Roberts-Smith's appeal dealt blow after ‘fishing expedition' cut down
Disgraced soldier Ben Roberts-Smith has suffered a blow to his plans to appeal a defamation judgement which found he committed war crimes while on duty in Afghanistan.
The former Special Air Service corporal sued the publisher of this newspaper, then known as Fairfax Media, and T he Age and The Sydney Morning Herald investigative journalist Nick McKenzie, after a series of articles alleged he carried out war crime murders while deployed with the SAS.
The Federal Court dismissed the case in June 2023 when a judge found, to the civil standard of the balance of probabilities, that Roberts-Smith had committed multiple war crime murders, assaulted Afghans and engaged in a campaign of bullying against Australian troops a decade earlier.
The Victoria Cross recipient appealed the judgement and has been waiting for a decision for more than a year.
Last month he filed an application to reopen his appeal to introduce as evidence a recording of McKenzie speaking to a woman the famed soldier had an affair with, known in the trial as Person 17.
Loading
In the call, McKenzie allegedly says Roberts-Smith's ex-wife, Emma Roberts, and her close friend Danielle Scott, were 'actively briefing us on his legal strategy in respect of you'.
Roberts-Smith's legal team on Wednesday defended wide-ranging subpoenas they had issued to McKenzie, the journalist's lawyers, Person 17, Roberts, Scott, and the ABC.
'To say that (the recording) contents are shocking is an understatement,' Roberts-Smith's lawyer Arthur Moses, SC, told the court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
21 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
Australian released from Iraqi prison after more than four years behind bars
The federal government is welcoming the release of an Australian engineer from a jail in Iraq. Robert Pether has been granted bail, emerging from a prison in Iraq after spending more than four years behind bars. Mr Pether was arrested in April 2021 alongside his Egyptian colleague, charged with deception, however, he has always maintained his innocence.
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Former Victorian opposition leader John Pesutto served bankruptcy notice
John Pesutto has accepted a bankruptcy notice served to him yesterday, as the consequences of Liberal colleague Moira Deeming's successful defamation action against him continue to play out. One source close to the proceedings confirmed that the official notice had been served. Deeming successfully took Pesutto to Federal Court, which last December ruled he defamed her five times after an anti-transgender rights rally she organised in March 2023. That rally was unexpectedly gatecrashed by Neo-Nazis, and the court agreed with Deeming that in the aftermath, Pesutto defamed her as a Nazi sympathiser. Last month, a court ordered Pesutto to pay Deeming $2.3 million in legal costs by Friday, May 30, a deadline which he missed. Loading Only about one third of the money has been raised, including $212,000 via crowdfunding - and about $4000 of that in the past week. Under Australian bankruptcy law, Pesutto now has 20 days to either pay the $2.3 million in full or come to an arrangement where he can pay in instalments. Deeming's lawyers have previously said they plan to pursue third parties for costs if Pesutto is left bankrupt — including former premiers Jeff Kennett, Denis Napthine and Ted Baillieu and serving MPs Georgie Crozier and David Southwick.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Drug accused breaks down in front of cameras in Bali
Australian Puridas Robinson tried to shield his face from the cameras. Credit: MADE NAGI / EPA An Australian man arrested on suspicion of drug possession has broken down as he was paraded before the cameras in Bali. Puridas Robinson was pictured after police allegedly found a stash of marijuana at his Denpasar villa. If convicted of drug possession Mr Robinson, from Queensland, could face up to 12 years in jail. The teary 40-year-old covered his face as he was carted into a press conference alongside 20 other tourists accused of trafficking drugs into Indonesia. His arrest comes a few weeks after fellow Australian Lamar Ahchee was arrested for allegedly trying to smuggle $1 million of cocaine into Bali. Police allege 1.8kg of cocaine was concealed inside two Gold Lindt chocolate boxes, with each box containing 54 individually wrapped packets of the drug. Mr Ahchee, who has been living in Bali since 2017, could face the death sentence if convicted. Puridas Robinson. Credit: Firdia Lisnawati / AP
