Govt must move at cheetah's speed, not tortoise's pace: Justice Mandokhail
Listen to article
Supreme Court of Pakistan judge, Justice Jamal Mandokhail has remarked that while the government should be moving at the speed of a cheetah, it is instead proceeding at the pace of a tortoise.
He made the comments during a Supreme Court hearing on the establishment of the Climate Change Authority, Express News reported.
The case, heard by a five-member constitutional bench led by Justice Ameen-ud-Din Khan, focused on the formation of the Climate Change Authority.
Justice Mandokhail emphasised that climate change is a critical issue, and the government must expedite its efforts.
The Additional Attorney General informed the court that a third advertisement had been issued for the appointment of the Authority's chairman.
Justice Mandokhail questioned why the first two advertisements had failed to yield results.
The Additional Attorney General explained that the top candidate's dual nationality had disqualified him, as per the government's policy on high-ranking appointments.
Justice Mandokhail suggested that compromises might be necessary in finding the right candidate, adding that the real challenge lies in how the Authority will function in the provinces.
The Additional Attorney General responded that the provinces had already nominated members for the Authority.
Justice Ameen-ud-Din added that Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa had nominated Faisal Amin, the brother of the provincial Chief Minister, while Balochistan had appointed a university vice-chancellor.
Justice Mandokhail questioned the expertise of the Balochistan appointee, stating that they lacked the relevant experience.
The Additional Attorney General assured that they would contact the provinces to nominate technocrats instead. He also confirmed that the draft rules for the Authority were ready and would be sent to the Ministry of Law for approval.
Justice Mandokhail expressed frustration that despite the law being passed in 2017, the chairman has not been appointed, and the rules have not been finalized. He also questioned the process of appointing heads of environmental agencies in the provinces.
Secretary of Climate Change, Zulfiqar Younis, informed the court that 752 applications had been received in the previous round.
Justice Mandokhail inquired why the other two shortlisted candidates were not considered, to which the Secretary replied that they did not meet the required standards.
The petitioner's lawyer, Mian Samiuddin, argued that this case is about basic rights and expressed concerns over the difficulty of finding a suitable Pakistani expert. He noted that the Climate Change Authority has remained inactive since 2017.
The court adjourned the hearing for one month.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
CDA to be dissolved, all powers to shift to Metropolitan Corporation: IHC
Listen to article The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has ordered the federal government to dissolve the Capital Development Authority (CDA). In a written verdict, Justice Mohsin Akhtar Kayani ruled that the CDA has no legal authority to impose taxes. The court stated that if any individual or institution has been charged by the CDA under the names of 'direct access' or 'right of way' charges, such amounts must be refunded. The federal government has been directed to begin and complete the process of dissolving the CDA. Justice Kayani further ruled that, after dissolution, all powers and assets of the CDA should be transferred to the Metropolitan Corporation. The rights of Islamabad's citizens must be safeguarded under the law. The decision came in response to a petition filed by the Tijji Housing Society and its residents. In the judgment, the court nullified the CDA's SRO (Statutory Regulatory Order) dated 9 June 2015 concerning right of way and access charges. All actions taken by the CDA under this SRO were declared illegal, and the court ordered that any money collected under it must be refunded. Read: Temporary CDA staff regularised The judgment observed that the CDA Ordinance was originally enacted for the establishment of the federal government and for carrying out developmental work. However, with new legislation and governance structures in place, the ordinance has lost its practical relevance. The court concluded that the purpose of establishing the CDA has now been fulfilled and that the government should proceed with its dissolution. It also directed that the administration of Islamabad must remain transparent and accountable after the transfer of powers. Additionally, the verdict stated that all administrative, regulatory, and municipal functions in Islamabad fall under the Local Government Act, which provides for governance through elected representatives. Under this law, taxes cannot be imposed without the approval of the local government. Therefore, the CDA has no legal authority to impose taxes. It is worth noting that the CDA had imposed right-of-access taxes on petrol pumps and CNG stations, and direct access taxes on private housing societies with roads connecting to main highways, all of which were challenged in the High Court.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
No price tag yet: govt denies $100mn valuation for Roosevelt Hotel
The Privatisation Commission of Pakistan on Saturday clarified that no base price has yet been determined for the proposed sale of the iconic Roosevelt Hotel in New York, refuting recent media reports claiming a $100 million valuation. 'The Privatisation Commission has noticed a misleading news report appearing on 27th June 2025 in certain news media outlets asserting that Pakistan has set $100 million as base price for the sale of Roosevelt Hotel. 'It is clarified that no base price has yet been determined for Roosevelt Hotel, New York's privatisation, which can only be set at the time of bidding,' read the statement. The commission highlighted that the report misquotes Adviser to the Prime Minister on Privatisation, Muhammad Ali, who had referred to an estimated initial partial payment to be made by the successful party on signing the agreement, expected during the current fiscal year. 'The base price and timing for realisation of total proceeds from the privatisation of Roosevelt Hotel will be based on transaction structure and final terms of the agreement approved by the government,' it said, with the finalisation of the transaction structure expected to be taken up in the next CCOP meeting. Last month, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif told the National Assembly that the government is exploring a joint venture to operate the Roosevelt Hotel, aiming for long-term economic benefits rather than selling the asset outright. Describing the nearly century-old 19-story hotel as 'a strategic gem,' Asif praised its prime Manhattan location and stressed the government's intent to retain ownership. 'Selling might patch a short-term fiscal wound,' he said, 'but a joint venture ensures Pakistan keeps a foot on that lucrative property while raking in steady profits.' The Roosevelt Hotel has long been viewed as Pakistan's prized overseas asset, with repeated calls over the years to sell it for quick cash. The landmark hotel closed in 2020 after sustaining massive financial losses associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. It became operational in 2023 as a shelter for asylum seekers after the Pakistani government inked a three-year $220 million lease agreement with the New York City government to operate the Roosevelt Hotel. In February 2024, the government signed a Financial Advisory Services Agreement (FASA) with a consortium led by Jones Lang La Salle Americas Inc (JLL) for the joint venture development of the Roosevelt Hotel. In November 2024, it was learnt that Qatar had explored partnering with Pakistan in managing the Roosevelt Hotel. The hotel, which opened in 1924, was named after President Theodore Roosevelt. It is located next to the Grand Central Terminal, the city's central train terminal.
Express Tribune
6 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Pakistan, Saudi Arabia to enhance tech collaboration
Minister of State for IT and Telecommunication, Shaza Fatima Khawaja: PHOTO: APP Federal Minister for IT and Telecommunication Shaza Fatima Khawaja held a high-level meeting with Saudi Minister for Communications and Information Technology Engineer Abdullah Al-Swaha to enhance collaboration in emerging technologies, artificial intelligence (AI) and digital infrastructure. The two sides discussed the establishment of the Pakistan Digital Corridor to China and Central Asia to strengthen global connectivity. They emphasised the need for cooperation in AI and computing technologies, reaffirming their commitment to strategic partnerships. Shaza Fatima highlighted a Rs4.8 billion project approved under the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) to train over 7,000 Pakistani youth in semiconductor technologies. She reiterated Pakistan's support for Saudi Arabia's National Semiconductor Hub, expressing confidence in the kingdom's leadership in the tech domain. Discussions also covered collaboration under Saudi Arabia's National Technology Development Programme and ways to foster partnerships between Pakistani and Saudi companies. Shaza Fatima outlined Pakistan's cybersecurity successes and the strong role played by its armed forces in recent geopolitical developments. She reaffirmed that Pakistan remains a committed partner in Saudi Arabia's growth and success.
