logo
Elderly douple died after Covid ‘taken into house by carers'

Elderly douple died after Covid ‘taken into house by carers'

Independent14-05-2025

A Northern Ireland woman whose parents succumbed to Covid -19 within a month of each other believes care workers inadvertently brought the virus into their home.
Testifying before the UK Covid-19 Inquiry, Hazel Gray shared her heartbreaking experience, stating the infection was spread by "people doing their jobs", caring for vulnerable individuals like her parents.
The inquiry's seventh module is currently scrutinising the effectiveness of test, trace, and isolate protocols implemented during the pandemic.
Ms Gray described the enduring trauma of being unable to be with her parents in their final moments, saying they simply "disappeared." Her testimony underscores the devastating personal toll of the pandemic and raises questions about the safety measures in place to protect vulnerable individuals receiving in-home care.
Ms Gray's parents, George and Violet Little, from Co Fermanagh, died in December 2020 and January 2021. They were 80 and 78 years old.
Ms Gray, a member of the Northern Ireland Covid Bereaved Families for Justice group, told the inquiry on Tuesday that people in the region had presumed that 'things were being done' to prevent the spread of Covid.
She said: 'Only when it came to my own doorstep did I realise that what I presumed was not happening at all.
'People who were working with vulnerable people – carers coming to my mother – were actually not being tested, nor were other healthcare workers.
'To me, it seemed to be a total lack of common sense; this was nine months into the pandemic.
'These people were actually spreading a virus and nothing was being done to counteract that.'
The inquiry heard that Ms Gray's parents lived in a rural area and depended on carers who went to their house four times a day to move Mrs Little, who used a wheelchair.
Counsel to the inquiry Sophie Cartwright asked Ms Gray if she was confident Covid was taken into her parents' house by the carers.
Ms Gray said when her father first tested positive for the virus, she took a test herself.
She said: 'I immediately went and had a test and I was negative, so I knew that it wasn't me that had passed the virus to them.
'My mum, we got her a postal test. Hers came back positive as well and then mine was positive.
'I am fairly confident I didn't bring the virus to them and nobody else would have been in the house other than the carers.'
She said she spoke to the carers' manager and asked when they had been tested.
She told the inquiry: 'His answer was, it wasn't the hospital trust policy to actually test carers who were going into the homes of vulnerable people.
'That was the shocking realisation that this was what was happening in the country – carers were going into the homes of people who were not tested.'
Ms Gray said she sent a text message to then-health minister Robin Swann about the situation and he responded that he would look into it.
She told the inquiry that her father died first, in December 2020, while her mother was in hospital.
She said: 'I can't begin to imagine what it must have been like for my mother, knowing that my father had passed away and nobody was there with her to comfort her.
'They said on the day of my father's funeral she watched the clock.'
Ms Gray also raised concerns about paramedics who attended to both her father and mother while wearing 'basic PPE '.
She said: 'When I asked them did they get tested, they said no, who would do their jobs if they were going to be tested and come back positive?
'It was this attitude – 'If we don't get tested we won't know whether we are positive or not'.
'This virus was being spread by people who were doing their jobs and caring for people who were already sick.
'The process to me just did not make sense.'
Ms Gray said she was not able to be with either of her parents when they died because of Covid restrictions.
She said: 'If it had been an animal, a vet would encourage the animal's owner to be there with them to the very end.
'I, twice, didn't get that opportunity and so many people have had similar experiences.
'The trauma of not being there for your parents' last breaths will stay with me forever.
'My parents disappeared, I never saw them again.'
Ms Gray added: 'My parents' lives were cut short. Their experience was horrendous – for me, for them, for the whole country.
'All those who were lost, their lives must not have meant nothing, they cannot have died in vain.
'We must have changes in this country that people never have to experience this kind of trauma over a virus again.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Grimsby hospital's stroke advice prompts concerns from charity
Grimsby hospital's stroke advice prompts concerns from charity

BBC News

time35 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Grimsby hospital's stroke advice prompts concerns from charity

A charity said it was "deeply concerned" after a hospital advised patients presenting with a suspected stroke not to attend its emergency Lincolnshire and Goole NHS Foundation Trust said its Diana, Princess of Wales Hospital was "not the most appropriate place" for those experiencing symptoms because it did not have a specialist stroke unit. The trust advised patients to call 999 for an ambulance to take them to Scunthorpe General Hospital concerns have been raised by patients on ambulance waiting times.A spokesperson for the Stroke Association said any lengthy wait for an ambulance was "unacceptable" as every minute could shorten the chance of survival. 'Journey could cost time' In a social media post on Thursday, the trust said it had seen "a lot of instances recently" of patients arriving at the trust said: "This is not the most appropriate place to be seen, as we don't have a hyper-acute stroke unit at Diana, Princess of Wales Hospital."You should instead ring 999 if you've got symptoms and you'll be taken via ambulance to Scunthorpe General Hospital, which has the necessary facilities."If you do attend at Grimsby ED, you'll be sent to Scunthorpe via ambulance."The post received criticism from some social media users with a number of individuals questioning what could happen to them if they were taken person wrote: "Why as a member of the public in a state of emergency should we have to ensure we are heading to the right place?"Others questioned the time taken and distance they would travel to reach the hospital by ambulance.A user wrote: "The trip to Scunthorpe could add an extra 30-40 [minutes] on the journey."Another wrote: "If you live closer to Grimsby then maybe that's the natural place you'd automatically think you should go!" 'Systemic challenges' Samantha Jones, associate director at Stroke Association, said they were "hugely grateful" to medical practitioners who were working tirelessly under extreme said: "Despite their best efforts, systemic challenges are severely compromising ambulance response and hospital treatment times."If you spot any of the signs of a stroke in you or someone else, it's vital to call 999 straight away," she said.A spokesperson for East Midlands Ambulance Service said: "Every 999 call is assessed based on the information provided by the caller and people experiencing a life-threatening emergency are responded to as a priority."The NHS Humber Health Partnership said a hyper-acute stroke unit at Scunthorpe General Hospital provides "immediate specialist treatment and high quality care for all stroke patients in our area".The unit at Scunthorpe was opened in 2013 after an NHS report described stroke services in Grimsby as "inadequate", which led to health bosses consolidating treatment onto one site. Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here.

PE teacher, 31, who was obsessed with not going bald took his own life after switching to an unlicensed drug in Dubai to treat his hair loss, inquest hears
PE teacher, 31, who was obsessed with not going bald took his own life after switching to an unlicensed drug in Dubai to treat his hair loss, inquest hears

Daily Mail​

time42 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

PE teacher, 31, who was obsessed with not going bald took his own life after switching to an unlicensed drug in Dubai to treat his hair loss, inquest hears

A teacher obsessed with not going bald took his own life after switching to a powerful unlicensed drug to treat his hair loss, an inquest heard today. Sam Applegarth, 31, who had no history of mental health problems, hanged himself in Dubai after starting an online course of dutasteride - a drug not licensed for hair loss in the UK. The PE teacher, who had first sought help for his hair loss aged 22, had used minoxidil and finasteride for years without any side-effects. The inquest heard that there are no known 'suicidal ideation' side-effects from taking dutasteride - a drug primarily used to treat an enlarged prostate - because there has been a failure to report such feelings in men taking the drug. Today Mr Applegarth's heartbroken girlfriend Anya Guy, 30, urged anybody having suicidal thoughts after taking dutasteride to inform medical experts in the hope of preventing similar tragedies. Mr Applegarth was brought up in Outwood, near Wakefield, West Yorkshire, and after working for the Rugby Football League took up teaching science and PE at Minsthorpe High School. After his death one parent praised him as an 'absolute diamond and role model'. Wakefield Coroner's Court heard that since 2015 he had been concerned about losing his hair and visited top specialist Dr Bessam Farjo at his trichology clinic in Manchester. Dr Farjo told the hearing that Mr Applegarth visited for consultations and advice, but was never prescribed any drugs. Sam Applegarth's heartbroken girlfriend Anya Guy, 30, pictured outside his inquest in Wakefield today, urged anybody having suicidal thoughts after taking dutasteride to inform medical experts He was aware that Mr Applegarth had started taking minoxidil, which is easily available over the counter at pharmacies such as Boots. The teacher later complemented it with doses of finasteride, which has been linked to terrifying side-effects including erectile dysfunction, depression and anxiety. Dr Farjo told coroner Oliver Longstaff that Mr Applegarth had 'self-sourced' those drugs and both had been happy with their effects. In 2017 Mr Applegarth underwent a successful hair transplant at the clinic. In follow-up consultations Mr Applegarth informed the doctor that he had also undergone platelet-rich plasma treatment, where a concentrated portion of his own blood was injected in a bid to rejuvenate his hair. He had also had his head tattooed to give the appearance of hair, in a process called scalp micro pigmentation. 'He was happy with the overall appearance after the tattoo,' Dr Farjo told the inquest. Mr Applegarth last saw Dr Farjo in July 2024, two months before he flew to Dubai. Leading hair loss expert Dr Bessam Farjo, who saw Sam Applegarth at his clinic in Manchester but did not prescribe him medication, told today's inquest in Wakefield there may be an under-reporting of suicidal ideation by patients following a course of dutasteride He reported still taking minoxidil and finasteride tablets, which he had sourced himself. He was also using camouflage products to conceal his hair loss and the doctor suggested cognitive therapy to alleviate his anxiety about going bald. 'He was a young man with an exaggerated view about how big an issue his hair loss was,' said the doctor. 'I had no concerns he was having any side-effects from the drugs.' He stated that 'suicidal ideation' is one recognised side effect of taking finasteride. But if a patient had not experienced those thoughts whilst on the drug they would not suffer them after the drug is out of their system. Dr Farjo said he was unaware that Mr Applegarth had begun taking dutasteride, which he described as 'more powerful' than finasteride. He said the known side-effects of both drugs are the same, apart from the fact finasteride has been reported by the British National Formulary to cause suicidal ideation. Dr Farjo acknowledged, under questioning from Ms Guy, there may be an under-reporting of suicidal ideation by patients following a course of dutasteride. 'Dutasteride is not licensed for hair loss in this country and it is not commonly prescribed,' he said. 'The reason the BNF suicide ideation is not mentioned for dutasteride is because it has not been reported, whereas it has been reported for finasteride.' Dr Farjo said that it would have been easy for Mr Applegarth to access a course of dutasteride himself. 'Unfortunately, it is not difficult to get medication online,' he said. He said numerous private medical supply companies are 'sprouting up' to prescribe drugs to patients, without seeing them in person. Ms Guy told the inquest that Mr Applegarth had moved to Dubai to teach in August last year, with a view to her joining him at a later date. She said he had 'struggled at times with his self-esteem' due to his perceived hair loss, but she felt his condition was not a bad as he believed. His GP and family told the inquest Mr Applegarth had no history of mental illness or self harm and was a 'bright and happy individual'. He appeared to be thriving in Dubai, enjoying swims, the gym and getting in more than 20,000 steps a day, the inquest heard. However, he was found hanging in his apartment by a work colleague on September 19 - just five weeks after arriving in Dubai. He left no suicide note and a post-mortem found no alcohol or drugs in his system. Following Mr Longstaff's conclusion of suicide, Ms Guy said outside court that she hoped people who may be suffering suicidal thoughts whilst taking dutasteride would come forward. She said: 'People feeling by side-effects with dutasteride should report them, especially if they are feeling suicidal. 'People need to be aware that they may be having suicidal ideation because of the drug.' Last month the European drugs regulator said it was not possible to establish a link between suicidal ideation and dutasteride tablets based on the reviewed data. The European Medicines Agency confirmed suicidal thoughts as a side effect of anti-hair-loss drug finasteride but said the benefits of both medicines continue to outweigh their risks for all approved uses. Following Mr Applegarth's tragic death, Craig Shepherd, who recruited him to work at Wakefield Trinity Rugby League Club, said: 'It was inevitable Sam went on to be a massive success in teaching. 'He was so loved by all who knew him. RIP Sam.' Anita Godfrey responded by posting: 'An absolute diamond and role model he really engaged my three in rugby league and would go above and beyond.' For confidential support, call the Samaritans on 116123 or visit

Teacher, 31, ‘took own life after using unlicensed hair loss drug' – as girlfriend issues heartbreaking plea
Teacher, 31, ‘took own life after using unlicensed hair loss drug' – as girlfriend issues heartbreaking plea

The Sun

timean hour ago

  • The Sun

Teacher, 31, ‘took own life after using unlicensed hair loss drug' – as girlfriend issues heartbreaking plea

A TEACHER took his own life after using an unlicensed hair loss drug he bought online, an inquest heard. Sam Applegarth, 31, had no history of mental health problems before the tragedy. 3 3 The PE teacher had recently started a course of dutasteride, which is not licensed for hair loss in the UK. An inquest was told there are no known "suicidal ideation" side effects for the drug as there has been a failure to report such feelings by men taking the drug. Sam's heartbroken girlfriend Anya Guy has now urged anybody having similar thoughts after taking dutasteride to inform medics. She said: "People feeling by side effects with dutasteride should report them, especially if they are feeling suicidal. 'People need to be aware that they may be having suicidal ideation because of the drug.' Wakefield Coroner's Court heard Sam was concerned about losing his hair since 2015. He had been visiting Dr Bessam Farjo at his clinic in Manchester but was never prescribed any drugs. However, Sam did take minoxidil, which is easily available over the counter at Boots, and finasteride without any side effects. In 2017, he had a successful hair transplant at the Farjo Hair Institute and underwent platelet-rich plasma treatment to rejuvenate his hair. Sam also had his head tattooed to give the appearance of hair, which Dr Farjo said he seemed "happy" with. Sam last saw Dr Farjo in July 2024 and confirmed he was still taking minoxidil and finasteride tablets. The medic told the court he suggested Sam undergo cognitive therapy to ease his anxiety about going bald. Dr Farjo added: "He was a young man with an exaggerated view about how big an issue his hair loss was,' said the doctor. 'I had no concerns he was having any side effects from the drugs.' The court was told Sam moved to Dubai to teach in August, last year, with Anya planning to join him at a later date. She said he had "struggled at times with his self esteem" due to his perceived hair loss but his condition was not a bad as he believed. The inquest heard Sam had no history of mental illness or self harm he was a "bright and happy individual". Sam was discovered dead in his apartment by a work colleague on September 19 - just five weeks after arriving in Dubai. He left no suicide note and a post-mortem found no alcohol or drugs in his system, the inquest heard. Dr Farjo said that "suicidal ideation" is one recognised side effect of taking finasteride. You're Not Alone EVERY 90 minutes in the UK a life is lost to suicide It doesn't discriminate, touching the lives of people in every corner of society – from the homeless and unemployed to builders and doctors, reality stars and footballers. It's the biggest killer of people under the age of 35, more deadly than cancer and car crashes. And men are three times more likely to take their own life than women. Yet it's rarely spoken of, a taboo that threatens to continue its deadly rampage unless we all stop and take notice, now. That is why The Sun launched the You're Not Alone campaign. The aim is that by sharing practical advice, raising awareness and breaking down the barriers people face when talking about their mental health, we can all do our bit to help save lives. Let's all vow to ask for help when we need it, and listen out for others… You're Not Alone. If you, or anyone you know, needs help dealing with mental health problems, the following organisations provide support: CALM, 0800 585 858 Heads Together, HUMEN Mind, 0300 123 3393 Papyrus, 0800 068 41 41 Samaritans, 116 123 He told the hearing he was unaware Sam had begun taking dutasteride, which he described as "more powerful" than finasteride. The doctor said the known side effects of both drugs are the same, apart from finasteride has been reported by the BNF to cause suicidal ideation. Dr Farjo acknowledged there may be an underreporting of suicidal ideation by patients following a course of dutasteride. He added: 'Dutasteride is not licensed for hair loss in this country and it is not commonly prescribed. 'The reason the BNF suicide ideation is not mentioned for dutasteride is because it has not been reported, whereas it has been reported for finasteride.' Coroner Oliver Longstaff ruled a verdict of suicide. If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this article, please call the Samaritans for free on 116123.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store