#SkinnyTok, the latest weight-loss trend, is more dangerous than you think
EDITOR'S NOTE: Oona Hanson is a writer, educator and parent coach who specializes in helping families navigate diet culture and eating disorders.
While the internet's darkest corners have always harbored harmful ideas, a new TikTok trend takes hazardous pro-eating disorder content out of the shadows and into the view of millions of people.
SkinnyTok, the viral weight-loss hashtag on TikTok, goes beyond typical fitness and nutrition advice and instead recommends dangerous levels of restriction with a side of verbal abuse.
Those in hard-fought recovery from anorexia have raised concerns that this craze poses a serious health risk, particularly for young women, who are the main target of these weight-loss messages.
Often referred to as 'thinspo' or 'pro-ana,' online content encouraging eating disorder behaviors is nothing new, but TikTok's video format and algorithm now spread this type of content far and wide rather than it staying confined to a smaller community of users .
TikTok declined to respond to my questions directly, but a spokesperson shared some of the steps they say the company takes, such as interrupting repetitive content and directing users to mental health resources, including organizations that specialize in eating disorder recovery. Those users who want to limit weight-loss content can filter out particular words and hashtags.
Despite TikTok's policy that explicitly prohibits 'showing or promoting disordered eating and dangerous weight loss behaviors,' I still find that these shocking videos continue to proliferate on the platform.
Prior pro-eating disorder content on sites like Tumblr or X 'were more niche in the sense that they were more directed toward people who had eating disorders,' said Mallary Tenore Tarpley, an assistant professor of practice at the University of Texas at Austin, whose first book, 'Slip: Life in the Middle of Eating Disorder Recovery,' will be released in August.
Rather than something an already struggling person might seek out to reinforce their mental illness, SkinnyTok is out in the open and even presented as healthy.
Tarpley worries the average viewer is unlikely to recognize how extreme and dangerous these messages are. 'Because they are framed as just this sort of wellness movement or healthy eating, they become more mainstream, and therefore people don't necessarily see the toxicity in them,' she said.
When Los Angeles-based licensed clinical social worker Shira Rosenbluth first came across this kind of content, she was surprised at the resurgence of these dangerous messages.
'We're still doing this twentysomething years later?' Rosenbluth asked. 'We're still in exactly the same place where we're glorifying not just fitness, we're glorifying eating disorders and disordered eating? You see them say it's not about being skinny, it's just about being healthy. And it's like, OK, but why is it called SkinnyTok?'
Some of the viral content is so outrageous, Rosenbluth even wondered if it's simply 'rage-bait,' an attempt to get reactions and attention simply by being so offensive. Even if influencers are posting this shocking content primarily to drive engagement, the primary audience — teen girls and young women — are still being put in harm's way.
While some defenders of this content argue it's not meant to be taken seriously, Tarpley finds the trending motifs often describe specific anorexia symptoms. 'Sometimes the advice given may seem like it's supposed to be humorous, but in fact a lot of people struggling with eating disorders actually engage in those very same behaviors, and it is far from funny.'
She shared how one popular SkinnyTok trend was eerily similar to something she experienced while in the throes of anorexia as a child. 'I saw one video where someone said, 'If you're sleeping and wake in the middle of the night hungry, just chew on your pillow,'' she said. 'I remember doing something similar when I was younger.'
The kinds of weight-loss tips popular on the platform 'could become a guidebook for people with eating disorders or for people who are flirting with dieting and are predisposed to developing an eating disorder,' Tarpley added. 'It becomes this very slippery slope where you hear these ideas that are expressed in jest, or you hear the shaming and then you begin to really believe that it's true.'
Demeaning messages about people's eating and bodies are popular on SkinnyTok, and Rosenbluth understands why people might be attracted to such negativity.
'It's almost like an abuse victim who thinks that's what they deserve,' said Rosenbluth, who is in recovery from anorexia. 'I'm especially thinking about like a larger teenager who has been taught that their body is bad and their body is wrong, and that they need to do everything they can to change their body. They think they deserve to be talked to like that.'
Speaking from her clients' experiences and her own, Rosenbluth recognized the way these influencers' cruel messages often directly echo the internal torment of people with eating disorders.
'The bully voice sounds similar to the eating disorder voice,' she said. 'Someone in any size body with an eating disorder is talking to themselves like that internally. People describe it as this monster that's in their head, kind of screaming at them all the time.'
While Rosenbluth noted that she and her patients used to feel that 'nobody could be meaner than this monster, (it's possible that) the TikTok bullies are equal. This constant voice, telling them that they are nothing, that they're garbage, that they're not worthy, that they shouldn't be seen, that they shouldn't be heard, that they need to be thin.'
Rosenbluth finds one of the popular taglines — 'You don't need a treat. You're not a dog' — particularly disturbing because of its implication that satisfying basic hunger and need for pleasure makes you less than human. 'It's scary that we're saying the human right of eating and enjoying food is something that is so wildly wrong when it's actually human, a part of life,' she said.
These dehumanizing messages are a recipe for stress and suffering, but they're sold to viewers as 'tough love' or even self-care. Particularly for impressionable young people, these influencers promote 'this belief that we need to be thin in order to be beautiful and accepted and loved,' added Tarpley.
People swept up in following these 'thinfluencers' aren't usually aware of the serious risks that come with adopting their rigid dietary advice.
'What's really scary to me is that teenagers and young adults, if they start restricting, they can do permanent damage. We're talking about permanent bone loss and osteoporosis later on in life,' Rosenbluth said. 'Restriction can impact the entire body.'
The conflation of thinness with health can make it hard for parents to notice if their teen is absorbing this dangerous content. Rosenbluth worries especially about adolescents and knows they need support to set limits on how much time they spend on social media. 'People can get sucked in for hours on end, and no teenager needs that.'
The sheer volume of exposure to this harmful content concerns Tarpley, too. 'The algorithms are designed in such a way that if you begin to kind of flirt with some of this content, you're going to start seeing it more and more in your feed,' she said. 'It becomes very hard then to escape that. And that can lead people down these rabbit holes that can be really dark and really hard to get out of.'
Parents who observe their child restricting food or exercising excessively shouldn't dismiss the behaviors as just a fad diet or an attempt to 'be healthy' and get in shape.
'There's this tendency to think that eating disorders are just some sort of passing phase or something that can be quickly overcome, and I will say, eating disorders can ruin lives. They can take lives,' Tarpley warned.
Most parents don't know that trouble can start after exposure to content far less extreme than what's on SkinnyTok. Throughout her career, Rosenbluth has worked with countless people 'who started out on these innocent diets or just wanting to lose a few pounds, and now they're completely consumed.'
It's easy for an eating disorder to start but incredibly hard to end it. 'That period of developing an eating disorder can be quite quick, but it can take years, and in some cases a lifetime, for people to actually recover,' Tarpley noted.
Tarpley wishes adults and teens understood the serious risks of engaging with this kind of content: 'People think, well, it's just social media. There's no way I could develop an eating disorder just because of some videos I see. But in talking with lots of people with all different types of eating disorders, I recognize that's very much something that could happen. So, I think the more we can talk about this reality, the better.'
Note: If you or someone you know may be struggling with an eating disorder, the National Alliance for Eating Disorders provides resources and referrals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Health Line
an hour ago
- Health Line
What Is ‘Skinny Tok?' Experts Debunk the Harmful TikTok Trend for Weight Loss
' Skinny Tok,' an extreme form of dieting that equates thinness with health, continues to trend on TikTok. Experts warn that the trend perpetuates negative body image and toxic diet culture. Extreme calorie restriction has mental and physical consequences. There are many sustainable, evidence-based ways to achieve a healthy weight. A harmful and misleading body image trend continues to surface on TikTok. So-called 'Skinny Tok' is a controversial corner of the social media platform where proponents tout extreme thinness under the guise of wellness and lifestyle advice. Leading the Skinny Tok movement is Gen Z influencer Liv Schmidt, who rose to internet fame by sharing what she referred to as 'skinny girl hacks.' Her content, which included low calorie 'What I Eat in a Day' videos, sparked widespread concern about its potential to normalize disordered eating. After being banned from TikTok in 2024 for violating the platform's community guidelines, Schmidt resurfaced with a new username. Skinny Tok content continues to gain traction. There are currently over 74,000 videos shared under the #skinnytok hashtag, many of which share extreme calorie deficits and regular body checks, where users document their shrinking bodies. Skinny Tok: A dangerous way to lose weight Registered dietitian Emily Van Eck, described the trend as a 'dangerous' and 'extreme' take on weight loss and health. 'Glorifying thinness as a marker of morality, health, or discipline is harmful to physical, emotional, and mental health,' she told Healthline. 'Dieting is a major risk factor for eating disorders, and the younger someone starts, the higher their risk. Because these videos often feature teenagers and young adults, they're especially concerning.' Van Eck noted the vilifying of essential macronutrients (in particular carbohydrates and fats) as another red flag. 'Our bodies need these nutrients,' she said. Lindsie Meek, founder of HumanMend, an eating disorder and anxiety psychotherapy practice in New York City, said the trend perpetuates harmful diet culture, celebrates extreme thinness, and promotes unrealistic body standards. 'The 'What I eat in a day' content is particularly harmful because it suggests all bodies have the same nutritional needs,' she told Healthline. 'These posts don't take into consideration individual body factors, such as genetics and health needs.' Risks of extreme calorie restriction Some influencers promoting this trend share very low calorie diets. Both experts agreed that extreme calorie restriction has mental and physical consequences. 'On 800 calories per day, it's virtually impossible to meet your body's nutrient needs,' Van Eck said. 'Deficiencies in iron, B12, and calcium are common, which can lead to fatigue, low mood, poor sleep, and muscle loss. Over time, undernourishment can cause immune dysfunction, hypothalamic amenorrhea (which causes infertility), and bone loss,' she noted. From a mental health perspective, Meek said dieting to the extreme could contribute to 'exaggerated or limited mood fluctuations and obsessive thoughts about food and body image.' Many of these videos frame weight loss and extreme thinness as the ultimate sign of health, a narrative that is dangerous and misleading. 'Weight is not a reliable indicator of health status,' said Meek. 'Health is multifaceted and cannot be determined by appearance alone. 'People in thin bodies may or may not be healthy, just as people in larger bodies may or may not be healthy,' she continued. Meek noted that true health isn't a body size; it encompasses physical, mental, emotional, social, and spiritual well-being. Healthy weight loss vs. disordered eating Not all weight loss is bad. There are healthy, sustainable ways to reach a healthy weight, but with so much conflicting advice online, it can be difficult to know what's helpful and what's extreme. Van Eck agreed. 'The line between intentional weight loss and disordered eating can be blurry, especially online, where extreme behaviors are often framed as wellness and get rewarded with massive attention due to their polarizing nature,' she pointed out. For Van Eck, health-supportive behavior change feels like part of a broader self-care routine. 'It's flexible and rooted in nourishment, not fear or punishment,' she said. Disordered eating on the other hand, often shows up as rigid food rules, food guilt, and obsessive control. 'If someone feels anxious deviating from a plan, skips meals to earn food, or thinks about food and their body constantly, that's disordered, even if it's normalized online,' Van Eck said. If in doubt, Meek recommended assessing how the behaviors impact your daily life. 'If weight loss is the goal, it's important to consistently assess flexibility and anxiety levels when plans change, as disordered patterns are often rigid and distressing,' she said. 'Disordered eating also typically interferes with relationships, work, and life enjoyment, whereas balanced approaches enhance overall well-being.' Achieving a healthy weight Despite recent strides made by the body positivity movement, mainstream culture continues to conflate thinness with health. According to Van Eck, part of the issue may be tied to misconceptions about healthy body weight. 'Healthy weight is a term I often find problematic. The metrics we use, like BMI, are deeply flawed and don't account for natural, individual variation,' Van Eck said. 'If we define it more functionally, a healthy weight is the range your body naturally lands when you're eating enough, moving in ways that feel good, and not caught in the restrict-obsess-repeat cycle.' There are many sustainable, evidence-based ways to get into this healthy zone. 'If someone wants to support their health long term, the most sustainable approach is to focus on behavior, not the weight. 'That includes eating regular, balanced meals with enough energy, fiber, protein, and fat to support fullness and satisfaction,' she said. It also means honoring hunger cues, finding enjoyable movement, and addressing sleep, stress, and emotional health. Another way to support yourself is to ditch the idea that foods are inherently good or bad. 'Virtually everyone in our culture has been influenced to some extent by toxic diet culture. Healing involves rejecting food morality by challenging the idea that certain foods are good or bad,' said Meek. Diet trends like Skinny Tok can reinforce dangerous ideas around weight loss and health, but true wellness is multi-dimensional. 'Equating thinness with health ignores human complexity and reinforces weight stigma,' Van Eck said. manage stress, sleep, and connect with others, than it is in a size.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
People Are Sharing Things They Used To Buy Regularly But Now Never Do
@marisasav_ asked people on TikTok what's one thing they used to buy regularly that they'll never buy again. @marisasav_/ For her, it was paper towels. "We used to buy paper towels pretty much every week. We used to spend, I don't even know how much on them, and we will never buy paper towels again. We use napkins, we use t-shirt rags, we've created a system to phase paper towels completely out of our lifestyle," she explained. "A six-pack of paper towels at Target costs an average of $20-22. So, that would mean about $3 per roll on paper towels. If the average American household goes through one roll of paper towels of week, you are looking at over $150 on something you literally use once and throw away over and over and over again," she continued. "This was actually one of the first sustainable switches we made in our home." People in the comments are sharing products they've also abandoned, and here's what they had to say: sheets plates drinks coffee paper Related: 17 "Old" Home Design Trends People Desperately Want To See Make A Comeback popcorn 8.K-Cups dressing scent boosters Related: These 14 DIY Fails Are Just So, Sooooo Bad (And I'm Laughing So, Sooooo Hard) candles and menstrual products soap/dish soap bags water creamer water wash softener air fresheners lastly, "After today it's going to be most things*." *That was posted on "LIBERATION DAY." Also in Nifty: "She Just Wanted To Hang A Picture...": 30 Photos Of People Trying To "Help Out Around The House" That Backfired Spectacularly Also in Nifty: "I Saved An Embarrassing Amount Of Money": Frugal People Are Sharing The Habits They Stick To Year-Round Also in Nifty: People Are Sharing "Expensive" Adult Purchases That They'd Actually Recommend, Despite The Price Tag
Hamilton Spectator
an hour ago
- Hamilton Spectator
From thyroid issues to cancer, here's what your fingernails can tell you about your health
There's more to fingernails than hangnails and nail polish. In fact, your nails can reveal surprising facts about your health, if you're paying close enough attention. They can be clues to problems with your blood, thyroid gland, immune system, heart, liver and gastrointestinal system. 'Be vigilant for changes to the nails in general,' said Kendall Billick, a dermatologist at UHN who runs Canada's only medical clinic dedicated to nails. 'Those could be signs of something totally not worrisome, or a sign of internal conditions.' Here's what to watch out for, and what it could mean. This is a common complaint that Paul Cohen, a Toronto-based dermatologist at the Rosedale Dermatology Centre, hears from his patients. Often, this doesn't indicate an underlying health issue — it points simply to the way you take care of your hands. Nail polish remover, cold and dry weather, frequent handwashing and too much hand sanitizer are common causes of brittle nails. 'The harsh environment can affect the way the nails grow,' Cohen said. On rare occasions, brittle nails can be caused by a medical condition, like the thyroid gland not working, but it's more often a sign of how you're caring for your hands, according to Cohen. He recommends using lots of hand moisturizer — especially ones that include urea, an ingredient that attracts water — and using gloves while washing the dishes and cleaning with harsh chemicals. If you're protecting your nails and they're still brittle, Billick recommends asking if there is something else going on. 'The most important thing to know about nails,' Cohen said, 'is when you have to worry about melanoma.' People often associate skin cancer with moles on their skin, but it can also pop up in the nail as a dark stripe changing in size and shape. These stripes can be naturally occurring, especially in people of colour, or caused by medication or other health concerns, but they shouldn't be ignored — 'especially if that brown stripe is changing in appearance,' Cohen said. These stripes often get overlooked because they usually don't cause pain or discomfort, Cohen said, but can have severe consequences. 'It's more common to have bands the darker your skin tone,' said Billick, also an assistant professor at the University of Toronto. 'But any changing band, especially if it's in a single digit, should prompt a call to your doctor to have it assessed.' There are many different types of nail lines, Billick said, and many different colours they can appear as. The most common reason for a white line is trauma to the nail, typically from manicures. Depending on if they're located in the nail or beneath the nail, white lines can also indicate exposure to toxins, like undergoing chemotherapy, or low levels of protein in your blood — which can, in turn, be a symptom of kidney or liver disease, according to Heidi Engelhardt, a professor at the University of Waterloo who specializes in physiology. If you're seeing a line, Billick recommends asking about it on your next checkup. 'There's very little in the nail, except very nuanced and painful conditions, that can't wait for a future visit,' Billick said. White marks on the nail can also be caused by nail fungus, Engelhardt said. But Billick also sees many people come to his clinic because of a so-called fungal infection that isn't improving with drugs — and that's because, most of the time, they don't actually have a fungus infection, he said. Often, it's another condition that has been misdiagnosed. 'Don't accept antifungal or antibacterial treatment without a firm diagnosis,' Billick said, which can be done through a nail sample. Ridges or dents that appear in the nail are called Beau's lines. The most obvious cause is trauma to the nail, like being slammed in a door or hit by a hammer, Engelhardt said. But if that hasn't happened and the ridges appear on multiple fingers or toes, it can indicate interrupted nail growth under stress or illness — potentially diabetes, hypothyroidism, a skin condition like psoriasis or vitamin deficiencies. Engelhardt recommends taking multivitamins and asking a doctor. Billick recommends avoiding manicures and pedicures, as that's the 'single biggest problem' he sees in his clinic. And if you can't avoid them, don't let the nail technician cut the cuticle at the base of the nail. 'It's a seal that prevents dirt, germs (and) water from getting to the factory that produces the nail,' Billick said. Once it's cut, 'all sorts of bad things happen.' Billick also recommends not using artificial nails or UV lamps. And avoid biotin supplements, too. They simply don't work, according to Billick, and also interfere with blood tests — even producing false results after a heart attack. Overall, Billick believes many doctors and the public underestimates how much nails can impact quality of life. In his clinic, he's seen a woman who felt her nails were preventing her from getting married, a businessman who felt he couldn't shake on a deal and an optometrist who was embarrassed to show people glasses on account of her hands. 'If nails are affecting quality of life,' Billick said, 'I think that's a very reasonable thing to bring to someone's attention.'
