te out of him if he came near me again. But, on a real human level and not to be funny or anything, but yeah he terrifies me.' The court ultimately acquitted Brueckner in October of raping Ms Behan - ruling that there was insufficient evidence to find the convicted rapist and child abuser guilty. Ms Behan also spoke in detail about the trauma she suffered as a result of the horrific crime in 2004 - and how it continues to affect her to this day. 'You're very much stuck there. Not by choice. It's like something is just imprinted on you. The sad thing about it is I didn't choose that. This is something that, not to sound dramatic, but it murders the person that you were. You're gone,' she said. Speaking about living with that trauma, Ms Behan said she is still constantly battling with the horror she suffered 20 years on. 'Nothing is ever going to take away the fact that that happened. So for me, I think the hardest part of that was the control I felt he still had in my life, and still does have and I hate admitting that,' she told us. 'I have developed, you know, different quirks in my life, like I won't travel on holidays without, like, a portable door lock because of him. My family has suffered because of him. My friends have suffered. Like this is all because of him.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store