Why Trump's deployment of military in California is so controversial
US President Donald Trump ordered California National Guard to dispatch at least 2,000 soldiers to LA to control thousands of demonstrators. PHOTO: REUTERS
Why Trump's deployment of military in California is so controversial
President Donald Trump ordered the California National Guard on June 7 to dispatch at least 2,000 soldiers to the Los Angeles area as thousands of people demonstrating against immigration raids clashed with security forces.
After vandalism and violence broke out, the Pentagon escalated the federal response by also mobilising 700 active-duty Marines.
The president said on his Truth Social platform that federal agencies were to take 'all such action necessary' to stop what he called 'migrant riots'.
The rare move by a president to mobilise military forces to quell domestic unrest was quickly condemned as unnecessary and counterproductive by local authorities, including Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass and California Governor Gavin Newsom.
On June 9, California sued the Trump administration over its 'illegal' deployment of state troops and US Marines, claiming it had overstepped its authority.
What is the National Guard?
The National Guard has its roots in the colonial militias formed in the 1600s to defend the colonies against Native Americans and European powers, making it the oldest component of the US military.
As the militias evolved and became more organised and professional, National Guard units were founded in all the states and US territories.
Presently, the National Guard comprises more than 325,000 members recruited mostly from the communities they serve as a state-based reserve force to assist with emergency responses to natural disasters and civil unrest.
Most members are civilians who volunteer to serve part-time. They are also available for federal service, including overseas deployments.
Who normally calls on the National Guard, and why?
State governors typically coordinate the activation of guard troops to respond to local events, from wildfires to floods, when civil authorities are overwhelmed.
When the guard is called in to help restore order, state and local law enforcement agencies remain responsible for security.
On some occasions, the president has deployed National Guard troops to respond to civil unrest and rioting. President Lyndon Johnson, for example, deployed National Guard soldiers under federal control in Detroit, Chicago and Baltimore to help quell race riots in the late 1960s.
This was in response to requests for federal assistance from state and territorial governors.
Likewise, President George H.W. Bush activated the California National Guard in 1992 at the request of Governor Pete Wilson and Los Angeles Mayor Tom Bradley when rioting broke out in the city following a jury's acquittal of police officers charged with severely beating a Black man, Rodney King, after a high-speed car chase.
The last time a president has activated a state's National Guard without a request from the governor was in 1965, when President Johnson sent troops to Alabama to protect civil rights demonstrators.
Under what circumstances can the president call on the military?
The law strictly limits the federal deployment of troops within US borders. The 1878 Posse Comitatus Act, along with amendments and supporting regulations, generally bars the use of the active-duty US military - the Army, Navy, Air Force and Marines - from carrying out domestic law enforcement.
Important exceptions to the 1878 law are contained in the 1807 Insurrection Act and its modern iterations, which allow the president, without congressional approval, to employ the military for domestic use in certain circumstances.
The Insurrection Act has been used very rarely to deploy troops under federal control domestically without a request from a state government, with examples mostly dating from the Civil Rights era.
The law on which Trump relied to unilaterally dispatch California National Guard troops to Los Angeles - a provision of Title X of the US Code - permits domestic deployment only in cases of invasion by a foreign nation, rebellion, or danger of a rebellion.
The president's June 7 proclamation gives Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth the authority to direct troops to take 'reasonably necessary' actions to protect immigration agents and other federal workers and federal property.
It also permits him to use members of the regular armed forces 'as necessary to augment and support the protection of federal functions and property in any number determined appropriate in his discretion'.
Mr Trump and top officials in his administration have sought to justify the current Los Angeles deployments by arguing that local and state officials have failed to restore order.
The president joined White House border czar Tom Homan in suggesting that Newsom should be arrested over his handling of the unrest.
In its legal challenge, California is arguing that the president has abused his authority, saying there is no rebellion or invasion that justifies Mr Trump sending troops into Los Angeles.
How else has the National Guard been controversial?
Perhaps the most infamous deployment in modern history was in May 1970 when the Ohio National Guard opened fire on a crowd of students at Kent State University, who were protesting the Vietnam War and President Richard Nixon's announcement of an invasion into Cambodia.
The resulting deaths of four students and injuries to nine others sparked widespread outrage.
In his first term, Mr Trump asked state governors to send troops to Washington to curb protests that erupted after the murder of Mr George Floyd in 2020.
Years later, former Defence Secretary Mark Esper testified to a House committee that he and others had to convince Mr Trump there was no legal justification for that use of the military.
At the time Mr Trump felt the unrest in the wake of Mr Floyd's murder in Minnesota made the US look weak, Esper told the committee.
As he campaigned for a second term, Mr Trump made clear he wanted to be more aggressive in using the military.
At an event in Iowa in 2023 he labelled several big cities 'crime dens' and said he previously held back from sending in the military. BLOOMBERG
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AsiaOne
21 minutes ago
- AsiaOne
Trump tells soldiers 'we will liberate Los Angeles', World News
FORT BRAGG, North Carolina — President Donald Trump used a speech honouring soldiers on Tuesday (June 10) to defend his decision to deploy troops to Los Angeles in a confrontation over his immigration policy, a move critics have decried as a politically motivated over-reaction. "Generations of Army heroes did not shed their blood on distant shores only to watch our country be destroyed by invasion and third-world lawlessness," Trump told soldiers at the Army base in Fort Bragg, North Carolina. "What you're witnessing in California is a full-blown assault on peace, on public order and on national sovereignty, carried out by rioters bearing foreign flags," Trump said, adding his administration would "liberate Los Angeles". Trump's visit to Fort Bragg, home to some 50,000 active-duty soldiers, followed his move to deploy 700 Marines and 4,000 National Guard troops to Los Angeles in an escalating response to street protests over his immigration policies. The Republican president said the military deployment was needed to protect federal property and personnel. California's Democratic-led government has sued to block Trump's move, calling it an abuse of power and an unnecessary provocation. Street demonstrations have been underway since Friday, when activists clashed with sheriff's deputies. Los Angeles officials have said the unrest has been limited to a few downtown blocks and that the majority of demonstrators are protesting peacefully in support of immigrants. In North Carolina, Trump and Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth took part in long-scheduled commemorations of the US Army's 250th anniversary, watching soldiers demonstrate a special forces assault and use a long-range missile launcher. It was the first in a series of celebrations of the Army anniversary involving Trump, ahead of a major parade in Washington on Saturday. Speaking to reporters earlier on Tuesday in the Oval Office, Trump warned against demonstrators at that parade, saying "they're going to be met with very big force". He made no distinction between peaceful and violent protesters. The FBI and the Metropolitan Police Department have said there are no credible threats to the event. Pomp and politics The week's Army commemorations combine Trump's penchant for patriotic pomp and his political positioning as a law-and-order president. Saturday's celebrations in Washington include thousands of troops, dozens of military aircraft and coincide with Trump's 79th birthday. The Army was established on June 14, 1775, more than a year before the Declaration of Independence. During his speech at Fort Bragg, Trump led a crowd filled with traditionally non-partisan service members through punchlines he repeats at political rallies. He drew jeers directed at the press corps and cheers for attacks on efforts to embrace transgender service members. He also announced that the military would rename a number of bases which were changed after racial justice protests in 2023, including reverting to Fort Lee, which was originally named after Civil War-era Confederate commander Robert E. Lee. Earlier this year, Trump restored the name Fort Bragg to the base, one of the largest in the world, despite a federal law that prohibits honouring generals who fought for the South during the Civil War. His administration says the name now honours a different Bragg — Private First Class Roland Bragg, who served during World War Two. In 2023, the base had been renamed Fort Liberty. Since launching his second term in office in January, Trump has made the military a focus of his efforts. The president's cost-cutting government reforms have largely spared the Defence Department's nearly US$1 trillion (S$1.3 trillion) annual budget. He has pledged to avoid international conflict while launching new weapons programmes and increasing the use of the military domestically, including in immigration enforcement. Trump has pledged to deport record numbers of people who are in the country illegally and to lock down the US-Mexico border, setting the ICE border enforcement agency a daily goal of arresting at least 3,000 migrants. Demonstrators in Los Angeles have assembled, among other places, at a government facility where immigrants are detained. Though military forces have been deployed domestically for major disasters such as Hurricane Katrina and the attacks of Sept 11, 2001, it is rare for troops to be used domestically during civil disturbances. Even without declaring an insurrection, however, Trump can deploy Marines under certain conditions of law or under his authority as commander in chief. The last time the military was used for direct police action under the Insurrection Act was in 1992, when the California governor at the time asked President George H.W. Bush to help respond to Los Angeles riots over the acquittal of police officers who beat Black motorist Rodney King. [[nid:718909]]
Business Times
28 minutes ago
- Business Times
US, China officials agree on plan to ramp down trade tensions
THE US and China de-escalated trade tensions, agreeing to a preliminary deal on how to implement the consensus the two sides reached in Geneva, negotiators for both sides said. While the full details of their accord weren't immediately available, US negotiators said they 'absolutely expect' that issues around shipments of rare earth minerals and magnets will be resolved with the framework implementation. 'We have reached a framework to implement the Geneva consensus,' US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick told reporters in London. The US and Chinese delegations will now take the proposal back to their respective leaders, said China's chief trade negotiator Li Chenggang, after two days of discussions that spanned nearly 20 hours in a Georgian-era mansion near Buckingham Palace. 'Once the presidents approve it, we will then seek to implement it,' Lutnick added. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer said there were no other meetings scheduled, but added that the American and Chinese sides talk frequently and are able to do so whenever they need. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The talks in London came at the urging of the Trump administration to cement a pledge the Chinese government made to ease shipments of rare earths during last month's trade talks in Geneva, which yielded a tariff truce. The disagreement over critical mineral exports reignited open economic conflict between the US and China and raised the prospect their nascent deal could collapse, which would pose a fresh threat for the world economy. 'We do absolutely expect that the topic of rare Earth minerals and magnets with respect to the United States of America will be resolved in this framework implementation,' Lutnick said. 'Also, there were a number of measures the United States of America put on when those rare earths were not coming,' Lutnick added. 'You should expect those to come off - sort of, as President Trump said, in a balanced way. When they approve the licenses, then you should expect that our export implementation will come down as well.' 'When it comes to export controls and all those different things,' Greer said, 'in eight years of negotiating with the Chinese, I've never had a meeting where they didn't want to talk about export controls.' BLOOMBERG
Straits Times
30 minutes ago
- Straits Times
US Marines arrive in LA on Trump's orders as immigration protests persist
Protesters blow bubbles near a row of police in riot gear during a protest in Los Angeles on June 9. PHOTO: AFP Law enforcement officers confront demonstrators outside the Federal Building as protests continue in Los Angeles on June 10. PHOTO: AFP US Marines arrive in LA on Trump's orders as immigration protests persist LOS ANGELES - Hundreds of US Marines arrived in the Los Angeles area on June 10 under orders from President Donald Trump, stirring street protesters and raising alarm among Democratic leaders who warn of authoritarianism. Trump has also activated 4,000 National Guard troops to quell protests in the city despite objections from California Governor Gavin Newsom that the deployments were unnecessary, illegal and politically motivated. The city has seen five days of public protests since the Trump administration launched a series of immigration raids on June 6, with police moving on downtown Los Angeles protesters again on June 10 and Mayor Karen Bass considering a curfew for parts of downtown Los Angeles. Even so, state and local officials have called Trump's response an extreme overreaction to mostly peaceful demonstrations. About 700 Marines were in a staging area in the Seal Beach area about 50 km south of Los Angeles, awaiting deployment to specific locations, a US official said. California's two senators, Adam Schiff and Alex Padilla, said in a joint statement that active-duty military personnel should only be mobilised domestically 'during the most extreme circumstances, and these are not them.' Mr Trump, who has made the immigration crackdown his signature issue, used a speech honoring soldiers on June 10 to defend his decision, telling soldiers at the Army base in Fort Bragg, North Carolina: 'Generations of Army heroes did not shed their blood on distant shores only to watch our country be destroyed by invasion and third-world lawlessness.' 'What you're witnessing in California is a full-blown assault on peace, on public order and on national sovereignty, carried out by rioters bearing foreign flags,' Mr Trump said, adding his administration would 'liberate Los Angeles'. Demonstrators have waved the flags of Mexico and other countries in solidarity for the migrants rounded in a series of intensifying raids. Homeland Security said on June 9 its Immigration and Customs Enforcement division had arrested 2,000 immigration offenders per day recently, far above the 311 daily average in fiscal year 2024 under former President Joe Biden. Mayor says: Stop the raids Los Angeles mayor Ms Bass emphasised at a press conference that unrest has been limited to a few downtown areas and she drew a distinction between the majority of demonstrators protesting peacefully and a smaller number of agitators she blamed for violence and looting. She told CNN she would consider a curfew limited to certain areas of downtown. The city has seen five days of public protests since the Trump administration launched a series of immigration raids on June 6. PHOTO: AFP In what has become a ritual each afternoon, police on June 10 started forcing demonstrators away from the streets outside the Metropolitan Detention Center, where many detained migrants are held. More than 180 people have been arrested in the region since June 7 and more arrests were being made on June 10 as police helicopters buzzed overhead and other officers stood at the ready with their hands on batons and less lethal munitions. A few protesters verbally accosted police. Nearby business owners who were scrubbing off graffiti and sweeping up litter said they did not support the immigration raids and felt Mr Trump's response was only fanning the flames. 'I agree with what the protesters are defending -- they're standing up for the Latino community,' said Frank Chavez, 53, manager of an office building. 'But there are a few carrying out vandalism and violence, and that must be stopped.' Protests took place in other cities including Chicago, where police led at least two demonstrators away in handcuffs from a combative march through downtown. Other protesters shouted 'Shame! Shame!' as officers took away detained demonstrators. Hundreds of people turned out for the evening protest, carrying signs with messages such as: 'The people say ICE out' and 'Immigrants made America.' 'Even if they send the police, or dogs or whatever, we're always going to be out here,' said protester Marquise Howard, 24. More immigration raids The Marines do not have arrest authority and will protect federal property and personnel, according to military officials. There were approximately 2,100 Guard troops in greater Los Angeles on June 10, with more on the way, the official said. Mr Newsom and the state sued Mr Trump and the Defense Department on June 9, seeking to block the deployment of federal troops. California Attorney-General Rob Bonta told Reuters the state was concerned about allowing federal troops to protect personnel, saying there was a risk that could violate a 1878 law that generally forbids the US military, including the National Guard, from taking part in civilian law enforcement. 'The federal property part I understand - defending and protecting federal buildings,' Mr Bonta said. 'But protecting personnel likely means accompanying ICE agents into communities and neighbourhoods, and protecting functions could mean protecting the ICE function of enforcing the immigration law.' US Immigration and Customs Enforcement on June 10 posted photos on X of National Guard troops accompanying ICE officers on an immigration raid. Trump administration officials have vowed to redouble the immigration raids in response to the street protests. Marines are trained for conflicts around the world and used for rapid deployments in case of emergencies, such as threats to US embassies. Some units also learn riot and crowd control techniques. Mr Trump has left open the possibility of invoking the centuries-old Insurrection Act, which would allow the military to take part directly in civilian law enforcement. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
