Judge rejects bid to split lawsuit against investment adviser into 78 separate cases
Social Sharing
A Nova Scotia judge has rejected a request from an investment adviser to split a lawsuit against him into 78 separate cases.
Frederick Saturley, with his company High Tide Wealth Management, is accused of wiping out the life savings of his clients.
The case has been dragging on since late 2020.
Earlier this month, Saturley's lawyer, Christopher Robinson, made an application before the Nova Scotia Supreme Court to break up the case against his client. Robinson had argued the plaintiffs didn't have enough in common to justify a single trial.
In an oral decision delivered Monday, Justice Denise Boudreau rejected the request.
She said if she granted the severance request, the individual trials would drag on for years. As it is, the case is still in its early stages, even though the initial statement of claim was filed in September 2020.
The case centres on the stock market collapse at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. The plaintiffs allege that Saturley had engaged in investment strategies that were far more aggressive than they were comfortable with, and that he did it without their knowledge.
The market collapse wiped out their accounts. In some cases, investors actually owed the bank additional money. One of the lawyers for the investors estimates their losses at around $40 million.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
3 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Mark Carney says sacrifice is necessary to pay for defence spending. So what will Canadians be asked to do?
Mark Carney 's bold new plan to increase Canada's defence spending comes with two price tags. The prime minister's announcement was clear on one of them: more than $9 billion will be injected into military spending this year alone, and increases in the years after. The other price — 'sacrifice' — got a mention from Carney, but little more by way of detail. Federal Politics Canada plans huge boost in defence spending to hit NATO target by year's end, Carney says Prime Minister Mark Carney tore up Canada's timelines for boosted military spending on Monday 'None of these goals will come easily or quickly,' Carney said, listing the ways in which a stronger defence budget fits into his larger plans to make Canada a bigger, bolder, more independent nation. 'All will require ambition, collaboration and yes, on occasion, sacrifice.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Carney was asked at a news conference later what he meant by this. Did it mean, for instance, that all those dollars for defence would come ahead of health-care spending? This is where the prime minister got vague. He said: 'There's no true security without economic strength, and this is true for defence and security. It's true for our social programs as well. We can't redistribute what we don't have.' Carney, by his own admission, is still learning how to be a politician, but on this and in other areas, he is proving to be a quick study. It is very hard for politicians to ask citizens to make sacrifices. We saw this during the COVID pandemic, when governments and public-health authorities asked an awful lot of the citizens, whether that was mandatory vaccines, wearing a mask, or submitting to lockdowns for weeks and months on end. Canadians were remarkably good about these demands on them, by and large, but there's also no question that it took its toll on them too. The convoy protest was the most outward expression of the pent-up frustration among some of the population, but experts are also drawing some straight lines between the pandemic restrictions and the rising resistance to vaccines of other types too, such as measles. Star Columnists Opinion Andrew Phillips: Mark Carney takes a risk by choosing guns over butter The prime minister announced a 17 per cent hike in military spending on Monday. 'It will be a This is all to say that Carney is probably wise to speak in only general terms of what trade-offs the government — and Canadians — will have to make to turn Canada into a serious, fighting force. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Earlier this year, Kevin Page, the former parliamentary budget officer, laid out for Global News what could be required to bring Canada's defence spending up to the target of two per cent of gross domestic product — which Carney said on Monday would now happen by the end of this fiscal year. Page didn't sugar-coat it. He said it would require either big spending cuts, or a budget deficit or a tax hike, or some combination of these measures. Raising the GST by one percentage point, Page offered as an example, would bring an extra $10 billion — that's just slightly more than Carney is promising to give defence this year. That last option would be political poison in a time when Canadians are reeling from affordability challenges and the havoc that Donald Trump's tariffs are wreaking on the economy. Besides, a government that just cut the carbon levy because of its unpopularity, which just received unanimous support for tax-cut measures last week, is unlikely to turn around and ask Canadians to pay more GST. Opinion Althia Raj: Mark Carney can't be allowed to ram through his plan to build big Bill C-5 has been quickly panned by Indigenous groups, human rights organizations, and There's the option of increasing taxes only on the wealthy, but Carney is in the midst of building back Liberals' standing with business and corporate Canada, which saw itself — rightly or wrongly — as under siege from Justin Trudeau's government. Assuming that running a deficit is also not on brand with Carney's fiscal-manager reputation, thus, not on at all, that leaves this government looking for big savings. Everyone always thinks this is a good idea, right up until their services or benefits or jobs get cut. As former PM Jean Chrétien liked to say, everyone wants to go to heaven but nobody wants to die. None of this is to pour cold water on the idea of this big, bold boost in Canada's defence ambitions. Carney's speech on Monday was eloquent, even occasionally poetic, on this score. One of my favourite lines: 'In a darker, more competitive world, Canadian leadership will be defined not just by the strength of our values, but also by the value of our strength.' The announcement too, is buying the Liberals a lot of good words from unaccustomed places: the defence community and Conservatives. It will also give Carney and Canada some added heft at this weekend's G-7 meeting, which this country is hosting in Kananaskis, AB. Federal Politics Analysis Mark Carney revives tough talk about America and warns 'a new imperialism threatens' A Canadian government official told the Star that it is 'difficult to say whether or not we'll The prime minister is, then, to borrow from his own phrase, seeing some immediate value for his strong words on defence. Where the value of that strength will be tested is in the cost — not just the $9 billion the government is promising to lay out this year, but in the as-yet unspecified 'sacrifice' it requires from Canadians. Politics Headlines Newsletter Get the latest news and unmatched insights in your inbox every evening Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. Please enter a valid email address. Sign Up Yes, I'd also like to receive customized content suggestions and promotional messages from the Star. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Politics Headlines Newsletter You're signed up! You'll start getting Politics Headlines in your inbox soon. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page.
Global News
4 hours ago
- Global News
Edmonton faces $1.5B capital funding budget shortfall — which is set to grow
The City of Edmonton doesn't have enough money to maintain its existing infrastructure, let alone build anything new. In a fiscal update on Tuesday at City Hall, administration said there is $1.5 billion capital funding shortfall. The money goes towards grants, neighbourhood renewals, fleet replacements and also for debt finance infrastructure. Edmonton isn't unique in this struggle — the city said this is an issue many cities are struggling with in the years following the COVID-19 pandemic. Five years ago, Edmonton paused increasing taxes — something thought to be necessary at the time when many households were dealing with financial struggles such as layoffs or business closures due to the global health emergency. Story continues below advertisement But now, Mayor Amarjeet Sohi says decisions like that, made by previous councils, are coming back to bite the city now. 'They froze taxes, they reduced taxes, they left this council with a huge deficit in our day-to-day operations — underfunding of city services like snow removal, not caring much about social equity issues that we are trying to tackle here, or grant funding that we have increased to community organizations.' 'Neglect will catch up on you and that's exactly what we see.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "Neglect will catch up on you and that's exactly what we see." 2:01 Edmonton city council approves 8.9% property tax increase in 2024 City leaders say the solution isn't as simple as just spending less, because that can end up costing more down the road. Get weekly money news Get expert insights, Q&A on markets, housing, inflation, and personal finance information delivered to you every Saturday. Sign up for weekly money newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'Fiscal responsibility isn't just about keeping taxes low or repressing things because this is what you end up getting,' said Ward Anirniq councillor Erin Rutherford. Story continues below advertisement 'You end up with deferred maintenance, deferred renewal, and then we have the deficit that we're seeing today. 'That hole was dug over years and years — probably decades — and we can't get out of it in one fell swoop.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "That hole was dug over years and years — probably decades — and we can't get out of it in one fell swoop." Rutherford said one of the long-term solutions the city has come up with is a Universal Renewal Fund. She explained it's dedicated to things like neighbourhood renewal and road maintenance – which can't be funded through loans or money from other levels of government. 'Renewal isn't sexy. It's a lot of behind-the-scenes stuff. So you need what we call pay-as-you-go funding, which means we need cash in hand to fix the things. That's really hard to find unless you build up a piggy bank, so to say, of tax funding that is going straight to that purpose,' Rutherford said. 'It's saying to the residents, 'You know, I know we're taxing you on this, this is what it's going for. You know those potholes that you're complaining about all the time? It's because we're actually not renewing at our ideal state.' So to get there, we need to actually have this fund that, on an ongoing basis, will give us more cash in hand to do the work of maintaining our city.' 1:44 City of Edmonton explores avenues to address funding shortfall Sohi said the city has reduced the operating budget by nearly $200 million but more still needs to be done. Story continues below advertisement The mayor said the city's finances took a hit due to changes the province made to Municipal Sustainability Initiative (MSI) funding. The program allocated more than $15.2 billion to Alberta communities when it was in place between 2007 and 2023. The provincial government replaced MSI with the Local Government Fiscal Framework (LGFF) in 2024-25. 'We are getting one-third of what we were getting before, and we had to make it up by raising taxes or deferring the repairs. So I think municipalities in Alberta do not get the kind of support that is necessary to continue to provide good quality public services,' Sohi said. On top of the current shortfall, the city expects to be another $1.8 billion short in the next budget cycle, making the gap $3.2 billion. But that doesn't mean the city can just stop maintaining its assets — if nothing is done, Rutherford said it could mean closing down facilities and selling off assets. 'If we do nothing, in 20 years we'll have a huge proportion of our city assets in D and F condition, which means they're basically at failure level, and we will have to shut down some of the most valuable assets that Edmontonians have come to love, right? Our recreation centres, our libraries, our transit service will get worse. 'We will start to see those failures in service across the system.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "We will start to see those failures in service across the system." Story continues below advertisement 1:54 City of Edmonton environmental policies driving up capital budget costs Rutherford said that means the City of Edmonton will be quite limited in what new builds it commits to in the next four-year budget cycle. 'Any growth projects need to very strategic on things like safety — so fire halls, police stations — things that create tax uplift and economic wellness, and things that have funding from other orders of government.' Ultimately to tackle a billion-and-a-half-dollar gap, Edmonton taxpayers will be on the hook.
Calgary Herald
7 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
University of Calgary concludes record-breaking convocation ceremonies
The University of Calgary concluded its record-breaking spring convocation ceremonies on Tuesday, celebrating its largest-ever graduating class of 6,989 students. Article content University registrar Amy Dambrowitz said this year's numbers reflect the steady growth the school has seen in recent years, and she expects enrolment to continue to increase. Article content Article content Factors such as population growth, increases in government funding and the expansion of key programs have all contributed to the university's growing numbers. Article content Article content Article content The honorary degrees were awarded to Patrick Carlson — an engineer, entrepreneur and University of Calgary alumnus — for his contributions to Canada's oil and gas industry, and former CUPS CEO Carlene Donnelly for her leadership and contributions to the organization's growth. Article content Dambrowitz said seeing the joy in the faces of graduates as they cross the stage and the excitement of their families cheering them on is a highlight of the academic year. Article content Article content Through her work as registrar, Dambrowitz is well-versed in the challenges that students face, which included the COVID-19 pandemic for many among this year's graduating class. Article content '(Many of) these students would have been the ones who started in the fall of 2021,' she said. 'So you think about where that is in the COVID cycle. These are students who really, really had to want to be here.' Article content Article content Having watched thousands of students cross the stage, Dambrowitz considers herself an expert in picking out the ones who are most nervous. Article content 'I lean over and I'm like, 'OK, you've got three jobs: breathe, walk, smile,' ' she said. 'To see them stand at that corner of the stage and own the space is just lovely. Article content 'In September, we see them show up with their new backpacks and their new shoes, and they're walking around holding their phones in front of their faces trying to navigate campus,' Dambrowitz said.
