Editorial: Japan gov't must reflect on illegal reduction of welfare benefits, make amends
The Japanese Supreme Court ruled June 27 that the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare's decision to reduce welfare payments between 2013 and 2015 was illegal. The ministry had cut "living assistance" -- funds for daily expenses such as food and utilities -- by up to 10%, significantly impacting recipients' lives.
The welfare system is a crucial lifeline that guarantees a minimum standard of living for people. The latest judicial decision harshly criticizes the state for disregarding this principle.
The key issue was the validity of the government's method for calculating the reduced payment amounts. The welfare ministry based its decision on prolonged deflation and used price fluctuation rates as a benchmark. However, the declining prices of TVs, computers and other items that are infrequently purchased were used to calculate the rates. Welfare recipients argued that the reductions did not reflect their actual living conditions and were excessive.
The court ruled that reducing the standard amount of living assistance solely based on price fluctuation rates constituted an abuse of discretion. There was no precedent of payment adjustments based solely on price changes, and the welfare ministry's decision did not involve consultation with experts. The ministry must take this ruling seriously.
As of April 2013, more than 2 million people were on welfare. The decision to reduce people's benefits affected even those who did not join in the lawsuit, and the government must promptly compensate them for the unjust reductions.
It cannot be overlooked that this measure was implemented amid a growing backlash online and elsewhere against welfare recipients. The ruling Liberal Democratic Party pledged a 10% reduction in benefit levels in principle in its 2012 House of Representatives election manifesto, and the cuts were executed under the second administration of then Prime Minister Shinzo Abe.
The ministry's approach appears to have been predetermined and forceful. It cannot be denied that they lacked the self-awareness expected of a governmental body tasked with protecting people's lives. A thorough examination of the decision-making process is essential.
Welfare payments are not "handouts" for those in need but the foundation for a society where all people can live with a sense of security. Anyone can lose their foundation of livelihood due to illness or accidents.
It is said that only 20-30% of eligible individuals actually utilize the welfare benefit system, indicating that the safety net is not functioning sufficiently.
There is also a social stigma surrounding welfare, making recipients feel ashamed. The government's aggressive reductions may have exacerbated prejudices against those on welfare.
The Japanese government must deeply reflect and create an environment where those who need the welfare system can use it with peace of mind.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Times
2 hours ago
- Japan Times
LDP to discuss governance plans after Upper House election, Moriyama says
The ruling Liberal Democratic Party will discuss how to best run the government after next month's House of Councillors election, as arranging a partial coalition would take time, Secretary-General Hiroshi Moriyama has said. "The most important thing is that we run the government as we listen to what each parliamentary group has to say on various issues," Moriyama said in an interview Thursday, when asked about the possibility of expanding the LDP-Komeito coalition after the July 20 Upper House election. Moriyama said that "arrangements take time" to forge a partial alliance under which the ruling camp asks opposition parties for cooperation on individual political issues. "We need to consider whether we will be able to continue such a framework," he added. During this year's ordinary parliament session, which ended on Sunday, the ruling coalition secured the passage of some bills through partial alliances. Regarding the Upper House election, Moriyama said, "We need to demonstrate honest politics at a time when the future is filled with uncertainties." Emphasizing the importance of sticking to policies that take responsibility for the future, he stated, "The focal point of the upcoming poll is whether people choose to pass burdens on to future generations or create a present with the future in mind." The LDP aims to build a strong economy with nominal gross domestic product of ¥1 quadrillion by 2040 and raise the average personal income by at least 50 pct from the current level, he said. At the same time, the party will support people's daily lives through planned cash handouts, he said. On opposition calls for a consumption tax cut, Moriyama said, "Our proposal (for the handouts) is the best option for people struggling right now." A consumption tax cut "would benefit low-income individuals less and higher earners more," Moriyama said. "Even if such a tax cut is decided in this autumn's extraordinary Diet session, the measure would not take effect until next April," he added. On his assessment of the administration of Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, who heads the LDP, Moriyama said that Ishiba has managed to steer the government although the LDP-Komeito coalition is a minority in the House of Representatives, the all-important lower chamber. Moriyama said that the administration realized the enactment of the fiscal 2025 budget in time for the start of the fiscal year after discussions with some opposition parties on individual issues. "I think that the administration fulfilled its responsibilities to the people as it managed to reach a conclusion on each issue," he said. On the possible timing of a Cabinet reshuffle and an LDP executive roster revamp, Moriyama said, "I don't expect such shakeups to take place before the Upper House election because as we all know that is just unfeasible." He added that it will be up to Ishiba to decide when to implement reshuffles after the election.
Yomiuri Shimbun
2 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Japan, U.S. Agree to Continuously Hold Tariff Talks; Akazawa Seemingly Considering Extending His Visit for Negotiations
WASHINGTON — Japan and the United States agreed Friday to continuously hold a series of talks toward settling an agreement in the two countries' tariff negotiations with July 9, the day considered to be the critical date, approaching. July 9 marks the end of the pause on 'reciprocal tariffs' imposed by the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump. In Friday's hour-long meeting, Ryosei Akazawa, the minister in charge of economic revitalization, held a seventh round of ministerial-level talks with U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick in Washington. According to the Japanese government's announcement, both Tokyo and Washington reaffirmed their position on tariff measures during the meeting. As in previous talks, the Japanese side is believed to have sought a common ground, including a review of reciprocal tariffs on automobiles, the main focus of the talks. The announcement did not mention a schedule for future negotiations including those on and after July 9. Akazawa also is believed to have sought an opportunity to hold talks with U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who serves as chief negotiator for the United States, during the visit. Akazawa seemed to be considering extending his visit, which originally was scheduled to end Saturday.
Kyodo News
2 hours ago
- Kyodo News
Iran envoy urges A-bombed Japan to stand against U.S. attacks
KYODO NEWS - 20 hours ago - 20:02 | All, Japan, World Iranian ambassador to Japan Peiman Seadat has urged Tokyo to stand against U.S. and Israeli strikes on nuclear facilities in his nation after President Donald Trump's remark likening the U.S. attacks to the 1945 atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The ambassador said in a recent interview with Kyodo News that the comment is an "insult" not only to Iran, but also to Japan, the world's only country to have suffered atomic bombings. Japan should raise a "very loud voice," Seadat said, adding that Japan's voice is "important" to the international community. The interview was held after the United States, Japan's close ally, bombarded key Iranian nuclear sites on Sunday. Israel and Iran had been engaged in a tit-for-tat conflict following Israeli airstrikes on military and nuclear targets on June 13 before announcing a cease-fire on Tuesday. Trump said Wednesday during his visit to the Netherlands for a NATO summit, "I don't want to use an example of Hiroshima, I don't want to use an example of Nagasaki, but that was essentially the same thing. That ended that war." Japanese Foreign Minister Takeshi Iwaya said in a statement Monday that Japan "understands" the U.S. military action as a demonstration of its resolve to de-escalate the situation while preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. Stability in the Middle East is vital for resource-poor Japan, given its heavy dependence on the region for crude oil, and it has traditionally maintained friendly ties with Iran. Seadat criticized Trump's reference to the atomic bombings on the two Japanese cities in the closing days of World War II as an "outrageous" and "irresponsible" statement showing "total disregard for human suffering." The envoy said the U.S. attacks on the nuclear sites deserve "global condemnation," calling them "acts of aggression" committed in violation of international law. He also said that "forcing peace is not peace," in reference to Trump's comment on his Truth Social media site that "Perhaps Iran can now proceed to Peace and Harmony in the Region." The U.S. military action right in the middle of nuclear negotiations was an act of "betrayal by the Trump administration," Seadat said. Related coverage: Trump likens U.S. strikes on Iran to bombings of Hiroshima, Nagasaki NATO leaders agree to raise defense spending to 5% of GDP by 2035
