MLSD, OSPI spar over transgender athletics

Yahoo

14-03-2025

Mar. 14—MOSES LAKE — The Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction has responded to a letter from the Moses Lake School District Board of Directors that was sent to State Superintendent Chris Reykdal with a copy addressed to Governor Bob Ferguson. The letter from MLSD addresses the issue of transgender athletes in girls sports.
Distributing the letter, which Board Chair Kirryn Jensen said was composed by a "concerned citizen" of Moses Lake, was unanimously approved March 5 and signed by all board members.
OSPI responded to the district's letter March 6.
MLSD letter
In the initial letter, the board accused Reykdal of disavowing directives from the United States Department of Education and a Feb. 5 executive order issued by President Donald Trump concerning the participation of transgender individuals in sports. The letter can be read here: bit.ly/4bSiiN2.
"Your actions, Superintendent Chris Reykdal, and words could have dire consequences for all schools in Washington State, and your viewpoints do not reflect the community we serve nor the students we have the honor to serve and protect," reads the MLSD letter.
The letter further states that Reykdal's comments risked the well-being of Washington students, and cited a recent executive order from Trump designed to bar those born male from participating in girl's and women's athletics.
"In recent years, many educational institutions and athletic associations have allowed men to compete in women's sports," reads the MLSD letter. "This is demeaning, unfair, and dangerous to women and girls, and denies women and girls the equal opportunity to participate and excel in competitive sports. Moreover, under Title IX of the Education Act of 1972 (TitleIX) educational institutions receiving Federal Funds cannot deny women an equal opportunity to participate in sports. As some Federal courts have recognized 'ignoring fundamental biological truths between the two sexes deprives women and girls of meaningful access to educational facilities.'"
The letter emphasized the importance of adhering to federal law, particularly Title IX, which prohibits discrimination based on sex in federally funded education programs and activities. It states the board's commitment to revising athletic eligibility policies to align with federal directives, including prohibiting individuals born biologically male from participating in girls' sports teams.
The board's resolutions include updating the student handbook and athletic guidelines to conform to the executive order; reviewing facility usage policies to ensure compliance with federal mandates regarding student privacy and safety and ensuring clear communication with students, staff and families about these changes.
In articulating their position, the board quoted Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., stating, "Discrimination on the basis of race, color or national origin is illegal and morally reprehensible."
The board said the community and Moses Lake School Board believe in King's vision and believe the goal can be achieved if elected leaders would follow "that very simple rule."
"As the Board of Directors of the Moses Lake School District, we are committed to adhering to federal law, as per our sworn oath," reads the conclusion of the letter. "We trust that your office will also uphold federal law, without allowing personal biases or differing viewpoints to jeopardize the Moses Lake School District's Federal funding."
OSPI response
OSPI responded with its own letter dated March 6 from its Equity and Civil Rights Office, addressing concerns about MLSD's new policies. The letter reiterated that the board's intention to limit athletic eligibility based on gender identity contradicted state nondiscrimination laws enshrined in Chapters 28A.640 and 28A.642 of the Revised Code of Washington.
The OSPI letter articulated that "Washington nondiscrimination laws already comply with federal civil rights and nondiscrimination statutes," emphasizing that states can offer greater protections for students than federal mandates require. The office expressed concern that the MLSD's proposed actions could expose students, particularly transgender and gender-expansive individuals, to discrimination.
OSPI warned that if the board proceeded with its policies that "may be seen as implementing, enforcing, or otherwise giving effect to the Board's letter," it could face corrective action in accordance with state laws. Additionally, OSPI cautioned against any actions that could be interpreted as retaliation toward employees refusing to comply with discriminatory directives.
OSPI said if the board or district is unable to "voluntarily resolve these concerns" OSPI may take further action regarding the district's new policies.
District response
In acknowledgment of the OSPI's letter, Jensen spoke with the Columbia Basin Herald.
"Our recent actions as a board were taken in alignment with federal directives and our belief in maintaining fairness and safety in our schools," Jensen said.
Jensen said the board is committed to assessing its next steps while prioritizing the community's values and students' well-being.
"The Moses Lake School Board of directors is committed to adhering to federal law as per our sworn oath," Jensen said.
When contacted, district staff were unaware of any transgender girls participating in girls sports.
Neither OSPI nor MLSD addressed the potential for transgender boys playing on boys sports teams.
According to the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, or WIAA, which organizes competitive play between school districts in the Evergreen State, association members will vote on an amendment to its rules that would only allow participation in girls' sports to biological females.