'Good case' Israel breached international law with Madleen seizure
On Monday, Israel imprisoned 12 crew members on board the vessel that was sailing along the Egyptian coast and heading towards Gaza to deliver aid.
It is understood that the Madleen was captured in international waters some 200 kilometres (120 miles) from Gaza.
Heidi Matthews, a professor specialising in international criminal law at York University in Toronto, Canada, said that as the naval blockade on Gaza is 'unlawful', there are several points of law that the Israeli forces breached by capturing the Madleen.
READ MORE: LIVE: Gaza Freedom Flotilla, Madleen tracker and updates
Matthews explained that there are two specific conditions which allow countries to enforce a blockade in international waters.
First, if a vessel is making an 'effective contribution to opposing forces', for example, if it had weapons on board.
Second, if it was posing an 'imminent and overwhelming threat' to Israel, that would allow them to 'invoke self defence on the high seas'.
Matthews explained: 'Obviously, neither of these conditions have been met in these circumstances.
'So because of that, intercepting the vessel and taking custody of the crew members is not the enforcement of a lawful blockade, as Israel is claiming.'
The Madleen, which carried campaigner Greta Thunberg and French member of the European Parliament Rima Hassan, was sailing under the UK red ensign, meaning it was under UK jurisdiction while in international waters.
'I think there's a good case that these actions, specifically the detention of crew members could constitute crimes against humanity, specifically unlawful confinement and unlawful appropriation of property, as well as an attack against civilians as such,' Matthews (below) added.
(Image: Heidi Matthews) 'Others have made the case that could constitute a war crime too.'
Mitchell pointed out that Israel's response to the capture of the vessel, such as deeming it a 'selfie yacht' and releasing pictures of Thunberg being handed a sandwich, were intended to undermine the mission as a 'silly thing'.
However, she added that it was clearly being 'treated as though it were a threat' by the deployment of Israeli forces.
Matthews added: 'Therefore arguably bringing in war crimes and in terms of crimes against humanity here like the way that would work, this is a little technical, but because the UK is a state party to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, and Israel is currently conducting a widespread or systematic attack against the civilian population of Gaza, intercepting this vessel on the high seas would trigger the territorial jurisdiction of the United Kingdom, and again, a couple of those crimes against humanity that I mentioned.'
She added that the UK Government should be thinking about the incident 'in terms of international criminal law and the law of war' and that it should 'be acting accordingly'.
The National have repeatedly pushed the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) for a response following the crew being detained on Monday.
READ MORE: Labour Government 'must protect' UK-flagged Madleen aid ship
After refusing to respond for hours, they directed our journalists to a BBC live blog with comments from the Prime Minister's spokesperson who said they wanted Israel to resolve the situation 'safely with restraint, in line with international humanitarian law'.
Earlier, Israel was preparing to hold the 12 unlawfully detained activists in separate cells in Givon Prison in Ramla, according to local media.
Israel Katz, Israel's defence minister, said that he had instructed the IDF to show the crew 'video of the horrors of the October 7 massacre when they arrive at the port of Ashdod'.
Matthews said the UK should consider taking a case to the International Criminal Court (ICC).
However, she noted the attack the Israeli navy committed in 2010 on the Mavi Marmara, a flagship of a flotilla crewed by pro-Palestinian activists who were attempting to deliver 10,000 tonnes of aid to Gaza.
(Image: PA) Israeli forces attacked the boat, which like the Madleen (above) was trying to breach the blockade on Gaza, leading to the death of nine people, and leaving a further 50 injured.
The UN Human Rights Council found that Israel's military had broken international laws by taking 'disproportionate action'. Prosecutors at the ICC declined to open an investigation into the alleged war crimes that took place during the attack.
Matthews said it was 'unfortunate' the case didn't proceed as it may have 'acted as a deterrent'.
READ MORE: LBC spark fury with pro-Israel report on seizure of Madleen Gaza ship
'The Madleen itself has obviously captured global attention, right? And so the purpose was always to do that,' she explained.
'Given the amount of media attention, I wasn't expecting them to actually sink the ship.
"Instead, they're trying to create this alternative narrative where a military intersection is actually not an attack, but some kind of rescue mission.'
She added: 'The battle is really over framing.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
26 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Putin could attack Nato by 2030, alliance boss warns as ‘Europe needs to build its own Golden Dome defence system'
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) VLADIMIR Putin could launch an assault on NATO by 2030, an alliance chief has warned. Mark Rutte, NATO's secretary general, has urged Europe to build "its own Golden Dome defence system" to protect countries from Russia's looming threat. 6 The NATO chief warned the end of the war in Ukraine won't stop the Russian threat Credit: AP 6 The alliance boss warned of Russia's threat to the UK and other European countries Credit: Getty 6 Nato Secretary General Mark Rutte spoke about Russia's looming threat at Chatham House Credit: PA The NATO head said that the alliance would need to take a "quantum leap" in building up its defence systems as Putin's war machine is "speeding up, not slowing down." Speaking at the world-leading policy institute, Chatham House, he urged European leaders to increase their air and missile defence capabilities by a staggering 400 per cent. Europe should also be prepared to protect its skies, as Russia's war on Ukraine has shown the despot leader "delivers terror from above". He said: "The fact is, we need a quantum leap in our collective defence. "The fact is, we must have more forces and capabilities to implement our defence plans in full. "The fact is, danger will not disappear even when the war in Ukraine ends." In an urgent plea to leaders, he called for militaries to be armed with thousands more vehicles and tanks, and millions more artillery shells. He also insisted allies double their resources supporting military power including logistics, transport and medical aid. Terrifyingly, Rutte also hinted at a potential triple threat - with Mad Vlad teaming up with despot leaders in China, North Korea and Iran. Russia currently produces in three months what the whole of NATO produces in a year, he said. Russia's ambassador to the UK 'blames Britain' for Ukraine's daring drone attack & warns of 'WWIII risk' China is also modernising and expanding its military, with its battle force expected to increase to 435 ships by 2030. He warned: "Wishful thinking will not keep us safe. We cannot dream away the danger. "Hope is not a strategy. So NATO has to become a stronger, fairer and more lethal alliance." The alliance chief's comments came as he pushed for NATO members to commit to ramping up defence spending at a key summit of the western military alliance later this month. Rutte is urging NATO members to commit to 3.5 percent of GDP on direct military spending by 2032, and an additional 1.5 percent on broader security-related expenditure. The proposal is a compromise deal designed to satisfy US President Donald Trump, who has demanded that allies each spend 5 percent of economic output on defence, up from a current commitment of two percent. Rutte said he "expects" leaders to agree to the proposal at the summit of the 32-country alliance on June 24-25 in The Hague. 6 The Israeli Iron Dome air defence system has protected the state from missile attacks Credit: AP 6 Donald Trump recently unveiled plans to build a Golden Dome over America "It will be a NATO-wide commitment and a defining moment for the alliance," he said in his speech. Russia condemned Rutte's comments before he took to the stage, denouncing NATO as "an instrument of aggression". NATO "is demonstrating itself as an instrument of aggression and confrontation", Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters in Moscow. This follows Rutte's meeting with the UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer - their second Downing Street talk since the Labour leader came into power last year. Starmer's government this year pledged to increase defence spending to 2.5 percent of GDP by 2027, but has not yet set a firm timeline for further hikes. Meanwhile, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announced Canada would hit two percent this year. US Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth said last week the allies were close to an agreement on the split five-percent target. "That combination constitutes a real commitment, and we think every country can step up," he said on Thursday. Space rockets & hypersonic interceptors…Trump unveils half-a-trillion dollar Golden Dome air defence to be ready by 2029 DONALD Trump has unveiled plans for a high-tech "Golden Dome" missile defence system, which the president claims should be operational by the end of his term in office. The futuristic concept announced by Trump would see American weapons put in space for the first time ever. Trump had already signalled his intent to set up a Golden Dome following his return to the White House, calling missile attacks the "most catastrophic threat facing the United States". The idea is modelled on Israel's Iron Dome defence system, which uses radar to detect incoming missiles and calculates which ones pose a threat to populated areas. But the Golden Dome would be an infinitely bigger project, not least because the United States is more than 400 times larger than Israel. During his announcement in the Oval Office yesterday, Trump said his new Golden Dome would be "capable of intercepting missiles even if they are launched from the other side of the world". NATO members have been scrambling to bolster their defence capabilities since Russia launched its invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Trump's return to the White House in January, and question marks over his commitment to European security, has added urgency. Rutte warned: "Danger will not disappear even when the war in Ukraine ends. "We must have more forces and capabilities to implement our defence plans in full." He added that if countries cannot commit to 5 percent for defence spending "you could still have the National Health Service, or in other countries, their health systems, the pension system, etc, but you better learn to speak Russian. I mean, that's the consequence". Britain announced plans last week to build up to 12 nuclear-powered attack submarines and six munitions factories to rearm the country in response to what it said were threats from Russia.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Expert gives verdict as BBC bosses plan to win over Reform UK voters
THE BBC is 'taking its cue from Donald Trump' by proposing to alter its drama output in a bid to win the trust of Reform UK voters, an expert on mainstreaming the far-right has said. BBC bosses including director-general Tim Davie have reportedly drawn up plans to win over Reform voters due to a belief their news and drama output is creating 'low trust issues' with supporters of Nigel Farage. Minutes from a meeting of the broadcaster's editorial guidelines and standards committee from March, revealed by The Byline Times, show that BBC News CEO Deborah Turness gave a presentation in which she discussed plans to alter "story selection" and "other types of output, such as drama" to win the trust of Reform voters. Professor Aurelien Mondon, an expert at the University of Bath on the mainstreaming of the far right, said he is concerned the BBC are 'caving in' to a backlash against equality and diversity with these plans, largely spearheaded by US President Trump. READ MORE: LBC spark fury with pro-Israel report on seizure of Madleen Gaza ship Asked about proposals to alter drama output specifically, Mondon told The National: 'This is the most concerning element to me. 'I think what we are seeing here is a pushback against equality and diversity and inclusion and it seems to me the BBC is taking its cue from Donald Trump, quite directly. 'It seems they are caving to this backlash against equality, diversity and inclusion. 'My worry is that they are jumping the gun and we're seeing that not just in the media, we're seeing it in universities as well, we're seeing a pushback in businesses. 'I think people are accepting a new world order without even pushing back. My worry is that this is what this is about, the changing [of] drama programmes.' Farage has repeatedly attacked the BBC, having called it a 'political actor' last year while appearing on GB News. He threatened to boycott the corporation following a Question Time appearance in which he was taken to task by members of the public over repeated instances of Reform candidates being involved in allegations of racism and homophobia. Following the broadcast, Farage said the audience was rigged and that they 'were not ordinary members of the public'. He threatened to not appear on the BBC until the broadcaster apologised. A YouGov poll last September showed less than 20% of Reform UK voters trusted the BBC to tell the truth. However, the same poll also showed more than 50% of people in the UK overall do not trust the BBC to tell the truth. (Image: University of Bath) In revealing plans to alter its coverage to try and win the trust of Reform voters, Mondon said the BBC is misunderstanding its role as a public broadcaster and how popular the party actually is. 'I think they misunderstand their role as a public broadcaster whose mission should be the defence of democracy,' he said. "It should platform a diversity of views, but that does not mean that it should give uncritical space to ideas which are contrary to democratic principle or a threat to some communities. This is deeply counterproductive as the case of the US has shown. 'The other thing I think they wilfully misunderstand is the level of support for Reform. In a way, they've bought into their own hype. 'Much of the media has been hyping the popularity of Reform in the last few months which I think is very problematic. I don't want to downplay the recent opinion polls that have shown Reform could be the most popular party, for example, but I think we need to take this with a grain of salt. "We've seen that in many other democracies the far right rising not because they are popular but because the mainstream parties are failing and losing support mostly to abstention. We have witnessed countless times now that giving uncritical platforms to the far right or disproportionate attention, it only ends up benefitting them." READ MORE: Richard Murphy: What to expect from Rachel Reeves's spending review The BBC has repeatedly been criticised for the extent to which it has platformed Farage and radical right or far right figures in recent years. The Question Time episode criticised by Farage was hastily arranged by the BBC so he could appear after not being involved in a previous edition, while a Panorama interview with Nick Robinson was also rescheduled last year after Farage pulled out at the last minute. Tom Mills, a sociology expert who wrote The BBC: The Myth of a Public Service, said last July said BBC had been 'really bad' at robustly questioning Farage throughout the election because, he claimed, it is more comfortable with an anti-establishment figure on the right than the left. The BBC was also found to have been disproportionately platforming people from right-wing media outlets on Question Time over the past decade by researchers at Cardiff University. They analysed a total of 352 programmes with 1734 guest slots, which were filled by 661 different people. However, while they found that the BBC had 'broadly balanced' appearances from representatives of the UK's main political parties, when it came to members of the media a right-wing bias became evident. The BBC was additionally called out on air in April by former presenter Matthew Stadlen for platforming anti-Muslim 'extremist' Douglas Murray, after he was given an eight-minute interview on Newsnight. The committee which discussed the plans to appeal more to Reform voters in March, included former GB News executive Robbie Gibb, who is also a former director of communications at Number 10 and an outspoken Brexiteer. Mondon has warned the BBC that continuing to hand a platform to Reform UK and far-right figures is a serious threat to democracy that the broadcaster should be seeking to protect. 'You don't need Reform in power to have far right politics in place,' Mondon went on. 'What we're seeing with a Labour government is that a lot of the discourse Reform was pushing is becoming increasingly normalised. The more they are given airtime on legitimate news sources, the worse things are going to get for democracy. 'We should be talking about the climate, education, housing, pensions and the cost of living and all we end up talking about is immigration in ways that are completely disproportionate. 'This is not what most people in the UK care about. This is what our media, our mainstream politicians, have placed high on the agenda to divert attention from the real crises they have no answers to.' The BBC has been approached for comment.
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Stop the War protest outside Glasgow's Buchanan Galleries
The demonstration, held on the Buchanan steps outside Buchanan Galleries, was organised by Glasgow Stop the War as an 'emergency protest' in response to the interception of a yacht carrying aid to Gaza. The group began to gather at around 5.30pm today, June 9. The vessel, described by organisers as a 'symbolic' mission, was reportedly attempting to break the Israeli naval blockade and deliver humanitarian supplies. RIGHT NOW: Emergency demonstration in Glasgow Release the Madleen crew immediately, end Israel's genocide now! — Glasgow Stop the War (@GlasgowStopWar) June 9, 2025 (Image: Newsquest) READ MORE: Activists surround police van as man 'detained' at pro-Palestine protest It was carrying 12 pro-Palestinian activists from around the world, including Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg. In a video recorded before the yacht's interception, activists said: 'If you see this video, we have been intercepted and kidnapped." The Glasgow protest was held in solidarity with the detained activists, with organisers urging the public to 'defend the flotilla.' Footage from the scene showed demonstrators chanting 'Stop the bombing' and holding signs that read 'Cut war, not welfare.' Emergency demo 🚨 Defend the Flotilla Buchanan steps tonight Monday 9 June 5.30pm 🇵🇸 — Glasgow Stop the War (@GlasgowStopWar) June 9, 2025 (Image: Newsquest) The protest takes place amid intensifying global scrutiny of Israel's military operations in Gaza, which began nearly 20 months ago following the October 7, 2023, attack by Hamas, in which approximately 1200 people were killed and 251 hostages taken. In the months since, the Hamas-run health ministry in Gaza reports that more than 54,880 people have been killed during the ongoing Israeli campaign. READ MORE: Pro-Palestine protesters target Glasgow firm linked with supplying weapons to Israel The activists aboard the intercepted yacht included nationals from Brazil, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Spain, Sweden, and Turkey. Israel's foreign ministry confirmed the vessel had been seized and was 'safely making its way to the shores of Israel.' The Glasgow protest is the latest in a series of demonstrations held across the UK and beyond, as calls grow louder for an immediate ceasefire and unimpeded humanitarian access to Gaza.
