2025 Shadow Drafts: What would've happened if Cowboys picked WR or DE instead of Booker?
2025 Shadow Drafts: What would've happened if Cowboys picked WR or DE instead of Booker? The Cowboys are getting quality marks for their haul, but would they have been better off going a different direction?
Shadow drafts are always a fun exercise. I got the idea several years ago from Locked on Cowboys podcast host Marcus Mosher. The concept is simple; what other options were available to the team you follow instead of how they proceeded with things in reality. For the Dallas Cowboys, that means what if the they made a different decision than drafting Alabama offensive guard Tyler Booker with the No. 12 overall pick?
The rules are straight-forward.
At each draft slot, the only prospects available are ones who went later in the real-life draft.
The team can only use drafted capital that was actually traded in order to move around. So the Cowboys were willing to trade 5.174 and 6.211; those are the only picks that could be used to move around with.
When the team bypasses the position it picked in reality, assume the last prospect taken at that position before their next pick is now available. i.e. If the team took WR2 in reality, and WR5 last off the board before the club's next pick, WR5 would still be "on the board" for them.
Also, one doesn't have to be married to the order that positions were addressed, but they do need to adhere to the spirit of the agenda.
Could there have been a better haul awaiting Dallas if they steered in a different direction, with hindsight being 20/20?
Edge Rusher First
1.12 - Edge Jalon Walker, Georgia
2.42 (Trade 2.44, 5.174, 6.211) - DT Alfred Collins, Texas
3.76 - WR Savion Williams, TCU
5.149 - OG Marcus Mbow, Purdue
6.204 - CB Robert Longerbeam, Rutgers
7.217 - RB Brashard Smith, SMU
7.239 - RB Phil Mafah, Clemson
7.247 - DT Zeke Biggers, Georgia Tech
Wide Receiver First
1.12 - WR Emeka Egbuka, Ohio State
2.44 - OG Jonah Savalineaea, Arizona
3.76 - RB Bhayshul Tuten, Virgnia Tech
4.117 (Trade 5.149, 5.174, 6.211) - Edge David Walker, Central Arkansas
6.204 - CB Robert Longerbeam, Rutgers
7.217 - DT Jay Toia, UCLA
7.239 - RB Phil Mafah, Clemson
7.247 - TE Luke Lachey, Iowa
Would the Cowboys have been better off with either of these two hauls?
Follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
28 minutes ago
- USA Today
Cowboys Countdown to Cutdown Day: Player profiles No. 90 - No. 81 as pass catcher play
Cowboys Countdown to Cutdown Day: Player profiles No. 90 - No. 81 as pass catcher play Cowboys Wire's running series of player profiles has reached another milestone. These profiles allow fans to have a general idea of a player's background, how they arrived in the league and how they ended up on the Dallas Cowboys' roster, along with the journey that will be ahead of them. For star players, these will look at their accomplishments and for players who are just trying to make either the 53-man roster of 16-man practice squad, it will be a brief look at the fight ahead of them. This piece will serve as a repository for each of those articles, as well as a link to each previous 10-number repository. No. 90: DT Solomon Thomas | Link No. 89: TE Brevyn Spann-Ford | Link No. 88: WR CeeDee Lamb | Link No. 87: TE Jake Ferguson | Link No. 86: TE Luke Schoonmaker | Link No. 85: TE Princeton Fant | Link No. 84: WR Kelvin Harmon | Link No. 83: WR Jalen Brooks | Link No. 82: None No. 81: WR Jonathan Mingo | Link Repositories 99 - 91 | 90 - 81 | 80 - 71 | 70 - 61 | 60 - 51 | 50 - 41 | 40 - 31 | 30 - 21 | 20 - 11 | 10 - 1 Follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Nation's Top LB To Officially Visit SEC Powerhouse After Trips To Clemson, Oregon
Nation's Top LB To Officially Visit SEC Powerhouse After Trips To Clemson, Oregon originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Class of 2026 five-star linebacker Tyler Atkinson remains uncommitted as he entertains some of the top college football programs in the country. Advertisement The Grayson High School product out of Lawrenceville, Georgia, ranks as the nation's No. 1 linebacker, the No. 1 player in the state and the No. 22 overall recruit in his class (Rivals). Ratings aside, Atkinson's production over the last two seasons raised some eyebrows on the recruiting trail. As a sophomore, the 6-foot-2, 205-pound linebacker broke the Grayson record for tackles in a season (197). Atkinson went on to lead the Rams to a 6A state championship title as a junior while racking up 166 tackles (32 for loss), 13 sacks, an interception and a forced fumble. Atkinson is coming off official visits to both Clemson (May 30) and Oregon (June 6). He also unofficially visited Ohio State and Miami last year. Grayson High School linebacker Tyler AtkinsonLori Schmidt / Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images Where Atkinson has spent the most time, though, is SEC powerhouse Georgia. Advertisement Head coach Kirby Smart's Bulldogs have hosted the elite in-state recruit multiple times dating back to his middle school days and are slated to receive an official visit from Atkinson this weekend, the linebacker announced Wednesday via On3's Hayes Fawcett. 'It feels like I grew up at UGA because of all the camps and visits I've been to over the years since I was younger," Atkinson said. Georgia is believed to be the favorite to land Atkinson, according to recruiting experts from On3, 247Sports and Rivals. That wouldn't be a surprise considering the long-running relationship, proximity to home and UGA's knack for producing NFL players at Atkinson's position. Advertisement Smart and co-defensive coordinator/linebackers coach Glenn Schumann have recruited and coached three Butkus Award winners, along with multiple first-round draft picks, since 2017. However, Clemson and Oregon should be considered as heavyweight contenders as Atkinson considers the best option for his future. Related: Kirby Smart, Georgia Add Another Recruiting Win as Surge Continues Related: College Football Fans Emotional After College GameDay's Announcement On Week 1 Location This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cowboys cap strategy must evolve to keep contending
Cowboys cap strategy must evolve to keep contending originally appeared on Athlon Sports. If you're serious about contending, it's time to start keeping up with the Joneses, so to speak. As highlighted by Blogging The Boys, Jerry Jones' Dallas Cowboys are drastically behind the league's elite in both total void-year spending and the number of high-salary players on their roster. The Eagles lead the NFL with a staggering $452 million in void-year allocations — a strategy that has allowed them to maintain one of the deepest rosters in football. Advertisement In contrast, the Cowboys rank 16th with just $44 million in future void years, most of it tied up in Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb. Philadelphia also has 10 players making at least $10 million annually, while Dallas has just five. The difference isn't necessarily about being "cheap''; it's about refusing to use every tool (or loophole) available to win now. The best teams in the league have figured it out. The salary cap isn't a hard ceiling; it's a strategy game. You can manipulate the cap through void years, restructures, and deferred money ... all with the understanding that the NFL dollar is ever inflating. The cap is fake today and real tomorrow ... but is not a team-building restriction. Advertisement Rather, it is simple accounting. And it's something we've been saying for years. The Cowboys have slowly shown signs of a 'changing of the guard' in how they approach cap management, but complacency or old-fashioned thinking or maybe frugality still looms to a degree. In a family-run front office, there's no pressure from ownership to push harder. ... because of course here, "the front office'' and "ownership'' are one in the same. That's exactly why fans must keep applying it. (For whatever good that does.) Micah Parsons, Tyler Smith, DaRon Bland, and George Pickens are next in line and the Cowboys could quickly shrink the "talent gap" in the NFC with those specific extensions. Advertisement Get ahead of the ever-increasing positional market that also parallels with the ever-ballooning cap. Push some money into future void years and trust the cap growth. Do it now. For years, the Cowboys have leaned on in-house superstar retention, cheap labor and compensatory picks as the foundation of their roster-building philosophy. And to a degree, it's worked — they draft well, they find value, and they stay under budget. But there's a ceiling to that approach. ... as exhibited by the fact that they win regular-season games ... and nothing more. You can't build a Super Bowl roster on rookie deals alone. At some point, you have to pay to keep your homegrown stars and you have to supplement that core with proven, high-priced talent. Advertisement Comp picks are nice — but banners aren't raised for mastering the comp pick formula. They're raised for winning in January and February. And that requires financial aggression, not financial caution. The league is evolving — and if the Cowboys truly want to stop spinning their wheels, they need to spend like contenders and exploit every modern cap tool available. Related: Cowboys Get Major News On New Cap Announcement Related: Cowboys George Pickens Must Move To 'Mojo' From 'Misfit' This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
