Murderer tricked police into arresting wrong man after horrifying Facebook posts
Police mistakenly arrested Shawn Bailey, 33, for murder but soon realised he was framed by 34-year-old Nigel Thomas from Ohio - who faked social media accounts to confuse officers
An innocent man spent around 10 days behind bars for a murder he didn't commit - after the real killer staged an "elaborate plan to frame" him using fake social media accounts and chilling videos of the victim's body, Indiana authorities say.
Police were called to carry out a welfare check on 35-year-old Wilma Gayle Robertson on April 15 at a property on Hickory Drive in Hanover, near the US ' Kentucky and Ohio borders. They found her dead from stab wounds to the back. Later that same day, officers arrested 33-year-old Shawn Bailey of Louisville for her murder after finding what appeared to be concrete evidence against him. He had a video of Robertson's body and even appeared to confess to the sick crime.
According to court documents, the girlfriend of Robertson's ex-husband received a friend request from a Facebook account in the name of "Shawn Bailey." Two disturbing messages followed. The first was a five-second video allegedly showing Robertson's body on the floor, soundtracked by the Chris Brown song Stutter, with the lyric: "Got me trippin' because you really f**k my head up." The second message read: "Tell her babe daddy that he doesn't have to worry about her anymore and my bad for me and him getting in it over this b**** me and him both got the same last name I did him a solid favor."
But investigators later cleared Bailey using DNA evidence. The real killer, prosecutors say, is 34-year-old Nigel Thomas of Oxford, Ohio - also known as "Nati Bang." After stabbing Robertson, Thomas allegedly launched a calculated campaign to frame Bailey, creating multiple fake social media accounts to make it appear as though Bailey had confessed.
Police arrested Thomas on Friday, then dropped the charges against Bailey and released him. Thomas remains in custody in Ohio, awaiting extradition to Indiana. No motive has been released, and prosecutors haven't shared any details on how Thomas knew Robertson.
"The criminal justice system is ultimately a search for the truth," said Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter. "Multiple agencies across three states worked tirelessly in their pursuit of all investigative leads to uncover the crimes of Nigel Thomas and clear Shawn Bailey."
According to her obituary, Robertson was a certified nursing assistant, a mum-of-two, and was known for posting uplifting videos on social media to inspire others.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
23 minutes ago
- Wales Online
He throttled a teenager with a fence post, then bragged on Facebook he'd do even worse
He throttled a teenager with a fence post, then bragged on Facebook he'd do even worse George Kovacs told his 17-year-old victim "I'm going to kill you… come back again and I will slice you" George Kovacs (Image: North Wales Police ) A man attacked a teenager who he believed was "up to no good" near his property and broke his arm and wrist, a court has heard. George Kovacs set about the 17-year-old with a fence post and pole and threatened to kill him if he returned. Sending the 57-year-old father to prison a judge said he had read about issues involving people misbehaving and causing damage in the area where the defendant lived, but he told him: "What you did went far beyond anything you reasonably thought you could do to protect that property." Amy Edwards, prosecuting, told Caernarfon Crown Court that on December 17, 2022, two then-17-year-old friends were walking in the mountains in the Waunfawr area of Gwynedd when they noticed an abandoned outbuilding and "out of curiosity" walked towards it. The barrister said as they approached the building a vehicle drove past them before stopping and reversing back to them. The driver of the vehicle, Kovacs, got out and shouted "What the f*** are you boys doing here?" The court heard that one of the teenagers, Kian Williams, who is now an adult, apologised to the driver but Kovacs continued "ranting" and the teenager told him: "There's no need to be a d*** about it." The prosecutor said Kovacs then grabbed a fence post and began swinging it around and striking Mr Williams, with the teenager putting his arms up to protect himself. The force of the blows were such that the post snapped. The court heard the defendant continued shouting that the boys should leave the area before grabbing Mr Williams, pushing him up against a wall and throwing a number of punches, all of which missed their target. The prosecutor said the teenagers made for the footpath but Kovacs armed himself with a pole and followed them. The defendant struck Mr Williams a number of times to the legs and the back, though the blows to the back were cushioned by the rucksack he was wearing. Kovacs told the teenagers: "I'm going to kill you… come back again and I will slice you." For the latest court reports sign up to our crime newsletter Article continues below The court heard that the teenagers made their way home and Mr Williams was subsequently taken to Bangor's Ysbyty Gwynedd by his father where doctors found he had a fractured arm and a fracture to bones in his wrist which required surgery. Meanwhile Kovacs put a post on a Facebook saying: "The lads who came from Liverpool or Manchester to my place, don't come back… next time they will have more then just a limp. Merry Christmas." He also said he had the registration of a vehicle they had been seen getting into. The court heard Kovacs was arrested and interviewed and admitted striking the teenager with a pole saying his actions were justified as he was protecting his property. In an impact statement written in May this year which was read to the court the victim said he still suffers with pain in his wrist and gets flashbacks to what happened in Waunfawr. He said he feels fearful when he goes out and constantly thinks of the defendant, adding: "This incident has taught me a lot of lessons about the man I want to be. I want to be the complete opposite of him." George Kovacs, of Ceunant, Caernarfon, Gwynedd, had previously pleaded guilty to unlawful wounding when he appeared in the dock for sentencing. He has five previous convictions for eight offences including weapons offences but none for violence. Laura Knightly, for Kovacs, said the defendant lived in a "secluded area" with his wife and children and said he was a hard-working man. She, while in no way excusing his actions on the day in question, said there had been "concerns and fears in the area for some time" and that Kovacs' suspicions of the teenagers and his fears of what might happen "caused him to behave in this out-of-character way". The barrister added that her client thinks he may have blacked out during the incident. Article continues below Judge Timothy Petts said in December 2022 Kovacs saw two young men in the vicinity of a property near to where he lived and, believing they were "up to no good", he confronted them. He said he had read references written to the court detailing problems with people misbehaving and causing damage in the rea but he told the defendant: "What you did went far beyond anything you reasonably thought you could do to protect that property." With a 15% discount for his guilty plea Kovacs was sentenced to 33 months in prison. He will serve up to half the sentence in custody before being released on licence to serve the remainder in the community. The defendant was also made the subject of a 10-year restraining order banning him from contacting his victim.
STV News
2 hours ago
- STV News
Disgraced lawyer 'can't attend court hearing due to wedding'
A disgraced lawyer serving time for money laundering can't attend court for a hearing as he's attending a wedding on the same day, a judge heard. Iain Robertson, 71, told judge Olga Pasportnikov on Monday that he wouldn't be able present for a proceeds of crime case on June 23. The High Court in Edinburgh heard that this was because he was a guest at a marriage ceremony on the same day. Robertson, who is representing himself in a bid by the Crown to recover money he made from a £1.5m laundering racket, told judge Pasportnikov: 'I'm on home leave for a wedding that day. I have a week of home leave every month.' Robertson, of Kilmacolm, Renfrewshire, is currently the subject of an action brought by prosecutors under proceeds of crime laws. Robertson was given eight years in January 2023. He and two other corrupt solicitors – Alistair Blackwood, 69, and David Lyons – used their law firm Robertson & Ross in Paisley, Renfrewshire, to launder cash obtained illegally. The trio acted alongside Mohammed Aziz, 63, and Robert Ferguson, 69, in a course of criminal activity. The five men were sentenced following a nine week trial at the High Court in Glasgow before judge Lord Richardson. The trial was the culmination of a process which had been triggered by a Law Society probe into activities at the firm. They were convicted of fraud and multiple charges under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. Robertson, Lyons and Aziz were also convicted on charges of being involved in serious organised crime. All were sent to prison. Prosecutors told jurors the case centred on four transactions carried out between May 2015 and July 2016. The first transaction involved a £79,340 stolen cheque due to be paid to a law firm in Jersey. The next centred on £240,000 from a fraudulent house sale in London. The third transaction saw £985,000 stolen from the hacked bank account of an individual. And the final illegal activity was uncovered after Robertson claimed to be acting for a man who wanted to sell his home in Essex. The court heard that the 'seller' was said to be staying at a flat that turned out to be Ferguson's address. A total of £181,786 was made from the fraudulent sale. In each transaction, the proceeds were funnelled through the client bank account held by Robertson's firm in Paisley, Robertson & Ross Limited, and false records were created to make them appear legitimate. Fake papers and fake IDs – including a passport and driver's licence – were collated in a bid to cover up the crimes. The Law Society raised concerns about several of these transactions before alerting police to the potential illegal activity. The trial heard that lawyer Robertson, who has been suspended by the Law Society along with Blackwood, was at the heart of the money-laundering scheme since he had access to his firm's client account. Judge Pasportnikov fixed a hearing in the proceeds case to take place on June 30, 2025. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
STV News
2 hours ago
- STV News
Urgent search to reunite girl with epilepsy with missing therapy dog
An urgent search has been launched to reunite a young girl with epilepsy with her missing therapy dog in the Highlands. Louie, adopted as a therapy dog for his owner Louise Manson's daughter, who lives with epilepsy, ran off after slipping his lead near Steall Falls in Glen Nevis on May 26. Louise has since led an 'emotional and tireless' campaign to find her pet, supported by a Facebook group with over 1,200 members. The search has been backed by volunteers combating vast, rugged terrain after Louise appealed to the public in the hope that someone picked Louie up thinking he was lost or abandoned Fort William resident Iona Macdonald has since launched a GoFundMe campaign to support the search for the Golden Retriever. The raised funds hope to bring in professional support, including drone search teams and tracking dogs, to continue the effort. So far, £2,690 has been raised, smashing its original £2,000 goal. Louise has expressed overwhelming gratitude for the public's help so far, saying their home 'isn't home without him.' The fundraiser reads: 'A good friend was up Steall Falls in Glen Nevis on Monday May 26 in the evening and her family dog Louie slipped his lead and ran away. Despite numerous hours spent searching by everyone and strangers who have kindly joined in searching Louie has still not been found. 'As many will know the area Louie has run of is very big open spaces with lots of rough terrain and the searches so far have not been successful. 'Organised searches will be sorted soon on the Facebook page. 'Louie is a Golden Retriever and is a lovable, friendly dog, now all the searches have so far not shown anything we now think we could try and raise some funds to help Louise towards paying for specialists to come up with thermal drones. 'Anyone who has a dog will know they are not just an animal, they are part of your family. I cannot imagine how Louise, Charlie ,and the girls are coping.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
