Points of order: Who were Alberta's most unparliamentary MLAs this sitting?
Alberta MLAs returned to their constituencies this week following the early Thursday conclusion of what was at times a combative spring sitting of the legislative assembly.
Article content
Article content
Tension often ran high inside the chamber during debates, with MLAs from both parties periodically running afoul of the assembly's standing orders that set out the rules for debate MLAs must follow.
Article content
Article content
Such alleged violations, known as a point of order, are called out in real-time by MLAs and adjudicated by the Speaker, with those found to have have breached the rules typically apologizing and withdrawing their remarks.
Article content
That analysis shows that violations were most frequently called for making allegations about a fellow MLA, and while members of both parties were found to have broken parliamentary rules, the numbers show the most recurrent violator was Edmonton-Gold Bar representative Marlin Schmidt.
Article content
Government house leader Joseph Schow was the most frequent MLA to rise and call for a point of order and sometimes joked in the chamber about 'not skipping leg day.'
Article content
'This is an important place where we come to work every day, argue and to debate the things that matter most to Albertans. Sometimes those debates get heated,' he said last week.
Article content
Article content
'It's a unique workplace,' said Opposition house leader Christina Gray. 'Standing up to ask questions while there's a wall of noise of people yelling at you.'
Article content
Making allegations against a fellow MLA amounted to just under one-quarter of both all alleged points of orders and those that were upheld, with other violations including insulting language, imputing motives, language creating disorder, as well as more minor transgressions such as referring to a member by his or her name rather than riding.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Bettman says NHL, NHLPA in 'really good shape' on talks for new collective agreement
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman says the league and its union are in "really good shape" with negotiations on a new collective bargaining agreement. Speaking ahead of Game 1 of the Stanley Cup final rematch between the Edmonton Oilers and Florida Panthers, he added that this round of talks with NHL Players' Association executive director Marty Walsh are "no comparison" to past CBA discussions. "We are having very constructive, professional, cordial dialogue," Bettman said Wednesday. "We started a little bit later than we had anticipated for a variety of reasons on both sides, so I don't have an announcement to make that we have a deal." The current CBA, which was extended during the COVID-19 pandemic with the NHL's financial situation on shaky ground, is set to expire Sept. 15, 2026. "We have more than a year to go," Bettman continued. "I think we're in really good shape, having really good discussions; we're in a really good place in terms of our relationship." Walsh held a media scrum with reporters after Bettman's availability and called conversations "good" and "ongoing." "It's moving steady, it's moving forward," he said. "I feel good with where we are, and we'll see what happens. It gets complicated at certain times -- any collective bargaining agreement -- but it's not where it was in the past here where you're seeing national disputes between organized labour and companies." Walsh, who took over from former union head Donald Fehr in February 2023, added the league and players are working through "different pulls on both sides." The positive tone is a welcome sign for fans of a league that lost the entire 2004-05 season to a lockout and went through labour disruptions that shortened both the 1994-95 and 2012-13 campaigns. Asked directly on when a deal might be signed, Walsh replied: "We didn't start (negotiations) until April, so a slow start there; I'm not going to give any timeline on that." Olympic question The NHL is set to return to the Olympics next year in Italy. Deputy commissioner Bill Daly said the league doesn't expect the International Olympic Committee or the International Ice Hockey Federation to change its ban on the participation of Russian teams, which means NHLers from that country, as things stand, will be barred from the first Games involving the world's best players since 2014 due to the ongoing war in Ukraine. Talking growth Daly said the NHL has received a lot of interest from markets looking for expansion teams -- Atlanta and Houston are believed to be on the list -- but it won't be going through a formal process to add to its 32 clubs. "If somebody wants to essentially apply for an expansion franchise and has all the requisite elements that we would look for in an expansion franchise, we would raise it with the board of governors and see if they have any interest," Daly said. "There are some people we've talked to more than others, but there's a lot of interest, which I think we're gratified with."
National Observer
3 hours ago
- National Observer
A new poll says Canadians are divided on whether the US is an 'ally' or 'enemy' country
Faced with a trade war they didn't start, Canadians are divided on whether they see the United States as an "enemy" or an "ally," a new poll suggests. The Leger poll, which was conducted online and can't be assigned a margin of error, surveyed more than 1,500 people between May 30 and June 1. Almost a third of respondents said they view the US as a "neutral country," while 27 per cent said they consider it an "ally" and 26 per cent see it as an "enemy country." Just over a third of men said they consider the US an ally, compared with one in five women. Almost 30 per cent of women said they view the US as an enemy, compared with 22 per cent of men. Older Canadians, those at least 55 years of age, were more likely to consider the US an enemy than younger Canadians. Regionally Albertans were most likely to consider the US an ally while Ontarians and British Columbians were most likely to see it as an enemy. The difference is starkest between political party supporters, with 44 per cent of Conservative supporters saying they view the US as an ally, compared with 17 per cent of Liberal supporters and 12 per cent of NDP supporters said the same. Comparatively 16 per cent of Conservative supporters said they view the US as an enemy country, while 36 per cent of Liberal supporters and 41 per cent of NDP supporters said the same. US President Donald Trump signed an executive order Tuesday to double his levies on steel and aluminum to 50 per cent. He claimed the measure will protect the country's national security and domestic industries. Prime Minister Mark Carney has said his government will need to take "some time" to craft a response to the increased US tariffs. The number of Canadians that report seeing the US as an enemy country has dropped by six points since mid-March. At that time, 32 per cent of survey respondents told Leger they viewed the country as an enemy. The number of Canadians that view the US as an ally also decreased by two percentage points since March, from 29 to 27 per cent, while the number that view it as a neutral country increased by six percentage points, from 24 to 30 per cent. Andrew Enns, Leger's executive vice-president for Central Canada, said that, broadly speaking, the patterns haven't changed much since the organization asked the question in February — when 27 per cent of respondents said they viewed the US as an enemy and 30 per cent said they viewed it as an ally. Enns said the decline in the number of people saying the US is an enemy likely reflects the overall sentiment on tariffs. "It's still obviously there and, you know, clearly now we're dealing with higher steel tariffs, but the commentary coming from the White House and the Trump administration seems to have dissipated a bit and that's probably helping just tone things down," he said. Enns said Canada also has a new prime minister with a mandate that might "take the edge off things." "I think that just keeps things more at a moderate level, and I think that reflects in people maybe feeling a little less threatened by the US," Enns said. Enns said political and business leaders have also sent a consistent message that the US remains an important trading partner. He said that may encourage Canadians to believe there's a way to "work things out." The polling industry's professional body, the Canadian Research Insights Council, says online surveys cannot be assigned a margin of error because they do not randomly sample the population.
CBC
4 hours ago
- CBC
'I'm game': Alberta Premier Smith invites Prime Minister Carney to Oilers game
Social Sharing Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she has invited Prime Minister Mark Carney to watch an Edmonton Oilers Stanley Cup final game. Speaking to The Canadian Press in Washington, D.C., on Wednesday, Smith said she's waiting to see if Carney will join her for Game 5, which could take place next weekend ahead of the G7 conference in Kananaskis, Alta. Carney, who grew up in Edmonton, made his allegiance to the home team clear when he stopped at Rogers Place to skate with the Oilers in March. That was his first visit to the city after being sworn in as Liberal leader, replacing Justin Trudeau. "I am pleased to see that we at least have a prime minister who knows what team to root for," Smith said. "I'm game. We'll see if we can go together." The Prime Minister's Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment Wednesday. In response to a request for further details, Smith's press secretary Sam Blackett offered a brief statement. "Let's see if the series goes to five games first," he said. It would be the first game Smith has publicly acknowledged planning to attend during this year's Oilers NHL playoff run. Last year, the premier and some of her cabinet members faced criticism for accepting free luxury box tickets to playoff games. At the time, Smith defended their attendance, saying Albertans expect their elected representatives to support the team. WATCH| Canada cheers for Edmonton as the Oilers take Game 1 over Panthers: Canada rallies behind Edmonton Oilers to bring home the Stanley Cup 8 hours ago Duration 3:45 Canadians across the country are pulling for the Edmonton Oilers to knock out the Florida Panthers and bring home the Stanley Cup for the first time since 1993, after the Oilers won game 1 at home in Edmonton. While Smith said the tickets she accepted were courtesy of a provincial Crown corporation, a few ministers were given tickets by a private businessman whose contracts with the Alberta government are now part of multiple broader investigations into government health-care contracts. The premier has said that she and her ministers' moves were above board, and broke no ethics rules. Subsequent allegations of bloated sweetheart deals from the former head of Alberta Health Services sparked investigations from the RCMP, Alberta's auditor general and a former Manitoba judge hired by the government. Peter Guthrie ultimately resigned from cabinet as infrastructure minister over the government's handling of the contract scandal, and he was later booted from the United Conservative caucus altogether over his criticism.
