Image of Crimea explosion falsely linked to India-Pakistan conflict
The image of a fireball and thick black smoke was shared on Facebook on May 8, 2025, as India and Pakistan exchanged tit-for-tat jet fighter, drone, missile and artillery attacks across their shared frontier.
"Indian S-400 air defense system site in Adampur hit by unknown missiles and drones," reads both the Urdu and English-language captions of the image.
The violence, the worst between the neighbours in decades, erupted after New Delhi launched missiles at sites in Pakistan it said were hosting militants responsible for an attack on tourists in Indian-administered Kashmir (archived link).
India had accused Pakistan of backing the "terrorists" behind the April 22 attack -- a charge Islamabad denies.
Four days of intense fighting that killed at least 70 people followed, before the arch-rivals agreed to a ceasefire on May 10 that US President Donald Trump said was brokered by Washington.
Image
Screenshot of the false Facebook post, captured on May 15, 2025
The same image also circulated in similar X posts that were shared hundreds of times.
While Pakistan's military claimed on May 10 that its air force had destroyed the defence system, Indian media reported that Prime Minister Narendra Modi "debunked Pakistan's claim" by posing in front of it during a visit to the Adampur airbase on May 13 (archived here and here).
The circulating image also predates the current conflict by almost two years.
Crimea explosion
A reverse image search led to the same photo published in several articles, including from American magazine Newsweek, about explosions in July 2023 in Crimea, the Black Sea peninsula which Russia annexed a decade earlier (archived here).
The photo in the Newsweek article is credited to photographer Viktor Korotayev of Russian media Kommersant and to AFP which also distributed the photo.
"A picture shows detonation of ammunition caused by a fire at a military training field in the Kirovsky district of Crimea on July 19, 2023," reads its caption in AFP's archives.
An AFP report from July 19, 2023 said the fire prompted authorities to order the evacuation of more than 2,000 civilians (archived link).
"Authorities did not specify the cause of the blaze, but some Russian media reported that detonations were heard in the area and footage showed columns of black smoke in the sky," the report added.
Image
Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared image (left) and the same photo in AFP's archives (right)
The conflict between India and Pakistan has triggered a flurry of misinformation, some of which AFP has debunked here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
an hour ago
- LeMonde
Pope Leo and Putin hold 'constructive' call on Ukraine war, says Kremlin
Vladimir Putin discussed the war in Ukraine with Pope Leo in a telephone call on Wednesday, June 4, with the Kremlin claiming the Russian president wanted peace through diplomacy. Putin, however, also claimed "the regime in Kyiv is betting on an escalation of the conflict and carrying out acts of sabotage against civil infrastructure on Russian territory," it said in a statement. In the phone call, Putin "reaffirmed his interest in bringing about peace by political and diplomatic means," the Kremlin said, describing the call as "constructive." He did so "underlining that in order to come to a definitive, just and comprehensive settlement to the crisis, it was necessary to eliminate the deep-seated causes." That evoked language typically used to refer to a mix of sweeping demands regularly put forward by Russia, including limiting Ukraine's military, banning the country from joining NATO and massive territorial concessions. Ukraine has rejected those calls and demanded an unconditional ceasefire, which Russia refuses. The afternoon phone call was the first between the US-born pope and Putin since Leo became head of the world's Catholics last month. After taking office, the pontiff offered to mediate between leaders of countries at war – an offer that Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni later said meant hosting Ukraine peace talks at the Vatican. But Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov cast doubt on the idea, saying "it would be a bit inelegant for Orthodox countries to discuss (the conflict), on Catholic ground." On Wednesday, Putin thanked Leo for "his willingness to contribute to a settlement" of the conflict, the Kremlin said. 'Seek solutions to the conflict' The Vatican said in a statement that during the call with Putin, "the pope made an appeal for Russia to make a gesture that favours peace." Leo also "underlined the importance of dialogue for the realisation of positive contacts between the parties and to seek solutions to the conflict." The two men talked about the humanitarian situation and the need to favour aid where necessary, and the exchange of prisoners between Russia and Ukraine. In addition, the pope offered his thanks for Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill, a close supporter of Putin, for his good wishes at the start of his pontificate. He "emphasized how common Christian values can be a light that helps to seek peace, defend life and seek true religious freedom," the Vatican statement said. Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the Holy See has been at odds with Kirill, who has described the conflict as a "holy war." More than three years into Russia's grinding invasion, which has cost tens of thousands of lives, Russia and Ukraine have opened direct talks searching for a way to end what has become Europe's largest conflict since World War II. At a second round of negotiations on Monday, the two sides swapped documents with their terms for a ceasefire and agreed to a large-scale prisoner exchange, which could go forward this weekend.
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
US blocks Gaza ceasefire resolution at UN Security Council
It was the 15-member body's first vote on the situation since November, when the United States -- a key Israeli ally -- also blocked a text calling for an end to fighting. "This resolution would undermine diplomatic efforts to reach a ceasefire that reflects the realities on the ground and emboldens Hamas," Washington's United Nations envoy Dorothy Shea said ahead of the vote. "This resolution also draws false equivalence between Israel and Hamas," she said. The draft resolution had demanded "an immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire in Gaza respected by all parties." It also called for the "immediate, dignified and unconditional release of all hostages held by Hamas and other groups." Underlining a "catastrophic humanitarian situation" in the Palestinian territory, the resolution, had it passed, would have demanded the lifting of all restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza. The veto was the first wielded by Washington since US President Donald Trump took office in January. Israel has faced growing international pressure to end its war in Gaza, which was triggered by the unprecedented October 7, 2023 attack by Hamas on Israeli soil. That scrutiny has increased over flailing aid distribution in Gaza, which Israel blocked for more than two months before allowing a small number of UN vehicles to enter in mid-May. The United Nations said that was not enough to meet the humanitarian needs. 'Judged by history' A US-backed relief effort called the Gaza Humanitarian Fund (GHF) has also faced criticism for going against long-standing humanitarian principles by coordinating relief efforts with a military belligerent. Israeli bombardment on Wednesday killed at least 16 people in the Gaza Strip, including 12 in a single strike on a tent housing displaced people, the Palestinian territory's civil defense agency told AFP. On Tuesday, 27 people were killed in southern Gaza when Israeli troops opened fire near a GHF aid site, with the military saying the incident was under investigation. Riyad Mansour, the Palestinian ambassador to the UN, on Tuesday urged the Council to act. "All of us will be judged by history as to how much have we done in order to stop this crime against the Palestinian people," he said. Israel's ambassador to the UN Danny Danon attacked the text ahead of the vote. "This resolution doesn't advance humanitarian relief. It undermines it. It ignores a working system in favor of political agendas," he was to tell the council, according to remarks released by his office.
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
US vetoes Gaza ceasefire resolution at UN Security Council, saying it emboldens Hamas
The United States vetoed Wednesday a UN Security Council resolution calling for a ceasefire and unrestricted humanitarian access in Gaza, which Washington claimed undermined ongoing diplomacy to resolve the conflict. It was the 15-member body's first vote on the situation since November, when the United States – a key Israeli ally – also blocked a text calling for an end to fighting. "This resolution would undermine diplomatic efforts to reach a ceasefire that reflects the realities on the ground and emboldens Hamas," Washington's United Nations envoy Dorothy Shea said ahead of the vote. "This resolution also draws false equivalence between Israel and Hamas," she said. The draft resolution had demanded "an immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire in Gaza respected by all parties." It also called for the "immediate, dignified and unconditional release of all hostages held by Hamas and other groups." Underlining a "catastrophic humanitarian situation" in the Palestinian territory, the resolution, had it passed, would have demanded the lifting of all restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza. The veto was the first wielded by Washington since US President Donald Trump took office in January. Israel has faced growing international pressure to end its war in Gaza, which was triggered by the unprecedented October 7, 2023 attack by Hamas on Israeli soil. That scrutiny has increased over flailing aid distribution in Gaza, which Israel blocked for more than two months before allowing a small number of UN vehicles to enter in mid-May. The United Nations said that was not enough to meet the humanitarian needs. 'Judged by history' A US-backed relief effort called the Gaza Humanitarian Fund (GHF) has also faced criticism for going against long-standing humanitarian principles by coordinating relief efforts with a military belligerent. Israeli bombardment on Wednesday killed at least 16 people in the Gaza Strip, including 12 in a single strike on a tent housing displaced people, the Palestinian territory's civil defense agency told AFP. On Tuesday, 27 people were killed in southern Gaza when Israeli troops opened fire near a GHF aid site, with the military saying the incident was under investigation. Riyad Mansour, the Palestinian ambassador to the UN, on Tuesday urged the Council to act. "All of us will be judged by history as to how much have we done in order to stop this crime against the Palestinian people," he said. Israel's ambassador to the UN Danny Danon attacked the text ahead of the vote. "This resolution doesn't advance humanitarian relief. It undermines it. It ignores a working system in favor of political agendas," he was to tell the council, according to remarks released by his office. "It ignores the one party still endangering civilians in Gaza: Hamas."
